Fatima Chooljian and the X-ray Patient - Essay Example

Case Study Fatima Chooljian and the X-ray patient Q Ans. The older patient would have shared with his family that he had very negative perceptions about the Muslim radiographer in the start till the time they had not had a conversation. He would have discussed his discomfort, uneasiness, lack of support, and preconceived notions about Muslim working women’s practice of wearing the Hijab at the workplace. He might have said that if somebody is as particular about practicing religion as the Muslim radiographer supposedly was considering the fact that she wore Hijab at the workplace, he/she must not be in such professions that impart the need for close encounters between members of opposite genders.

Irrespective of whatever the older patient discusses about his initial thoughts or perceptions about his encounter with the Muslim radiographer, there is great likelihood of his discussion going in favor of the Muslim radiographer since the commencement of the discussion upon Jesus. He might say that bringing up the topic of Jesus for discussion was very odd at that moment considering that he was having an X-ray done from a stranger who was a Muslim radiographer, but in spite of that, the Muslim radiographer’s response to his question and the discussion that followed was very gentle and meaningful.

He might even appreciate the fact that the Muslim radiographer said, “I may be wrong, sir, but that’s how I understand it” because this reflects that the Muslim radiographer was not offensive or criticizing in her response to the older patient’s refusal to accept her definition of Jesus. The older patient might appreciate her for being flexible in her response as well as for the fact that she showed respect for the opinion held by him. The older patient might have attempted to justify his refusal to wear the towel.

He might have said that the radiographer’s request to put on a towel before the X-ray made him feel bad because for the moment, it made him think that the radiographer was attempting to impress upon him her extreme modesty. He might as well have said that the radiographer’s request to him to put on a towel was not required as he was going to do it anyway out of his own modesty. Q. 2: Ans. No, all conversation about personal views on religion should not be banned from healthcare facilities and clinics because it may be uneasy for many to follow as well as has the tendency to put the staff and patients at odds with one another.

Let’s consider the case study for example, if all conversation about personal views on religion had been banned, the older patient would have felt disrespected for not getting the answer of his question from the radiographer about knowing Jesus while the radiographer would just be following the rules. While the staff may be stopped from indulging into all conversation about personal views on religion, stopping the patients is indeed, impracticable and beyond the control of the healthcare facilities’ or clinics’ administration in many cases.

Patients are after all, the fundamental consumers of the healthcare services and they cannot be made upset. The wearing of all religious grab and jewelry by the healthcare professionals should also not be banned because for many, it is a fundamental part of their identity and many like the Muslim radiographer are condemned by their religion to work if they do not follow the religious dictations regarding what to wear. In the increasingly multicultural society where growth and success is integrally linked with cultural integration and increased flexibility in attitude, imposition of such laws that are inconsistent with one’s culture or religion is not a good idea. Q. 3: Ans.

Views regarding modesty in the presence of the opposite sex are both a matter of culture and of religion, though for the individuals, it is more a matter of either of the two as compared to the other. It really depends what an individual is more committed to; his/her culture or his/her religion. As we know, not every follower actually practices his/her religion. Likewise, while certain people place a lot of emphasis on culture, it is really not that important for others to carry on the traits of their culture in a foreign setting.

Therefore, it cannot be generalized that views regarding modesty in the presence of the opposite sex are more a matter of culture or of religion, though, I personally think that this is more linked with religion because many nations derive their culture, ethical codes, norms, values, and practices from their religion, an example of which is the Muslim radiographer in the case study.