Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This paper evaluates the depths of patient autonomy as an ethical dilemma impacting the nursing profession. Patient Autonomy as an Ethical Dilemma in Nursing According to Tauber (2005), patient autonomy refers to the exclusive legal right of a patient to have his wishes accomplished by the medical personnel while in their custody. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession"

Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession College Lecturer Introduction Choosing to save life by applying the best perceived action might contradict the prevailing code of practice or legal rights of the patient. Either way, a number of nurses have found themselves along the corridors of justice for professional misconduct, negligence or malpractice (Gutierrez, 2005). But what would a nurse do at a time when one decision would jeopardize her profession or compromise the life of the patient? This paper evaluates the depths of patient autonomy as an ethical dilemma impacting the nursing profession. Patient Autonomy as an Ethical Dilemma in Nursing According to Tauber (2005), patient autonomy refers to the exclusive legal right of a patient to have his wishes accomplished by the medical personnel while in their custody. By this clause, every patient has a right to seek truthful details of their state of health. Besides, the patient reserves the right to choose not to take a particular course of treatment even if the practitioner deems it necessary. By that understanding, the right of autonomy already presents a potential conflict of interest between the patient and the practitioner (Cowen & Moorhead, 2011). For instance, patient got pregnant out of a rape ordeal that has since left her traumatized, demeaned and psychologically broken. Through family support and encouragement, this patient has carried the pregnancy for more than eight months but each passing day her emotional and psychological health status continue to deteriorate. She has become depressed, weak and torn to a point that she cannot take the pain anymore. The patient wishes to abort the baby by all means even if it means taking the crude options. How would a nurse deal with such cases especially when the law prohibits abortion? Encouraging her to abort against the law would amount to professional misconduct as argued by Botes (2000). Turning her away is no better than negligence in case she ends up executing her plans in the backstreet. Disregarding patient’s autonomy on the other hand is tantamount to malpractice as stipulated in the nursing code of practice (Casterle et al, 2008) Impact on the nursing profession Such hypothetical scenarios are common occurrences especially among the youthful population who might have got pregnant against their wishes and would therefore opt to abort, contrary to the law. Like many other clinical dilemmas, the issue of client autonomy often leave the nurse on the hot spot as to what would be best for their patients’ life and their nursing profession. Similar cases of autonomy and conflict of interest are also common among the terminally ill patients who may not wish to continue with their medication after years of deteriorating health as observed by Yamamoto and Aso (2009). The conflict that arises over patient autonomy in a clinical situation often touches on ethics, code of practice and the law. The available exceptions only allow a medical doctor or a physician to make a compromising decision, and only if the patient is not in her right state of mind to make a sound decision. Such critical decisions must be well-consulted and duly approved by relevant authorities in the medical hierarchy. Unfortunately, nurses do not have such provisions especially those below the managerial level who also forms the bulk of practicing nurses. They must always depend on the doctor’s directives or second opinion (Schermer, 2002; Hamilton, 2012). In reality, the balance between patient autonomy and professional opinion of nursing practitioners is a major issue in healthcare facilities below level 3 including community hospitals and village dispensaries. Not withstanding the number of nurses who have lost their jobs as a result of perceived malpractice, the law always favour the weaker party who happens to be the patient (Kulkarni, 2010). In the event that a doctor is not readily accessible, such cases that appear simple from the face value pose a major risk to the professional career of nurses. In addition to the conflict of interest associated with patient autonomy, a number of nurse have fallen victims of malpractice by making honest decisions that turned unsuccessful in saving the life of critical patients in the absence of a medical doctor(Guido, 2006; Boivin, 2009). On the contrary, the risk involved in nursing practice and the fear of malpractice cases have continued to discourage thousands of young professionals who would have wished to purse nursing. Veatch (2009) also argued that the complexities of handling patient autonomy have partially contributed to the increased shortage of nurses and precautionary approach to clinical medicine. Many patients have also suffered more harm than good when nurses finds their professional career at stake with respect to dealing with prescribed code of practice pertaining to patient autonomy. Conclusion While the integrity of healthcare service provision is entrusted in the hands of medical practitioners including nurses, it is high time that the law recognized the role of nursing in patient care. For that reason, the medical fraternity should draft an inclusive code of practice that takes into account the special conditions that might jeopardize the career of nurses. The law should articulate the grounds on which nurses can apply critical decisions to save life without undue fear as reiterated by Bandman and Bandman (2002). Such provisions should promote good practice, embrace ethics and empower nursing practitioners. References Bandman, E. & Bandman, B. (2002). Nursing Ethics across the Life Span. (4th Ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Boivin, J. (2009). Nurses Struggle with Ethical Dilemmas. Retrieved February 11, 2013 from: Botes, A. (2000). Critical thinking by nursing practitioners on ethical issues such as termination of pregnancies. Curationis Review, 23(1), pp.26-33. Casterle, B., Izumi, S., Godfrey, N. & Denhaerynck, K. (2008). Nurses’ response to ethical dilemmas in nursing practice. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 63(6), pp.540–549 Cowen, S. & Moorhead, S. (2011). Current Issues in Nursing Practice. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier Publishing Group. Guido, W. (2006). Legal and Ethical Issues in Nursing. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall. Gutierrez, M. (2005). Critical care nurses’ perceptions of and responses to moral distress. Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing, 24(1), pp.229-241. Hamilton, R. (2012). Ethical and Moral Dilemmas Faced by Nurses. Retrieved February 11, 2013 from: Kulkarni, S. (2010). Ethical Issues affecting the nursing profession. Retrieved February 11, 2013 from: Schermer, M. (2002). The different faces of patient autonomy: Patient autonomy in ethical theory and hospital practice. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers. Tauber, I. (2005). Patient Autonomy and the Ethics of Responsibility. Cambridge: MIT Press. Veatch, R. (2009). Patient, Heal Thyself: How the new medicine puts the patient in charge. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Yamamoto, M. & Aso, Y. (2009). Placing physical restraints on older people with dementia. Journal of Nursing Ethics, 16(2), pp.192-202. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession Article”, n.d.)
Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession Article. Retrieved from
(Brief Discussion of an Ethical Issue Impacting the Nursing Profession Article)
Brief Discussion of an Ethical Issue Impacting the Nursing Profession Article.
“Brief Discussion of an Ethical Issue Impacting the Nursing Profession Article”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession

Ethical issue

...the current and future value of social responsible policies and corporate philanthropy? What is best for reconciling corporate social responsibility with economic logic? What approaches to corporate social responsibility and reputation building are likely to be effective for optimal mitigation of impacts of activities that destroy the environment and society? What facets of reputation, including reputation as corporate citizen, reputation as ethical organisation, reputation as consumer centric organisation etc. are likely to prove most useful for mitigating the impact of activities that destroy the environment and the society? How best should corporate social responsibility initiatives...
28 Pages(7000 words)Dissertation

Nursing as a Profession “the backbone of the healthcare system.” It also cannot be disputed that there exists a large and continually expanding body of knowledge related to nursing. There is a great deal of personal accountability involved in nursing as well. Each day nurses world-wide make decisions within a professional context which have a significant impact on the lives of their patients, as well as colleagues and even administrators. Nurses are required to undergo profession-specific education, as well as to maintain awareness of current research in the field in order to perform their jobs effectively. Likewise, nursing can easily be...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Nursing Profession

...and licensing required of all other registered nurses (RN). More so, they are specialists who offer basic primary healthcare through diagnosis and treatment of common acute illnesses and injuries. Nursing has its hazards especially in hospitals and other facilities where nurses may care for individuals with infectious diseases. Thus, nurses must observe strict guidelines to protect themselves against diseases and other dangers such as those posed by radiation, chemicals used for sterilization of instruments and anesthetics. The value of registered nurses The next part of this paper will discuss the nursing...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Nursing Profession

...or social mission. Learned profession are valued by societies by the services learned professionals render and use selectively. Creatively, effectively, humanely and ethically in providing those essential services. Secondly, every profession must support a group of investigators who work towards improving its practice by advancing it's knowledge continuously. Unfortunately, the caring provided by nurses were considered as mere extensions of the duties of mothers and wives and also, lay members of the society did not recognize or organize their caring function. Now the idea have changed to appraise the social mission of nurses. Nursing...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Discuss an Ethical Issue in Nursing

...described by Wells. In view of rising medical costs, tapping nurses from developing countries to either assist or substitute for occupational or physical therapists can emerge as a trend in the United States. Thus, an ethical dilemma for a nurse is whether he or she will allow himself or herself to be a party to the dilemma described by Wells (2007). In the case described by Wells, the patient encountered difficulties in keeping up with appointments with the health providers. Medicare rules for client to receive home health require that the patients meet certain criteria (Wells, 2007, p. 31). Directly quoting Medicare sources, Wells said that a homebound patient situation exists when...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Community Health issue Impacting the Health Profession

...Community Health Issues Community Health Issues Impacting the Health Profession (First and of (Institution’s Name) April 4, 2013 Introduction This present research paper mainly intends to highlight on health issues in the community and how these issues are impacting on the health profession. Community health issues impacting the health profession In reference to the writings by Johnson (2011), he stated that some of the community health issues that are presently prevalent in the United States of America were not existing in the past...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Ethical Issue in Advanced Practice Nursing

...are the Brown model, Benner’s model and the Strong model. Before embarking on a discussion of the models, the following is a brief discussion of the factors that may make the nurses fail in delivering optimal patient care. The effectiveness of communication Communication is a cornerstone to every successful institution, especially in health institutions. The manner in which a nurse or any healthcare provider, including the senior medical providers communicates any information to their patients is equally important to the message or information itself. A lucid understanding between the healthcare provider and the patient is paramount to the development of...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Ethical Care & Nursing as a Profession

... Nursing as a Profession Ethical Care and Nursing as a Profession Nursing as a profession has various regulations in concern to the entry level In the profession. Nursing is a sensitive profession that requires highly qualified professionals. As such, the entry-level education should be prioritized, in ensuring the services provided in the profession are of high quality. Previously, malpractice has occasionally been cited, due to limited education and experience. For instance, surgeons have to be experienced and well educated to start practicing in the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Issue Brief

... Issue Brief Issue: Austin is has been experiencing a significant decline in African-American population for the past few decades. Background: Austin, Texas was founded in 1839, one amazing historical fact is that it was the only state to exist a decade-long as a republic afore becoming a state. 1836 to 1846 Texas existed as a sovereign state. Texas gained independence from Mexico’s governance in 1836, there was need to come up with a City for the honor of Stephen F. Austin who was known as the father of Texas. Racial segregation was severe in the city in early twentieth century, however racial relation improved during the Civil Rights era. It this relation Austin, Texas made history as the first southern university to admit black... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Issue brief

... Dr. Goyzueta Medical Spa Introduction Medical spas are profitable business entities, which physicians have taken up to increase their earnings. The essence that spas treatments are not insured has helped the physicians to limit insurance malpractices. The aim of this essay is to persuade Dr. Goyzueta to start his medical spa in New Haven instead of New York. The essay will also discuss other issues pertaining starting medical spas in New Haven instead of New York and the law governing ownership of spas. Ownership of medical spas The law governing ownership of medical spas states that directors of the medical spas must possess an MD degree and can be owners with the advantage of forming partnerships with other physicians or other... ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Brief discussion of an ethical issue impacting the nursing profession for FREE!

Contact Us