Free

Abraham, Issac and Regan - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the research paper “Abraham, Issac and Regan” the author analyzes the animal rights movement in the United States. Behavioral research that supports certain animals having 'comparable emotional abilities to humans' further strengthens this proposition…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Abraham, Issac and Regan
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Abraham, Issac and Regan"

Abraham, Issac and Regan
Tom Regan is widely viewed as the seminal philosopher in the animal rights movement in the United States. He argues that at least certain animals—those with comparable cognitive abilities to humans – should be considered to be bearers of rights comparable to humans. Behavioral research that supports certain animals having 'comparable emotional abilities to humans' further strengthens this proposition. Regan's view, to paraphrase Kant, is, “Act in such a way that you treat humanity [and comparable species], whether in your own person or in the being of any other, never merely as a means to an end, but always at the same time as an end.”
It is reasonable to assert that Regan applies that second formulation to human minors or children as well if he extends it even beyond humanity in another situation. That being the case one can only conclude that Regan would raise serious objections to Abraham's behavior.
In direct violation of the second formulation Abraham as merely 'a means to an end' and not as 'an end', in and of himself. A man who claimed a direct line to God, who saw supernatural manifestations of his power would today be treated as suffering from a mental illness. Abraham's belief that God had ordered him to kill his son may have been sincere but it was not ethical according to the basic principles of Regan's philosophy.
Happiness
“Which of the two was wiser?”
Briefly, neither.
This brief vignette brings to mind the first line of Anna Karenina, “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.' Joan and Kate are both unwise 'in their own way.'
Consider the case of Joan's wasted life. Early in her career Joan took a highly ethical stand on an issue central to academia, student grading. Specifically, she refused to grade students on the basis of anything other than the work they submitted and her assessment of it. Undeniably, this decision effected the arc of her entire career. However, this is no reason to remain embittered throughout her life. Many people at the age of fifty deeply regret decisions they made with little thought half a lifetime earlier. This does not condemn them to a live of regret. Joan's academic discipline is not specified but if it were anything other than cost intensive-scientific research (history, languages, writing) she might have continued with her research.
She could easily have moved from the 'athletic factory' she could not see eye-to-eye with into teaching at smaller, private universities without a deep commitment to athletics and admiration for her academic integrity. Joan is unwise to have abandoned her personal search for fulfillment because a significant, but single aspect – her career – was unexpectedly disrupted early on in her adult life.
Kate, in a nutshell, is leading an unexamined life. She viewed her early unethical behavior as 'unfortunate'. However, nowhere does the case mention that she made use of her profile and success to address this deeply disturbing problem of student athletes that she herself encountered and recognized as unethical but necessary. Kate has abandoned any kind of social commitment and individual ethic in pursuit of personal aggrandizement and vanity. This too is unwise.
Mary, the wisest pursued another course. After attaining her graduate degree in Art History she took a position at a small, private and prestigious school in the Piedmont of North Carolina. She spent her summers in the south of France pursuing her research into Van Gogh and Gaugin, and painted year round. A modified version of her dissertation was published to positive reviews a decade after she started teaching and five years later she had her first individual gallery show in San Francisco. True to herself in terms of ethics and life story, Mary lived a rich and happy life pursuing her own star.
Bibliography
Cahn, Steven M. (2009). “Two Lives” in Steven M. Cahn. ed. Exploring Ethics: An Introductory Anthology Oxford University Press: 68 – 69. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Abraham, Issac and Regan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Abraham, Issac and Regan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1569273-cahn-contrasts-the-fates-of-joan-god-test-abraham
(Abraham, Issac and Regan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Abraham, Issac and Regan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/1569273-cahn-contrasts-the-fates-of-joan-god-test-abraham.
“Abraham, Issac and Regan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1569273-cahn-contrasts-the-fates-of-joan-god-test-abraham.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Abraham, Issac and Regan

Abraham Maslow

...? In 1943, Abraham Maslow the founder of Humanistic Psychology published his monumental work “A Theory of Motivation”. This is the first time, in the history of psychology; the inner side of the human mind was presented thru the study of human needs, desire, and behavior and not thru the stringent researches over animals or thru the behavior of anomalous humans. We are born, on this earth, to satisfy individual needs while approaching specific goals. Abraham Maslow studied to find out if there exists a framework of needs that could be applied to the human race, which at the same time serves as motivation. This work in detail studies this issue in order to determine if we humans could satisfy our inner...
15 Pages(3750 words)Research Paper

Tom Regan and Animal Rights

...Tom Regan and Animal Rights There was a time when it was commonly accepted by “civilized” people that those of non-European descent deserved to be chattel. There was a time when women could be viewed as property. In general, it seems that humanity has over time increased its level of moral sophistication and expanded its moral universe. In particular, there has been a focus on rights-based analysis: People have intrinsic rights, inalienable, and it is always wrong to eclipse them. In the modern era, there are many, such as Regan, who submit that perhaps the next logical evolution in our expanding moral universe is animal rights, treating animals with certain inalienable levels of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Issac Newton(Scientist)

...?Sir Isaac Newton On January 4, 1643, Isaac Newton was born to Isaac Newton, Sr. and Hannah Ayscough in Lincolnshire, England. Only three months after his birth, Newton’s father died; his mother eventually remarried and went to live with her new husband, leaving Newton in the care of his maternal grandmother. He greatly disliked his stepfather and often made threats against him, as well as his own mother. However, upon entering school, Newton shunted aside any other thoughts and emotions to allow himself complete concentration on his studies. Between the ages of twelve and seventeen, Newton’s primary focus was on his education. When he was sixteen, his mother, who had become widowed once again, pulled her son from school... Isaac Newton On...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Issac Newton

...? Day Month Year Isaac Newton Introduction It is amazing to think over what must go through one’s mind when considering the greatest of anything. Whether it is the greatest athlete, cook, or even philanthropist, there is perhaps no bigger honor than having the title of “greatest” bestowed upon you. Sir Isaac Newton is one such individual who garnered such praise. Being called by many as “the greatest genius and scientist who ever lived” (Smith 345), Newton is attributed with much of the knowledge available to modern scientists and mathematicians today. There are, however, many facets to this man’s life, other than being a scientist, that are worthy to know. Perhaps that is what truly causes mankind to label an individual... Day Month Year...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Regan to Obama years

...? Regan to Obama Years al Affiliation Regan to Obama Years The history of United s was significantly shaped by events that took place in the last half of 20th century and beginning of 21st century. Some of the events were important to the progress of United States as a world superpower. On the other hand, there were events that affected growth and progress of America as a nation. Despite these challenges, America continues to dominate the world in most affairs. America remains important in the dominance of world affairs. Most of the events that shaped American history took place from the time of Reagan to Obama administration. This paper seeks to describe major events that took place from the period of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Abraham Lincoln

...Order: 285235 Abraham Lincoln Had Abraham Lincoln died in the spring of 1860, he would today be a forgotten man; it was his handling of the greatest crisis ever faced by America that sparked the continuing interest in his life. (Neely, Mark E. Jr.; "The Last Best Hope of Earth: Abraham Lincoln and the Promise of America"; Harvard University Press; pp.5). "Whatever made Lincoln's life memorable occurred in the brief but eventful time between the summer of 1860 and the spring of 1865." (Neely, Mark E, Jr.; "The Last Best Hope of Earth: Abraham Lincoln and the Promise of America"; Harvard University Press; pp.5). "With the possible exception of the depth of Confederate...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Abraham Lincoln

...Abraham Lincoln Abraham Lincoln is considered to be one of the greatest American presidents who expressed himself as not simply a forceful war while demonstrating the vast power inherent in the presidency, but as a dictator, albeit in many accounts a benevolent and constitutional dictator. Lincoln, it is said, took the law into his own hands in meeting the attack on Fort Sumter and subsequently in dealing with the problems of internal security, emancipation, and Reconstruction. The author of a well-known treatise on emergency government in the Western political tradition states that "it was in the person of Abraham Lincoln that the constitutional dictatorship was almost completely...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Abraham linkon

...Abraham Lincoln vs. Stephen Douglass Abraham Lincoln vs. Stephen Douglass Lincoln was critical of slavery and its effectsin America, to Lincoln, though Africans Americas could not be given the same political and social equality as enjoyed by the whites, they were however entitled to enjoy the most basic human rights, the same rights that the whites enjoyed after the Declaration of Independence. For instance, Lincoln argued that if slavery were to continue, it would imply that even the white servants working in the western territories by the mere facts of being servants could not be treated in the same way as other whites. Moreover, though Lincoln believed slavery was morally wrong, he could not have been...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

ABRAHAM LINCOLN

...ABRAHAM LINCOLN Abraham Lincoln was the sixteenth president of United s and he served from March 1861 to April 1865 when he got assassinated. He led America through her Greatest, military, moral and constitutional crisis. He played a significant role in ending the American civil war, modernizing the economy, abolishing slavery and he also strengthened the national government. He grew up in a poor family in the Western Frontier. He was born on twelfth February 1809 in Kentucky, Hardin County and later moved to Indiana in 1816. He only attended three brief school periods as he was busy working looking for money to support his family. In 1830 he moved with his family to Southern Illinois in Macon County and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Abraham Lincoln

...Abraham Lincoln On 1861 March, Abraham Lincoln took an oath of office being the 16th president of the U.S. The country had long struggled with slavery for long. Kansa City was affected since laws against slavery had been broken. Anti-slavery and pro-slavery partisans did engage in a war aimed at control of the territorial government. Lincoln’s supporters in 1860 preferred union preservation as opposed to abolition of slavery. In contrary, Lincoln election was not emanating from his followers, most of them Republicans that wanted the complete abolishment of slavery (Erick, 134). Abraham Lincoln became a martyr following his assassination in 1865. In history books, he has been portrayed as...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Abraham, Issac and Regan for FREE!

Contact Us