Nobody downloaded yet

How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper "How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics" states that Renner's analysis of the governess's spectral visions centres on two propositions: first, that she is a casebook sexual hysteric, and second, that her detailed description is based on the imaginary product…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics"

Download file to see previous pages The identification of sexual repression and female hysteria as the motive force behind the governess apparent encounter with the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel dates back to Edmund Wilsons 1934 orthodox Freudian critique, “The Ambiguity of Henry James”, and since then the tale has been the centre of numerous debates based around both Freudian and anti-Freudian interpretations (Renner, 176, fn. 2). As with Wilsons landmark account, Stanley Renners identification of female sexual hysteria to explain both the supernatural aspect to the story and the governesses subsequent behaviour (176) would appear to bear out Peter Barrys claim in Beginning Theory that psychoanalytic critics privilege “the individual psycho-drama above the social drama of class conflict” (105). Certainly, Renner makes no reference to the class conflict in this essay. Much less does he see it as a mere “ghost story”; rather, it is to him very much a projection of internal fears and anxieties – its “dramatization of a woman's psychosexual problem and the damage it does to the children in her charge” is, he confidently states, “the true – and clearly the richer – story [...] (175).
Nevertheless, the supernatural aspects of the story cannot be dismissed out of hand, as Renner notes – indeed, his particular reading of the story arises in response to one of the strongest arguments against a purely naturalistic interpretation: how did the governess manage to give a detailed description of a man she had never seen, unless she had genuinely seen a ghost? (175) “Not only is it reasonably certain that James knew about physiognomical theories and the use of such devices by novelists familiar to him,” writes Renner, “but he also creates in his governess a character who fits the profile of the typical sexual hysteric, who has hysterical hallucinations, and whose mind projects her sexual fear in a form that draws on the very religious and physiognomical stereotypes with which a mind such as hers would logically be furnished.” (187) ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics Research Paper, n.d.)
How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1549085-how-does-stanley-renner-address-the-problem-of-psychoanalytic-critics-tending-to-privilege-the-individual-psycho-drama-of-the-author-or-characters-over-analysis-of-the-novels-cultural-context-and-dramatization-of-social-conflict-in-his-essay
(How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics Research Paper)
How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1549085-how-does-stanley-renner-address-the-problem-of-psychoanalytic-critics-tending-to-privilege-the-individual-psycho-drama-of-the-author-or-characters-over-analysis-of-the-novels-cultural-context-and-dramatization-of-social-conflict-in-his-essay.
“How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1549085-how-does-stanley-renner-address-the-problem-of-psychoanalytic-critics-tending-to-privilege-the-individual-psycho-drama-of-the-author-or-characters-over-analysis-of-the-novels-cultural-context-and-dramatization-of-social-conflict-in-his-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics

How Technology Support Investigation Function:Morgan Stanley

...to adapt new technologies such as telecommunications technology, computers, and computer networks. The integrated bank is supported by front office, business support, and shared services, which at the same time has three specific functions: investigation, underwriting, and selling. The main thrust of this paper is to discuss the investigation function within the investment of Morgan Stanley and how the technology supported the function. The Technologies That Support The Business Function The three business segments and functions of Morgan Stanley are supported by shared services and information technology (IT). These are the critical areas that ensured a smooth running...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Stanley Cavell

...?Naomi Liang Directed Reading: Stanley Cavell Cavell and The Philosophical Pursuit of A Rational Basis for Morality Stanley Cavell's The Claim of Reason is an immensely ambitious work that attempts to explore the ethical dimension of human life by focusing on self-knowledge, that is, towards an understanding of one’s moral yet rational self. Although the nature of reason and morality may seem contrary to one another, morality is not utterly beyond the veil of reason. It is in this regard that individuals ought to revaluate the kinds of ethical and moral theories that are most influential to them, by reconsidering the fundamental question of philosophy on how to live an ethical life. One...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Stanley Milgram

...Stanley Milgram Stanley Milgram’s social psychology experiment of obedience has become one of the most important ones in the history of psychology. The subjects taken in the experiment as “teachers” were influenced by several factors to obey the experimenter and shock the learner when the learner answered incorrectly. Firstly, the presence of an authoritative figure like the experimenter in this case, increased the gravity of the situation and forces the participant to comply. Secondly, the fact that the experimenter continuously asked them to continue the experiment, by saying things like “it is necessary that you go on” etc must have had an impression that the experiment was important Thirdly, the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Psychoanalytic Personality

...and develops pleasure. Additionally, the stage happens between the time of birth and 2 years and if it happens to be a problem or fixation, an individual would want to go back to that stage and develops unusual behaviors like chewing the thumb because he was preoccupied with oral stimulation. The next stage happens between the age of two and four years, and the psychologist called this the anal stage. The child’s sexual energy is centered on the anus, he or she will have to know how to retain or remove faces. The mother will have to train the child to know about the toilet because this where the child’s pleasure is focused on. The parent will have to develop good communication with the child to avoid...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Psychoanalytic criticism

...mind it, Jig. It's really not anything. It's just to let the air in" (3). He has become pushy on the issue. Again, Jig says nothing. Not only is she submissive, but she is allowing him to bully her into a decision she is not yet ready to make. Yet, Jig's superego is still overriding the desires of the man's id. The man makes the statement that he does not want anyone else but her. He is stating very clearly that he does not want the child. She discusses that she knows what harm can come to her from having an abortion, even though he continues to claim how very simple it is. She states "I just know things" (5). The girl's ego is utilizing defense mechanisms and her superego...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Psychoanalytic theory

...their purpose and identity. Psychologists Rollo May adopted this theory and implemented it in the humanistic approach to psychology where the patient went about resolving psychological problems by considering questions of meaning and change in this humanistic context (Fine 1990). One of the major criticisms levied against humanistic psychology by psychoanalysis was that it didn’t consider the complexities of human motivation. While psychoanalysis presented complex notions of unconscious impulses and human development, humanistic psychology was largely void of these elements. Humanistic psychology responded to these criticisms by arguing that while unconscious impulses and biological...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Critics

... No: Kafka’s Metamorphosis Kafka’s Metamorphosis is not just a simple story, as it is rich in meanings. The reader can fairly judge the story having symbols, hidden meanings and meaningful characters. The title of the story, the characters, the setting and symbols make the story thought provoking. A connection between the title, characters, setting and symbols can be found while interpreting the story and that connection is the concept of alienation. Metamorphosis is the life cycle of an insect in which, it changes different shapes to reach some final stage. In the story, we can find the character of Gregor Samsa going through the process of metamorphosis, changing shapes and finally reaching final stage that is death in his case... No:...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Article critics

...NIH GIVES SURPRISING BOODT TO CHELATION THERAPY Institution: NIH Trail Gives Surprising Boost to Chelation Therapy The AHA news revealed that heart attack patients given weekly infusion of chemical chelation therapy had fewer cardiovascular events than those who received identical appearing placebo infusion. The AHP press unveiled this information based on the clinical trial results presented at the American heart association’s scientific session 2012.Tthe study was done in the multicenter, double efficacy trail. The trail to assess chelation therapy was a 10 year, $ 31.6 million study involving 1708 participants at 134 centers. 1708 heart attack patient were randomization to receive... GIVES...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Why does the movie Blackfish address a Marketing problem

...1) The movie “Blackfish” not only presents the ethical dilemma being faced by the modern world due to the business activities of its organizations but also identifies a marketing problem to be dealt with. The movie is about how the killer whales are being confined for the entertainment purposes and how such businesses can actually be dangerous for the society as well as for the businesses itself. The movie highlights the incidences of how the whales have killed the trainers while at the same time outlining the mental and physical sufferings of these animals. A critical look at the movie would suggest that it essentially inform its audience that SeaWorld,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Stanley Park

...Stanley Park Stanley Park lies on an elevated peninsula stretching into the corresponding Georgia Strait, andentails four hundred and five hectares of flowering gardens, dense woodlands and the underlying lookouts providing views of the sea and the mountains. A nine kilometres waterfront promenades the seawall and runs around the park thus enabling of the pedestrians and cyclist to drink on the stunning scenery. Stanley Park scenic Drive runs one way in counter clockwise direction and offers an alternative drive way for the busses (Schultz, 2007). Stanley Park was founded by Lord Stanley on the romantic impulse in the nineteenth century. It is one...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic How Does Stanley Renner Address the Problem of Psychoanalytic Critics for FREE!

Contact Us