StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Different forms of paternalism - Coursework Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay “Different forms of paternalism” will disqualify that Paternalism is necessary and is useful in controlling the Blacks. This results from the assumption that Blacks are naturally rowdy since the colonial times and needs to be controlled…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Different forms of paternalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Different forms of paternalism"

Different forms of paternalism
Different forms of paternalism are manifested in different contexts depending on the situation at hand. This explains why Academician Murray Foreman justifies the paternalistic assumption based on the film, Colors. This results from the assumption that Blacks are naturally rowdy since the colonial times and needs to be controlled and supervised by the Whites at all times. However, in the film Drumline, the situation is different since no Black supervision is required in the specific context. This essay will disqualify that Paternalism is necessary and is useful in controlling the Blacks.
Thesis
Paternalism is not a mere construct that was used to subdue the Black race so as the Whites would take advantage of them since they were views as the weaker race. A move by the Blacks to fight for their rights does not justify that Blacks are unruly and must be controlled and supervised by the Whites.
Colors vs. Drumline in line with paternalism
The view on paternalism materializes in Colors in both a positive and a negative way. In the film Colors, the concept of paternalism is well presented by Dennis Hopper. In the film, gang culture is evident. Hopper (1998) presents the Black and Latino youth gangs fighting each other and with the police. The attempts to control the gang problems present a clear evidence of racist and paternalistic assumptions by the Whites. In this context one would argue that paternalism is required so as to control the gang issues. For instance, in the scene where a family is offloading beach stuff, and are suddenly attacked by a gang of people that are shirtless, in bandannas, sunglasses and in hairnets (Hopper, 1988). Even after the man attempts to protect himself, the gang stabs him. The scene on the White Fence neighborhood explains on the needs for paternalism to control the Blacks and their gang issues as we see a kid spray painted on the face and confrontations begin (Hopper, 1988).
It is essential to note, nonetheless, that not all the outbreaks of violence in the film are Black and gang related. In line with this thought, therefore, paternalism is disqualified. One would even argue that the police were actually fighting towards outnumbering the Blacks and the Latino in all means. The police are seen to dress in black and armed with guns while the Blacks and Latino look helpless and most of them having a bandanna on the heads and sun glasses (Hopper, 1988).
The film Drumline is a complete contrast of Colors. In this film, the cast is comprised of a majority Blacks that does not engage in crimes, rap music and crimes like in the case of Colors. Racism is also not existent in Drumline. The youths in this context are dedicated to their music and marching bands and are dedicated to succeed in this course and even win in the respective competitions (Stone III, 2008). In this context, no control and supervision is required for the Black population; thus, an invalidation of the basis of paternalism. The difference revolves around the communities of the Blacks in Colors and in Drumline being different. In Colors, the society is racist forcing the Blacks to revolt while in Drumline, the society appreciates the colored people; hence no revolts (Stone III, 2008). The representation of Black community determines the type of Black males that will be bred.
Conclusively, from the films, paternalism is applied to control the Blacks. It is not at all times that the Blacks were unruly and needed to be controlled. In the context of unruly Blacks, paternalism is still not justified, since it is the racist conditions that led to a revolt from the Blacks.
Works Cited
 Hopper, Dennis, dir. Colors.  Orion Pictures, 1988. Film. 
Stone III, Charles, dir. Drumline. Wendy Finerman Productions and Fox 2000 Pictures, 2008. Film. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Different forms of paternalism Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Different forms of paternalism Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682389-discussionessay
(Different Forms of Paternalism Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Different Forms of Paternalism Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682389-discussionessay.
“Different Forms of Paternalism Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1682389-discussionessay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Different forms of paternalism

Pateriarchy and Paternalism

... of the American Revolution, most states in northern America had already done away with the practice, but in southern states, the institution of slavery was flourishing especially in the large plantations that formed the major economic mainstay of the regions (Allport, 1954, p41). In this respect, Southern states supported slavery while the northern states opposed the practice, resulting to the civil war that was eventually won by the Northern side. For long periods, historians and social researchers have delved on how the slaves related with their masters to ensure that they coexisted peacefully without undue conflicts in such a harsh and dehumanizing working environment. This paper discusses similarities between paternalism and patriarchy...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Overview of Paternalism Law

Several laws and regulations have been enacted that encourage paternalism by the government such as requiring a motorcyclist to wear helmets. These actions by the government have been opposed by several utilitarian thinkers like John Stuart Mill. He is opposed to the actions that led to paternalism by the government based on his autonomy-based argument. Paternalism exists in the form of restrictions or requirements imposed on people to perform in order for the common good to be maintained. In his topic on liberty, Mill argues that the government encourages cyclists to wear helmets to promote a good (Skorupski, 34). The protection of the person from injury is a good that cannot be ignored and it is not that the cyclist does not val...
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Different forms of healing

...Healing Healing refers to the restoration of well being after a state of dysfunction of the mind and body. This may occur spontaneously or over time and is subject to many different factors. These factors help to create a difference of perspective and approach to different kinds of healing. People, therefore, tend to adopt the form of healing that works best for them. This may make all them skeptical of all the other forms, but that belittling is unnecessary. One thing that all do agree in the concept of healing is the occurrence of a state of dysfunction and the subsequent attempt to remedy it. Forms of Healing Different forms of healing have been devised and exercised throughout history. Their acceptance into different cultures has been...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Paternalism and academic performance

.... Paternalism uses people’s belief and customs to develop a plan of action without comparing the suitability of the program to the student. For instance, the learning process in the American Indian school is structured in a rigid format and does not accept external interference. According the structure, some public holidays are not considered necessary as such students are expected to attend classes during the holidays. Private teaching is also encouraged in the process making the whole process different from the standard models used in schools. The success of the module is possible in charter schools because of the control offered by the school directors. The freedom associated with the school enables Ben Chavis to develop the system...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Research Methodology (different forms of participant observation)

... RESEARCH METHODOLOGY: PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION (COVERT AND OVERT) Introduction The focal point of the paper is to discuss the arguments for the use of different forms of participant observation like covert and overt. Alongside it would be stated when, if at all, covert forms can be legitimately used in social science research. In general senses there are two principal methods of research. One is overt or the obvious usages of tools with complete awareness of the participants and the other is covert where the participants are not aware of the research being done. It should be mentioned that in an overt method of research qualitative form is generally used. This is not to say that quantitative methods are not used in overt operations...
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Different Forms of Corruption

...Different Forms of Corruption Introduction Sport has always had those who cheat – whether in a well planned way, by accident as when rules are not known or understood , or on impulse when an opportunity presents itself. In some cases it is the sportsperson in the first instance who is corrupt,. In other cases it is associated people such as coaches, umpires, referees and owners or with those who bet on such events or the book makers involved. Why do these cases seem to appear to be more frequent in modern day sport than previously? An obvious answer is that there is so much more media coverage. It is perhaps as much a matter of perception than of fact. A hundred years ago a person either attended a sports event in person or else...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Different Forms of Literature

...Comparing and Contrasting Literary Forms The different forms of literature discussed have similarities and differences when it comes to their literary elements. The discussion at hand shall make use of the Robert Frost’s poem, “The Road Not Taken,” Eudora Welty’s short story, “A Worn Path,” and John Millington Synge’s drama, “Riders to the Sea.” Drama, poetry and short story all evolve on a given theme and use conflict to fuel the literary form. For example, “The Road Not Taken” and “A Worn Path” use the theme of journey while “Riders to the Sea” evolves around the theme of loss and human endurance. In addition, all three poems have conflicts involving two choices. For Frost’s poem, it is choosing one road over another; for Welty’s short...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Two Different Art Forms

...Two Different Art Forms Two Different Art Forms Sculpture Sculpture refers to the construction of a three-dimensional demonstration or conceptual forms, normally through carvings from hard materials such as wood and stone. The sculpture arts also incorporate plaster, glass or metal casting. The frequent stone type utilized in the sculpture design is marble. Many individuals always perceive sculptures formations to originate solely from hard materials. Nevertheless, softer materials such as plastics can aid in the making of sculptures of dissimilar nature. The two examples of sculpture described here entail the dying Gaul and Pieta (Grossman, Podany & True, 2003). The Dying Gaul Two sculptors namely, Daphnis of Miletus and Paionios...
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Advanced Management Accounting: Considering Different Forms of Costing

...BRIEFING PAPER By Date : Part A: Briefing Paper To: Board of Directors From: Manager Subject: Considering Different Forms of Costing Besides the basic methods of costing, there are a number of different forms of costing techniques that can be uses by management with each producing a different cost for the product. These differences in costs of a particular product when using the different forms of costing techniques is as a result of the exclusion and inclusion of certain components in product costs. The type of costing that a company chooses can result in substantial differences in costs and as such the management should be keen to choose a costing technique that will benefit the company. Therefore, a company...
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Coursework on topic Different forms of paternalism for FREE!

Contact Us