Nobody downloaded yet

Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The week’s readings present a complex investigation in gender study. From an overarching perspective, this reaction paper argues that traditional means of examining gender in the Middle East are biased politically and culturally. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East"

Download file to see previous pages Subsequently, it is necessary to consider new epistemological frameworks for investigating gender in these regions. “How Not to Study Gender in the Middle East” contains a number of significant meta-critical insights into the process of gender study in the Middle East. The reading ultimately caused me to believe that gender study in the Middle East cannot be examined under a banner of ‘Middle East,’ but should be considered in terms of regional banners. Additionally, I now believe that one must now consider the histories intertwined with these regional divisions. Perhaps the most significant aspect of this vision of gender is that it functions to deconstruct the analytical discussion from one of simple genitalia, to one of complex and shifting and socio-dynamic political patterns. This critical representation of gender is one that has undoubtedly been implemented within the Western world. Still, I believe that within Western society, the emphasis on micro-political elements appears considerably less significant than in the divisive ‘Middle Eastern’ region. Indeed, the division between Western modes of gender analysis and Middle Eastern understandings is a critical interstice along which one cannot make ordinary one-to-one comparisons, but rather must implement a complex array of philosophical changes. The above argument is supported by Lazreg (1988) who further considers notions of gender within the East and West. While “How Not to Study Gender in the Middle East” indicates that Eastern and Western gender analysis requires separate epistemological frameworks, Lazreg argues that many of the same fallacies are implemented in both Eastern and Western analytical frameworks. Again, my reaction to these arguments is that as scholars we must continually examined our own political and cultural bias. When one considers Lazreg (1988) in conjunction with “How Not to Study Gender in the Middle East” it is clear that the works significantly augment each other. Specifically, ‘How Not to Study Gender’ meta-critically deconstructs the analytic framework, while Lazreg’s work establishes specific areas where this deconstruction occurs. Namely, Lazreg indicates that, “one's womanhood coincides with the realization that it has already been appropriated in one form or another by outsiders, women as well as men, experts in things Middle Eastern” (Lazreg 1988, p. 81). Abu-Lugod (2002) takes this a step further and argues that the analytical focus should not be centered on a gendered dialectic, but should instead focus on notions of human justice. I believe that the main significance of these findings is that they speak to a higher pragmatic knowledge about the way that critical practices have too emphatically used religion as a critical lens through which to judge Middle Eastern approaches to gender. In terms of the implementation of these new epistemological frameworks, there are a number of conclusions. I believe the most significant deconstruction is Abu-Lughod’s examination of the burqa in Afghan society. Even after the American ‘liberation’ of the region, Afghan women continued to wear the burqa to the consternation of American observers who had contextualized this in terms of patriarchal and oppressive dialectic. Instead, Abu-Lughod demonstrates that the burqa merely came to represent a modest form of fashion. This insight leads one to the recognition that, in large part, the Western critical lens may itself be politically motivated. For example, consider Abu-Lughod’s argument that one should not interpret the burqua as a limit of human agency. While this is a significant insight, it is even more relevant when considered in terms of the larger ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Essay”, n.d.)
Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1466262-reaction-paper-politically-and-culturally-biased-assumptions-regarding-gender-oppression-in-the-middle-east
(Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Essay)
Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1466262-reaction-paper-politically-and-culturally-biased-assumptions-regarding-gender-oppression-in-the-middle-east.
“Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1466262-reaction-paper-politically-and-culturally-biased-assumptions-regarding-gender-oppression-in-the-middle-east.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East

Gender inequalities in the Middle East

...? On addressing the impact of poverty and microfinance on gender/power relations and women’s empowerment, this study engraves itself into broader discourses and debates on gendered inequalities in the Middle East. Introducing the context that Saudi Arabia is an undisguised, self-evident patriarchal state, this study aims at investigating the positive and negative implications on female clients. By studying the microfinance initiatives and examining the underlying principles of Bab Rizq Jameel (BRJ), the positive and negative implication on female clients are analyzed, particularly in terms of its effects on their decision-making and bargaining power in the household. This...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Gender Oppression Glossary

...? Gender Oppression Glossary Marxist Feminism Marxist feminism can be explored based on two concepts ly Marxism and feminism. The former focuses on the class issues while the latter stresses the gender issues. Though combining the two concepts is somehow problematic, it can still be defined as the theory of gender and class that are needed to be studied and analyzed. That theory is essentially applied to the role of women in the society and family (Tijani 5). The interest was then revived in the 1960s together with other movements like the gay movement. Marxist feminism differs from other types of feminism as it focuses on the materialism as a way to explain...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Reaction Paper

...? Gender and Islam REACTION PAPER GENDER AND ISLAM Women and Gender in Islam is a book by Leila Ahmed that critically discusses the position of women in Islam. It is my opinion that the title does not encapsulate honesty and in full details what Leila Ahmed puts into the work. I found the piece very objective as it attempted to introduce the place of gender in Islamic history, rather than providing a view of Islamic history that attempts to serve political and ideological interests, like so many articles written by liberal Islamic women have. I found Ahmed’s contention that women are less empowered after Islam was founded...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Men & Women & Gender Oppression:

...Men & Women and Gender Oppression Naomi Wolf is a renowned and journalist who is famous for her post feminism book, The Beauty Myth. In this book, Naomi criticizes the way women are psychologically and physically abused based on the cultural myth of beauty. The society has put a lot of pressure on women, providing unattainable expectations of how women should look and behave just by virtue of being women. This gender oppression has taken a huge toll on women whom struggle to achieve this ‘ideal beauty’ that the society imposes on them. Deborah Tannen in her book, You Just Don’t Understand, agrees with Naomi that women are abused and...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Policy Paper Middle East

...: Civil War, Shiite community. One party state, chemical weapons. Background: Syria is situated in the south western part of Asia and is important on multiple accounts. One of these accounts is the neighborhood and demographic importance. Syria has its borders with Turkey, Israel and Lebanon. Hence the mere geography of Syria speaks of its strategic importance and mere turbulence in Syria would lead to the disturbance of balance in the entire region. Population of Syria makes up for around 22 million citizens and Syria is a multi cultural society that is relatively progressive in its outlook as compared to various other societies of the Middle East. Damascus is the capital city of the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Middle east

...territories. Military organizations such as Hamas were established as a response to the Israeli discriminatory authority. The Palestinians respond to this discrimination by launching attacks on Israeli territories. Military organizations such as Hamas were established as a response to the Israeli discriminatory authority. In conclusion, water is the main factor that caused the conflicts between the Israelis and the Palestinian. Middle East is a desert region and therefore the population mainly depends on underground water for domestic, agricultural and industrial use. Since the creation of the state of Israel, Israel officials have been accused of discrimination in distributing water resource in the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Gender in the Middle East

...have been introduced and these changes have allowed for some relief brought to women. Nevertheless, the patriarchal traditions and practices are still very much a major variable in Middle Eastern society. References Abirafeh, L. (2009), Gender and International Aid in Afghanistan: The Politics and Effects of Intervention, London, McFarland. Abu-Lughod, L. (2002) Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving? Anthropological Reflections on Cultural Relativism and its Others, 103 American Anthropologist 3, p. 783. Al-Hibri, A. (1982) A Study of Islamic Herstory: Or, How Did We Ever Get into This Mess? 5 Women Studies International Forum. Ayubi, N. (1996), Over-Stating the Arab...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Middle east

...Effects of Gas/Oil Production of the Middle East over the Past 50 Years Some of the main oil producers in the Middle East include Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Iran. Oil production is said to run almost everything and the production endeavors of these three nations has greatly influenced their success for the last couple of decades (Stevens 6). In these three countries, for instance, the countries has seen an improvement in their international relations with some of the most influential countries of the world such the United States, Britain, Germany and Russia among others. Russia, in particular, has made huge investments in Saudi Arabia to ensure that the future of oil...
1 Pages(250 words)Admission/Application Essay

Middle east

...Middle East and Number Paper Due Middle East The general impression on the Middle Eastern internal politics is that the same is interconnected within religious fundamentalism beyond national interest. This impression is partially correct because religious belief and internal politics are interconnected within the Middle Eastern context. Besides, this results in the growth of notorious fundamentalist/terrorist groups aiming to extend their influence beyond national boundaries. Within this context, the ISIS’s transformation from Al-Qaeda’s branch to the mastermind behind the formation of Islamic State is critical for the world nations because this transformation proves that extremism can swallow national politics. Thesis statement... : The...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Middle East

...Middle East: Women’s Rights and Veiling Practices Muslim women veil for different reasons. Drawing on the articles above, explain two different meanings for veiling. Be sure to provide an explanation of the foundation of each perspective. Why do various interpretations of veiling practices exist? The common meaning regarding veiling assumes a religious basis whereby according to Koran female gender ought to conceal their beauty except to certain people who include husbands and close members (Asser, 2006). Mostly, this to shun those of opposite gender sinning, which is utterly prohibited by Koran thus adherents especially women have no option but to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Reaction Paper: Politically and Culturally Biased Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East for FREE!

Contact Us