Nobody downloaded yet

Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name of of Professor Subject 3 September 2013 Critique of For Gay Marriage The article For Gay Marriage by Andrew Sullivan is an extract from his book Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality, published in 1995 by Picador Publishing. The book describes how homosexuality is perceived by Conservatives, Liberals, Prohibitionists, and Liberationists…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan"

Download file to see previous pages He argues that homosexual people are equally capable of demonstrating such commitment as heterosexual people. Hence, the state should not discriminate between the two by failing to legalize gay marriage. I agree with the opinions of the author because his argument promotes the equality of all citizens and opens the doors to a healthier emotional, social and psychological life for homosexuals. Sullivan argues that in addition to a private agreement, marriage confers a special social status and recognition on the married couple, which entitles them to certain social privileges and respect. No citizen who can commit to a lifelong emotional, sexual and psychological relationship with another should be denied this social acceptance because of his or her sexuality. The notion that marriage is an institution for childbearing is no longer valid. Homosexual people are capable of being committed and responsible towards their partners. Hence, their relationships should not be denied the social and legal recognition awarded to similar relationships between heterosexuals. Conservatives should support gay marriage because the alternative would be more disastrous to the institution of marriage and family. Domestic partnerships, recognized in several states, would make it much easier for individuals to enjoy the benefits and privileges of marriage without entering being married to each other. Liberals should support gay marriage because it would encourage equality in society. Recognizing gay marriage would also help gay people, children and their families lead well-rounded public and family lives. They would learn to see themselves beyond their sexuality and develop as individuals with healthy personalities. The scope of the article is limited to the role of the state; hence, many of the arguments made in that regard are logical. However, it appears that the article oversimplifies the values and principles of liberals and conservatives. Sullivan assumes that all liberals blindly advocate equal opportunities for all citizens (Sullivan, 407) while other factors such as social norms and religious values may also influence their decisions. Similarly, the conservative view is presented as a stereotyped fear of social change. Given the assumptions, the arguments are made logically and are thus sound. The author does not remain fair to the conservatives, for example, when he assumes that they only have two alternatives to gay marriage open to them (Sullivan, 406). The parallel drawn between the opportunities for homosexuals in the military and in the institution of marriage (Sullivan, 405) is also weak because the two institutions operate in very different environments. I agree with the author on the importance of recognizing gay marriage legally. The most striking arguments are those made with respect to the impact of such legal recognition on the emotional and psychological well-being of homosexual people. The anxiety about the future of homosexual relationships will be reduced to a great extent when these relationships are given a legal and social status. Instead of adversely affecting the institution of heterosexual marriage, recognizing homosexual marriage will encourage long-term relationships. It will also be beneficial for the socialization and adjustment of gay children and young adults. It will give them the confidence to ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay”, n.d.)
Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1487163-critique-the-article-of-gay-marrige-by-sullivan
(Critique the Article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay)
Critique the Article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1487163-critique-the-article-of-gay-marrige-by-sullivan.
“Critique the Article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1487163-critique-the-article-of-gay-marrige-by-sullivan.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Article Critique
...?Article Critique Effective Malaria control involves more than just combating mosquitos. In the modern era, the side effects of the chemicals used tofight such vector borne diseases have become just as much important to be considered as fighting the diseases themselves. The debates on benefits versus risks of these chemicals have heated up more than ever. Of these chemicals, the most effective and arguably the largest life-saving chemical ever made by man against vector borne diseases is DDT. While it has been banned in most countries due to environmental and health concerns, its unparalleled efficiency and effectiveness have made it indispensible in the most badly affected of areas, like the Sub-Saharan...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
Article Critique
... number Critiques # Thomson, P., Ellison, L., Byrom, T., & Bulman, D., (March 2007). Invisible labor: Home-school relations and the front office. Gender and Education. 19, (2): 141-58. This article exposes a gaping hole in public relations studies in that it shows the high level of involvement the front office staff has in the school's public relations with the surrounding community and the low level of attention these staff members receive regarding training, payment, and during the recruitment process. It is widely recognized that the front office plays a very important role in establishing the school's approachability and in working with the parents, but the researchers point out that there has not been a great deal of research... in this...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Article Critique
...? Bibliographic Information Agbo, S. A. (2007). Addressing School-Community Relations in a Cross-Cultural Context: A Collaborative Action to Bridge the Gap between First Nations and the School. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 22(8). Article Review The article by Seth Agbo (2007) highlights a number of issues that are inherent in the public relations in schools. The article includes literature review of the research work already conducted on the topic and the opinions of other authors. The author also provides the details of the research conducted for the purpose of the thesis and gives an appropriate conclusion. According to the article, the effectiveness of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Article Critique
...?Longaretti, L., & Wilson, J. (2006). The impact of perceptions on conflict management. Educational Research Quarterly, 29(4), 3-15. Review of “The Impact of Perceptions On Conflict Management” For Educational Research Quarterly, Lynetti Longaretti and Jeni Wilson (2006) examine how the perception of conflict that primary school teachers and students have impacts the effectiveness of conflict management. While the statement seems self-evident, the very perception of the word conflict had an impact on whether conflict management was successful in the school in this study. The introduction of the article is thorough. The authors define what is meant by conflict and conflict resolution. They also identify the environment...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Article Critique
...? Article Critique TEA AND SYMPATHY Who owns the American Revolution? By Jill Lepore And No Thanks for the Memories By Gordon Woods University Name October 11, 2012 Introduction Conservatives have for over two years been heavily involved in a tea party insurrection which has created a dynamic protest movement in American politics which had suggested promises such as a complete remodeling of Washington, a slash in taxes, thereby closing the federal deficit. The tea Party movement had no lack of precedents or operating representations (Tanenhaus, 2012). The movement was definitely influential in the 2010 elections when republicans made huge gains in the house and Senate was able to secure victories with...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Article critique
...with increasing number of head-teachers who are opting for early retirement. Effective succession planning for selection and retention of head-teachers through leadership development programmes has become priority for UK government. The paper would critically analyze the article for the various issues and paradigms within the educational system that promote the need for government programmes. The initiatives are designed to create future educational leaders who would be able to fill the vacancies of senior school staff. Critique The article is highly relevant and gives deep insight into the developing crisis situation in UK schools which are faced with the huge problems of filling the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment
Article Critique
...? Article review of the of the Introduction Physical health is one of the most important aspects of human life. Healthy body not only ensures physical health but also ensures mental and emotional health. Hence, maintaining physical health is an important goal of human beings. However, to maintain good health, what is important is to eat food that is full of nutritious value. This is because all the components of human body, its activities and its defense system against the diseases, is built with the help of nutrients that it gets from the food that is eaten (Whitney & Rolfes, 2011, p.2). The food choices that people make decide how successfully the body handles all its functions and activities (Whitney & Rolfes, 2011,...
3 Pages(750 words)Article
Marrige
...? Marriage Table of Contents Part Summary 3 Part 2: Sociological Concepts Application 4 Part 3: Critical Evaluation and Implications 5 Appendix: Interview Questions 6 References 7 Part 1: Summary The customs and practices pertaining to marriage and the establishment of families, including the bearing and rearing of children, are complex for Fil-Americans, and show within those customs and practices tensions relating to the pull of Filipino traditions and the counter-pull of entrenched American norms. This is not to say that American norms for marriage and family are static, but that they are largely more liberal and more atomic compared to those for Fil-Americans. The findings include that marriage for Fil-Americans is largely... Marriage...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
Gay marrige
...the view that sexual orientation is not a matter of choice. The conservative opposition to gay marriages also claims that gay marriages are detrimental to social security and the well being of the children a gay couple may choose to raise. In this context I would like to quote a case cited by Rosato, J. in her article Same-Sex Marriage: For the Children (Human Rights Campaign website). An unmarried couple opted to have children from the egg donated by one of the partners. The couple raised the twins till their breakup. After the breakup the partner who was not biologically involved was not part of any rights or responsibilities towards the children. In this case as in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Gay marrige
...An Analysis of Alexandria Sage’s Article on Gay Marriage Alexandria Sage’s article on gay marriage aims to present the arguments of those who opposeand those who advocate the passage of Proposition 8 in California. Sage aims to present that for advocates of Proposition 8, they argue that the latter is not discriminatory against the gays and lesbians; they emphasize that “gays and lesbians have ample political power, with key politicians backing their goals, including same sex marriage” (Sage). Sage also emphasizes in her article that for opponents of Proposition 8, they question whether or not the US government and the US voters have a “reasonable justification for denying same-sex marriage, such as promoting healthier families... , or if...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan for FREE!
Contact Us