Free

Ethics Case Analysis - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
I absolutely agree with Mark’s decision not to tell Annie about the seriousness of her illness. This is because telling the truth about the seriousness of her illness would cause more harm to Annie than good. This is because Annie would become psychologically…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Ethics Case Analysis
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Ethics Case Analysis"

Ethics Case Analysis By Ethics Case Analysis Question I absolutely agree with Mark’s decision not to tell Annie about the seriousness of her illness. This is because telling the truth about the seriousness of her illness would cause more harm to Annie than good. This is because Annie would become psychologically affected negatively, thus becoming distressed for the rest short time remaining in her life. In the case scenario we learn that Annie did never the truth about her condition till she died and she was hopeful of recovery up to the last minute. This fact shows that not telling Annie the truth did more good than harm to her.
Question 2. The physician also should never have spoken to Annie about the seriousness of her illness. This is because withholding the truth about the seriousness of Annie’s condition by the physician did more good to Annie and her family, more than revealing the whole truth to her. This is because, had Ann known that she was about to die, she would become distressed and make her family also distressed.
The main ethical dilemma in this case is to make the choice of either or not to reveal to Annie the seriousness of her illness. Revealing the truth to Annie would have meant that the physicians and the Annie’s husband have acted in the honest way by telling Annie the truth; the main disadvantage of telling Annie the truth, however, was that Annie would become emotionally and psychologically disturbed, thus becoming distressed and making her family also distressed. Withholding the truth, on the other hand, would have meant that the physicians and Annie’s husband have acted in the best interests of Annie and her family because Annie would remain hopeful throughout the short period remaining in her life; withholding the truth from Annie, however, would mean that the physicians and Annie’s husband lied to Annie, thus acting in a dishonest way towards Annie. Making a choice between these two options is a real dilemma because each of the options has both positive and negative consequences.
The main reason why I am of the view that the Physicians should never have revealed the truth to Annie about the seriousness of her illness is that the physicians are not under any obligation to reveal the whole truth to their patients. This view is supported by Sokol when he argues that, physicians have no moral obligation to tell their patients the whole truth about their condition (2002). For that reason, therefore, the physician acted in the morally right way by not disclosing to Annie about the seriousness of her illness. Secondly, although, withholding the truth from the patient by the physician about the physician’s health condition may seem dishonest, as long as the physician’s conscience is clear, making such a decision is morally right. This view is actually supported by Benn in his reflections on the role of conscience in medical ethics medical ethics; Benn argues that conscience can be of great help in helping the physician in making the right decisions when he/she is faced with an ethical dilemma in course of his/her practice (2005). In this case scenario, given the fact that the physicians and the Annie’s husband decision to withhold the truth from Annie was motivated by doing good to Annie, i.e. preventing Annie from becoming distressful in the remaining short period of her life, the physicians’ and the Annie’s husband consciences must have been quite clear. For that reason, therefore, the physicians and Annie’s husband acted in the best way and in a morally right way by withholding the truth from Annie.
References
Benn, P. “The role of conscience in medical ethics”. Philosophical Reflections on Medical
Ethics. Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan.
Sokol, D.K. (2006). “Truth Telling in the Doctor-Patient Relationship: A Case Analysis. Clinical
Ethics Journal”. Vol.1. No.3. London: Imperial College Publishers. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Ethics Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682980-ethics-case-analysis
(Ethics Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Ethics Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682980-ethics-case-analysis.
“Ethics Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682980-ethics-case-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethics Case Analysis

Case Study Analysis of Personal and Organizational Ethics and Values between For-Profit and Not-for-Profit Organizations

...? Case Study Analysis of Personal and Organizational Ethics and Values between For-Profit and Not-for-Profit Organizations s name] [Date] Executive summary Values and ethics in an organization determine the standards that are acceptable and help to construct behavior of an individual as per the organization requirements. If an organization whether it is a profit or nonprofit does not set its value and ethical standards then that kind of system increases the influence of individual value system within the organization. It is different from establishing the mission and goals and forming strategies. It is essential to frame living real values that would...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility a Case Analysis of Enron

...? Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility a Case Analysis of Enron This paper examines the Enron Case. The paper focuses on some important elements and aspects that led to the corporate collapse of the energy giant in the early 21st Century. From the case study, there are some elements of corporate social responsibility, governance and other matters that led to the eventual collapse of Enron. This research will focus on some important issues that relate to Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility Theory. In doing this, the following objectives will be addressed: 1. An assessment of whether Enron's long-time Chief Executive acted...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Christian Medical Ethics Case Analysis

...? Ethical Case Study Analysis   Word Count 581 Health care decisions have the potential to dramatically alter the lives of patients and their families in many ways. Because of this, it is critical that health care practitioners make ethical decisions which take all the relevant factors into consideration. For many people, Christian values and tradition play a strong role in the process of ethical decision making, and can play a significant part in the decisions that are made for any given patient. This essay will examine the process of ethical decision making within the case of Mrs. M and the application of Christian...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Ethics and Criminal Justice: A Case Analysis

...? Ethics and Criminal Justice: A Case Analysis Ethics and Criminal Justice: A Case Analysis In this case there are in place facts concerning the case and any attempt to incline the facts would jeopardize the overall handling of the situation. The first aspect is that there have been series of crimes executed by a single individual, the criminal. There seems to be a link between the six cases that have been experienced. This is probably due to the crime signature experienced by the investigators in the crime scene or possibly on the victims. The signature depicts a sense of similarity and...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

The East Asian Community: farce or reality

4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Analyze a Business Case Study. Provide an analysis with an application of at least two theories relating to Ethics. They also will recommend what action should be taken

...Business Case Study Analytical Report: “But What Happened to My Room?” 614 Philosophy and Ethics Elaine Kassanos “But What Happened to My Room?” Case Overview The case revolved around Liz Borden, a client who demanded a room at the Savory Hotel on a snowy night without previous reservations. Paige Lewis, the front desk clerk, was bribed with a $50 bill to find a room for Liz Borden. However, the confounding events occurred at midnight when a young woman with a small child came to occupy the previously reserved room that was inevitably given by Lewis to Borden. In this regard, the case analysis would be undertaken to specifically identify...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics Case

...Teacher: Ethical issues affecting accounting environment An accountant working in private of a private sector is sector must remain detached and devoted to ethical procedures when evaluating a corporation, private of individual’s monetary records for reporting reasons. An accountant normally encounters ethical concerns despite of the industry and should remain persistently vigilant to decrease the likelihood of outside forces influencing financial records, which could lead to both criminal and ethical violation. (Moore 19). Pressure from management The trouble for public organizations and companies to be successful at high levels may place unwarranted pressure and stress...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Ethics Case

... doings. The pressure could be in the working conditions or the way the employees are treated by the management. The benefit of coming up with this system is that it will be able to protect the integrity of the organization no matter how small it is. 2. Is this sort of whistle-blowing ethical? These hotlines are good. As they are currently referred to as a whistleblower, because of how one can tell of their problem without fear. This is because of the fact that they are able to discuss anything without the fear of retaliating. For example if there is bad leadership in the firm the people will speak out without the fear of being sacked. The firm should change the leadership style and come up with exactly what people need. Through... this, the...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Manfold Toy Company: Ethics. Case Study Analysis

...Conflict of Interest Table of Contents 0 Introduction 3 2.0 Definition of conflict interest 3 3.0 Analysis of the conflict of the interest issues in the case 3 4.0 Conclusions and recommendations 4 Reference 6 1.0 Introduction The present topic details the different types of interest that occurred in the preparation of acquisition of manful Toy Company by Mitchell & Meyers. 2.0 Definition of conflict interest Conflict of interest occurs when an individual or an organization is involved in the more than one interest. In the process, one of the interests can cause the corruption or degeneration in other interests (Mann 1901). 3.0 Analysis of the conflict of the interest issues in the case Ignoring the signs of bankruptcy Joseph Wan... to...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Ethics Case Analysis

...Ethics Case Analysis Ethics Case Analysis Summary Case Analysis Case Background Lauren works for a well-respected technology company owing to their reputation for high-quality as a quality engineer. The reputation of the company provided a platform to access a huge contract with a strategic customer/company. The contract involved the design and development of a device to be integrated into a new product developed by the strategic company. The strategic company required help from Lauren’s company to achieve market dominance owing to increased demand and considering its reputation for...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Ethics Case Analysis for FREE!

Contact Us