Racialization of Immigration - Assignment Example

What do you think of her discussion of the ways immigrants became white? Brodkin’s description of segregation in this discussion reveals a clear picture regarding its severe experiences, which diverse ethnic group encountered while in America besides Jews who are the focus (Rothenberg 43). Despite initially being very naïve concerning the real situation regarding segregation, Brodkin elaborates clearly the utter whiteness process, which the immigrants had to undergo to attain a decent recognition in America.

This is via utilizing Antonio, Gramsci and Zygmunt theories to defend her argument concerning the placement of “whiteness status” as an American national identity (Rothenberg 46). However, some sections seem more exaggerated, for instance, Jews’ hard work and education, which enabled them to assume the middle class or equal the whites. This is because the whites were constantly against any ethnic group, which seemed to equal them. Therefore, I disagree with her regarding lighter or mild segregation on some ethnic groups, for instance, the Jews.

What does this essay say about whiteness? Immigrants belonged to a low class compared to whites wherein attaining the same status, the few nonwhites (Jews) had to undergo a meticulous whiteness process. Therefore, this entailed first the then regime to put a sharp wedge between the Black Americans and Jews (Rothenberg 42). In addition, the Natives also ensured that the Jews adopted and emulated ideals that would differentiate them with other nonwhites. About the racialization of immigration?

American’s segregation despite the nonwhites belonging to the same group of the darks, the then incumbent regime classified people according to their ethnics (Rothenberg 46). The African Americans assumed the lowest class in the society whereas the Jews and some Black elites the middle class. This also was evident in the division of labor where the blacks earned living via manual jobs besides being the recipient exploitation (Roediger 234). Why are contemporary immigrants seen as dark, when many in fact are white?

It was a plan to deny nonwhites the chance of venturing into politics where they will outdo their superiors.