Ethics in Film Miss Evers Boys - Assignment Example

At the beginning of the study, ethical and was meant to explore the effect of lack of treatment in black males (Shaver's, Lynch & Burmeister, 2000).

However, the unethical part comes into focus later on in the study when a cure is, and no one bothers to use it. The team is only interested in the medical side despite human beings having a right to exist in the availability of treatment. The achievement of scientific and medical results is more important than the health of human beings. Codes of ethics explicitly state that doctors and nurses should not deny their patients treatment for reasons of judgment based on discrimination (American Nurses Association, 2001). The experiment raises many ethical questions on whether it is moral to continue an investigation even after a cure has been discovered. There is also the concern about whether professional nurses should allow the public to be misinformed during research.

Nurse Ever had prior knowledge of what was being researched and the effects that it would have on the subjects. As a professional nurse, the most appropriate action to take was to inform the patients of the nature of the study. However, she ignored her duties and participated in the denial of these rights to the patients. Her contribution to the study was a direct violation of the nursing code of ethics (Emanuel, 2003).

The Nazi medical experiments are similar to the test that was conducted on blacks in Tuskegee. A conflict of roles is identified; the nurse must do as the doctors prescribe for the patients. Although what is done is wrong, the primary responsibility of a professional nurse is to obey the doctor’s orders. The nurse should always be concerned with the well-being of the subject, and these should be more important than the interests of science (American Nurses Association, 2010).

There should be respect for the participant’s right to withdraw from research a factor that was considered in the film. Public administration of the nursing environment is put into question with nurses being socialized to a collective identity. The ethical difficulty in the movie revolves around the subversion of public interest for individual interests by the administrators. Some of the people on the medical team like doctor Broadus wanted a continuation of the funding. Despite the hurt and damage that was being implicated in the patients, he did not care about the codes and ethics of clinical research (Emanuel, 2003).

Conclusion
As identified in the essay there is a clear violation of research codes and ethics. The film nurse miss ever is caught up between her role as a professional nurse and an assistant to the doctors. Ever does not see anything wrong with her actions and does not disclose the purpose of the research. The American nursing association identifies the appropriate ethics to be followed as illustrated. Read More