Nobody downloaded yet

Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Films Stagecoach and Once upon a time in the West - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Name of Professor Introduction The traditional Western cinema is often characterized by gender biased themes. Film heroics are often attributed to the male protagonists, while supplementary roles are given to female leads…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Films Stagecoach and Once upon a time in the West
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Films Stagecoach and Once upon a time in the West"

Download file to see previous pages Two of the most prominent filmmakers in Western cinema, John Ford and Sergio Leone, exhibit indirect desires to deviate from traditional gender stereotypes. This essay analyzes how two Western films, namely, Stagecoach and Once upon a Time in the West represent gender and masculinity, and how they embody traditional American society. Stagecoach by John Ford John Ford often elaborates the gender stereotypes of Western films. Disgraced women, like Dallas, are portrayed to be detached from the compassionate, encouraging, and nurturing ideals of family life, whereas wives and mothers usually endure the difficulties of life on the American frontier. They do so not as cultured, urbane Easterners, but as antagonistic women who surprise their men. The male protagonists of Ford also hold civilizing ideologies and exhibit gentleness. The most praiseworthy heroes of Ford also show decorum and dedication to domestic life not usually identified with the Western genre (Grant 10). Conforming to the sense of Victorian culture, masculinity in Ford’s films who grieve for loved ones and deceased wives exhibit a higher ability to value the living and to make a difference in the world (Pearson 23). Regardless of their gender, the characters of Ford usually confront the social, economic, and emotional outcomes of the absence of their family, but Stagecoach indicates that these effects can be especially damaging for a female. At some point in the stagecoach passage to Lordsburg, the town-whore Dallas marches in the moonlight. The Ringo Kid, played by John Wayne, goes after her. He tells her that Apache captures wanderers. “I guess you don’t know how it feels to lose your own folks,” (Studlar & Bernstein 53) he tells her as he tries to explain the reason for his journey to Lordsburg. Dallas narrates how her parents died “in a massacre in the Superstition Mountains” (Studlar & Bernstein 53). He answers, “That’s tough, especially on a girl” (Studlar & Bernstein 53). The sexually naive Ringo, locked up for a long time, does not know that Dallas is a whore. In this particular scene, the viewers are given the chance to understand the sad acceptance reflected on Dallas’s statement (Grant 15): “You have to live, no matter what happens.” Dallas’s disclosures of the slaughter that killed her parents and denied her of a family inform the viewers of the situations that have pushed her into prostitution. Her reputation as a social recluse is shown in the beginning when she was carried away by the town’s Law and Order League. Along the voyage, she is silently avoided by other, more reputable travelers, as well as Mrs. Mallory, the wife of the soldier. Her anxiety, shame, and injured boldness show that she is sexually defiant due to economic need instead of personal liking. But situations also compel Dallas to carry out the task of a nurse for the child of Mrs. Mallory. It is the compassionate character of Dallas that strengthens Ringo’s romantic sentiment. Film scholars have correctly discerned that the “shots of her [Dallas] cradling Lucy’s baby… are quite transgressive, since prostitutes are outside the family and the law” (Cook 44). For Ringo, Dallas is “the kind of girl a man wants to marry” (Cook 44), and the movie bears out his assessment of her instead of society’s judgment. As is widely observed, Ford’s compassion is for outsiders, regardless of their gender, and Stagecoach is not the only Western movie of Ford to grant ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Research Paper”, n.d.)
Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Research Paper. Retrieved from
(Compare and Contrast the Attitudes about gender/Masculinity in Western Research Paper)
Compare and Contrast the Attitudes about gender/Masculinity in Western Research Paper.
“Compare and Contrast the Attitudes about gender/Masculinity in Western Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Films Stagecoach and Once upon a time in the West

Compare and Contrast between East and West

...? The clash between the east and the west culture continues to be the focal point in the modern society. The eastern culture tends to be more conservative and focuses on family values. In the eastern culture for instance, women are supposed to follow cult of domesticity. This could be perfectly depicted in the Saudi culture where women are covered from head to top. In western culture such as the American culture, women are free to wear whatever they want. In fact, the majority of the society in America portrays women as a sex icon. In eastern cultures, most of the food is eaten through hands. However, in western cultures, it is considered inappropriate to eat with hands. Much of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Masculinity Representation in Films

...? Representation of Masculinity in Die Hard 2 of Representation of Masculinity in Die Hard 2 Topic 4: Drawing on your Mulvey and Neale readings, as well as Tasker’s discussion, analyse the representation of masculinity in one of the Die Hard films. How is the McClane character represented as a site of identification? As spectacle? The extant literature in the field of films incorporates gender studies that examine the representation of masculinity or the male action hero. From this stance, studies in the film field pay specific attention to the herculean physical performances and spectacular body...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Once Upon A Quinceaera

...Once Upon A Quinceaera Quinceaera, the celebration of womanhood at the threshold of girlhood is a popular trend in Latino societies in America. Sometimes the American sweet sixteen celebrations and the celebration for a girl's coming of age, her "quince" is celebrated together. The overlapping of various traditions, social implications and the attempt to be in touch with ones roots, living in a foreign nation; is portrayed through the use of ambivalence in Julia Alvarez's book - Once upon a Quinceaera. The Plot The book narrates the story of a young girl's "Quinceaera," the official celebration that marks the transition from girlhood to womanhood. A Quinceaera is the 15th birthday celebration of a Latin girl. Julia Alvarez tells... their...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Visual aesthetics in movie Once upon a time in the west, and Frida

...Visual Aesthetics in: "Once upon a time in the west" and "Frida" By s of College Introduction This aesthetic analysis will focus on two films: Frida and Once Upon a Time in the West. Each film will be examined with selected scenes being used to discuss the visual aesthetical properties of their contents. These aesthetical elements will also be discussed in terms of how they interact with the films musical score. The analysis will reveal that although these films are both dissimilar in terms of the era in which they were made,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast attitudes towards Native Americans

...Topic Compare and contrast attitudes towards Native Americans The battle between Native Americans and Custer and seventh cavalry at Little Bighom became legend in American history and led to the formation of Custer as a national hero. The conflict between Native Americans and other were basically over the matter of race. After the battle at Little Bighom ,Custer and his men became fighters in the mind of American people and Native Americans were counted as enemies. Even though the Native Americans won the battle of Little Bighom they could not win the right over their land. Native Americans were not given their rights as they deserve, and the white American wanted to have the dominion...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast two films about religion

...Compare and contrast two films about religion: The Matrix and Kundun The two films which the religious aspects will be compared and contrasted will be The Matrix and Kundun. The religion that will be represented by Matrix will be Christianity while Kundun will best represent Tibetan Buddhism as the film was about the Dalai Lama. The movie Matrix may not have mentioned Jesus Christ to make it a movie that has obvious religious undertone but its characters and circumstances are patently Christian. For example, Morpheus ship is named Nebuchadnezzar which is a biblical character. On it...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Once Upon a Time

...ment to Community Parents In my opinion as a member of the school board, I am in total agreement with the s decision concerning the use of the textbook as a class reader for second graders. Community parents ought to let the book be used as a class reader, the fact that it got approval from the state is enough proof that it is fit for the school curriculum. Although the textbook has a number of stories, two of these stories are controversial; these are about two married princes as well as two married princesses. These two stories are of great importance since they touch on an issue that has been quite a taboo for a long time, and this is about same sex marriages. In my opinion, students...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Compare and contrast the films

...Comparative Analysis of the Films Directed by Darren Aronofsky The paper is focused on the comparative analysisof the different films which had been directed by the American film director Darren Aronofsky in terms of the different parameters related to film namely the theme, the camera work, the editing, the point of view, and the style. The films included in the study are the Pi, Requiem for a Dream, the Fountain, Black Swan, the Wrestler and Noah. Comparative Analysis of the Films Directed by Darren Aronofsky Darren Aronofsky is known for a few yet award winning...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast films

...COMPARE AND CONTRAST FILMS Ida film Ida film is a film that makes a person develops a bad feeling. It is because the worst moments of an orphan are when the person is told how his or her parents died. It is even worse when someone cannot see the bodies of her or his parents. The people hosting orphans should make everything possible to see that the orphans are happy. They should also try not to make them remember anything about their parents. Sadly, in most cases they are mistreated, and some abused making them remember that they are orphans. I don’t like the film because the entire film...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

Marital Conflicts In The Film Once Upon A Time

...Marital Conflicts In The Film, Once Upon A Time All marriages contain some conflicts that range from being mild to serious conflicts that may lead to break up. Since marriages are common in the society and since this is one of the most recognized institutions, many scholars have engaged in the study of marital conflicts. Some marriages work while others are explained as being total disasters. However, no marriage is like the other since the nature and the degree of conflicts vary from one marriage to the other. In most cases, people learn about marriages through experiences. However, others who are yet to get married learn about marriage...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Compare and contrast the Attitudes about gender/masculinity in western Films Stagecoach and Once upon a time in the West for FREE!

Contact Us