Nobody downloaded yet

Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma Essay Name of of Professor Table of Contents Section Title Page Number Introduction 3 The Debate 4 Comparison between Western Societies 6 Parental Rights and Corporal Punishment 11 Conclusions 14 Introduction Even though corporal punishment has been prohibited in numerous countries, there are still many where in it is prevalent, in fact approved by the public as a means to discipline children…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma"

Download file to see previous pages On the contrary, the punishments against a parent physically hurting a child at home are much less harsh. Corporal punishment in the home is currently unlawful in several countries, although this was much more difficult to establish as a law than a prohibition on corporal punishment in schools.1 However, the state will usually not intervene and prosecute unless the physical punishment was of a much more severe nature. Definitely mild spanking would not be considered as reasonable basis for prosecuting the parent.2 Approval of corporal punishment can differ because of cultural values and traditions. Cultural approval of corporal punishment seems to be deeply rooted in some Western countries like United States and the UK that parents who do not exercise it as way of disciplining their children feel compelled to either say they do use it even they do not or justify why they refuse to do so.3 Some researchers discovered that parents who refuse to use corporal punishment “tended to avoid the problem by recasting things in a culturally acceptable way, for example, by saying that they only spank ‘when necessary’ and leaving out the fact that they never found it necessary”.4 This essay analyses and discusses the clashing views amongst society about whether or not corporal punishment against children should be allowed in the modern day and era. The Debate The exercise of corporal punishment is one of the most debated traditions of parenting. Even though the impact of corporal punishment on children remains under extensive empirical investigation, less emphasis has been given on why parents physically punish their children in the first place. Existing studies show that the causes of corporal punishment are diverse, including parental traits and values, child attributes, cultural standards, and so on.5 In Western countries, such as the United States, UK, and Australia, the idea of the ‘bad’ or ‘problem’ child as manifested in the exercise of corporal punishment still persists to bring forth controversy as shown in studies and media accounts. Advocates of the exercise of corporal punishment, like Dobson (1970), have claimed that too much tolerance or lenience, both in school and at home, has worsened social ills like disrespect for authorities, deviant behaviour, and substance abuse.6 The standpoint supported by Dobson is that teachers have the right to uphold order and exercise authority in the classroom “... even if it requires an occasional application of corporal punishment”.7 The proponents of corporal punishment support the following arguments. First, corporal punishment is less harsh or inhumane than other forms of punishment and has less detrimental impacts than other practices. Second, corporal punishment is compatible with the beliefs of numerous parents and strengthens stability between school and home. Third, corporal punishment supports the notion that some misconduct deserves such punishment which society should carry out. It establishes definite rules for appropriate behaviour. And fourth, the use of corporal punishment is a very effective method of discouraging misconduct.8 On the other hand, critics of corporal punis ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1404358-corporal-punishment-the-varying-cultural-views
(Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1404358-corporal-punishment-the-varying-cultural-views.
“Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1404358-corporal-punishment-the-varying-cultural-views.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma

School corporal punishment

...Module: School Corporal Punishment Inflicting physical pain has been in use for centuries as a means ofinstilling discipline among people. Schools have used it to maintain good mannerisms among students and Nepal is a good example of countries where it is widely practiced. This practice is termed as corporal punishment and many Nepal people advocate for it based on Hindu teachings that state that children should get tadana which means reprimanding by beating in order to shape their lives. Year after year students across the world have been subjected to corporal punishment. Many nations however have enacted legislations against its use...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Corporal Punishment on School

... Ban on corporal punishment on school Many individuals still take corporal punishment as a way of effectively teaching the children. Consequently, the argue may come on both sides, that is, either in support of the corporal punishment ban, or against the ban of corporal punishment as below. Ultimately, long ago, corporal punishment did come in administration normally and no one could complain. Patently, as time went by, law enactors did associate themselves to matters of running the school, this made many teachers face the law, and even some went under detention (Graziano and Kunce 130). Corporal punishment induces fear in minds of many young people, which can eventually create harm to the physical growth of their brain. The plan... to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Issues of Corporal Punishment

..., but the practice is still continued in non-western societies, and the politicians of the western society keep on trying to making this punishment method a part of their legal system. Corporal punishment has existed in schooling systems and questions have been raised against and support has been given in the favour of corporal punishment in educational institutes. Activities that are categorized as Corporal punishment includes: whipping, gagging, flogging etc. These activities were practiced in US as well as Europeans nations for several years. Graeme Newman, a supporter of Corporal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Corporal Punishment in School

...? 15 July Corporal punishment in school: This essay is primarily based on discussingthe issue of whether corporal punishment should be legalized, introduced, or justified in all schools around the globe or not. This issue raises a huge concern for the wellbeing of the children or young adults which is why discussing it with the help of research facts and valid reasons remains highly important. Corporal punishment is basically about deliberate infliction of pain on the students by the supervisors or teachers in response to any offensive action taken by them as a way of restraining bad behavior. Though not taking proper...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

State Laws on Corporal Punishment

...massive support from various organizations that aims at protecting human rights. Although United States of America has made noticeable progress in addressing challenges that are associated with corporal punishment in public schools, human rights activists have observed that, a lot of work need to be done in order to effectively protect children against violation of their basic right. Moreover, present corporal policies prohibit use of corporal punishment by teachers and other school administrators. According to the existing policies, any form of corporal punishment against students is illegal and anyone or professional...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Corporal Punishment

...punishment seems to instill more violence than it can eradicate. Perhaps, it is because it is based on fear, and if the fear goes away, either the individual goes back to his original negative self or he becomes worse as a result of having to make up for the time that he was able to successfully suppress his violent behavior. Fourthly, corporal punishment is often associated with crimes and acts of violence in the same community, school or state where it is considered legal. In fact, according to Dupper and Dingus (2008), the incidence of corporal punishment in a particular area is associated with higher rates of child abuse fatalities...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Corporal Punishment for Children vs. Other Methods

...contended that “physical punishment typically evokes anger and emotional distress in the child, which, over time, may diminish positive feelings” (McLoyd & Smith, 2002). These claims therefore simply show that corporal punishment elicits anger in the child, and this anger will later on prove to become the reason for violent behavior. Moreover, since these pieces of evidence are based on actual studies, then they must be credible. There are many other problems associated with corporal punishment. One of these is the claim that the practice is often associated with a higher incidence of child abuse, school shootings, acts of violence, homicide and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Corporal Punishment

...to "identify with the aggressor" which characterizes the authoritarian personality The use of force on children stems from an inherent cultural belief that violence is an acceptable way to solve problems. Carried far enough, that position could suggest that the society itself is "mentally ill," judged by its approach to violence (Straus and Donnelley 2004). Corporal punishment is ineffective because it has extremely negative impact on learning and child development. Prom the psychological point of view, to be effective in the long run, however, corporal punishment must be extremely harsh and repeated -- and even then the research results are...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Corporal punishment

...November 2006 Inflicting Pain to Discipline a Child I. Introduction Discipline had always been a part of a child’s guiding light towards maturity. However, there are inevitable times when parents are unable to control their anger or temper when disciplining a child. This result to the infliction of pain, in order to emphasize that what had been done was wrong. In a child’s point-of-view, pain becomes equated to misbehavior, as more misbehavior leads to more pain. On the other hand, there are cases in which a single misbehavior leads to more harsh infliction of pain. Anger, combined with the will to inflict pain does not lead to a good outcome. Although corporal punishment’s aim is to impose discipline,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Child discipline and corporal punishment

...An Alternative to Corporal Punishment One practical alternative to corporal punishment, which is based on the principle that some children are naturally violent and disobedient, is to ignore them or to threaten to leave them somewhere like the store where they committed some misdemeanors. Naturally, the parent should try to assess the situation first in order not to put the child in a dangerous situation like, thus it would be stupid to think about leaving him or her in a dark alley at night. Nevertheless, this method will most likely work because of its advantages. One advantage of this is that the parent himself will not be held responsible for any act of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Corporal Punishment: A Cultural and Legal Dilemma for FREE!

Contact Us