StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Psychodynamic vs Humanistic Theories - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Psychodynamic vs Humanistic Theories" answers how Freud’s psychodynamic theory of personality compares with humanistic theories of personality. It critically discusses each psychological theory independently at first and then compares them as to their features…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Psychodynamic vs Humanistic Theories
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Psychodynamic vs Humanistic Theories"

?Comparing Psychodynamic and Humanistic Theories This essay purports to answer the research question: “How does Freud’s psychodynamic theory of personality compare with humanistic theories of personality?” by delving into a thorough research on theories from available literature. It will critically discuss each psychological theory independently at first and then compare them as to their features. The Psychoanalytic theory is premised on the belief that human nature is greatly affected by a person’s early childhood experiences and conflicts between impulses and prohibitions. From Freud’s early work (1910), he already introduced his theory as stemming from an individual’s sexual impulses from which he based his Psychosexual Stages of Development. He theorized that as a person grows, he derives satisfaction from stimulating a particular part of his body which he named “erogenous zones”. From the time a child is born until around age 2, his erogenous zone is his mouth, so Freud termed it the Oral Stage. This is the stage when the baby puts everything in his oral cavity or mouth in order to learn about the world. The next stage is a time of toilet training and mastering muscle control for defecation, so the anus becomes a source of pleasure. This stage is termed the Anal Stage. At around the age of 4 to 7, the child discovers that his genitals give him pleasure, so he learns to stimulate it. This is called the Phallic stage. This stage dies down into a latency period from the ages of 7 to about 12, when interest in discovering bodily pleasures cool off and children tend to look outwards in the hopes of making friends. The final Psychosexual stage is the Genital stage when adolescents up to adults confirm that genital stimulation in masturbation or the sexual act gives utmost pleasure. This is the time when people take interest in the opposite sex in the hopes of finding a mate. Freud theorized that experiences of individuals in each particular stage will have a significant effect on his or her personality when they grow up. For example, if during the Anal stage, the child experiences frustration in toilet training due to having “accidents” that embarrass him, then as a grown up, he would be very conscious keeping control not only of his bodily urges but of his words and actions, to avoid embarrassment of “letting go”. The same goes for every psychosexual stage. However, if the individual chooses to “sublimate” such urges into higher goals, then he gets to exchange their sexual goal for a more socially more valuable one. Freud’s views human behavior as determined by irrational forces, unconscious motivations and biological and instinctual drives evolving throughout his life (Weiten & McCann, 2006). Quite different from Psychodynamic theories, Humanistic psychologists wanted to analyze people’s personalities with the exploration of the nature of the self, self-actualization, health, creativity, being, becoming, individuation, and meaning (De Carvalho, 1990). Abraham Maslow, one of the proponents of Humanistic Psychology conceptualized the Hierarchy of needs which illustrates that a person goes through a ladder of needs for survival. His needs for safety is basic, as it encompasses biological and psychological needs of security –his hunger is satiated, he is clothed and sheltered and he does not feel threats to harm his cocoon of security. When these basic needs are met, then he goes up to the need for affection as he seeks warm and satisfying personal relationships to make him feel loved and to love others in return. Upon satisfying that need, he feels a need to build up his esteem, as how he feels about himself and how others think of him becomes essential to his survival. Finally, he reaches self-actualization which is the “full use of talents, capacities, potentialities, etc..” (Weiten & McCann, 2006). Since humanistic psychology focuses more on personal improvement instead of dwelling on frailties, much has evolved as concepts that support it. Several proponents have been named for humanistic psychology. Carl Rogers espoused his views in his Person-Centered theories that emphasized unconditional positive regard and the quest for congruence of self to achieve authenticity. This approach has great respect for a person’s subjective views and potential for self-actualization. It offers a fresh and hopeful perspective on its views on human nature. (Weiten & McCann, 2006). Another psychologist being associated with humanistic theories is Gordon Allport who is known to coin the term “humanistic”. However, due to the breadth and depth of his theories, he is more accurately characterized as an “eclectic” or “open” theorist (Nicholson, 1997). However, Allport did not totally agree with existentialist influences on humanistic psychology, thinking existentialism was “intellectually pretentious, self-indulgent, and unduly pessimistic” (Allport cited in Nicholson, 1997). This may have been because he was into including spirituality and religion in his theories which espoused faith in a higher being instead of just one’s self. That is why although he thought humanism had noble intentions for a better Psychological force, he admitted that he cannot totally embrace it as representing his own philosophy because it was not complete for him. It did not speak of human aspects of sin or guilt or provide answers as to what happens beyond one’s life experiences (Nicholson, 1997). Psychological Humanism theories emerged as the Third Force in contrast it to the prevailing major forces of Behaviorism and Psychoanalysis. Its conception was a reaction to humanists’ criticism that the prevailing theories of Psychology reduced people to mechanical parts, and so, their theories were considered dehumanizing. (De Carvalho, 1990). Humanists see reductionistic mindsets as hindrances to true healing. Humanists argue that people should be seen as whole beings and not as parts of the whole that can overrule the individual’s personality. This theory of Psychology realized that most psychological research studied the implications of something negative – abnormalities, maladaptive behavior, depression, learning disabilities, mental illness – to name a few. Most of these have been explained by Psychodynamic theories as effects of untoward experiences in certain psychosexual stages. Goldberg (2010) for one, came up with a list of his observations as to the problems in the discipline of Psychology that is making it lose its credibility. He believed that the pessimistic theories that prevailed over the years reflected the psychoanalytic emphasis on people’s loss and pathological circumstances. He contends that Psychology should focus more on more humanistic goals such as the quest for “personal identity, significance and unification” (p. 678). They are better understood when their experiences are made more meaningful for themselves. Conclusion The Psychodynamic and humanistic theories were developed in an attempt to understand human behavior, motivations and personality. Both theories, as well as Behavioristic theories have been influential to Psychology in the recent decades and have enjoyed their share of followers. However, upon careful research, Psychodynamic theories focused more on the negative consequences of people’s behaviors in each Psychosexual stage while humanistic theories urged on the positive side of people to surface, grow and work towards self-actualization. References Decarvalho, R. J. (1990). A history of the “Third Force” in psychology. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 30(4), 22-44. Freud, S. (1910). The origin and development of psychoanalysis. American Journal of Psychology, 21(2), 181-218. Goldberg, C. (2000). A humanistic psychology for the new millennium. The Journal of Psychology, 134(6), 677-682. Nicholson, I. (1997). Humanistic psychology and intellectual identity: The “open” system of Gordon Allport. The Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 37(3), 61-80. Weiten, W. & McCann, D. (2006) Psychology: Themes and Variations, 1st Ed., Nelson College Indigenous Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How does Freud's psychodynamic theory of personality compare with Research Paper”, n.d.)
How does Freud's psychodynamic theory of personality compare with Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1461731-how-does-freudyies-psychodynamic-theory-of
(How Does Freud'S Psychodynamic Theory of Personality Compare With Research Paper)
How Does Freud'S Psychodynamic Theory of Personality Compare With Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1461731-how-does-freudyies-psychodynamic-theory-of.
“How Does Freud'S Psychodynamic Theory of Personality Compare With Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1461731-how-does-freudyies-psychodynamic-theory-of.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Psychodynamic vs Humanistic Theories

Explain and Evaluate Psychodynamic and Humanistic Approaches

Psychodynamic and humanistic Approaches in Psychology Introduction There are different approaches in psychology.... Further on we will focus our attention on psychodynamic and humanistic approaches.... humanistic approach in psychology humanistic psychotherapy implies a wide range of various issues related to a patient, such as his mind, body and spirit.... psychodynamic approach in psychology: theoretical assumptions Sigmund Freud is the founder of psychoanalysis and psychoanalytic theory and is often referred to as the founder of the modern psychology....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Application of Psychodynamic and Humanistic Perspectives

4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The Psychodynamic and Humanistic Perspectives Applied to Anxiety

There are significant differences between the psychodynamic and humanistic theories on treating anxiety disorders today.... This assignment describes various methods of applying psychodynamic and humanistic perspectives to anxiety.... Because anxiety is both psychological and physiological, treatment requires cognitive-based and relaxation-based therapies, which is why psychodynamic and humanistic application both have advantages in reducing anxiety symptoms....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Hymanistic Versus Psychodynamic Approaches

These include psychodynamic, humanistic, cognitive-behavior therapy and transpersonal approaches.... Psychodynamic and humanistic approaches exhibit distinct differences, with some common points of similarities (Wetherell and Maybin 1996, p.... On the other hand, humanistic approach is defined to as the approach to human behavior as that which is informed by deviations from the natural tendencies of being good (Spurling 2009, p.... The social and the mental problems bring about the deviations in humanistic approach....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Behaviorist, Humanistic, and Psychodynamic Perspectives of Psychology

Psychodynamic theories developed from Sigmund Freud's work on the unconscious and mental processes (Weiten, Dunn, & Hammer, 2012, p.... Behaviorist, humanistic, and psychodynamic perspectives of psychology Name Instructor Class 26 August 2012 Questions about the human mind and behavior are critical to the birth of psychology.... This essay explores three early perspectives of psychology: Behaviorism, psychodynamic, and Humanism.... The psychodynamic perspective of psychology asserts that human behavior is significantly a product of the unconscious....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Psychodynamic Model

The core psychological theories encompassed by the psychodynamic model are those that regard human beings' functions, interactions and perceptions as based on the interrelationships between personal forces and drives, especially the unconscious interactions among the different structures of one's personality.... Among theories, the central one to psychodynamics is Freud's psychoanalysis and later theories postulated by other psychologists who based their works on Freud's ideas....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Humanist Theories

It is possible to achieve some explanations through humanistic theories that define why human beings will behave in a certain manner.... This paper examines the concepts behind humanist theories to define their role in forensic psychology when assessing people like Jeffrey Dahmer and Charles Manson.... In addition, the paper will examine how the humanist theories differ from psychodynamic theorist. ... Charles Manson is an American Criminal convicted of Tate-LaBianca Humanist theories 2nd, November, This paper examines the concepts behind humanist theories to define their role in forensic psychology when assessing people like Jeffrey Dahmer and Charles Manson....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Personality Theories

Besides, he argued that personality develops in a predetermined order, and builds upon each previous stage (McLeod, Personality theories By: Theorist Orientation Key motivational forces Model of personality structure View of personality development ... He was an ego psychologist who emphasized the role of culture and society....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us