Nobody downloaded yet

Ethical decisions in leadership - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In the given case, Karen Hathaway is confused as to who is to be selected for promotion from three potential candidates. While one is a male with excellent track record and long years of service in the company, one is an African-American divorcee woman who too possesses considerably high energy levels. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Ethical decisions in leadership
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Ethical decisions in leadership"

Download file to see previous pages In the given case, Karen Hathaway is confused as to who is to be selected for promotion from three potential candidates. While one is a male with excellent track record and long years of service in the company, one is an African-American divorcee woman who too possesses considerably high energy levels. The third one is an Asian woman with dynamic management efficacies. The issue to be addressed here is to decide who is to be selected when there are three equally important candidates and out of them, two are minority women who deserve affirmative action (Garrett, 2009). In addition, all three have almost equal levels of support from top-management. Input At this juncture, it is necessary to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each of these candidates. First of all, Carmen is considered. Carmen is an African-American woman of 34. She is a divorcee and has a child. She has four years of experience in the company and eight years experience in the industry. However, she has below average educational record and an average work performance as a manager. She has certain problems in managing her staff, but as her child has medical problems, promotion will be helpful for her as there will be higher salary. Karen Hathaway is close to her, and is well aware of her financial needs. In addition, the public relations of the company feel that promoting Carmen would be a good idea. The second person is Ralph- a white married man of 57 having three children. He has excellent educational record and has long years of work experience in the company. He worked 20 years for the company and was consistent in his performance all these years. Though he possesses below average energy levels, many top performers of the company took birth under him. In addition, as he is nearing retirement, many people in the company believe that he deserves the promotion. The third person is Yingzi. She is an Asian woman of 27 and is single. She has excellent academic records. She has been with the company for three years and over this period, she has become famous for hard work and special management features. She has been dynamic throughout her career and even sued her previous employer. In addition, she has gained some criticism from the sales people working under her for her particular management style though she managed to reach record sales. However, she too receives support from top management people as she is engaged to an upper management individual’s son. The first issue to be addressed here is that of affirmative action. One is an African-American divorcee, and even the public relations of the company think that this would certainly give a boost to the public image of the company. In addition, Kant’s theory of categorical imperative (n.d.) calls for specialized attention towards females and minorities. In addition, it is generally alleged that females and minorities always face a glass ceiling when it comes to promotion to top management. However, in the field of management, the general notion is that it is necessary to give equal opportunity to candidates when considering for promotion. No factor including race or ethnicity should influence the decision making other than factors like ability and willingness to perform work. It is claimed that including other factors like gender and ethnicity will lead to the development of an unhealthy workplace. In addition, regarding affirmative action (as suggested in ‘Manager’s Guide to Understanding Affirmative Action’, 1996), the rule is that affirmative action does not mean that preference should be given based on a person’s minority or female status. In addition, it is pointed out that affirmative action does not require selecting an unqualified person for a position. Thus, in this particular case, it becomes evident that the two female managers do not need to be given special priority as far as their educational qualification, experience, performance, and skill are different. In addition, it ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Ethical decisions in leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Ethical Decisions in Leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
“Ethical Decisions in Leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical decisions in leadership

Case Study-Ethical Decisions

...? Ethical Decisions (Add (Add (Add According to Pollock p.16), the different stages in clarifying a dilemma identify the facts, relevant values and concepts, all possible moral dilemmas, decide the most immediate ethical issues and resolve the ethical dilemma using an ethical system. I Admittedly, Robert has a dilemma as the chair of the parole board. Either he has to relax the parole eligibility criteria to let more inmates to be released to community-based supervision or should keep the criteria intact and let the Federal government find a solution to the overcrowding. Evidently, Robert is convinced that a further relaxation in the parole eligibility...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Ethical Decisions

...Ethical Decisions A mankind owes duties to both the past and future generations being a link between the past and the future. On the one hand, wehave duties to our children concerning environment, technology and scientific developments. The main duty of our generation is to reduce global warming and environmental pollution. While the current generation enjoys a rather high living standard from the combustion of fossil fuels, future generations will have to suffer from global warming, diseases caused by environmental pollution and other problems related to the atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. The economic and social conditions surrounding us continuously evolve, new...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

ETHICAL DECISIONS IN LEADERSHIP an intensive hardworking Asian. Always among the top students of her class she has provided the company with record performances in the past. Moreover she is engaged to an upper management person’s son, who is intent on getting her promoted. Narrowing it down, the problem that Lael faces is: ‘Taking the best ethical decision without jeopardizing her career’ Input As Lael is a woman she is pressurized by everyone with power. The main reason upper management employees keep pushing her for their respective favorites in case of this promotion, is because they all think they can bend her according to their will, as she is a woman. If she goes against their will, they can do great harm to her career in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper


...:// glass-ceiling-or-glass-mirror-.asp. Susca, D. (2006). Making ethical business decisions. CBIA News 84 (6). Retrieved January 18, 2010 from 200607cs_ makeethicalbizdecisions.htm. Strauss, E. (2010). The glass ceiling: Women and barriers in the workplace. Associated Content. Retrieved January 18, 2010 from the_glass_ceiling_women_and_barriers.html?cat=3. Thornton, L.F. (2009). Leadership ethics training: Why is it so hard to get it right? T&D, 63 (9). p. 58-61. Retrieved January 19, 2010 from...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Ethical Decisions in Leadership Class

...Ethical Decisions in Leadership: PISCO Analysis Problem I am Lael Mathews and am currently the Human Resource Manager at a Fortune 500 Company in New York, New York. This report is a PISCO assessment I developed to ethically aid in determining which of a series of candidates the company should promote to a recently made available Supervisory position. The dilemma is complicated by the fact that this promotion is essential to the internal and external reputation of the company. The candidates have been narrowed down to three internal employees, who have varying experience levels, education, and levels of support among upper-level corporate executives. The essential...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


...An Ethical Dilemma < of of assignment> of OLS 26300 An Ethical Dilemma Problem The problem of Lucy Matthews revolves around the classic dilemma of promotion. There are three candidates for the position, all seemingly meritorious although in different capacities, including intellectual ability, drive and competence, leadership skills, seniority, performance, and personal circumstances. There are both advantages and disadvantages in the choice of any one of them, and some very highly regarded interests have vested in the all of them and made themselves known to Lucy. The decision to be made has more profound implications than that of a mere promotion, because of the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper


...An Ethical Dilemma* Introduction: Leadership is defined as “influence, the art or process of influencing people so that they will strive willingly and enthusiastically toward the achievement of group goals” (Koonz and Weihrich 437). It is also true that leaders face ethical dilemma while influencing people. The case under review presents one such scenario where the leader (Lucy) faces a precarious situation. This has been examined by using PISCO model which stands for Problem, Input, Solution, Choice and Operation. Problem: The problem here is Lucy has three candidates considered for promotion. The first one is Liz, an African American with the company for five years. Here performance...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Ethical Decisions

...Introduction In the business sector, decisions made should be transparent and ethical. Transparency helps to build confidence among workers thus boosting their working morale. On the other hand, these decisions should be ethical in order to ensure that there is fairness, and the common good is achieved by the decision. It is vital for every company to establish a strong code of ethics which should be used in the company’s decision making process. This enables the company to work efficiently under common good thus ensuring fairness. These ethics help to ensure a smooth decision making...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Ethical Decisions and Pluralism the fact that it requires one to take into consideration what others may consider wrong or right. Part Two According to Bates 2006, the best way to allocate resource in a democratic society is through application of social justice. The corpus of social justice values the existence of diversity in a society, where people have a common sense of humanity, thus are subjected to equitable treatment (Bates, 2006). On the other hand, the best way to allocate resources within an organization is through strategic resource allocation: Strategic resource allocation takes into consideration the operational strategies of an organization (Hergert, 2012). References Bates, R. (2006). Educational administration and social justice....
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Ethical Decisions in Leadership

...Ethical Decisions in LeadershipDecision making at the top level of an organization is always difficult especially when deciding about promotions. Even for a single higher position, there would be more than one eligible candidate. Logics and ethics are often influence the decision making process of promotions. However, which should be given more preference; logics or ethics, is a big question the top management should address while taking such decisions. Some of the candidates who are seeking promotions may have more experience while the others may have more abilities. Some of them may have sound...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Ethical decisions in leadership for FREE!

Contact Us