Nobody downloaded yet

How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
no Date The role of marijuana smoking in elevating the risk of lung cancer Thesis Under-determination refers to a scenario in which the evidence supplied to support a certain belief, is insufficient to warrant a conviction. Fundamentally, this means that the available data is insufficient to permit a person to make a decision between two rival theories…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article"

Download file to see previous pages As once stated, a theory can only be considered as evidence if it is tested in groups, and not in isolation. Basically, under-determination is a result of two rival theories, in which neither has enough evidence to out-do the other. It, therefore, follows that the lack of certainty about a phenomenon could lead to people believing various theories, so long as these theories have evidence. In the end, people are left with questionable conclusions about the said phenomenon. In addition, strong under-determination holds that if two theories have the same observable consequence, then a person cannot distinguish between the two. Introduction According to Callaghan, Allebeck & Sidorchuk , cannabis, popularly known as marijuana,is listed as the most widely used illegal drug in the world today (1811). Marijuana, like tobacco contains a lot of carcinogens which public health experts say increase the risk of contracting cancer. Additionally, health experts point out that the kind of smoke produced by marijuana is more toxic since it tends tocondense and mutate, thus making its effects more lethal than those of tobacco. To prove that there exists a direct link between marijuana smoking and elevated risk of lung cancer, a study was conducted between 1969 and 2009 (Callaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk 1812). In this study, 49, 321 Swedish young males, between 18-20 years, were observed for forty years to determine whether marijuana does really cause lung cancer (Callaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk 1812). The results of the study would shed light on whether smoking of marijuana increases the chances of contracting cancer, or it is just a belief. Accordingly, the results are containedin an article written by Callaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk which draws the conclusion that marijuana smoking might increase the chances of contacting lung cancer. InCallaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk’s article on the correlation between smoking marijuana and contracting lung cancer, however, under-determination is evident (1811). Some of the results of the study appear to suggest that there is a positive correlation between smoking marijuana and increased chances of contracting lung cancer; while other results tend to show that there the evidence presented is not enough to warrant such a conclusion. However, the under-determination contained in this article is not unusual considering that several other studies have failed in coming up with a completely convincing conclusion. As Callaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk write, there have been numerous studies on the association between marijuana smoking and lung cancer development, although some studies found no association while others have established a link (1812). Callaghan, Allebeck &Sidorchuk state that the concern on whether marijuana smoking increases the risk of lung cancer has several lines of evidence (1811). One of the theories used as evidence purports that since tobacco smoking is the chief cause of lung cancer and sincemarijuana contains the same carcinogens as tobacco; the latter could also be a major cause of lung cancer. However, there is no evidence in the article to support these claims and as such, this just remains a hypothesis that needs strong empirical evidence. The fact that two items have similar content does not mean that they deliver the same results, unless such a claim is supported by very strong ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article Essay”, n.d.)
How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article Essay. Retrieved from
(How Is under-Determination (UD) Handled in the Scientific Article Essay)
How Is under-Determination (UD) Handled in the Scientific Article Essay.
“How Is under-Determination (UD) Handled in the Scientific Article Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article

Summary of a scientific article

...?Client’s 14 July The article comprehensively presents how biological invasion affects the native plants and how the same can be stopped. It takes no time for the invaders to make native plants refugees; this is what the article talks about. Native species of grass is being displaced by several weeds and this is very harmful for the people. The article sheds light upon how Avena barbata which is a weed or slender wild oat displaces native grass in California. Other weeds such as Bromus diandrus and Hordeum murinum are also responsible for displacing native grass in California, it is a great cause of concern and the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Summary of a scientific article

...?Article Review Ecology is a diverse field, which extends into many different disciplines in the field of biology. All of the different disciplines are interconnected and the relationship among biological systems and the wildlife that inhabit it. There are complex biochemical process that occur simultaneously which stimulate and promote the expansion of ecosystems. In this particular study, ecologists were paying particular attention to the flora of a region and its relation to the different soil attributes in how this plays a role in stages of growth and colonization. In particular, scientists were interested in looking at how the complex interactions of shrubs played a role in nitrogen,...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Price Determination under a Freely Operating Market System

...?PRICE DETERMINATION UNDER FREELY UNDER A FREELY OPERATING MARKET SYSTEM Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Determination of Price in a Market 3 Equilibrium Price 4 Residential Property Prices in UK 5 Conclusion 6 References 7 Introduction Market can be defined as a particular situation where the sellers and the buyers are made to come in contact with each other, thereby facilitating the process of exchange of different commodities that can be utilized for intermediate use or final consumption of those commodities (Tewari, & Singh, 2003, p.163). Market can be considered as an environment which helps in the determination of the goods that...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Scientific Method Tracing In A Diabetes Scientific Article

...Upon analyzing the study of Yamauchi, et al. , it can be seen that it was based on scientific method. A scientific method begins with observation of an unexplained phenomenon. Similarly, this study in question started with the statement saying statistics showed that type 2 diabetes is associated with increased morbidity and early mortality. Several studies have thus concentrated on identifying lifestyle factors that can help prevent the development of this disease. It had mentioned three studies, which have concluded that higher coffee consumption was associated with a decreased risk of type 2 diabetes. Coffee had also been proven to be an antagonist of adenosine receptors, thus promoting wakefulness and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Scientific article review

...Scientific Article Review The immune system is one of the bodies most important functions, as well as one of the bodies still most mysterious. However, great scientific advancements are being made, as can be read about in several different articles. One article deals with the immune system and its part in MS. It discusses several new important breakthrough in figuring out why the immune system attacks the brain and spinal chord, and how this can be contained. One important new breakthrough is the discovery of "T-regs", a cell that regulates T-Cells (Inner Conflict). These cells stop T-Cells from jumping to attack, and can be helpful in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Scientific American article about cholesterol

...Scientific American Journal on Cholesterol What was the goal of the work? In the past, people believed that high density lipoprotein could protect the heart against stroke risk or heart attack and low density lipoprotein increased the risk of the two. Researchers recently then decided to do research on both these lipoproteins to find out if changing the levels of LDL or HDL could affect the risk of getting heart attack or stroke. The goal of the research was to find out if lowering low density lipoprotein or increasing the levels of high density lipoproteins had any effect on the occurrence of heart attacks or strokes1. This is because, in the past, people used to think that altering the level of any of this would have an impact... of many...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Default Determination

...Default termination or termination by default is the standard contract clause which enables/gives the the prevalent rights to terminate unilaterally the contractor if the contractor fails to perform or work according to the terms given/ agreed in the contract. In this scenario, the contractor is generally not entitled to any payment for the uncompleted part of the contract and may in fact be liable in return for the repayment of any money that that was paid to him or her in advance, liquidated and any other damages, and any excess costs incurred by the customer in completing the contract under a new contractor. This paper thus is going to handle and talk about the termination by default or default...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Income determination

...RESEARCH PROPOSAL, MACRO & MICRO ECONOMICS; RESEARCH METHODS IN ECONOMICS (INCOME DETERMINATION) Greenawalt and Sinkey in their research tests the income-smoothing hypothesis among 106 large banks for a period of eight years (1976-1984).1 The study intends to find the effect of bank provision for loan losses as a fraction of company’s income. Moreover, the study also intends to find other business conditions that affect bank’s loan portfolio. The author report that there is evidence of income smoothening effect over the study period. Greenawalt and Sinkey effort add important knowledge to the operation of banking services on the noninterest products.2 Though there has no other research on the study of income smoothening...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

How hr functions are handled

...HANDLING HUMAN RESOURCE FUNCTIONS Introduction Human resource is an important sector in any company. This department has several functions that include salaries regulation, hiring of employees and doing advertisements. This department also works to develop a companys long-term strategies together with the management for growth. Human resource department is an intermediate between employees and management. Employees can access all information they need about the company from this department. Functions by the human resource is a key department and should be handled with great keenness and seriousness. Hiring of employees is done by the hiring manager by identifying the vacancy and evaluating the need. A...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Trace the scientific Method in a Primary Scientific Article

...Trace the scientific method in a primary scientific article due: Trace the scientific methodin a primary scientific article This paper is a discussion of a scientific method published in an article by the Science Daily web-site New Evidence. The study was conducted by Fumuhiko Horio and colleagues to determine if regular coffee taking minimizes the risk of type 2 diabetes. Steps of the scientific method The main steps include separating the laboratory mice into two groups. The second phase is to make the living environment and the diet same for the two groups. The next...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic How is under-determination (UD) handled in the scientific article for FREE!

Contact Us