Free

What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the dialogue Crito written by Plato, an ancient Greek Philosopher, we get introduced to a back and forth conversation between Socrates and his rather affluent friend, Crito. The topic of discussion between Crito and Socrates revolved around justice, injustice and what they…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
What is Socrates argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not"

Crito In the dialogue Crito written by Plato, an ancient Greek Philosopher, we get introduced to a back and forth conversation between Socrates and his rather affluent friend, Crito. The topic of discussion between Crito and Socrates revolved around justice, injustice and what they considered as an appropriate response to injustice.
In Crito, Socrates gets incarcerated in prison, convicted and awaiting the day of his execution, a penalty he faced for corrupting young minds and impiety. The school of thought here was that by doubting and disbelieving traditional gods, he was practicing impiety, and by teaching others the same, he was corrupting the youth in effect. Crito gets to the prison where Socrates was serving time with a plan hatched to break Socrates out of prison. It is after learning about this that a debate ensues on the justification of Socrates escape (Anton 73)
In his argument, Socrates fronts that while the sentencing he received was wrong to begin with, it got reached through a legitimate process. In his thinking, Socrates was of the idea that the trial he got subjected to got done according to the law, he had the chance to defend himself against the allegations, and the verdict got passed by citizens. The matter at hand in this argument was whether content justice, which refers to getting the best result, overrules procedural justice that is following the laid down procedure, or vice versa (Anton 74).
Socrates states in his argument that we have to pick whether the law enabled social peace is more vital than an innocent man’s life. Socrates is of the idea that social peace, which gets enabled by the law, is superior to his innocence. In building his case, Socrates puts forward a paternalistic claim stating that since the laws enabled his dad to marry his mother, he considered the law as his parents. He also states that the laws ordered his parents to take him to school. As such, he is both a slave and offspring of law. Socrates feels that he owes the law similar unconditional obedience that slaves owe to their owners and children owe to their parents (Anton 75).
Socrates conclusion is that an injustice cannot be made right by another injustice. In this effect, the wrong conviction he had been given would not be made right by escaping prison. Socrates chooses to remain in the confines of his cell as a result of his unwavering belief and faith in Greek law, which he acknowledges awarded him the opportunity to lead a fulfilling life, and attain extensive knowledge (Anton 75). In his thinking, without the law, he would never have been able to achieve all which he did. His loyalty to Athens is like no other, and it is even prioritized before his own life. Socrates intelligence becomes evident as he eventually persuades Crito to shift his thinking. He wins Crito over and his argument suffices (Anton 77).
Whereas Socrates respect for the rule of law and procedural justice is to be admired, it is a fallacy of though in my view. This is so because he is putting a justice tag on a process that started with a great injustice. If a person is wrongly convicted in a court of law, no justification can be made to make the ruling right. Doing the time served not in any way have justified the wrongful conviction. However, his willingness to let the law prevail over his own life demonstrates the strong belief and dedication he has to the state.
Works Cited
John P. Anton. Essay in Ancient Greek Philosophy, Vol 3. New York: SUNY Pres, 1989. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same Essay”, n.d.)
What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1601422-what-is-socrates-argument-against-crito-in-the-argument-of-the-same-name-is-it-persuasive-why-or-why-not
(What Is Socrates' Argument Against Crito in the Argument of the Same Essay)
What Is Socrates' Argument Against Crito in the Argument of the Same Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1601422-what-is-socrates-argument-against-crito-in-the-argument-of-the-same-name-is-it-persuasive-why-or-why-not.
“What Is Socrates' Argument Against Crito in the Argument of the Same Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1601422-what-is-socrates-argument-against-crito-in-the-argument-of-the-same-name-is-it-persuasive-why-or-why-not.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not

Argument same sex marriage

...?Running Head: Same Sex Marriage Same Sex Marriage Inserts His/her Introduction Same sex marriage is the legal and socially recognized marriage of two people who belong to same sex or gender. It is considered a taboo in many societies all over the world. Some consider it against God and nature, other believe that such marriages will eventually destroy our family system. The controversy over same sex marriages is popular because the society itself has not accepted homosexuality. Due to religious influences people still think that homosexuality in unfavorable terms. In this essay argument will be presented as to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Persuasive argument

...Persuasive Argument In the writings of Rawls, he holds that in the free society people within that particular society have different views with regard to religion, different conception of what is wrong or right as well as other forms in which people relate personally. In view of this, and in the democratic society, people mentioned above would have contradicting commitments while there exists only one law to guide the diverse nature of the society. Rawls therefore tends to believe that enforcing a universal law within this diverse nature of the society is unworkable and hence raises two main fundamental issues: legitimacy and stability. In his view therefore democracy is based on justice in a liberal...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Argument against Tax Bailouts

...May 13, Argument against Tax Bailouts 2008 economic crises, triggered by the collapse of the subprime mortgage industry in the US, resulted in a need for massive government bailouts to prevent a sudden decline of large corporations going into bankruptcy. A bailout, is essentially, a government taking tax payer dollars and giving it to corporations on the verge of bankruptcy, as the collapse of these too big to fail corporations would not only result in job less at said company but will also impact all other corporations that have business associated with this failing company (Bezdecheck, 5).There are many advantages and disadvantages to a tax bailout, some which will be discussed in this paper....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

An Argument Against Platos Mimesis

...value. The main aspect of my argument against Plato’s views toward literature stems from the idea of the true forms. He felt that these were eternal and unchanging, so according to Plato’s view, the conception of honor found in The Iliad should be the same as our modern conception of honor. To the Greeks, honor and glory were the most valued virtues amongst heroes. This is because of the Greeks’ perception of the afterlife; once people died, they went to the underworld where they became mere shadows of their former selves. In order to earn some sort of immortality, the Greeks felt that their heroes had to become so honored and earn so much glory for their own name...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Persuasive/Argument

...to cancer (Sharmishta). And not just wine, studies show that a shot of whiskey provides the same benefits as the antioxidants in the recommended daily dose of Vitamin C (Sharmishta). Moreover, beer contains silicon which is beneficial for the development of bone strength (Sharmishta). So it is clear that alcohol can be a good thing – but only in fair and not excessive quantities. As mentioned so far, alcohol can be used both in good and bad manner. In my opinion, it is not good or bad in itself, but should be used responsibly, like a weapon. Handled with care, a weapon provides protection; in the wrong hands however, it causes death. The same is the case with alcohol, irresponsible consumption thereof...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Closing argument (persuasive)

... Topic: Teacher: Judging George Milton in “Of Mice and Men” by John Steinbeck “Of Mice and Men” by John Steinbeck is a story that informs about the friendship of two persons, George Milton and Lennie Small in which, one friend is forced to take the life of the other. George is quite knowledgeable about the deficiencies present in Lennie. He knows Lennie from his childhood and has always supported him. His support and assistance has made Lennie dependent on him. Because of Lennie, George also has to suffer but he never wants to wound his friend. At last, George has to kill Lennie because he continuously observes that he in unable to support his friend wholly. George Milton’s action was necessary. He has no other choice but to take... Topic:...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Crito- Socrates argument against escape via the voice of The Laws

...SocratesArguments SOCRATES ARGUMENTS In response to Critos arguments Socrates considers three things why the opinion of the majority is not the most important opinion, (2), what the consequences of escaping would be Athens, and (3), whether escaping is an unjust action such that it would harm Socrates soul. Crito presents three arguments for why Socrates should escape. His first argument is that if Socrates does not escape, then he will hurt Crito. In his second...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Persuasive argument

... College: Fad Diets: The Atkins Diet may not be the perfect Solution America is a nation primarily founded upon innovation and is, for this reason, filled with women and men who strive to make daily tasks easier and faster. As a result, many tasks are constantly being reinvented especially in the realm of fitness, health, and, most notably, weight-loss. America, considered by numerous people to be the homeland of fad diet, has seen hundreds of fast weight loss programs in the past: the grapefruit diet, the tuna diet, the low sugar diet, the salmon diet and the low-fat diet, just to name a few. While each of these weight loss programs enjoyed a short popularity period, none has rivaled the cult status of the Atkins diet. Dr. Atkins... ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay

On Socrates argument in The Crito is actually an argument developed by each PHI 101 student that explicates and evaluates Socrates argument in The Crito. S

...SocratesArgument in the Crito According to Crito, until the boat which left before Socrates’ trial would arrive was not in Athens, then no execution should take place. However, since the boat would arrive in Athens on that day, Crito urgently requested Socrates to escape from prison. What followed and transpired between Socrates and Crito was a meaningful dialogue where the latter convinced the former that an escape from prison would be the best solution. The philosopher, however, through a Socratic dialogue, reiterated his refusal to escape because he believed that a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Socrates and Crito

...CRITO by Plato Introduction Socrates and Crito were the two famous Greek philosophers. Socrates was imprisoned and was waiting for execution. At that time Crito visited him and had a long conversation. Crito wanted to take Socrates out of the prison but Socrates was ready for execution. In their conversation Crito highlighted many arguments for changing Socrates’ decision but that ultimately did not influenced Socrates to change his mind. This essay will highlight the important things which were discussed in between them during their...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic What is Socrates' argument against Crito in the argument of the same name Is it persuasive why or why not for FREE!

Contact Us