The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Distinction Between Pornography and Obscenity This paper will examine Catharine MacKinnon’s views on pornography and whether or not her views adequately illuminate the issues. Based on MacKinnon’s discussion, as well as other research on the subject, this paper will also address the question or whether or not the United States government or certain citizen groups should mount a concerted effort to clean up the internet by attempting to ban pornography…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity"

Download file to see previous pages MacKinnon, a feminist and an attorney, believes that society in the US applied different legal rights, lesser rights, to women as compared to men. Obscene speech is not protected under the First Amendment according to the U.S. Supreme Court, but there is much debate over the distinction between pornography and obscenity. Perhaps one of the most remembered Supreme Court Justice quotes is that of Potter Stewart, who said, I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description ["hard-core pornography"]; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that. (Jacobellis) Linda Susan Boreman MacKinnon rose to fame when she represented Linda Susan Boreman, the actress known as Linda Lovelace, in a lawsuit that claimed that Boreman had been forced at gunpoint to perform in pornographic films by her husband. Following her appearance in the film Deep Throat, Boreman gave up the adult film industry and became a spokeswoman for the antipornography movement (IMBD). Boreman also testified before the Meese Commission in New York City to the effect that while moviegoers were watching the sex scenes in Deep Throat, they were witnessing her being raped (105-113). MacKinnon’s View Certainly a dichotomy, Catharine McKinnon felt that the First Amendment should protect the First Amendment of the U. S. Constitution, but she also wanted to condemn and outlaw pornography. She actively pursued civil rights remedies for victims of pornography and advocated to treat pornography as hate speech. During a PBS interview with Ben Wattenberg, MacKinnon defined pornography as, a practice of sex inequality, and defined as the sexually explicit subordination of women through pictures and words that also includes a list of other very specific activities. In other words, it's defined in terms of what it actually does. It subordinates women as well as being a sexually explicit medium. There are other media that subordinate women but are not sexually explicit, and therefore don't have the same effects. (PBS) The harmful effects of those who engage in viewing pornography are widely described as including the following: Harm to existing marriages, including a 25.6% greater likelihood of divorce, 3.18 times greater likelihood of having an extra marital affair, and an 8% chance of being less likely to have a happy marriage (Weiss). Higher Rates of Substance Abuse (Weiss) Higher acceptance of premarital and casual sexual behavior (Weiss) A nearly five times higher number of lifetime sexual partners than non-pornography users (Weiss). In 1985, MacKinnon wrote about the civil rights violations of pornography in the Harvard Civil rights-Civil Liberties Law Review. She asserted that the female stars in pornographic films or photographs had clearly not given consent as evidenced by the scratches, bruises, and other injuries on their bodies. She further argued that audiences respond to pornography because it is perceived as real and as such, they act out in real life the violent acts ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity Essay”, n.d.)
The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity Essay. Retrieved from
(The Distinction Between Pornography and Obscenity Essay)
The Distinction Between Pornography and Obscenity Essay.
“The Distinction Between Pornography and Obscenity Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
...?I. What is the principle that Mill asserts and which area of life is it supposed to govern? John Stuart Mill expressly declares in his essay that heis asserting on the principle of self-preservation as the one and only reason for disturbing the peace and liberty of another. He stresses in no uncertain terms that in any civilized society, citizens must live and let live. Insofar as a mature and capacitated individual is concerned, he has absolute freedom over his own life. Nobody has valid reasons to interfere with his decisions on what to do with his own body and what to do with his own life on the condition that these decisions must affect only himself and nobody else. However, when an individual’s action causes or is believed... What is...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Pornography sexually explicit conduct and is obscene, or depicts an image that is, or appears to be, of a minor engaging in graphic bestiality, sadistic or masochistic abuse, or sexual intercourse, including genital-genital, oral-genital, anal-genital, or oral-anal, whether between persons of the same or opposite sex, and such depiction lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value (What is Child Pornography?) Pornography related to people below the age of 18 is usually included under child pornography whereas pornography above the age 18 is normally labelled as adult pornography. Even though adult...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
...of the passionate and obsessive sexual affair between Kichizo Ishidaa, a hotel owner, and Sada Abe, a prostitute turned servant who works for him. By portraying the unusual relationship and obsessive love between the couple, through several sequences of sexual acts, Oshima subtly redefines the meaning of pornography and obscenity. The movie depicts an “extended repertoire of graphic sex acts” that are typical of porn movies and due to stringent censorship laws in Japan Oshima has done all the post production work in France (Williams 183). Many critics have discounted the movie as pornographic but some, including the movie’s director, defended it on the grounds that it...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
.... The First Amendment to the US Constitution was in 1791; “The congress shall make no law reducing the freedom of the press and of speech” (Cohen, 282). From these provisions, the American citizens were freer to communicate in more ways. Additionally, the most fervently fought subjects have been centered a round pornography, and obscenity (Cohen, 277). It is a disturbing topic that does not varnish in so many traditions; the struggle over the right of scumbags like Larry Flynt to do what he does, is at the heart of America's unending struggle to balance individual freedom and community sensitivities. The movie reveals diverse themes that qualify it as a civil libertarian legal battle. Aspects of the movie...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Frankfurts Distinction between Bullshitting and Lying
...? FRANKFURT’S DISTINCTION BETWEEN BULLSHITTING AND LYING Submitted Frankfurt’s Distinction between Bullshitting and Lying Relaying wrong information about a person, event or act can take different approaches. Whereas some people may intentionally convey the wrong figures and distorted facts with malicious intents, others present misleading arguments for sheer lack of proper knowledge. This paper shall differentiate two vital classes of dishonesty that occurs in human society as well as in multi-agent systems. According to the work of Harry Frankfurt, someone who lies has the knowledge of the truth. A liar knows what he says is not true. In bullshit there is no knowledge of truth (Frankfurt, 2005, p. 43). A bullshitter lacks proper... . In...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Regulation of Obscenity and Pornography
...Statute regulating all aspects of obscenity and pornography Introduction How pornography should be regulated is one of the most controversial topics to have arisen in recent years not only because of lack of efficient regulating measures, but also because of problems with their definition. There is no settled definition of the pornography; all around the world it is difficult to define 'pornographic content' in a way acceptable to all1. What is considered simply sexually explicit but not obscene in England may well be obscene in many other countries. One of the most perplexing of all speech-related problems has been the issue of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment
Obscenity and pornography
...Obscenity and pornography Describe at least three of the methods that can be used by the legal system to reject sexual assault cases and discredit victims’ allegations of sexual assault. The number of sexual assault cases has increased tremendously with the growing amount of obscenity and pornography; subsequently, there have been an increase in the legal systems’ rejection or discrediting of the victims’ allegations of sexual assault too. It is not imperative that all the sexual assault cases are genuine and therefore the legal system makes use of various methods to discredit victims’ allegations of sexual assault during the court proceedings. For Lisa Frohmann, many...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
.... The use of porn for sexual gratification has become increasingly common among young males and females. Another study concentrated on persons from 14 to 18 years of age found that about 99% young men and 86% women have at some point in their lives used pornographic material (Sorensen and Knudsen, 2006). Along with pornography, other elements of the sex industry have also rapidly grown in the recent years such as, strip clubs, prostitution etc. An important issue related to pornography is its connection, if at all, with the rape and other forms of sexual violence and offense. There is no evidence or proof that a direct relationship between pornography and rape can be...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
...such as United Kingdom and some states in America recognize this aspect of gay marriages, and sexual intercourses. However, other societies are strongly against this aspect of gay marriages, and on this basis, there is a debate on their morality. However, it is important to provide an explanation that religion strongly advocates against gayism, as well as pornography. Works Cited: Johansson, Thomas, and Nils Hammaré. "Hegemonic Masculinity And Pornography: Young Peoples Attitudes Toward And Relations To Pornography." The Journal of Mens Studies 15.1 (2007): 57-70. Print. McKee, Alan. "The Relationship Between Attitudes Towards Women, Consumption...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
...24 July Pornography Pornography is the depiction of women as sexual objects, either in video, picture or word form. Pornography tends to display women as tools for pleasure and commodities for sex only. The female body parts in women are displayed in a manner to imply that women are defined by these body parts. Pornography tends to depict women as inferior and as filth while men are depicted as superior and as dominant beings (Hawkins and Zimring 155). From this definition, it is outright that rules and regulations about pornography would have to be set up. Mainly because the natural laws of nature do not allow for the subjection of another being to...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic The Distinction between Pornography and Obscenity for FREE!
Contact Us