Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment - Dissertation Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Subject: Cruel and Unusual: The End of the Eighth Amendment Justice Brennan found that death penalty is unconstitutional. In Justice William Brennan’s words, capital punishment was “irrational, arbitrary and degrading to human dignity…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment"

Download file to see previous pages However, the punishment is applied on a trivial number of cases where it has been made compulsory. The punishment is irregularly and unfairly applied. In a country of over 200 people, the Justice Brennan observed that it was applied less than fifty people. As a result, the practice was perceived to be unconstitutional and prejudicial in the circumstances (Bigel, 59). The Justice concluded that the state is expected to confine the convicts in prison rather than kill them arbitrarily. The application of death penalty for the mentally retarded was considered to be unfair and cruel by the eight amendments. According to Justice Brennan, death treats members of human race in an inhumane manner (Bigel, 51). Capital punishment suggests that human beings can be used and discarded at will. In the Gregg v. Georgia case, it was observed that death in inconsistent with human rights. Justice William Brennan observed that even the vilest criminals were entitled to human rights and human dignity. Civilized treatment of human beings demands that the ultimate fate of a human being should not be made subject to human judgment (Bigel, 19). According to the premise of 8th amendment, the death penalty violates the premise of civilized treatment as guaranteed in the clause. According to Brennan, death penalty is cruel and should be classified as unusual form of punishment because it is prohibited by the clause. This formed the basis for stating that death punishment violates 8th and 14th amendment. According to Justice John Roberts, in the Baze verses Rees case, the pain experienced in the process of execution does not constitute unusual or cruel death. He argues that the pain is objectively tolerable risk. Justice john Roberts argued that punishment through execution was the most human method known in Kentucky and many other states. He disagreed with the notion that death penalty is a violation of 8th amendment because is cannot be perceived to be probative with regard to careless killing or infliction of pain (Bigel, 31). He acknowledged that the society is moving towards more humane forms of capital punishment. Death punishment challenges the evolving standards of human decency. The state is limited when it come to power over human life. According to Justice Potter Stewart, death punishment has a strong history of acceptance and is expected to apply to death row conflicts (Bigel, 39). The arguments against executions are challenged as emotional and unbalanced. Chief Justice Warren in the case of Trop verses Dulles argued that capital punishment does not violate the concept of cruelty as defined by the constitution in the United States. He argued that the punishment is imposed according to the enormity of the crimes or crime committed. The traditional penalties need to be observed and appreciated according to the law. The chief justice urged the legal fraternity to draw a demarcation through the 8th amendment to deal with the evolving decency standards that are expected to mark a shift of societal perception. However, he suggested that it may not be appropriate to dismiss death penalty in entirety. Capital punishment is said to enhance deterrence. Deterrence is the belief that the severity of a crime can discourage the members of the society from performing criminal acts. It has been argued that capital punishment is known to cause increased violence rather than reduce it (Bigel, 59). This is referred to as ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1”, n.d.)
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1. Retrieved from
(Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1)
Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1.
“Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment Dissertation - 1”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment

Eighth amendment of the US constitution

.... The murderer had pleaded that since he was 17 years old at the time of committing murder; he had not reached the age of majority. Consequently, he was not liable to be inflicted with the death penalty. He had also pleaded that eighth amendment also prohibits the infliction of the cruel and unusual punishments. Since capital punishment certainly comes under the definition of the cruel penalty, the issuing of such punishment was strictly against the statute of the US law. On the contrary, the plaintiff submitted that the Supreme Court had sustained death penalty at many occasions, on the basis of the nature and intensity of the crime on the one hand, and...
3 Pages(750 words)Thesis

Should lethal injection be considered cruel and unusual punishment

..., as it makes death more palatable, therefore would lead to more widespread use of the death penalty in general. Yet opponents of the death penalty are also for the procedure, as it makes it less likely that prisoners will suffer torture (Denno, 2002, p. 2). These are the broad reasons why both opponents and proponents of the death penalty are for and against lethal injection. However, regardless of whether or not lethal injection appears to be a humane way of execution, it does not necessarily mean that it passes muster under the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment. This paper will analyze whether the method of lethal injection should be...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Eight Amendment of the U.S. Constitution - Freedom from Cruel and unusual Punishment

...contradicting)(contradicting the Court's extension of the Amendment ``beyond all limits of history and precedent'' in emphasizing that there is no need to establish ``significant injury'' to prove sadistic and malicious beating of shackled prisoner is another form of cruel and unusual punishment). In the Rudolph v. Alabama, 375 U.S. 889 (1963), Justices Goldberg, Douglas, and Brennan, dissenting from a denial of certiorari, argued that the Court should have heard the case to consider whether the Constitution permitted the imposition of death ``on a convicted rapist who has neither taken nor endangered human life,'' and presented a line of argument questioning the general validity of the...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Does capital punishment equate to cruel and unusual punishment

...?Capital Punishment as a cruel and unusual punishment The controversies regarding capital punishments in the United s assumed newer dimensions with the Eighth amendment that guarded the citizens against cruel and unusual punishment. However, the question whether capital punishment equates to "cruel and unusual punishment?" needs to be answered. While the abolitionists oppose capital punishments on moral and human rights grounds, the proponents of capital punishments hold that there should be retributive justice in the nation. There are also researchers who hold that capital punishments act as the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Historical Background that Led to the Eighth Amendment

...Historical Background That Led To the Eighth Amendment The origin of the 8th Amendment is the English Bill of Right MagnaCarta principle, and which stated that punishments should fit the crime as a free individual should not be fined for petty offenses except based on the magnitude of the offense. The founding fathers used the Magna Carta principle that when it comes to great offenses, a man ought to be fined based on the enormity of the offense. The Massachusetts Bay colony sought to recognize human rights as they had knowledge of the English Bill of Rights which tried individuals for numerous acts of perjury that had resulted in lots of executions with no right to bail coupled with...
3 Pages(750 words)Coursework

Cruel and Unusual Punishment

...their opposition to capital punishment. This led to a drop in the number of executions. In the 1960s, the legality of capital punishment got challenged. Before 1960, the eighth, fifth and fourteen amendments were interpreted as having endorsed the death penalty. It was later suggested that the death penalty was unusual and cruel, and hence unconstitutional in accordance to the Eighth Amendment (Mandery 77). In 1985, the Supreme Court ruled that the 8th Amendment had an evolving standard of decency which marked progress of a society that was coming of age. This newly found decency no longer had room for the death penalty....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment

...? “Cruel and Unusual: The end of Eighth Amendment” Joan Dayan analyzes the severity of pain suffered by convicts throughout their period of confinement and a relief brought to them in the form Eighth Amendment. The Amendment was approved and included in Bill of Rights in 1791 as part of the US Constitution. It condemns the inhuman and unethical persecutions on the slaves captured. Precisely, evidences reveal that torture was beyond imagination as they were wounded both physically and mentally. Hence, the Amendment states “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed,...
3 Pages(750 words)Dissertation

Sentencing and the Eighth Amendment

...Sentencing and the Eighth Amendment Sentencing and the Eighth Amendment Question Currently, 344 individuals are serving life imprisonment in California for shoplifting a small amount of goods (Schmalleger, 2006). More than 650 people are serving life imprisonment for holding small quantities of narcotics. Such sentences are inhumane and make no rational sense. Especially in a country that prides itself on human courtesy, and with a charter that prohibits unusual and cruel punishment. This is not right. Question 2 The U.S Supreme Court denied certiorari in this case because it had to consider the accused previous offenses. The three...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Is the Texas Prison System cruel and unusual

...Is the Texas Prison System Cruel and Unusual? Clear, Todd et al. American Corrections in Brief. New York, NY: Cengage Learning. Print. Todd Clear is an experienced author in the field of prisons and correctional facilities. He has recently published three major books in the field having American Corrections in Brief being the most successful from the vast amount of data that it offers in the area. The fact that he is a lecturer at Rutgers School of Criminal Justice gives him a lot of credit in the field. In the book, he states that the numerous ill behaviors that have occurred under the purview of Texas Prison system leads a person to agree to the question rose. The following illumination will espouse...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

The change in Eighth Amendment cruel and unusual punishment standards in death penalty cases since Furman v. Georgia (1972)

...THE CHAGE IN EIGHTH AMENDMENT CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT STANDARDS IN DEATH PENALTY CASES SINCE FURMAN V. GEORGIA (1972) affiliation Abstract State legislation or congress describes capital punishment for capital crimes such as murder. The Supreme Court ruled out that death penalty should not be rates as a violation for the ban of eighth amendment on unusual and cruel punishment. The Eighth amendment shapes some procedural aspects based on when a court of law can use death penalty and how it needs to be conducted. The impact of the Due Process Clause on the 14th...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Dissertation on topic Cruel and Unusual. The End of the Eighth Amendment for FREE!

Contact Us