StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
This coursework "Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology" focuses on early Greek philosophers, Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology, and early 20th Century developments in Functional psychology. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology"

Evolution of Psychology In attempting to formulate a historical perspective on the evolution of psychology one is struck by the difficulty in developing a functional chronology. While psychology does demonstrate scientific development over time, one investigation doesn’t necessarily follow the next, and a number of competing schools of thought beginning with the Greek philosophers intermittently emerge and disappear throughout time. In developing a perspective on the evolution of psychology, this essay considers the sometimes competing factions of psychological thought, as well as distinct instances of functional chronology, within the psychological frameworks of the early Greek philosophers, Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology, and early 20th Century developments in Functional psychology. Early Greek Philosophers Most traditional accounts of the history of psychology credit the Greek thinkers for laying the scientific foundations for what would eventually evolve into the formal study of the subject. The early Greek thinkers began to think about the world in scientific and philosophical terms that went beyond traditional accounts that linked the physical world to a religious cosmology. It was the contributions of early Greek philosophers such as Democritus, Hippocrates, and Protagoras that began the long line of scientific inquiry into the nature of physical reality that has embodied the Western scientific tradition into the 21st century. While the early Greek’s have been predominantly credited with their broad scientific advances, thinkers such as Plato and Aristotle also developed preliminary investigations into topics that would later be considered psychological. Much like Freud many years later, Plato divided the mind into a number of parts each constituting a different function. Plato believed that the soul had a rational function that was located in the head, a spirited function that was located in the chest, and a courageous function that was located in the belly. The rational soul was the part of the mind that had to control the urges of the two other competing parts. The passionate section was understood to be particularly troublesome. One can see hear the archetypical blue-print for what would eventually evolve into Freud’s dichotomy of the Id, Ego, And Superego; it’s not far stretch to link a direct comparison between Freud’s Id concept and the licentious characterization Plato developed for the ‘passionate soul’. While Plato’s division between mind and body was an early example of dualist structure, Aristotle’s perspective linked the two into a functional whole. Aristotle indicated that the soul and the body were the same, and they couldn’t be separated, just as a statue can’t be separated from the material it was constructed from. Aristotle also believed that the soul had a number of different functions, which included nutrition, movement, and reason. The inclusion of reason into the functional category of the soul indicates an early foray into the study of psychology. Aristotle also references the facility of nutrition. This has led many theorists to align Aristotle’s theory of the soul as the “first functional psychology, an approach congenial to a biologist.” (Bakalis, 2005, p. 87) The biological ramifications of Aristotle’s theory of the soul would act as precedent to the psychological school of functionalism. The two theories share an emphasis on the “biological nature of mental functioning.” (Bakalis, 2005, p.89) Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Even as considerable investigations into the nature of consciousness and mental processes were made after the Greeks, it wasn’t until William Wundt and Voluntarism in the nineteenth-century that the first official school of psychological thought was founded. Wundt is regarded as the first psychologist for his crucial role in the development of experimental psychology. One of the notable experiments he undertook involved a clock with a pendulum that swung back and forth periodically striking a bell. The participants were asked to determine the exact time the bell struck, and Wundt determined that there answers were always 1/10 of a second off. This result led him to conclude that the human mind can only process one thought per 1/10 of a second. (Bringmann, 1980, p. 10) Voluntarism was a school of psychology that considered these findings when attempting to develop a theory of the human conscious. It followed that individual will was seen as the predominant conscious force, as the human volunteered to consider the ringing of the bell or to consider the swinging of the pendulum. This is significant in the evolution of psychology, as it distinguished from past theories. It discounted Materialistic psychology because consciousness, Wundt believed, “…cannot be derived from any physical qualities of material molecules or atoms” (Bringmann, 1980, p. 19) He also disagreed with empiricist philosophy because it lacked the emphasis on the human will that is found in Volunteerism. Another school of psychological thought that developed around this time was Edward Titchener’s Structuralism. Titchener believed that before the 1880s all forays into psychology lacked the experimental rigor required to classify them as a legitimate sciences. He believed that, “Science deals, not with values, but with facts. There is no good or bad, sick or well, useful or useless, in science” (Jalomn, 2000, p. 201) While both schools primary concern was the nature of consciousness, Structuralism differed from Voluntarism in that rather than attempting to “explain conscious experience in terms of unobservable cognitive processes…(it) sought only to describe mental experience” (Jalomn, 2000, p. 205) Through recordable conscious introspection, Structuralism sought to describe the structure of conscious events. While Structuralism and Voluntarism were the major psychological schools of the time, a number of other early approaches developed that challenged their assumptions. Some of the major competing views were held by theorists such as Brentano, Stumpf, Husserl, and Kulpe. Contrary to Titchener, Brentano believed that psychological investigations into consciousness should focus on mental acts instead of mental elements. Stumpf also accepted this premise and extended in stating that introspective research must include tangible psychological experience, rather than merely forms of thought. Husserl believed that in order to develop a science of psychology, a taxonomic structure of the mind had to be articulated. He disagreed with preceding theorists in that he believed this taxonomy needed to exist before experimental studies in consciousness could be developed. Functionalism Functionalism is widely regarded as the first United States school of psychology. While it originated around the same time as Structuralism, the paradigmatic aims of the two schools differed greatly; whereas structuralists investigated consciousness through research with introspection, the goals of functionalism were to “…understand how the mind and behavior work in aiding an organism’s adjustment to the environment” (Keebler, 1999, p. 50) While Structuralism relied predominantly on introspection as an experimental tool, Functionalism adopted a myriad of forms of inspection, including introspection, but also the study of animal behavior and the mentally ill. The functional school of thought evolved from previous research into evolutionary theory and as a result believed that the mind had a determinable function for survival in the environment. This led to a particular interest in the topic of motivation, as they believed that since …”an organism will act differently in the same environment as its needs change, these needs must be understood before the organism’s behavior can be understood.” (Keebler, 1999, p. 57) They went beyond previous psychological research as they attempted to determine these findings and apply them to real life scenarios. While Titchener believed psychology should be a science concerned only with the objective description of findings, the Functionalist school sought to make it a practical science and to use their findings to help institutions like education and industry, as well as improving personal lives. The Functionalists also went beyond previous psychological investigations in that they believed research methodology should include a broader array of subject matter, and incorporated anything that could be deemed informative. This progress attitude towards research methodology led to some of the first psychological investigations into abnormal psychology, animals, and children, as well as the incorporating mental testing. Conclusion In conclusion, the history of psychology demonstrates varying degrees of functional chronology and directly contradictory forms of psychological representation. The early Greek philosophers are credited largely for developing investigations into the physical world that went beyond traditional religious or mythological accounts. Thinkers like Plato and Aristotle explored the nature of the mind and soul in developing accounts of personality that would later be recalled in thinkers such as Sigmund Freud. They also explored the question of mind and body duality. Voluntarism and Structuralism were two of the first approaches to psychology that implemented experimental studies to attempt to determine mental processes. They were both concerned with understanding the nature of consciousness, but differed in the degrees of importance placed on individual volition. Finally, Functionalism was the first recognized American school of psychology. It was influenced by findings in evolutionary biology and attempted to determine the function of mental processes. It also went beyond Voluntarism and Structuralism in that it attempted to link its findings to practical uses in education and industry. References Bakalis, N. (2005). Handbook of Greek Philosophy: From Thales to the Stoics: Analysis and Fragments. Victoria, BC: Trafford Publishing. Bringmann, W. G. & Tweney, R. D. (Eds.) (1980). Wundt studies. Toronto: Hogrefe. Jalomb, P. (2000). The Psychologizing of Mind Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Keebler, D. (1999). Dynamics in psychology. New York: Liveright. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1731141-evolution-of-psychology-refer-to-instruction-for-details
(Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1731141-evolution-of-psychology-refer-to-instruction-for-details.
“Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1731141-evolution-of-psychology-refer-to-instruction-for-details.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Voluntarism, Structuralism and Other Early Approaches to Psychology

Post Structuralism Theories by Roland Barthes

The author of the current essay "Post structuralism Theories by Roland Barthes" points out that the statement by Roland Barthes (1968), “It is a language which speaks not the author,” may have significant implications for our understanding of literature.... According to structuralism theories, the literary text is a part of a genre or a recurring structure.... In light of the statement by Barthes, it can be said that the concepts of structuralism theories have some points of resemblance with the argument made by Barthes....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Volunteering as a Way to Travel

Voluntourism varies a great deal, ranging from individuals doing low skill work, such as cleaning areas that are an ecological hazard, to helping people in other countries using their advanced medical skills in hospitals.... Some types of voluntourism involve people visiting places for the purpose of studying their environment, or being able to conduct other scientific studies....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Perspectives of Early Psychology

psychology has existed for centuries under the label of philosophy.... Yet, modern psychology has looked deeper into the mind in an effort to pull psychology into the realm of science.... hellip; Modern psychology, at its heart, is the study of how we solve problems and why we act the way we do.... A study of it's evolution and the changes brought about by new thinking and research can be helpful in understanding the state of psychology today. An early psychologist, Pavlov, developed the Behaviorist theory of instruction and stated that learning is based on a change of behavior resulting from external stimuli, usually a reward or punishment....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Cognitive approach over Psychology

With this, it would be best to for these approaches to collaborate to come up with a complete understanding of the human psychology.... In your opinion, what will be the dominant approach (or approaches) during the next twenty to twenty-five years in psychology For example, do you think cognitive psychology will continue to be dominant, or will it be replaced by one of the more recent approaches, such as evolutionary psychology, neuroscience, or post-modernism Or do you think there will be some integration of two or more of these approaches Defend your answer based on your readings throughout the past two semesters, our class discussions, and any other source of relevant information. … psychology was dominated by cognitive approach after overpowering behaviorism....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Abnormal Psychology

The main aim of psychotherapy is ensuring that the individual has an increased sense of self and… As various schools of thought developed in psychology, each one of them came with its own therapeutic methods.... As various schools of thought developed in psychology, each one of them came with its own therapeutic methods.... The main aim of the paper is to discuss differences that are there among therapies for different schools of thoughts used in treatment of mental disorders in psychology....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

A history of Modern psychology

The introduction of this laboratory brought massive changes that improved the study of psychology in Europe and other parts of the world.... Before the 1800s, psychology was never studied as a separate discipline and it was not until the late 19th century that scholars started to study it as a discipline, which was distinct from the… Based on this idea, the body and the mind could be categorized as entities that were distinct and different from one another....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

The Concept of VolunTourism

For this, my personal minimum requirements would be running water, a place to rest, requisite apparels, electricity and other important tools such as cell phone and electronic equipment.... Basically, VolunTourism is regarded as travelling with the purpose of volunteering at the same time....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Postructuralism Approaches to Knowledge

… The paper "Postructuralism approaches to Knowledge " Is a great example of a Politics Essay.... nbsp; The paper "Postructuralism approaches to Knowledge " Is a great example of a Politics Essay.... The consideration of the “other” The most important aspect in which poststructuralism is different from modernism is in the way that the former approaches knowledge in a fluid manner that is capable of capturing different attitudes and frameworks....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us