Nobody downloaded yet

The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture Although torture constitutes a barbaric act it remains prevalent in the modern world. As society has gained greater understanding in terms of psychology, methods of oppression, violence, and detention, it should be no surprise that the nature of torture has expanded…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture"

Download file to see previous pages One of the major concerns when considering the relation between the spectacle of detention centres and the spectacle of torture is the relative nature of the detention situation. In the case of asylum seekers it’s understood that the question of human rights becomes a question of the state. As rights constitute individuals as human subjects rather than as simply humans the question of detention as cruelty or torture becomes readily apparent. While such torture within the detention complex is complex, Zizek and Foucault consider how such an environment actually constitutes violence for the subject. For Zizek the detention center constitutes systematic, invisible, and indirect patterns of violence. Ultimately, the pervading notion is that torture is not simply a single dehumanizing act, but constitutes a wide range of violence towards the human subject. Another prominent concern is the nature of the spectacle torture as linked to the spectacle of detention in the modern world. For Foucault the nature of detention as torture, through his notion of panopticism, can be argued to be an essential aspect of social organization. One also considers Foucault’s notion of torture as spectacle in this context of understanding. In these regards, state actions against the human subject are not simply punitive or reform motivated, but structured in such a way as demonstrate the state’s power through a spectacle; in the modern state this spectacle show of power finds incarnation in detention centres. Lenta extends this discussion noting, “The possibility I want to consider is that something analogous might oc- cur nowadays if the power of a sovereign state is challenged, perhaps through attack, such that the state is rendered vulnerable or fragile” (Lenta 2006, pg. 54). This understanding sharpens and direct Foucault’s notion of the spectacle of torture. One considers the act of terrorism as a major act against the state through which the spectacle of detention is the response. Perhaps the most pronounced understanding of detention as torture emerges in a consideration of the architecture of the detention centre. In these regards, it’s been understood that the very nature of the detention centre is designed in a way as to exemplify a sinister darkness. One of the prominent concerns in these regards is the nature of the barbed wire surrounding modern detention centres. While the wire ostensibly constitutes the functional purpose of limiting prison escapes, it more accurately is implemented for the symbolic separating of the prisoner from the citizen. In these regards, the architecture of the detention center is constructed in such a way that dehumanizes the human subject. This is a form of violence that is comparable to an act of torture. A number of counter-objections have been raised against the notion that detention is unethical. In this context of understanding, one considers the ASIO act passed recently by the Australian parliament that allows governmental agencies to detain suspects for interrogation up to seven days. The argument that while the government may be violating human rights, these actions are ethically necessary as a means of preserving human lives. Although such an argument is sound, one still notes that even if the act of torture is undertaken for ethical reasons it remains a torturous act. In these ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of Essay”, n.d.)
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as
(The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay)
The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as.
“The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture

Torture

...? 24 February, Torture and its psychological aspect: The term “torture” has been derived from “torquere” which is a Latin term that means to twist (Gushee). Torture is the name of extreme mental or physical suffering that is inflicted upon an individual so that he/she may be intimidated, punished, or be made to make a confession for the presumably committed crime. Definition of torture offered by the United Nations Convention Against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (UNCAT) is, by far the most comprehensive and widely used definition. The definition also mentions several ways and reasons for which people may be...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Torture

...was so deeply dependent on slave labour, whether in chained gangs in the fields, or in craft and production in the cities, we cannot wonder that modern technological revolutions driven by reduction of labour costs had no place in their world. But while this offends against the core values on which the modern world is based, brutality and human rights abuses are not limited to the past. Enough to think of the stream of refugees struggling to break into the fortunate zones of Europe, and recall that the Roman empire collapsed in the West because of the relatively deprived struggling to get in, not out. Torture and Entertainment in Antiquity Torture has been widely used in the ancient world as a form of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Torture

...?Original Texts: Jeremy Waldron (http www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2007/oct/25/is-this-torture-necessary But trading off liberty against security has a treacherous logic. It beckons us in with easy cases—the trivial amount of freedom restricted when we are made to take our shoes off at the security checkpoint before we board an airplane is the price of an assurance that we will not be blown up by any imitators of Richard Reid. But it is also a logic that has been used to justify spying without a warrant, mass detentions, incarceration without trial, and abusive interrogation. In each case, we are told, some safeguards and rights that were formerly regarded as civil liberties have to be given up in...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Spectacle of Terror

...?Saturation of Visual Media Spectacle – The Spectacle of Terror The first element of power in the present world is media. The important point of consideration at this juncture is that media violence has been creating various problems in everyday life. The consequences of visual media, especially on children and young people have been an issue for debate even since the very introduction of mass media. Evidently, violence in the media negatively influences children and adolescents. Thus it calls for greater self-regulation and social consideration from the part of media people. Fiske (1989, p.127) says that represented violence is admired and accepted as it provides the people with points of significance in societies where the power... to lead...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Spectacle of Detention Centres is the Same as the Spectacle of Torture

...? THE SPECTACLE OF DETENTION CENTERS IS THE SAME AS THE SPECTACLEOF TORTURE Introduction Detention centers can be defined as the areas that are set aside for the purpose of holding convicts or suspects of any criminal nature. Normally these places bear conditions that are far from the normal conditions in the outside world. These places are characterized by lack of several forms of freedom that range from physical to social freedom. Hence this means that the spectacle of detention centers is the same as the spectacle of torture. This paper seeks to address the several...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Society of Spectacle/Hegel

...and guided by self-consciousness through subjective will, individuals often seek to justify what they term as right by exercising actions that appear to be right to them. Since consumers are not the same in terms of preference, the choice and actions of one consumer may offend or affect the choice and action of another consumer. This forms a basis of conflict among consumers. This results in a structure of consumers which seems to frustrate the aspect of human autonomy. This is because the conflict arising from consumer structure may hinder the freedom of each individual in the society. The actions and practices of consumers in pursuit of their freedom may be considered by the other members of the consumer circle as...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Torture

...?License to Torture: Dershowitz vs Scarry Introduction As a rule, torture is presumably one of those issues liberal societies are most averse to. However, in the light of several major acts of terror that have occurred a relatively short time ago and claimed thousands of lives in America and Europe alone, the use of torture as a means to obtain vital information, which would prevent destruction on a massive scale and save human life, became more or less a standard practice of the respective security services. Correspondingly, it’s increasingly becoming a focus of the public debate. Being considered of crucial importance to both the very existence of liberal states and societies and regard...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Involuntary Detention

...will not allow psychiatrists to restrict the liberty of patients to refuse treatment on the basis of potential danger alone. Only in the cases of patients who repeat the same patterns of dangerous behaviour and which respond favourably to psychiatric treatment but have reoccurrence of these behaviours when the patient discontinues such treatment may there be justification in treating a patient against his will on a preventive basis. La Fond (1992) remarks that: "States may use police power to enact laws empowering public officials to forcibly confine any citizen considered mentally ill and dangerous to others or to himself. In modern times this special system of social control, which amounts to 'preventive...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Torture

...torture by using the same tactics as the Taliban and al-Qaeda, then we become no different than the ones we oppose. Terrorism has spread fear among Americans. Our citizens have desperately tried to justify the means of torture. The ticking bomb scenario, which implies that torture should be used to gain useful information that may prevent the possible loss of many lives, is just a scenario. It is a tactic used to persuade fearful Americans that torture is necessary. In discussing the fear of Americans, Porter states, "It is to be hoped that their very understandable fears do not lead to a further deterioration of human rights."5 Common sense and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Chinas Urbanization as a Spectacle

...in the architectures (Campanella, 2008; Ren, 2011). The skyscrapers are a depiction of a deteriorating culture and a mere cover up of a failing economy. The developments led to vast migration from the rural areas to urban centres to an extent that the urban population overtook that in the rural areas. From the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese culture started depreciating and in the next few years, the culture might become extinct (Wing, 2009). One of the consequences of development of spectacle city is the increased abuse of Labour rights with the migrants into the metropolis earning meagre wages while working in poor working conditions. The mass migration is expected to cause immerse strains in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture for FREE!

Contact Us