Nobody downloaded yet

In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Sociology Date: June 15, 2011 In Support of Olympic Judging Objectivity This paper will argue in support of the proposition that: Because of the intrusion of politics in judging such events as gymnastics, the Olympic games should consist only of sports decided objectively, by times, goals, and points…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity"

Download file to see previous pages The fourth assumption is that more objective judging is better than more subjective judging at Olympic events. This paper will treat each of these four assumptions as sequential arguments which, once explained, will provide a case for the support of this proposition. Politics has been intruding into the judging of some Olympic events. Straight Dope’s message board (Adams, 2011) asked posters for mentions of particularly controversial Olympic judging subjectivity. The posted responses were international in scope and covered a number of sporting events, with considerable repetition. Examples of cited controversies with political allegations included; the Gold medal basketball game between Americans and Soviets, at the 1972 Summer Olympics, in which officials repeatedly re-set the clock in alleged bias against the Americans an Olympic fighting event in which obvious bias by bribed judges (later suspended) was shown against the Americans and in favor of the South Koreans, in the 1988 Summer Olympics in Seoul an ice-dancing event in 1998, in which bias against the Canadians, due to corruption and collusion among 3 judges, was proven judging scandals in the 2002 pairs figure skating event and in the women’s ice hockey final a 2004 men’s gymnastics controversy Research examining Olympic judge bias in figure-skating events from 1948 to 2002, during and after the Cold War, found that three factors influenced scoring: performance quality based on shared standards, national identity and patriotic self-interest, and the status of skater national identities (friend, rival, enemy) (Sala, Scott, Spriggs, 2007). Our first argument, that politics has been intruding into the judging of some Olympic events, clearly has merit. Our second argument is that this political intrusion is something that should be corrected. This preference is clearly expressed on message board postings, but is also expressed by sporting experts who are responsible for formally managing event judging. News accounts abound about the embarrassment caused by politically biased judging, and there have been inquiries and suspensions in various scandals, obviously aimed at discouraging nationalistic bias. In one particularly memorable case, the whole entire Soviet judging core was suspended for nationalistic bias, in 1978-79 (Sala, Scott, Spriggs, 2007). Another type of example is the report by the FEI Dressage Task Force (DTF). The DTF was founded with international representation, in response to judging controversies at the 2008 Olympics. The 50 page report refers to judging as the “most emotional issue in the sport”, and they recommend assessment, evaluation, education, clear position guidelines, and check and balance for judges, in order to maximize ethical judging of their sport (Braddick, 2009). The third argument of our proposition is that the emphasis of times, goals, and points, in judging Olympic events, will lead to less subjective, more objective judging. Certainly this argument is a sensible one for the modern era, in which the greatest respect is reserved for science. The baseline mythology of modern science is that subjective truth is not consensual, non-replicable, disorganized, inaccurate, too often based on emotion and superstition. The scientific method is embraced as a way to struggle toward objectivity and consensus. We ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging
(In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging.
“In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity

Original Olympic Games

...Original Olympic Games Introduction: The history of Olympics is far more interesting and intriguing than anyone would imagine it to be. The role played by the Olympic events in the ancient Greece was in contrast from what it contributes today. This owes mainly to the difference in the underlying notion and the laying foundation between the two sets of events, separated by centuries of time span. Although, the spirit by which this festival was revived again in this present world involves replicating that same concept on which ancient Olympics originated. But unfortunately the cloning was not successful due to insufficient data and absence of actual...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

History of olympic games

...AD, virgins were allowed entry to the Olympic Games as spectators. But for the married women traced watching the game, it was inviting death. They would be thrown off the cliff at Mount Trypeum. Punishment for cheating was almost instant. Judges carried a switch to beat the frauds they were able to catch. Those who indulged in malpractices were fined and bribery and fixing of bets were punishable offences. Complaints regarding corruption were properly investigated and punishment was severe. The participating athletes mostly did not receive any monetary rewards but were hailed as the proud boys of the city. Sometimes, olive oil, and vases were given as prizes. Star...
3 Pages(750 words)Term Paper

The Olympic Games

...The Olympic Games The Olympic Games have its origins in Greece, in the 8th century, around 3,000 years ago. The birthplace of the games was Olympia, the city which hosted the first known games and so the name Olympics got coined. Mythology is frequently associated with the history of the Games. “Like so much of ancient history, the origins of the Olympic Games are shrouded in myth and legend” (Gill). Unfortunately, that time was filled with war, local combats and battles. To assure safe commuting of athletes and audience, to and from the sites of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

London 2012 Olympic Games

...for watching the games. Additionally, tickets to various games should be priced differently. Games or sports having incredibly many fans should have priced relatively high so as to maximize profits and also reduce the chances of overcrowding. On the other hand, games and sports having limited number of fans should be priced relatively low to ensure that seats are never left empty, at any moment of the game. It is also fundamental not to sell tickets to individuals who have the intention or potential to cause disturbances or chaos in stadiums. This is possible by doing some background check on fans thus denying the ones possessing any form of chaotic...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

The Olympic Games

...English 101 The Olympic Games Tracing their roots all the way back to Ancient Greece, the Olympic Games have become oneof the most renowned competitions in the world. The games started over 2000 years ago, bringing locals and regional countries into competition grounds (Young 84). Today, Olympic Games are a worldwide event, encompassing not only competition by participants, but also commercial events by local and international individuals, firms, corporates and governments. These games have taken diverse and dynamic positions throughout the years, to become an internationally anticipated event after...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

2012 London Olympic Games

...Explanation and analysis of the London Olympic Games BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE HERE Explanation and analysis of the London Olympic Games Outline of the event On August 10, 2012, the Great Britain women’s hockey team was pitted against the New Zealand women’s team at Olympic Park. Tickets for this event, the deciding match that would determine bronze medal status for the loser, were fully promoted for the historical opportunities in advancing women’s hockey as well as the inability of Great Britain to achieve a medal in this sport since 1992 (IHF 2013). When tickets were initially put on sale, there was little promotion involving national pride or...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Olympic games

...in the Olympic Games to enjoy a harmonious environment. The tradition also had an objective to allow foreigners into the nation and travel back safely. Due to this peaceful environment, foreigners would come to Ancient Greece; enjoy the Olympic Games and travel home safely (Toohey, 19). In 1896, the other nations realized the essence of the Olympic Games culture. Other nations adopted the Olympic Games culture due to its peaceful objective in Ancient Greece. In this case, other nations adopted the Olympic Games culture as a strategy of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Transforming of Olympic Games

...Transforming of Olympic Games The concept of Olympic Games was taken by Baron Coubertin from the British history of gaming festivals, ly the Wenlock Olympian Society Annual Games. All sports historians acknowledge the impact of the Wenlock Games on the modern Olympic movement. The word ‘Olympian Class’ was first used in the Wenlock Games to show the overall betterment of the people of the Town and its neighbourhood. Thus, from its inception, the tradition of old Greece was imbibed by the organisers (Coubertin, 1890). Budgetary transformation has been one of the leading factors. The...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Boston 2024 Olympic Games

...(Bednar, 2015). Last but not the least, some advertisers may not find it worthwhile to sponsor the Games. There were 600 sponsors in the Montreal Games. The lesser known companies simply got lost in the crowd. Support from Locals The organizers will have to pull up their socks and garner support of the local public if they intend to host the 2024 Olympic Games in Boston. Latest surveys reveal that 52 percent of the local population is against the Games while only 36 percent back the hosting of the Olympic Games in Boston. Cost, transparency and inadequacy of infrastructure are being...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

The Olympic Games

...Stadium in Egypt, and Salt Lake Stadium and Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium both in India. This selection adhered to the PESTLE method of analysis. The initials PESTLE in PESTLE analysis stand for Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal and Environmental conditions of a country. It as such represents the process of analyzing and auditing a country’s external and internal environmental influences with the main objective of using the results obtained from this analysis for effective decision making (Jameson, 1997:5). In this case, the method used in the selection of the best six countries that suit the location of the youth Olympic Games in the year 2015....
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity for FREE!

Contact Us