StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Native American Beliefs and Goals of Development - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper "Native American Beliefs and Goals of Development" looks into the causes of the conflicts between various races and cultural groups and try to understand their causes and the role that can be played by Native American tribes in the resolution of this conflict…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Native American Beliefs and Goals of Development
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Native American Beliefs and Goals of Development"

?RUNNING HEAD: NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT Sensitivity to Native American beliefs and their conflict with goals of development Note Name, Department, University, Correspondence address. NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 2 Sensitivity to Native American Beliefs The United States of America has been described as the melting pot of various cultures by many. Various races and cultural groups have made it their home and the general impression that the administration would have the world believe is that of a nation that is genuinely one where these groups exist peacefully. However, this is not always the case as the goals of development are in constant conflict with the interests of people of different ethnicities. The case of the hydroelectric projects that came up in America during the 1950s and 60s is a case in point. The building of dams such as the Grand Coulee Dam and the Garrison Dam at sites that were earlier graveyards of Native American tribes indicates insensitivity to the needs of groups that are in a minority. Apart from this, it also reminds one of the cruel colonial past of the United States of America, the foundation of which required the wiping out of entire tribes that were native to this area. This paper shall look into the causes of such conflicts and try to understand their causes and also the role that can be played by Native American tribes in the resolution of this conflict. The United States of America had announced a change from its earlier policy of providing a certain special status to them, from the mid 1940s to the middle of the 60s. It then advocated an approach that would enable the tribes to become a part of the mainstream as NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 3 individual members and not as a collective that would maintain its identity. As a part of this policy, which was called the Indian Termination Policy, Native Americans would be made subject to the state laws and would have to pay the taxes that normal Americans had to. This, on the surface, may seem like a broad-minded approach to preserving the integrity of the nation; however, it is not only short-sighted but also problematic when one considers the fact that this would mean the erasure of the history and the culture that the Native American tribes believed in and the ways of life that they followed. Relevant to the purpose of this paper is the clause in the acts that were formulated during this period according to which a lot of land lost the protected status that was granted to it earlier. As a result, it became possible for a lot of land that was considered sacred by certain Native American tribes to be acquired for the purposes of constructing dams and other buildings. This created a lot of tension between the tribes and the government and a lot of the tribes took to approaching the judiciary as a means of redressing their grievances. This led to long drawn out battles that ended in some tribes regaining the sovereignty that they had lost to the government. However, their lands which had been sites of burial had already been lost to huge hydroelectric projects that could not be displaced. This gives rise to the question as to where the fault lies and to whether the question could have been dealt with in a better manner. The question of whether the rights of the tribes could have coexisted with that of the goals of development is a significant NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 4 one since the answer may be able to provide directions and guidelines for the future that may enable lesser conflicts arising from insensitivity to the concerns of various ethnicities. Establishment of dams leads to the displacement of people from their traditional ways of living that is based on the flora and fauna of the particular place in which they live. Displacement from these regions leads to trauma that accompanies the loss of identity that these people face as a result of the loss of the modes of living that they are used to. The rights of the tribes over their land is something that is a cause championed by people like Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak who place great emphasis on the creation of a voice for the subaltern groups that are at the mercy of their governments which are run by people who are not interested in their empowerment. It was owing to the politics of pressure that majority groups are able to exert on individual governments that legislation was pushed through in order to remove burial sites of the Native American tribes from the list of places that enjoyed a ‘protected’ status. As a result of this policy, however, there was no appreciable gain in the stature that America enjoys and the international standing that it has as a protector of human rights has only improved after the enforcement of legislation that seeks to reverse the laws that were created under the Indian Termination Policy. This led to the enforcement of a policy that encourages self-governance, a new policy that allows tribes to develop their businesses and gives incentives for the preservation of tribal Indian culture (Kessel 64, 2005). This increased autonomy was welcomed by the tribes that were native to America. NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 5 A part of the reason as to why the policy of termination failed was because certain tribes recognized the need for tribal unity to survive in the new dispensation (Waldman 55, 2006). The position of the tribes within the crisis is thus not free from its own politics of power. Larger tribes have a greater say in negotiations and power politics plays a role within the group of tribes as well. This results in a complex situation where both parties are not clear about their position. It is thus important that both the government and the ethnic groups involved conduct negotiations based on the concerns of their beliefs and goals of development rather than that of power equations within each group. The concern that the tribes may have, related to the insensitivity to their sites of burial may be explained by referring to the theory of the archive that Jacques Derrida propounded. Derrida claimed that the archive was a site where a memory could be stored as a means of authorizing certain groups that derive their validation from the archive that in turn derives its authority from its geographical location as well (Derrida, 1995). The sites of burial thus may be termed as forms of archives. An attempt to demolish these sites would be tantamount to an obliteration of the history that is formed with the help of these archives. The aim of the government too, may have been the same. The aim of creating a uniform society without any cultural ethnic differences through the destruction of the cultural symbols of marginalized communities has time and again proved to be counter-productive and seems to be the real cause NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 6 of terrorism and insurgency in many parts of the world. An attack on the community’s sense of identity fostered through symbols that are archives that help rebuild centuries of ancestry, it is important that these steps are not taken without the consent of the concerned group. Such steps may be necessary for the purpose of development of the larger community and all groups concerned must be ready to make concessions. However, it is only by taking these groups into confidence and reassuring them about the protected status of their holdings of land that it is possible to achieve the growth targets that are set for an economy and for a community. The tribes that are a part of America have had a history that reeks of intense marginalization. Their integration, however, cannot be achieved through a denigration of their history that would further marginalize them. Integration, however, would require compromises from both sides, which ensures the protection of sacred sites while members of native tribes take up employment in the mainstream which may be provided them under special schemes. Such incentives may offer them incentives to get integrated into the mainstream. Since the philosophy of a federation implies the coexistence of many groups as a single unit while maintaining the individuality of each, the integration of the tribes as a group makes sense. The tribes are groups which feel a sense having being wronged and have mistrust towards the other races in America, not only in the United States of America but also in other North American nations like Canada. This is because of the genocide that happened during the colonial past of the federation and the NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 7 marginalization of the tribal communities that followed. This needs to be remedied. The balancing of the needs of development with the aims of integration is possible and is what is needed for the unity of the federation. The insensitivity that was once demonstrated by a section of the American government by positioning hydroelectric projects where burial sites of the Native American tribes were located is now absent in the creation of policies, with the protected status being restored to these sites. There needs to be such policy decisions to maintain the unity of a multicultural multilingual federation. NATIVE AMERICAN BELIEFS AND DEVELOPMENT 8 Works Cited Kessel, William B; Wooster, Robert. (2005). Encyclopedia of Native American wars and warfare. New York: Book Builders LLC. Print. p. 64. Waldman, Carl. (2006). Encyclopedia of Native American tribes. New York: Checkmark Books. Print. p. 55 Derrida, Jacques. (1998). Archive Fever: A Freudian Impression. Tr. Eric Prenowitz. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Print. Jones, Lisa. “A Dam Brings a Flood of Diabetes to Three Tribes”. The Crisis Jones Report. Accessed on 15th July, 2011. Grand Coulee Dam -- Native American Culture Was Destroyed, Forgotten. The Seattle Times. Accessed on 16th July, 2011. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Sensitivity to Native American Beliefs and Their Conflict with Goals Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1428120-sensitivity-to-native-americans-to-protect-their
(Sensitivity to Native American Beliefs and Their Conflict With Goals Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1428120-sensitivity-to-native-americans-to-protect-their.
“Sensitivity to Native American Beliefs and Their Conflict With Goals Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1428120-sensitivity-to-native-americans-to-protect-their.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Native American Beliefs and Goals of Development

The Contrast of Bradford and Franklin

Thomas Jefferson and Mary Rowlandson had different experiences and goals in life, although they both hold strong spiritual beliefs.... Hence, he advocates that America will prosper more as an autonomous nation than as a colony, because it will attain peace and focus on economic development.... In 1753, he became the joint postmaster general for all the american colonies.... Thomas Paine and Anne Bradstreet both embarked to the american colonies and were well-known writers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Religion of the Native Americans

hellip; According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that beliefs and practices of Native Americans form a seamless part of their very essence and their style of life.... beliefs and practices of Native Americans form a seamless part of their very essence and their style of life.... tm Summary beliefs and practices of Native Americans form a seamless part of their very essence and their style of life.... native american spirituality is not regarded as a religion in the full meaning of this word....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Early Inhabitants of the Americas

As such, the United States is extending various development programs to Africa with the hope of neutralizing China's presence (Jones, 70).... On various occasions, the United States has used such proxy wars involving natives in achieving some of its goals.... Countries like England, Portugal, and France were envious of Spain on the great wealth it got from the american and this led to the fight for control of the colonial lands.... The political and religious activities in Europe had profound effects on the lives of the native Americans as the European countries sought to acquire resources in foreign lands....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Immigrant Stories Critique

In this case, this problem is presented in the form of the problems facing the families living outside their main stream social construct of the native american culture.... The immigrant families struggle to cope with the american culture.... hellip; Kingston, Mukherjee, Gish, Lahiri, and Jhumpa, where Asian women writers who narrated their lives in american as immigrants....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A Voyage Long and Strange by Hortwiz

Through these movements, Eirik establishes trade with Europe that led to the development of the trade in luxury goods.... The wife considered Eirik a pagan due to the religious beliefs prevalent then.... It deals with the discussion of the different encounters through which the different people interacted and led to the settling of many other people in the area that led to the formation of the discovery of… The details of this research work dwell on the contrasting and comparison of the different encounters between the native Americans and the Europeans, the interactions between the different races ranging from the English, the French and other Spanish explorers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

The Indigenous Population in the USA

For instance, the native american population in the American continent, especially in the USA is the original inhabitants or the owners of the land.... The paper "The Indigenous Population in the USA" describes that coordination and cooperation among public and private agencies within american health care scenario plays an important role in the success of its health systems/ services for the Native Americans.... The federal government shows keen interest and attentiveness to help the indigenous population to be part of the mainstream of american society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Proposal

Sensitivity to Native American Beliefs

It then advocated an approach that would enable the tribes to become a part of the mainstream as   native american beliefs and DEVELOPMENT                                                       3 Individual members and not as a collective that would maintain its identity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Cross-Cultural Research, Values and Beliefs

Hence, in order to sustain and to create enhanced business prospects, development of an urge for the organizations to gain a better comprehension of the different business cultural practices in other corners of the world has been noted.... The reporter stated that cross-culture relates to the interaction of people or a group of people sharing a particular culture or values and beliefs with the people belonging to other cultures in a global environment....
15 Pages (3750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us