Means of Controlling Illegal Immigration - Essay Example

Should Illegal Immigration be Controlled? Table of Contents Introduction 3 Background 3 Expert Testimony & Statistics 5 Cause and Effect of Illegal Immigration 6 Subsidizing College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants Is Unfair 7 Illegal Immigrants Do Not Drain Public Services 8 Solution of Illegal Immigration 9 Anticipation of Readers’ Objections 9 Counterarguments 10 Reassert own position 11 Conclusion 11 References 14 Bibliography 15 Introduction One of the most argued topic of today is that if the allowance of an illegal immigrant in a country will help their economy. Majority point out that every people should be worthy of a great life in any country; everybody can enjoy its liberties and also freedom. Illegal immigrants basically flee to a country from domineering regimes. Of course, every law might not be accurate or just. If one law is incorrect, it should not be followed and also people can fight to revoke it. But the immigration laws survive for good causes. They avoid criminals, carriers of transferable disease, as well as other treacherous individuals from crossing their border. The Northern Virginia Regional Gang Task Force grants that “immigration has … played a major role in the rise and proliferation of Hispanic gangs in the region.” Most of their associates are possible illegal immigrants, and also while anybody doesn’t imagined that everybody of these individuals will be eradicated had they moved out by the legal immigration procedures. So, it should be controlled (Normandin, “Illegal Immigration: It’s Illegal”). Background In the last few years, illegal immigration was pursued as the most controversial issue. On the whole, this is an issue involving millions of citizen working, staying and entering in a country ‘with no’ official permission. This is also an issue of citizen who primarily enters into a country legally and also end up their violating or overstaying the terms and conditions of their visas. This is a dilemma where the credence of supply as well as demand usually bypasses regulation of law. Managers want lower cost employees and the illegal immigrants (employees, in this case) are ready to work for lower salaries. Illegal immigrants for the United States are mainly people from the Mexico and that of South and Central America. Statistics from Pew Hispanic Center indicate that 56 percent of the illegal immigrants in U.S. come mainly from Mexico with the intention of supplying the manual worker to near about thousands of U.S. companies. While economic replicas do come across at relative income and wealth stuck between home as well as destination nations, they don’t essentially involve that illegal immigration are always impecunious through standards of home nation. The poorest lessons in one developing nation may be short of resources desired to mount an attempt to annoy illegally, or the relations to friends and family by now in destination nation. Studies from Pew Hispanic Center have revealed that the wage levels as well as education of the illegal Mexican migrants in US are approximately the medium for the Mexico, and also those families who have lived elsewhere or being from one society with lots of emigrants is much better forecaster of ones selection to emigrate. The examples of illegal immigration show that amplified poverty, mainly when connected with immediate catastrophe can increase the probability of the illegal migration. In 1994, economic catastrophe in the Mexico, successive to start of North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was connected with extensive poverty as well as an inferior valuation for Peso comparative to Dollar. Expert Testimony & Statistics There so many experts who have shared their views on illegal immigration. According to Stephen H. Legomsky, professor of Washington University in the St. Louis, there is a simple way to set one serious cavity in the illegal immigration and also bring back together the families of lawful immigrants at same time (Martin, ‘“Reduce illegal immigration by reuniting nuclear families of legal immigrants,’ expert says”). Ainslie revises the possessions of racial conflicts on the communities and also psychological practices of immigrants. He produced a documentary “Ya Basta! Kidnapped in Mexico”, which inspects a sign of kidnappings as well as violent felony that has overwhelmed Mexico throughout the past decade. He is accessible to talk about a collection of topics relating to the U.S.-Mexico border brutality (The University of Texas at Austin, “Experts Available to Discuss Border Violence and Immigration Issues”). Research of Kamal Sadiq who is the associate professor of Political Science focuses on the immigration from and also surrounded by developing countries, global criminal flow as well as ethnic conflict (University of California – Irvine, “Border security and immigration reform”). According to Monisha Bansal, the key to helping Mexican economy is to end illegal immigration. She is the staff writer of CNS News. Cause and Effect of Illegal Immigration United States was created by immigration of numerous people from all across the world. Americans take arrogance in eloquent that they are a people of huge ethnic culture and backgrounds. Nevertheless, at present time, flow of illegal immigration, and a large incursion of other lawful immigrants is creating damage on their land of “huddled masses”. Lawful immigration to United States can simply be knobbed and is salutation by nearly all Americans. Moreover, the illegal immigrants flow, mainly from the Mexico, should be stemmed, for the damage this is inserting on government, (at federal, state and local level), and the normal population. Illegal immigrants are accommodated in United States with over 24$ billion in one year by taxpayers’ money. Something has to be done to diminish the illegal immigration flow into United States. The degree of illegal immigration, are positively and significantly related to the violent offense rates. The approximation suggest that 10 percent increase in uneasiness, for one given height of force, enforcement to near about 0.6 percent boost in one sector’s violent offence rate. In equal stipulations, neighbor sector anxieties as well as average sector anxiety shows that there are nix offense spillovers from amplified immigrant flows in another border area (provisional on enforcement as well as other controls). Crime spillovers happen when enforcement reacts (Orrenius, & Coronado. “The Effect of Illegal Immigration and Border Enforcement on Crime Rates along the U.S.-Mexico Border”). Subsidizing College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants Is Unfair According to the Ward Connerly, the U.S. College Board has been absent from the debate about the in-state education for the illegal aliens, awaiting now. The Board, which comprises 5,000 universities and colleges, is debating Congress to permit states to suggest in-state charges to the illegal aliens as well as give a pathway to residency. Four states have approved legislation barring illegal aliens from attaining the lower charges, and also most of the states pursue federal law which specifies that states cannot suggest lower charges to the illegal aliens than they propose to the out-of-state pupils. According to the Associated Press statement, College Board initiate that near about 360,000 illegal aliens can qualify for education aid with other 715,000 between 5 to 17 years of age which could benefit whether they complete high school. They also narrate that states which propose education aid to the illegal aliens saw a boost in college profits. According to the Ward Connerly, most of the states in America spent huge money for the illegal immigrants for their health care and others public benefits. These financial supports are right because America has a pledge to serve relief to any child, woman and man whose health and life is endangered. But, education is a different thing altogether. Government should give the equal value for every student. According to the author’s opinion, health care, emergency and others public benefits are the apt subsidies for the illegal immigrants. Illegal Immigrants Do Not Drain Public Services After finishing the study of Mexican Migration Project, near about 2,100 undocumented immigrant’s inspection through the project, only 4 percent said that they exercised food stamps on their final U.S. trip as well as only 3 percent said that they acknowledged government welfare payments. On the contrary, 60 percent said that they had federal taxes inoperative from their recompense. Furthermore, although undocumented immigrants are lawfully entitled to send kids to the U.S. public schools, merely 11 percent accounted doing so. In the year of 2002, there is only 26% of illegal immigrants accounted using hospitals, according to the Mexican Migration Project study, as mentioned by the author. According to the Masseys view, there are mainly two reasons for legal and illegal Mexican migrants more liable to make a payment to the U.S. public reserves relatively then receive from them. These are failing rates of the welfare usage and chilling effect. Everybody observes that one important gap lives between rate of tax payment as well as rate of service usage amidst undocumented Mexican immigrants, a fact which might reveal many Americans. The U.S. citizens may be even much surprised to study that this gap is broadening over time in pathways which are constructive to taxpayers: Charges of tax payment are rising while charges of service usage are decreasing. Since undocumented immigrants mainly have low charges of service usage, on the other hand, this chilling effect has exaggerated documented more than undocumented immigrants. In between 1987 to 1992, for instance, 60 % of legal immigrants’ investigation by Mexican Migration Project used one hospital but in between 1997 to 2002 the share had decreased to 42%. Solution of Illegal Immigration The problem associated with “illegal” immigration can be resolved by stroke of pen: make lawful immigration. The exerts have believed that with increasing thrusts upon lawful immigration in greater number can definitely reduce the pressure from illegal immigrations as it has been observed that it is only when people do not get legal permission, they resort to illegal and illicit ways. Anticipation of Readers’ Objections A federal court struck down decree passed through Hazleton, Pennsylvania, which were planned to limit where illegal immigrants could work and live. In 2006, Hazleton approved the Illegal Immigration Relief Act Ordinance that will have fined landowners who borrowed to the undocumented immigrants and also will have the companies penalized that employed them. Under one more law, tenants will have to show they were lawful residents as well as pay for rental consent with the purpose of receiving the occupancy consent. The court lined that Hazleton does not ratify any regulations dealing with the illegal immigration for the reason that they conflict with the supremacy phrase of U.S. constitution. Hazleton, in its fanaticism to manage the incidence of a team deemed uninvited, violated rights of those people, and others inside the society. In view of the fact that United States Constitution protects even disfavored, the decrees cannot be forced. Counterarguments Though it is fact that illegal immigration can never be supported, yet one should understand the logic behind such happening. Illegal immigration have always attracted penalties and punishments yet, people have taken repeated plunge to het migrated to any of the superior nations. What brings them in another nation? This has been the hope for better living for them as well as their children. Also, political disturbances in the home country also contribute to it. This is hard to discover any historical century, in which as a result huge number of people get a better conditions in their life without taking the opportunity to stay in other nations. Reassert own position Illegal immigration is not just a wrong thing but also it brings in the unlawful activists in the country and therefore the immigration should be stopped. Taking the example of America, one can find that about 27% of criminals in the federal custody are hostage illegal aliens as well as most of them are Mexican people. Near about 240000 illegal immigrants are sex offenders in America. There are only 28% illegal taxpayer households in America. Conclusion Illegal immigration is an unfair for the residents, citizens, taxpayers and illegal aliens also. Unfortunately, there is no ideal solution for the illegal immigration; on the other hand it is one problem which needs to solve as soon as possible. The government of the country should look into all the departments like economy, political, crime, legal as well as humanitarian to devise a strategy about the illegal immigration. Presentation Introduction: Illegal immigrants mainly flee to a nation from overbearing regimes. Background: In the last few years, illegal immigration has been pursued as the most controversial issue. On the whole, this issue involves millions of citizen working, staying and entering in a country ‘with no’ official permission. This is also an issue of citizen who primarily enters into a country legally and also end up their violating or overstaying the terms and conditions of their visas. Expert Testimony & Statistics: Research of Kamal Sadiq, who is the associate professor of Political Science focuses on the immigration from and also surrounded by developing countries, global criminal flow as well as ethnic conflict. According to Monisha Bansal, the key to helping Mexican economy is to end illegal immigration. She is the staff writer of CNS News. Cause and Effect of Illegal Immigration: The degree of illegal immigration, are positively and significantly related to the violent offense rates. The approximation suggest that 10 percent increase in uneasiness, for one given height of force, enforcement to near about 0.6 percent boost in one sector’s violent offence rate. Subsidizing College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants Is Unfair: According to the Associated Press statement, College Board initiate that near about 360,000 illegal aliens can qualify for education aid with other 715,000 between 5 to 17 years of age which could benefit whether they complete high school. According to the author’s opinion, health care, emergency and others public benefits are the appropriate subsidies for the illegal immigrants. Illegal Immigrants Do Not Drain Public Services: Near about 2,100 undocumented immigrant’s inspection through the project, there is only 4 percent said that they exercised food stamps on their final U.S. trip as well as only 3 percent said that they acknowledged government welfare payments. On the contrary, 60 percent said that they had federal taxes inoperative from their recompense. Furthermore, although undocumented immigrants are lawfully entitled to send kids to the U.S. public schools, merely 11 percent accounted doing so. In the year of 2002, there is only 26% of illegal immigrants accounted using hospitals, according to the Mexican Migration Project study, as mentioned by the author. Solution of Illegal Immigration: The experts have believed that with increasing thrusts upon lawful immigration in greater number can definitely reduce the pressure from illegal immigrations. Anticipation of Readers’ objections: In 2006, Hazleton approved the Illegal Immigration Relief Act Ordinance that will have fined landowners who borrowed to the undocumented immigrants and also will have the companies penalized that employed them. Counterarguments: Illegal immigration have always attracted penalties and punishments yet, people have taken repeated plunge to het migrated to any of the superior nations. Reassert your own positions: Taking the example of America, one can find that about 27% of criminals in the federal custody are hostage illegal aliens as well as most of them are Mexican people. Conclusion: The government of the country should look into all the departments like economy, political, crime, legal as well as humanitarian to devise a strategy about the illegal immigration. References Martin, Jessica. ‘“Reduce illegal immigration by reuniting nuclear families of legal immigrants,’ expert says” June 03, 2010. Washington University. June 17, 2007. Normandin. R, “Illegal Immigration: It’s Illegal”. June 03, 2010. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. January 13, 2010. Orrenius, P. & Coronado, R. “The Effect of Illegal Immigration and Border Enforcement on Crime Rates along the U.S.-Mexico Border”. June 03, 2010. University of California - San Diego. December, 2005. The University of Texas at Austin, “Experts Available to Discuss Border Violence and Immigration Issues”. June 03, 2010. News. May 5, 2010, University of California – Irvine, “Border security and immigration reform”. June 03, 2010. News. May 26, 2010. Bibliography Connerly, Ward. “Subsidizing College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants Is Unfair”. June 07, 2010. Opposing Viewpoints: Students Rights. Greenhaven Press, 2005. Massey, Douglas S. “Illegal Immigrants Do Not Drain Public Services”. June 05, 2010. Opposing Viewpoints: Welfare. Greenhaven Press, 2008. Read More