Nobody downloaded yet

Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does - Book Report/Review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
One of the prominent developments of the twentieth century in the Western world was the rise and wide expansion of feminist world views. As a consequence of that process, many of the existing inequalities that negatively influenced women in social, economic, and cultural spheres were removed or significantly reduced…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Review Sarah Rutherfords (2001) article on sameness difference in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does"

Download file to see previous pages Aside from such court cases, there is also an ongoing public discussion of the possible limits for the equality between men and women (Halford and Leonard, 2001; Karsten, 1993). Indeed, as when placed in similar circumstances men and women may tend to behave in different ways, it is necessary to have a better knowledge of existing difference and, also importantly, of sameness between general effectiveness of men and women within the same fields of activity. In this regard, Sarah Rutherford, a consultant specialising in organisational culture and diversity, in her article "Any Difference An Analysis of Gender and Divisional management Styles in a Large Airline" provides results of a very insightful research that explores a specific aspect of the sameness/difference between women and men, namely their managerial approaches, and does so in a specific and at the same time quite representative environment, namely in a large airline. Let us take a closer look at the research of Rutherford, single out important conclusions that she reaches, and try link her contribution with wider debates on management and gender.
Sarah Rutherford opens her article with the general observations about the ongoing debate "as to whether woman manage differently from men and whether this may constitute a reason for womens lack of progress to the top echelons of organizations" (Rutherford, 2001, p.326). In this way, by presupposing the possibility of existence of real barriers for the career progress of women in business on par with men she immediately suggests that the topic of her research may be placed into the wider social context of what she calls "a feminist theoretical framework" (Rutherford, 2001, p.326) that recognises that inequalities exist. At the same time, Rutherford quickly moves on to an assumption that in reality things may be more complex and that it may prove to be quite difficult to clearly separate management peculiarities dictated by individual traits, including the gender of a manager, from those dictated by business function and specifics of an organisation. Also, before detailing the findings of her research the author expands the relevant underlying theoretical base by discussing the very notions of masculinity and femininity as not determinants based purely on biological differences between genders but as socially constructed behavioural patterns. For example, she points out that display of a certain range of emotions that both genders experience is traditionally considered to be a feminine way of reaction, an observation which will be very useful later in the article. So, already in this part of the article we encounter one of the very important points of the author that as far as masculine and feminine social roles have corresponding modes of behaviour, it is possible for men to mimic feminine roles, and vice versa. As will be evident from the authors report of the results of the research, this phenomenon indeed takes place, and, moreover, its usage by both genders is perhaps the most influential factor in the part of management discourse which deals with differences between managerial peculiarities of men and women. In fact, this early observation is very important for wider debates on management and gender as it rightfully broadens the scope of traditional feminist criticism of existing inequalities in treatment of men and women. It does so by pointing out that such strategies as the adoption by woman ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in Book Report/”, n.d.)
Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in Book Report/. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/people/1510958-review-sarah-rutherfords-2001-article-on-sameness-difference-in-male-and-female-management-styles-what-conclusions-does-she-reach-what-contribution-does
(Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) Article on 'sameness difference' In Book Report/)
Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) Article on 'sameness difference' In Book Report/. https://studentshare.org/people/1510958-review-sarah-rutherfords-2001-article-on-sameness-difference-in-male-and-female-management-styles-what-conclusions-does-she-reach-what-contribution-does.
“Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) Article on 'sameness difference' In Book Report/”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/people/1510958-review-sarah-rutherfords-2001-article-on-sameness-difference-in-male-and-female-management-styles-what-conclusions-does-she-reach-what-contribution-does.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does

In Raymond Carver's, short stories, How does one reach enlightenment

...abilities of the characters usually are major precursors of their future personal failure or success. Annotated Bibliography 1. Champion, Laurie. “What's to Say”: Silence in Raymond Carver's “Feathers”. Studies in Short Fiction. 34.2, 1997, 193-205. Champion’s article is a thorough analysis of Carver’s works. She compares many of his short stories, among which “Cathedral”, “A Small, Good Thing”, “Where I’m Calling From”, “Cathedral” and “Feathers”. The author finds that the most of Carver’s short stories are unlighted by the same central theme which is self enlightenment through communication and mutual understanding. Champion compares writer’s literary devices used in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Autism: male versus Female

...unheard of for one with autism to recover from it on his own (Helt et al, 2008). Autism: Males and Females While this condition can occur in both genders, there are those who have observed its increased prevalence among males. Bazelon (2007) of the New York Times even notes this, citing how autism is often perceived to be more of a boys’ affliction judging from the fact that boys seem much more likely to be susceptible to classical autism in particular. It has even been reported in the same article that 75% of the 560,000 Americans below 21 suffering from autism were in fact male, and that while it is not impossible for a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Male-Female Relationships

... oppressed but due to her desire, she managed to change the situation through writing. Conclusion In conclusion, relationship among male and female has improved over the years. Furthermore, stereotypes about relationships have also declined and faded. In addition, gender socialization and media have also affected modern relationships. Work Cited Abowitz, Deborah et al. Beliefs about Romantic Relationships: Gender Differences among Undergraduates. June 10 2009. Web April 30 2012.... Male-Female Relationship For a very long time, the difference between women and men was socially distorted and defined through varied lens of sexism whereby men assumed to be superior to women. Men have tried for...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

DIET EVALUATION : MALE / FEMALE FITNESS TRAINER & MALE / FEMALE ATHLETE

...such as osteoporosis, which often affects women athletes (ISSA, n.d e). As such, supplements such as calcium and iron are often recommended, but in her case there is a clear lack of supplements in the diet (ISSA, n.d e). In conclusion, both athletes have met the protein requirement with regard to whole proteins. However, there is a clear deficiency in the supply of carbohydrates in the female trainer’s dietary schedule. She only has a single serving of oatmeal. Additionally, she does not supplement her whole protein sources and there is no clear water intake rate within the definition of her diet. She also lacks any form of supplements...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Male and Female Leaders

...Running Head: MALE AND FEMALE LEADERS Male and Female Leaders [The [The of the What Are The Different Characteristics Of Male And Female Leaders And Is There Any Evidence That One Is More Effective Than The Other Project Title "Male And Female Leaders" Contents Abstract Acknowledgements Chapter # 1 Introduction Chapter # 2 Literature Review Chapter # 3 Discussion Chapter # 4 Conclusions and recommendations References Appendices Abstract According to the expert analysis investigation on leadership and teams suggests that men and women...
32 Pages(8000 words)Coursework

Male Verses Female Leaders

...to work for a male leader more than a woman because I believe the male leaders take everything into their grasps before taking a decision which could be regarded as one that is purely from a leadership perspective. My opinion is based on my prior work experiences where I had this woman leader who did not know what to do and how to work along with most of the people within the workplace settings. Hence I would definitely vouch for a leader who is a male rather than a female as it will make me work diligently and would let me apply at my best to achieve the professional goals that I have set for the organization as well as for my own self. Works Cited Winter, J...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

How Much Difference Does Ethnicity Really Make

...How Much Difference Does Ethni Really Make? al affiliation How Much Difference Does Ethni Really Make? Questionnaire 1. Are there ethnic or traditional variations amongst groups that wish for government action to secure the surrounding? 2. Does regression analyses imply that the seventies and eighties pragmatism of main support for surrounding security? 3. Do demographic indicators hold for Asian and Spanish-language Hispanic Americans? 4. Are Asian and Spanish-language Hispanic Americans the two fastest-growing subpopulations in the United States? 5. Is it more practical for elements of surrounding protection not to wait and instead to attempt...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Does Technology Make a difference

...Does Technology Make a Difference? Task: Does Technology Make a Difference? Technology has become central in the lives of people. Technological advancement has transformed all the sectors. In this way, it has led to progression in sectors such as hospitality, education manufacturing and medicine. Evidently, the transformations have significant impacts on such industries. The impacts are both positive and negative. Technology provides additional opportunities while it also outdates certain aspects of the industry. Overall, the advancements in technology have resulted in massive improvements in other industries (Richter, 1982). Technology has transformed communication...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Human Male and Female

...Module Question A human female is born with millions of immature eggs (oocytes) arrested at an early stage of meiosis.By the time of maturity, only 200,000 or so are actively remaining in the ovaries, and they re-initiate their development each month, though only one of them makes it to full maturity. The ovarian cycle, as such, is the cycle that an oocyte takes during its maturity, eruption from the ovary and travelling down to the oviduct and eventually to the uterus. This lasts on average twenty-eight days. The released egg will align itself to the uterine cycle where the lining of the uterus grows in preparation for the fertilization of an embryo. If the fertilization does not take place, the uterus...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Does Prayer Make a Difference for Patients

...Evidence Based Paper: Does prayer make a difference for patients? From times immemorial, prayer has been considered to be one of the strategies to cure illness and promote good health. Certain religious groups believe that prayer is the most important therapy for any sick person, placing it above medical therapy. Several research-based studies have evaluated the effects on prayer on the health of patients. However, the results have been contradictory and non-conclusive. In some cultures, like the African-Americans, who lack proper health care, individuals with poor health resort to faith in prayers. Despite the fact that intercessory praying, which means praying for others, is a "common...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic Review Sarah Rutherford's (2001) article on 'sameness difference' in male and female management styles. What conclusions does she reach what contribution does for FREE!

Contact Us