Free

"Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
He refutes this Kant’s position through the French Philosopher that indicates that it is a responsibility to tell the truth. The duty conception is inseparable from that of law or right. The philosopher explains that…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
"Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample ""Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant"

The Pretended Right from Motives of Humanity to Lie Affiliation According to Constant, it is not always wrong to tell a lie. He refutes this Kant’s position through the French Philosopher that indicates that it is a responsibility to tell the truth. The duty conception is inseparable from that of law or right. The philosopher explains that a duty is that corresponds in one being another’s right. Thus, where there are no rights, there will be no duties. Hence, people have an obligation to tell the truth, but the duty is towards an individual with the right to truth. Additionally, there is no individual with the right to the truth that harms others (Kant, 1873).
It is always our duty answering truthfully a question that we cannot avoid answering (Kant, 1873). It is because truthfulness in statements that we cannot avoid answering is a formal duty that everyone owes to everyone despite how great it gets disadvantaged to the individual or another person.
Sometimes it is redundant to define a lie as a falsehood that might harm another person. It is because a lie is simply a willful untrue state. Hence, it does not need the additional definition that it should inflict harm to another person as it always hurt another individual or at least mankind in general through making all right sources useless. Additionally, it is argued that not every individual gets entitled to the right truth; thus some lies may not hurt them (Kant, 1873).
A lie can also be told to save an innocent friend be punishable under the civil law. In this case, the condition may, for instance, tell a lie that will prevent someone who intended committing murder (Kant, 1873). However, in this good-intended lie, one may become punishable by accident under the civil law because one who escapes punishment by accident can get adjudged a wrong by the external laws.
Constant rest on a confusion between an act to wrong another and harming another by stating that a principle known as true must never get abandoned no matter its apparent to incur danger.
REFERENCE
Kant I., (1873). Concerning a Pretended Right To Lie From Motives of Humanity. France in the
Year 1797, Vol (6) No. 1. Pp. 14-19 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“"Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Assignment”, n.d.)
"Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1697617-quotconcerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanityquot-by-immanuel-kant
(&Quot;Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Assignment)
&Quot;Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Assignment. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1697617-quotconcerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanityquot-by-immanuel-kant.
“&Quot;Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1697617-quotconcerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanityquot-by-immanuel-kant.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF "Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant

Immanuel Kant

...by the secretary. It is also obvious that the information will be broadcast later to all of us. My friends, ignorant of this, plan a weekend road trip, and set out early on Friday evening. I find myself excusing myself from the trip on the pretext of a bad cold. The next day, I put in my time at the office. On Monday, the Manager offers me the promotion. My silence is definitely an ethical decision. My motive of securing the promotion makes me hide the information in the memo from Tom. I am aware that this action is in conflict with my duty as a friend. However, I justify my action on the basis that I am not responsible for the road trip: in fact the idea is Tom’s. Tom voluntarily goes on the trip. I am not using Tom...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

"The Graduate" And "Bonnie and Clyde"

...with children. This production would not have exposed infidelity this much owing to the fact that “The Graduate” movie targets a larger audience. "Bonnie and Clyde" movie unethically presents a rare reflection of the full range of human life. Movies should ethically be produced as per human nature reflection as in most cases they target human society as the general viewers. "Bonnie and Clyde" movie contemplates human life presentation as a movie revolving around pitiless cruelty, which emerges as an irritant to the audience. This film aimlessly portrays un-forgiveness at this time we are living. Clyde walked into the bank with a major aim of robbery together with the...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

"Civil Rights Revolution"

...Civil Rights Revolution The 1960s were the golden years of the civil rights movement; the civil rights movements had gained significant traction in the early 1960s and it seemed inevitable that all Americans would be considered equal in no time. The rise of more vocal and charismatic individuals such as martin Luther King Jnr ensured that the minority groups became better organized in their clamor for equal rights. Furthermore, these leaders undertook to organize nationwide activities that were more effective in capturing the nation’s attention and imagination. This thus made it relatively difficult for the government to ignore the minorities anymore. Besides these...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

"Verbicide" Assignment

...Verbicide It goes without saying that language is under consistent assault from a wide spectrum of elements, both seen and unseen. This assault, perhaps, is our undoing as we embrace technological advancements. The reason for this purge is because it is difficult to ascertain the adverse effects that technology brings to our language prowess. It is a common thing to find teenagers, and even adults, who cannot relay information without using words whose meaning they do not know. However varied the reasons for this surge are, it remains clear that humans, are the planners of this massive undoing. One challenge that people face is not the lack of knowledge of the language, but a lack of coherence in speaking it. This...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

"Shiloh"

...Shilo” By B.A. Mason Introduction Bobbie Ann Mason’s narrative “Shiloh” chronicles the troubled marriage of Norma Jean and Leroy Moffitt, which ends at the Shiloh Civil War battleground. The storyline also addresses the social changes that influence individual identity, adding pressure on the Moffitt’s matrimony. In this regard, the story reveals the relationships between family members, for instance, Mabel and the Moffitt’s and friends (Mason, 2001). It is apparent that the women are actively involved in the work to support their families. This makes the Leroy uncomfortable in his marriages because Norma Jean turns out to be more powerful and stronger than him. In the story, the relationship between men and women is supportive... By B.A....
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

"FLOW" Assignment

...on the idea that the meaning of animals’ lives is simple, which enables them to focus their energy on the achievement of fulfillment. Even though they might not find their lives as enjoyable, the simplicity allows them to determine the point of their focus. On the contrary, a significant number of complicated concerns overwhelm human beings. For this reason, it is difficult for them to determine where to focus their psychic energy in order to achieve the flow. Conversely, Csikszentmihalyi provides a description of eight characteristics that determine an enjoyable experience. However, in my opinion, I believe that he could have summed up the eight features into four fundamental aspects. Firstly achieving...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

"Creative Spark"

...How to Build Creative Confidence How to Build Creative Confidence The talk we analyze in this paper is d how to build your creative confidence by David Keller. Creative confidence is the skill to come up with new ideas and have the self-belief to pursue them. The speaker, David Keller, is the founder, chairman, leader and managing partner of design company IDEO. His managing partner at IDEO is Tom Keller. David Keller is also a professor at Stanford University and has received several credits for his contributions to design and design education. David gave the talk “how to build creative confidence” on May 16th, 2012 (Ted Summaries, 2014). Through the talk, we are able to gain an in depth perspective on creative confidence while... to Build...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

"Faith"

...prophet of Allah. The main reason why I believe that Prophet Mohammad was the final prophet of Allah was because Allah revealed to Mohammad the truth about himself; Mohammad was the messenger of Allah. I also believe in Quran as the holy book of Allah; I believe that Quran contains the messages of Allah as revealed to Allah’s prophet, Mohammad; I believe that Allah revealed his eternal message to Mohammad in its definitive form. The main reason why I believe that Quran contains the messages of Allah is because Allah himself gave the Quran to his prophet Mohammad. Besides Mohammad, I also believe in other prophets of Allah. As the Quran says, God sends his messengers in every human age to reveal to his people his will...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

"Modeling Money"

...Modeling Money Money Models A person with the limited economic background would prefer ATM model of since it offersthem an opportunity to minimize the cost of holding cash by balancing the number of transactions from the ATM and with personal income and risk of holding cash (Malz, 2011). Therefore, a person can minimize the cost of holding cash by balancing the frequently of visit the ATM with income and other factors such as nominal interest fee and risk of keeping cash. It is unlike dynamic model that assumes the need for money is based on the prevailing economic conditions beyond their control such as nominal interest rate and inflation rate (Malz, 2011). Also, it is unlike liquidity preference model that assumes all economic... Money...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework

Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Immanuel Kant

... truthfulness cannot cause harm because it is a formal duty. Harm can be caused only by an accident (casus) to which the veracity is irrelevant. For this reason, truthfulness should be considered as an unconditional duty in any situation. Work Cited Kant, Immanuel, and A. E. Kroeger. “Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity.” The Journal of Speculative Philosophy 7.2 (1873): 14-19. Print.... cannot avoid answering. This is due to the fact that a man who speaks the truth should not be seen as responsible for the consequences resulting from his/her honest answer. The harm caused to a person as a result of the truthfulness does not impose any moral or legal responsibility to the one who has told the truth, because in this...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic "Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant for FREE!

Contact Us