Anna O. Case Study - Coursework Example

The experience and behavior of individuals are continuously influenced by the unconscious without our awareness. He used an iceberg to demonstrate the different levels of the mind and emerged that unconscious was the bulkiest end of the iceberg, which is beneath water and invisible to human. In Ann’s case, she had hallucinations where she thought her hair ribbons were snakes, that is, unpleasant content which she experienced. Her suicide attempts, extreme hallucinations and inability to focus are experiences that were influenced by her unconscious (Freud, 1977).

Jung views personal unconscious as the psyche aspect in which awareness of an individual is never interred and is generally expressed through dreams or overt behaviors. Creative deals, new thoughts and other meaningful symbols originate from it. Collective unconscious is the unconscious aspect in which universal and inherited themes in human life are manifested. The human race history from primitive times still prevails within us. Her suicide attempts, extreme hallucinations and inability to focus are experiences in which overt behaviors were expressed.

Caring for her father was a good thought that originated from her unconscious according to Jung. They agree that ego cannot access this psyche part (Smith, 1990). Unconscious clearly expresses itself when the human ego guard drops such as in dreams. She expressed her unconscious through her extreme hallucinations (Jung, 1989). On what specific points would they agree and disagree on regarding the purpose and manifestation of the unconscious in the case of Anna? Freud would argue that the larger part of her storage was composed of unpleasant and unacceptable content, for instance, the hallucinations she experienced are not considered as pleasant experiences but they were manifested in her due to her unconscious.

He would also continue to claim that her experiences and behaviors were continuously influenced by her unconscious without her awareness. That is, suicide attempts, completely speaking in English after the death of her father and loss of concentration were influenced by her unconscious. She was not aware of all these experiences but its only other people who observed them (Freud, 1987). Jung would disagree with Freud in various ways. First, she went thorough loss of appetite, lack of concentration, suicidal attempt and extreme hallucinations.

Jung would disagree that these are not influenced by her unconscious as Freud argues. This is because Jung argues that these are part of the collective unconscious in which are universal and inherited themes in human life are manifested. They have been in human race history from primitive times and still prevail within us. It is true even today that people still go through these behaviors and am sure most of us at one point of life has hallucinated, lost appetite or expressed any of the above behaviors (Jung, 1978).

It is clearly observed that they agree that ego cannot access this psyche part. Unconscious clearly expresses itself when the human ego guard drops, such as in dreams. She expressed her unconscious through her extreme hallucinations. She would not have expressed and shared her experiences if she had a high level of ego (Smith, 1990). Naturally, human ego makes human not to share and accept any negative experiences they go thorough in their life. This can be extracted from their