Nobody downloaded yet

Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay will attempt to address pertinent issues that flows from the EU’s burgeoning role in European and in international affairs. Is the leverage that the EU wields one of a civilian, normative, or military power? Should the EU focus on any particular one of these powers?…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power"

Download file to see previous pages Before answering the question whether the EU should focus on being a civilian, normative, or military power, it is important to establish how these different forms of power have historically manifested in the EU's policies and activities. Conceptualising the terms 'civilian', 'normative', and 'military' is important in any analysis where these terms are used to describe the activities of EU's. Maull's (1990) view of a civilian power includes the employment of "solidarity with other societies, and a sense of responsibility for the future of the world - and particularly the global environment". (p.106) It is important to note that Maull's analysis of the exercise of civilian power is quite restrictive as it relates to the state or the exercise of national civilian power. Thus using a 'statist' perspective of the exercise of civilian power in the context of a supranational EU, would have its possible limitations. Vital lessons can, however, be drawn from his analysis and can be transposed into the EU's experience. Manner's (2002) conception of the EU as a civilian power is interpreted primarily in economic terms. Simply put, civilian power can be said to be the exercise of non-military power and would include "economic, diplomatic and cultural policy instruments." (Smith, n.d. p.1) Smith's conception of civilian power would thus exclude any use of the military, even if the military were used in situations of peace-keeping, whether armed or unarmed. To Smith (n.d.) even though the military can be used in unarmed peace-keeping situations, they have also been trained to kill and thus such an activity cannot be said to be civilian. Smith (n.d.) further identifies four core elements in the exercise of civilian power - "means; ends; use of persuasion; and civilian control over foreign (and defence) policymaking". (p.2) Consequently, in employing civilian policies, the means and the ends of those policies must be non-military, with persuasion (and not coercion) being the main instruments of achieving policy objectives. Based on the above conception of civilian power, Smith (n.d.) has argued in relation to the EU that: " clinging to the notion of civilian power EU not only stretches the term 'civilian' past its breaking point, but also tends to induce excessively rosy-eyed views of the EU as an international actor. 'Civilian' often means 'good', and deploying the 'civilian power EU' argument can close down critical analysis of actual EU foreign policy activities". (p.1) With regards to concepts of normative power, Manners (2002) views the EU's normative power as its capacity to mould or influence notions of what constitutes 'normal' in politics at the international arena. This exercise of normative power is very evident in the EU's relationship with Africa. The Council of the European Union has for instance stated that "Europe has a strong interest in a peaceful, prosperous and democratic Africa. Our strategy is intended to help Africa achieve this."  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1502894-european-union-essay
(Should the EU Focus on Acting As a Civilian, Normative or Military Essay)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1502894-european-union-essay.
“Should the EU Focus on Acting As a Civilian, Normative or Military Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1502894-european-union-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power

Civilian courts and military courts

...? MILITARY COURTS AND CIVILIAN COURTS [School] Number] May 28, MILITARY COURTS AND CIVILIAN COURTS In ademocratic state, it is essential that an independent and impartial judiciary system is established for the purpose of achieving the republican concept of the separation of powers among the three co-equal branches of the government. The legislative and the executive branches have their own specific functions under the Constitution. Actions made beyond the scope of their jurisdiction will tantamount to encroachment of functions, which is a violation of the separation of powers recognized under the Constitution. The judiciary in...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

The EU should have remained a civilian power. Discuss

...and political means in absence of any military means (Stavridis, 2001, p.3). Many wonder which type of power the EU exercises, whether civilian, military, or normative power, as they try to identify the roles of the EU in the international politics. This paper presents a very thoughtful discussion, specifically arguing for why the EU should have remained a civilian power. The first part of this paper focuses on the meaning of civilian power; the second part presents arguments explaining why the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Normative Theory

...pursue their career as responsible professionals who work for the betterment of their country despite the fact that they might have to reveal hard truth. This notion is not an advantage for the government however it provides a guideline for media professionals that regulate their acts to keep them in accordance with morals. This assumption in the mass media will provide a code for media professionals to understand their responsibilities as media personnel without having to take advantage of their positions (Stern et al 2007; UN News Center 1948). The normative philosophy mentioned above contains several aspects of the role of government in media. The government of any particular country possesses...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Military Service vs Civilian Employment

...or through joining insurance companies. When it comes to education, military offers the best benefits package unlike civilian compensation package. It is hard to find employers who offer tuition reimbursement for workers. The few employers who offer tuition reimbursement for workers demands that the worker pay the cost of tuition up front and clear the education program before getting reimbursement. The worker should have also attained certain grade (GPA) to qualify for tuition reimbursement, these are not demanded in the military (State Employee Benefits 2013). After completing the education, the employers always demand that an employee works for the company for a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

A critical evaluation of normative power EU

...for notions beyond the military and civilian authority so as to conceptualise the EUs normative power in Europe. The European Community must be a power for the international dissemination of democratic and civilian standards, or it will itself be more or less the causality of authority politics run by states mightier and more organised than EU (Duchene 1973:20). The notion of normative power can also be seen in the critical viewpoint of Johan Galtung (1973: 33), who claimed that the ‘ideological power is the power of ideas’. On the other...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Acting and Acting Styles

...Acting and Acting Styles Acting The setting of scenes is vital in creating mood, sense of place and reflects the emotional state of mind of the character. Costume also acts a big role in acting. The make-up and wardrobe limns the actor’s status or personalities. It is also used to produce the divergence between two or more characters. In off-screen space, the actor uses a non-physical present space in the frame. In this action, the person who views is able to realize something beyond the stage frame through the response of the character to the person. In Frontality, the character faces the camera directly. This provides the viewer with face to face...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Normative Ethics

...Normative ethics Normative ethics Ending the life of another human being is not morally permissible. However, there can be someexemptions in some cases including in abortion. Abortion is the termination of a pregnancy due to various reasons. According to me, I feel that abortion should be morally permissible in some cases. Not that terminating of a pregnancy is a noble thing to do but there are some cases that abortion should be allowed. Only the mentioned cases should anyone conduct abortion. In case, the health of the mother is at stake and there is no way the fetus can survive under those circumstances. It is unfortunate if doctors or other concerned...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Normative philosophy

.... The first ethical theory that should be engaged in the analysis is referred to as Virtue ethics. As one can easily see, the very name of it suggests that the focus of this approach will be on the idea of virtue – the ideal balance between excess and deficiency of a particular trait of character. In other words, this ethical theory draws a strong connection between the idea of morality and the character of a particular person. This is quite important since it holds several significant implications for the evaluation of the actions. For example, the action which is largely considered to be an immoral one, such as lying, might be justified by the approach of Virtue ethics as it will argue that the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Acting

...the naked body, but to touch aesthetic senses of a person (3 News). That is what makes erotica an art. And that is what makes Eva an artist, but not an embodiment of vice. However, it is a huge mistake to compare moral norms of the early 20th century to the ones of our time. They are totally different, as well as our society. Besides, perception is subjective, as it was already mentioned. Who can say what actually should be regarded a norm? Who can be such a quintessence of virtue of our time? It is a difficult question to answer. Taking all of this into consideration it is possible to say that such profession as acting still has a certain taint of immorality. What is...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Normative Ethics

...Normative Ethics Normative theory revolves around the philosophies of moral guidance. It comprises the moral standards of people, the general moral principles and the judgment that acts as a basis for how people behave. It is what we depend on when making moral judgment and acts as a critical thinking guideline towards understanding people’s behavior. There are dilemmas associated with normal daily living that cannot be avoided. To solve such dilemmas requires an appeal to the constructs related to existing theories. The normative theories are broken down and are three basic theories that guide on how people live. The consequential framework that speaks of the moral rightness of an action or wrongness of an action depends... these...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power for FREE!

Contact Us