Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary relevance - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Over thirty, years have passed since Edward Said published his influential book, Orientalism, whereby he changed the vision of the Orient, which was been propagated across the Western knowledge. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Writing a Critique on Edward Saids Orientalism and its contemporary relevance
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary relevance"

Download file to see previous pages The assumptions made by Said brought a controversial debate that remains relevant even today. The Orientalism is a critique of the academic field of Oriental studies. This field has been a scholarly quest in a majority of the European universities for a number of centuries. Oriental Studies are a combination of scholarships consisting of ethnology, linguistics, philosophy, and decoding of culture via the detection, recovery, collection, and translation of Oriental texts. Said was categorical that his intentions were not to cover the whole area of Oriental studies, but to concentrate on how American, English, and French scholars view the Arab societies living in Middle East and North Africa (Trefflich 2011, p. 2). Said’s main concerns on Orientalism In the Orientalism, Said makes three main claims. The first claim is that, despite orientalist claiming to be an objective, non-interested, and an esoteric field, the truth is that it worked to serve political ends. In relation to this claim, Orientalist scholarship offered means that would help Europeans take over Oriental lands. Said further notes that, towards the final part of the twentieth century, Orientalism played a critical role in preserving American power in the Middle East and further defended the invasion and colonization of Palestine. However, in the contemporary world, there is less interest in the conventional fields of literature and philology. One fact that is worth mentioning is that American academic centers that offer Middle Eastern studies have immense concern in giving advice on public policy to the government (Said 1979, p. 31). In the second claim, Said argues that Orientalism assisted in defining Europe’s self-image. In relation to this claim, Said was of the opinion that creating an identity in every society and age entails establishing others and opposites. This is so because creating and maintaining each culture calls for the existence of a different and competing culture. Through Orientalism, the West began to perceive the Islamic culture as static in reference to time and place. In addition, the West also perceived the Islamic culture as uniform, foreign, and without the ability to define itself. In doing so, the West gained a sense of superiority in its culture and intellectual capacity (Said 1979, p. 36). As a result of this, the West perceived itself as innovative, dynamic, growing culture, and as an observer, a jury, and a judge of every Oriental behavior. Today, this claim becomes relevant since it offers an explanation for the Western imperialism, which could have been described by the West as an effort to redeem the degenerate world (Said 1979, p. 38). In the third claim, Said is of the opinion that Orientalism has created a false analysis of Islamic and Arab cultures. This is mainly due to the essentialist nature of the venture, which is the belief that there are possibilities of defining the essential characteristics of the Islamic culture and Arabic natives. The defined characteristics were viewed as uniformly negative. The definition brought out a perspective of a place in isolation from the mainstream of human development in arts, commerce, and sciences. This definition provides an inadequate perspective of Arabs and the Islamic culture, which by large influences the way the contemporary society views Arabs and Islam (Said 1979, p. 44). Orientalism further goes wrong in making an assumption that Islam has acquired a unity dating back from the seventh century and it is evident through the Koran and the contemporary Algerian, or Egyptian society. Therefore, the idea that Islamic culture suffers from static development is false and further overlooks the impacts of imperialism, colonialism, and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary Essay”, n.d.)
Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471470-writing-a-critique-on-edward-said-s-orientalism
(Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' And Its Contemporary Essay)
Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' And Its Contemporary Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471470-writing-a-critique-on-edward-said-s-orientalism.
“Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' And Its Contemporary Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471470-writing-a-critique-on-edward-said-s-orientalism.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary relevance

The Development of Christology and Its Relevance for Contemporary Christianity

...?Introduction Christology is one of Christian theological disciplines that comprehensively examine the development of the doctrine in various dimensions including its limitations and legitimacy. Since the inception of Christianity, the church proclaimed that reconciliation between man and God occurs only through Jesus Christ (Dunn 2003, 13). This pronouncement compelled the church to reexamine its faith to enhance the understanding of the doctrine. One of the most pertinent questions that originated from the proclamation is who exactly Jesus is in relation to the sinful man and God (Sung 2009, 32). It is through this interrogation that Christological doctrine developed. This paper examines the development...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

In What Ways Does What Edward Said Calls Orientalism Affect Art and Art History

...as literary theory. Said’s Orientalism was important in the creation of post-colonialism in art history as well as literary theory and he was instrumental in the new understanding of the term Orientalism. Whereas several other writers and thinkers had written histories of empire and colonialism, most of these writings were not post-colonial as they still proceeded from the point of view of the centre rather than the margin. The publication of Said’s Orientalism was central to the exact awareness of the concept and this work marks the opening of post-colonialism. The definition of the term Orientalism by...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Power and Knowledge In Edward Said's Orientalism

... and Egypt is somehow tinged and impressed with, violated by, the gross political fact - and yet that is what I am saying in this study of Orientalism. (Said 1995, p. 11) There is no direct dictate, of course, on the part of those representing political power; vice versa, the ideas of Orientalism are introduced subtly and imperceptibly, gradually becoming the common knowledge - and that is how the power reveals itself. All in all, throughout the book, E. Said emphasized the idea that even a sincere interest to the East in terms of its culture and traditions (knowledge) can eventually transform into political oppression (power). Works Cited Said, Edward W. Orientalism. New York: Penguin, 1995.... Power and Knowledge in Edward...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

INTRODUCTION from Edward Said's ' Orientalism'

...material. Discussing how the West has managed to maintain control over the East, Emmanuel Sivan indicates authors use “a method that prefers abstract generalities about the East, especially those that are based on texts that represent classic Eastern culture, over direct testimony from contemporary Oriental reality.”6 To distinguish how these texts establish their authority, Said indicates it is necessary to study the “style, figures of speech, setting, narrative devices, historical and social circumstances, not the correctness of the representation nor its fidelity to some great original”7 for evidence of the exteriority of the representation. Finally,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Edward Said Colonial Discourse Theory

...ideological concepts and its naïve attempts to understand its innately different value system through the Western epistemological precepts forms a major part of the book. Shalimar is only described from various points of view, often tethering on mysticism, while all the other major characters of the novel are well delineated through first person narratives. Rushdie succeeds in presenting multiple views regarding the birth of terror, but contests the Orientalist preconceived notions. By juxtaposing the contrastive elements of Eastern and Western view points and lifestyles, Rushdie digs out some ghosts from Said’s Orientalism that set in a trail of anti-colonial reactions...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Review about Orientalism by Edward Said

...Edward Said’s On Orientalism Edward Said is a well-respected philosopher and who’s most influential work is arguably his book On Orientalism. In this book, which was discussed in a movie by the same name, he brings up several points which shape the way we think about people from the East. Throughout the video, he highlights several points that make his ideas clear to the average viewer. After providing these several points, what stood out most to me as a viewer were the ideas that a lot of what we think we know of these people is actually incorrectly shaped by the media and that there may be many more people ‘there’ that want peace just...
7 Pages(1750 words)Movie Review

Edward Said article-- States

...9th February Assignment Palestine has always held a wondrous idea in people’s minds with respect to the conflict that it has been caught upwithin all these years and the manner in which people have still been carrying out their daily lives, albeit without ease, but with a sense of determination. In Edward Said’s States, the author takes time to emotionally map out the experiences that he underwent while being exiled out of Palestine, his homeland, and the physically as well as the mentally pressing issues that he felt. Even though he left the country as a child in order to avail of better opportunities, he finds himself in the midst of an identity crisis – something that many people around the world...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Critique Writing

...Critique writing Critique writing anxiety tends to increase during the last days of the semester. It is clear from the article that students flock University library during the end of semester so that they can study and prepare for final exams. For instance, n Texas Austin, the university library operates 24 hour to give students more time to study and prepare themselves. In an attempt to assist relieve the stress and depression that comes with finalizing the semester, stress-relieving lesions, and massage therapy are provided to students (Byrd, 2004). The emails and frequent visits to the lecturer focus on final exam and written papers or essays in Brazilian Portuguese language. Students tend to discuss with the lecturer about... their...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Edward Said on Orientalism

... Edward said on Orientalism On Orientalism is a short movie which is based on Edward Said’s discussion of main themes in his critically acclaimed scholarly work “Orientalism”. Orientalism refers to a set of preconceived notions which west and European nations hold about Middle Eastern and Muslim people. Said explains that Orientalism is the way Middle East is perceived in western society by authors, painters, media, and artists and gradually this perception assimilates in masses. It talks about Middle Eastern beliefs, and lifestyles without even knowing the facts...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

The Relationships Between Imperial Europe and Colonized East by Edward Said

...of empire’, Post-Soviet Affairs, vol.11, no.2, pp.149-84. Chatterjee, P 1986, Nationalist thought and colonial world: A derivative discourse, London: Zed Books. Emberley, J 1993, Thresholds of difference: Feminist critique, native women’s writing, postcolonial theory, Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Escobar, A 1995, Encountering development: The making and unmaking of the Third World, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Hafez, S 2004, ‘Edward Said’s intellectual legacy in the Arab world’, Journal of Palestine Studies, vol.XXXIII, no.3, pp.76-90. Huggan, G 2005, ‘(Not) reading Orientalism’, Research in African...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Writing a Critique on Edward Said's 'Orientalism' and its contemporary relevance for FREE!

Contact Us