Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1417723-ethics
https://studentshare.org/other/1417723-ethics.
Since Deborah is working as a nursing practitioner at a private hospital, she forgets the very reality that private clinics and medical centers keep the profit motif in priority while offering their services and pecuniary gains are of vital interest to them. Furthermore, private health centers are run on the basis of the self-reliance doctrine, the administration of such organizations has to devise money-generating schemes in order to keep the ball rolling. Though in professions, other than health and medicine, the people do not pay much care to the mercenary motifs of the organizations, the healthcare centers are criticized and condemned for such avaricious purposes due to the very fact that they are expected to serve humanity by saving their lives in one way or the other. Consequently, the tricks and crookedness observed by these organizations are looked down upon in society. The same is applied to the community hospital in which Deborah has been working as a nurse.
Deborah has two divergent moral obligations: one towards her organization, violating the rules of which may put her job at stake. However, her second obligation is towards her Lord and humanity at large. It is therefore Deborah views the hospital’s recommendation of diseases diagnosis through laboratories as entirely unethical and cruel one due to the very fact that every patient does not require diagnosis through a laboratory provided the doctors are in a position, on the basis of their qualification and experience, to diagnose the ailment without consulting laboratory test reports. Secondly, every patient is not in a position of affording costly tests, and the imagination of further expenditures due to laboratory tests enhances their ailment and disturbs them mentally, by putting their health condition in grave jeopardy. Hence, Deborah is justified in criticizing such a condemnable act exercised by the hospital administration. Nursing practice is a synthesis of the interaction among the concepts of person, health, environment, and nursing. It is a direct service provided to a variety of patient/client populations throughout the life cycle, as well as groups and communities. (nurses.ab.ca)
However, since she is sincere and committed to her profession, she keeps working at the hospital with loyalty and honesty. By staying at the hospital, she would be able to guide the most deserving and serious patients so that they do not require the fulfillment of the condition of costly diagnosis. Moreover, such honest staff members are the asset of an institution, that continuously pricks the conscience of the irrational, senseless, and selfish staff members by realizing the imperative significance of sincere and unflinching service to the suffering humanity. Thus, Deborah should comply with the commands of her superiors along with requesting them not to ask everyone for a diagnosis. Furthermore, her presence at the hospital would also be a blessing for the community members, who seriously need the services of sympathetic, sincere, sacrificing, and kind-hearted professionals at large.
Read More