Nobody downloaded yet

Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Eyewitness the Movie and the Issue of Identification Introduction For many years,a debate on the issue of eyewitness identification and testimony has been raging with thin the justice system.One camp pushes the concept that that eyewitness identification is not reliable and is,in fact,detrimental to the pursuit of genuine justice. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification"

Download file to see previous pages Eyewitness the Movie and the Issue of Identification Introduction For many years, a debate on the issue of eyewitness identification and testimony has been raging with thin the justice system.One camp pushes the concept that that eyewitness identification is not reliable and is, in fact, detrimental to the pursuit of genuine justice. This side of the argument insists that eyewitness accounts have many times resulted into the resolution of cases based on testimonies, which could be subjective and inaccurate, instead of on the merits of physical evidences, which could be more concrete and objective. The opposing camp, on the other hand, insists that eyewitness accounts are necessary to hasten the resolution of criminal cases in court. It stresses the point that without the testimony of a person who saw the crime committed, positive identification of the suspects cannot be achieved. Even as the debate on the merits and demerits of the two sides continue though, there have been films and television shows that tackle the issue directly and indirectly. The movie Eyewitness may not have presented a courtroom drama that dealt with the pros and cons eyewitness testimony but it did present the filmmaker’s own perspective on the issue. It did so by depicting a character that wishes to present himself as a witness to a crime not because he is interested in seeing the resolution of a murder case but because of his personal objective of winning the affection of a person. Weakness of Eyewitness Testimony Eyewitness is a movie that was released in 1981. The film was directed by Peter Yates and written by Steve Tesich. It stars William Hurt as Daryll Deever, the janitor who discovered the body of a murder victim in the building he is working in. Sigourney Weaver plays the role of a zealous television reporter, Tony Sokolow, who wants to get a scoop of the murder case. Deever sees the opportunity of becoming close to Sokolow when he presented himself as someone who discovered the body. While this may be true though, Deever goes to the extent of insinuating that he saw more than just the dead body but also the actual crime while it was committed. This leads Tony to be interested in Deever’s account, hoping to be the first to broadcast the story to the public. Tony actually is already in a relationship with someone else, Joseph played by Christopher Plummer. However, just to have a story, she manages to flirt a little with Deever. Joseph, on the other hand, is also very interested about what Deever knows which is why he is not quite concerned about the relationship between Tony and Daryll. The attempt by Deever to maintain Tony’s interest in him later turned into the source of conflict in the film. The murderers begins to consider the possibility that Daryll may have indeed witness the commission of the crime and that Tony already knows about it. For fear of being caught by the police, who are already doing investigations on the matter, they run after both Tony and Daryll with the aim of silencing them before their identities are divulged to the public. The police for their part have also begun believing that Daryll may have indeed witnessed the crime and that he could identify the perpetrators. However, the issue that is at stake here really is regarding the credibility of the eyewitness. Deever is obviously motivated by his desire to become personally close to Tony. On the other hand, Tony, who can amplify Deever’s claim because she is a journalist, is only interested in getting a scoop. The police, whose objective is to see that the crime is solved as soon as possible, also have the tendency to believe in whatever story Deever may come up with because of convenience. Here lies the central issue of eyewitness identification. Without determining the possible motivation of the witness, a case could be brought to court with suspects pointed out through the most biased and unscientific means. Through the jury system employed by the American judiciary, the honesty of the witness has a very profound impact on the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1411777-eyewitness-the-movie-and-the-issue-of-identification
(Eyewitness the Movie and the Issue of Identification Essay)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1411777-eyewitness-the-movie-and-the-issue-of-identification.
“Eyewitness the Movie and the Issue of Identification Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1411777-eyewitness-the-movie-and-the-issue-of-identification.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification

EYEWITNESS TO HISTORY

... Describe the goods that Diaz sees in the market. Do you find any of the items surprising? The goods or quantities of merchandise which Diaz had discovered include precious stones, gold, silver, embroidered stuffs, feathers, and cloaks which were properly sorted in the market. Negro slaves were also part of the merchandise to be sold besides other objects of trade as ropes, sandals, cotton goods, fabrics, coarse cloths, and chocolates. In addition, it would cause amazement to make mention of skins of tigers and lions, otters, jackals, and deer, badgers, mountain cats, and other wild animals in the enormous market but it is hugely surprising to find out that several canoe-loads of human excrement were also up for selling... Describe the goods...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Eyewitness reliability

..., Southeast – Asian(1.5%) and Asian(4.6%), Indian(1.5%), Australian(1.1%) and Australian aboriginals(1.1%), Mediterranean(1.0%), Africans(0.4%), South Americans(0.2%) and South Pacific(1.0%). The confounds of the study might be due to a number of other situational variables and the presence or absence of the target or their look alike in line up can also decrease the accuracy of the result. Other distinguishing features of the target might effect their identification rather then the distance so it can also interfere with the result. Population validity was high making the study reliable. The strength of evidence is strong as it is done on the spot and in front of the researchers and with large number of sample. The thesis...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Eyewitness error

...questions to the interviewee towards a certain direction when interrogating eyewitnesses (Wise, Dauphinais & Safer, 2007). This prompts eyewitnesses to err while delivering the essential information meant to help judges and those arbitrating the case impose unnecessary charges on the defendant (Tillman v. State, 2011). Therefore, information collection as well as representation during ligation process ought to consider proper legislative process, which this study seeks to present based on certain given cases (Kenneth Adams v. State, 1993). Mainly, this legislative action entails eliminating eyewitness errors coupled with considering essential issues that characterize...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Identification

...Supervisor: History and Political Science identification Die Welle According to Weber, the real politics is far much different from what is taught in the lecture room. In classroom, there is no one present to oppose the imprints of a teacher on the student like the case is in a political arena. In the political world, one does not hide his or her standpoint like it happens in lecture rooms. It is therefore inappropriate to state that democracy is absolutely perfect. As matter of fact, it has been argued that democracy can also be a bad form of government (Ingram 2). This has been reinforced by the fact that some nations that are non-democratic have managed to achieve impressive economic production. Fascism has been...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Identification

...in the history of the United States. First, it created a strong ground to address poverty that had affected most Americans during that time. The programs establish ways that improve the living conditions of people in the United States. These ways include better health care, education, and creation of job opportunities. Secondly, this initiative created a platform where the American government could address and eradicate poverty. It helped the government to address the basic needs of many disadvantaged families. Thirdly, it created job opportunities for the youths. Thirdly, the initiative introduced measures to deal with environment issues such as clean water and air. Lastly, the initiative guaranteed free health care to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Eyewitness Testimony

...the lack of statistical evidence to support this fact. Suggestibility is another error that should be given a lot of focus when it comes to eyewitness accounts in the courts. Gazzaniga stipulates that when information is mistakenly incorporated in the memory of a person through information from the media or another person thus distorting actual memory is referred to as suggestibility (Gazzaniga 133). This is clearly shown in the book in the case of Elizabeth where subject’s were convinced that at one time she was lost at the mall which had actually never happened yet a quarter of the subjects cited remembering the event (Gazzaniga 133). Among the errors, suggestibility is of utmost concern since it becomes a major...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Eyewitness Evidence

...Description Hurt Face Recognition; Psychology, Crime & Law, Vol. 0 p 1-14; Copyright 2001; http://www.abdn.ac.uk/psy282/dept/children%20verbal%20overshadowing.pdf Narby, D.J. & Cutler, B.L. & Penrod, S; The Effects of Witness, Target and Situational Factors on Eyewitness Identifications; In Sporer, S.L. & Malpass, R. & Koehnken G. (Eds.). Psychological Issues in Eyewitness Identification, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; http://web.jjay.cuny.edu/spenrod/papers/narby96.pdf Pezdek, Kathy & Blandon-Gitlin; Children's Face Recognition Memory: More Evidence for the Cross-Race Effect; http://www.emporia.edu/sarmac/html/SARMAC_Abstracts.html Tredoux,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Eyewitness Testimony

...to antisocial disorder and witnesses under such conditions are capable of giving false accounts (Loftus, E 1996). In an experiment carried out by Levesque 2005, to determine the level of eyewitness accuracy, two groups were chosen to identify a mock-thief robbing from a hotel. The incident was recorded in a telegraphic video and later showed to the participants. Afterwards, the witnesses were brought eight different people in public for identification. Unfortunately, the actual person who participated in the mockery theft was not amongst the victims. The eyewitness, however, identified wrongly of the persons who were never engaged in the clip. They were then asked to rate their level...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Eyewitness Testimony

...Eyewitness Identification One of the most important moments in a criminal investigation comes when an eyewitness comes forward you can identify a perpetrator in a crime. Unfortunately, eyewitness identification has been proven to be inaccurate many times and DNA has shown that eyewitness accounts have been false in the conviction of a number of defendants. The problem of eyewitness memory is one that have been researched through psychological studies throughout the last three decades. The following paper examines the way in which psychological research has impacted the processes for eyewitness...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Qualitative Research On Errors Of Eyewitness Identification

..., 2011). In this case, the eyewitness identification error occurs because a witness will alter his or her memory to make the statement or choice in agreement with others. The other source of eyewitness identification is because when an individual sees the perpetrator in a different scenario from the crime scene, the eyewitness will not identify the perpetrator correctly. On the other hand, presenting a witness with multiple offenders also has the potential of decreasing the accuracy in the identification procedure(Brewer & Wells, 2011). Conclusion In summary, the research paper has identified some of the issues that...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Eyewitness the movie and the issue of identification for FREE!

Contact Us