StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
"Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man" paper states that women should not be put into combat unless they create no burden with respect to their gender and if they can pass the requirements that are placed on men…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man"

Download file to see previous pages Support positions such as logistics, medical, intelligence, and administrative are also not allowed to be filled by women when in combat sectored zones. Although women are unofficially fulfilling these positions on a regular basis in Afghanistan and Iraq, they are not allowed to be assigned positions that “regularly collocate with ground combat units” (McSally, 2011). Through being banned from these types of positions, women are impeded on progress through their military careers, unable to gain rank through experience in combat situations, and therefore unable to be given promotions due to inexperience in these levels of military duty.

According to Fenner and DeYoung (2001), “Most of the jobs that remain closed to women are in specialties that the Services consider likely to engage enemy forces in direct combat (or that serve in close proximity to those that do) and those in which members run a higher risk of capture” (p. 3). There are a great number of reasons why this policy remains in effect. The first reason given by Fenner and DeYoung (2001) is that there is a resistance by men to the idea of women in combat. Military men feel their own combat capabilities will be compromised if women are allowed to participate in ground missions. The public is uncomfortable with the consequences of women being captured in combat situations. As well, the dynamic of combat, capture, and imprisonment changes when women are brought into the equation. The second argument presented by Fenner and DeYoung is associated to the first in that these social issues that arise with women in combat have and will affect military readiness when faced with an action that needs a military response. The roles become clouded and too much effort is taken away from other problems in focusing on who and how roles should be fulfilled.

The first argument that is proposed suggests that women present a change in the dynamic of combat. This change affects the way in which men face the enemy and the way in which the enemy response is interpreted. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Should women be allowed in military combat Why and to what extent If Essay, n.d.)
Should women be allowed in military combat Why and to what extent If Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1759066-should-women-be-allowed-in-military-combat-why-and-to-what-extent-if-not-why-not
(Should Women Be Allowed in Military Combat Why and to What Extent If Essay)
Should Women Be Allowed in Military Combat Why and to What Extent If Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1759066-should-women-be-allowed-in-military-combat-why-and-to-what-extent-if-not-why-not.
“Should Women Be Allowed in Military Combat Why and to What Extent If Essay”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1759066-should-women-be-allowed-in-military-combat-why-and-to-what-extent-if-not-why-not.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man

Women in Combat

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Bans on women in combat continue to be a pressing issue among the military, specifically because of regulations and reinforcements which are placed on women. The continuous debates are now moving into issues directed at the ability for women to assist in combat. This debate is one which is now showing in current news, as women in the air force are restricted from flight and don’t have the ability to be trained to fly. The change in this occurred on March 30th, when the first woman flew in the Air Force while on combat duty; however,...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Conflict with man and women

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... of men and women, the conflict of mentality and understanding is going on as long as the humanity exists. How many men were searching for an answer to the question “What women want?” Women think they figured men out – men want basic things: food, TV and, well, to be satisfied. Men are considered to be limited in their conversations to sport, cars and women only. Women are considered idle and vain, with conversations centered only around fashion, looks and gossip. At the best, women talk about their children. It seems that no intelligent...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Women in combat positions: Women should be respected as women, not because they can emulate being a man

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Head: ETHICAL/PHILOSOPHICAL ARGUMENT Women in combat positions: Women should be respected as women, not because they can emulate being a manName Class University Women in combat positions: Women should be respected as women, not because they can emulate being a man Women are currently barred from serving in more than 220,000 positions in the United States military. This is due to policy that was revised 17 years ago in which women are barred from serving in infantry positions, special forces, tanks, combat engineering and other specialized...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Should Women be Allowed in Combat

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Should Women be allowed in Combat? In the world nowadays, the long dis on the politics of gender has neverbeen resolved. There has already been a notion of gender equality. However, people, since they have been used to the traditional gender norms, are having a relative difficulty engaging the rise of different approaches towards gender that is geared towards equality. In the long course of military has an institution, the inclusion of women in the operations of the institution has been a long heated debate. Should women be allowed? Given...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Women

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Contemporary Perspectives on Women in the Workplace “Sometimes equality means treating people the same, despite their differences and sometimes it means treating them as equals by accommodating their differences”. Discuss this statement by Abella with reference to remedies offered by Agocs, Burr and Somerset or in any other readings studied in the course. Equality refers to the state where individuals living in a society are free from the discrimination at all the levels. However, the discrimination and its various components are subject to ...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Women in Combat

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... in Combat 2008 Women in Combat Nowadays the US Army represents a diverse body composed of male and female soldiers of different ages, ethnic, social and cultural backgrounds. Naturally, gender diversity is a very essential aspect in military studies nowadays. The growth of interest toward this topic seems to be absolutely justified and up to date. In the past, the role of women in military affairs was minor and insignificant: they performed functions of nurses or worked for national defense. As feminist movement grew stronger, the voices...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Article Critique: Women in Combat

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Article Critique: Women in Combat Introduction James W. Revels is a retired U.S. Army colonel and a contributing editor of DefenseWatch, the official magazine for Soldiers For The Truth (SFTT), an educational organization started by a group of concerned veterans and citizens to inform the public, the Congress, and the media on the decline in readiness of the U.S. armed forces (SFTT 2008). In Revel's article, "Time to Rethink Women in Combat", published March 9, 2004, he writes about why women should not be put on combat duty. His purpose is ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Women

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... 3 Women always played important role in the political and social life of s, in spite of their inferior status. While men were waging wars and struggling for new lands, women were trying to maintain the social order; in general they didn't rule directly, since the society always restricted their power, but acted as 'grey cardinals', whole control was always hidden. Nevertheless, literature and world history contains the outstanding personalities of those women who were both wise and magnificent and governed the whole countries, keeping in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Role of Women in Top Executive Positions

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... of Women in Top Executive Positions: Does Diversity Factor have an Impact Executive Summary Quite often the glass ceiling effect is cited as a reason which prevents women from reaching the top echelons of management in various business organizations. Various researches and studies conducted in this field of study indicate that apart from glass ceiling effect several other factors also are responsible for the poor representation of women not only in top executive positions but also in parliament. These studies hold the view that women are...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Why do women belong in combat

...Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Women in Combat Positions Women Should Be Respected as Women Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man... Why women belong in combat! Women in combat are female soldiers allocated/assigned to combat positions. History suggests that the combat positions were initially assigned to male individuals. Over time, however, individual women serving in combat were usually disguised as men or in leadership positions as queens e.g. queen Boudica. She led the Britons against Rome. Also, Joan of arc is a famous example. In the WWII(second world war), hundreds of thousands of German and British women soldiers served in combat roles but only in anti-aircraft...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Women in Combat Positions: Women Should Be Respected as Women, Not Because They Can Emulate Being a Man for FREE!

Contact Us