Applying Ethical Framework in Practice - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Professional Position Regarding Patients’ Confidentiality Institution Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Introduction Any healthcare system requires that the patients’ confidentiality regarding health status be maintained and should only be known to the doctors and the patient…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Applying Ethical Framework in Practice
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Applying Ethical Framework in Practice"

Professional Position Regarding Patients’ Confidentiality Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Introduction Any healthcare system requires that the patients’ confidentiality regarding health status be maintained and should only be known to the doctors and the patient. However, this principle may not hold in some cases, and the confidentiality requirement may have to be broken. Several ethical principle and theories have been postulated to guide medical officers and nurses in handling dilemmas such as those relating to the breaking of confidentiality. Ethical Implications of a Breach of Confidentiality In medical practice, four main principles apply; beneficence, least harm, respect for autonomy and justice (Rainbow, 2002). The principle of beneficence demands that the healthcare provider does what offers most good. Least harm demands that the medical officer does the least harm in the event that they are faced with situations in which alternative actions present harm or no benefit to the patient. The principle that relates to respect of autonomy demands that patients should be allowed to make decisions that affect their lives. This principle is based on the assumption that people best understand their lifestyles and are therefore the only ones who fully appreciate how decisions affect their personal lives (Rainbow, 2002). Lastly, the principle of justice states that actions prescribed by ethical theories should be fair to the parties involved. In view of Hathaway’s case, the principle of beneficence calls for good actions in cases of dilemma. By maintaining confidentiality of the patients, the health expert acts for the good of the patients. By maintaining confidentiality, Andrea would not have attempted suicide. However, Hathaway would have acted without considering the good of the public and the legal requirement for parental consent. In this respect she would be exposed to litigation for treating the patient without parental consent. Yet again, by breaking the patient’s wish for confidentiality in handling their cases, Andrea gets to act against the principle of Autonomy. In this respect, Hathaway’s choice would have discourage the patients from further opening up to treatment and cause them to lose respect for her. Professional Position Regarding Patient Confidentiality Nurse Hathaway’s choice to break confidentiality (Nathanson, 2000) was the best choice given the situation at hand. By respecting the patient’s autonomy and maintaining their confidentiality, the Nurse would have done greater harm to the society than to the patients. More students would have continued to participate in the sex parties leading to more infections and possibly a health crisis. By breaking confidentiality, the nurse acted in respect of the principles of least harm and beneficence and preserved more people from harm. Furthermore, it would be fair to preserve the lives of more people in the society by breaking the confidentiality of two patients. Reasonable Alternative to Address the Dilemma The dilemma faced by Hathaway may be solved by considering the application of the utilitarian theory. The theory demand that the predicted consequences of an action be considered before action is taken. Breaking patient confidentiality will result in loss of respect of the patience, and their stigmatization as noted in the attempted suicide. On the other hand such an action will result in the proper treatment of the patients with the involvement of the society and parents with less risk of facing litigations for breach of consent laws. However, keeping confidentiality will result in less stigmatization of the patients, but potentially greater harm to the school children. Yet again, the nurse would be subject to probing considering the breach of consent laws. Considering the utilitarian theory, breaking confidentiality would be a reasonable alternative to solving the dilemma considering the lives of the bigger society against two individuals whose diseases are also exhaustively diagnosed and treated. How an Ethics Committee Might Approach the Dilemma When an ethical committee has to solve the dilemma, it has to first get the relevant facts related to the cases (Graber, Beasley & Eaddy, 1985). Based on the facts, the committee will begin to appeal to ethical values. The ethical committee will consider the various ethics theories and principles related to the solving of dilemmas. The principles in this case include autonomy, beneficence, justice and least harm. On the other hand, the ethics theories that the committee will consider include deontology, utilitarianism, rights, casuist and virtue (Rainbow 2002). Based on the utilitarian theory, the committee will analyze the consequences of each decision and establish which offers most good and least harm without infringing on the autonomy and rights of the patient. In making the decision, the committee will also seek to establish the obligations and duties of the nurse as a healthcare provider. In this respect, the nurse has a duty to offer medical care to the patients while at the same time seeking ways to protect the larger society from health threats. The committee may also refer to previous cases similar to the one at hand in making a decision. The decision made may be guided by the premises and decisions made in the past case(s). The nurse’s character may be questioned in the process of decision making based on the virtue theory. Conclusion Nurses face a lot of ethical dilemmas in the course of offering their vital services. There are a number of principles and theories that may be applied in solving such dilemmas. The consideration of the various theories and principles makes decision making easier during professional practice. In the case under review, the nurse’s decision to break patient confidentiality may have gone against their some rights and autonomy. However, considering the situation in light of beneficence, utilitarianism, more good, least harm and deontology, the nurse’s choice to breach confidentiality was the best decision. References Graber, G. C. Beasley, A. D., Eaddy JA, (1985). Ethical Analysis of Clinical Medicine: A Guide to Self-Evaluation: Professional Codes and ethical theories. Urban and Schwarzenberg. Nathanson, PG, (2000). Bioethics on NBC's ER: Betraying Trust or Providing Good Care? When Is It Ok to Break Confidentiality? Rainbow C. (2002). Descriptions of Ethical Theories and Principles. Retrieved 20 January, 2012 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
“Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
eddie76 added comment 1 month ago
Student rated this paper as
Wonderful work done on the "Applying Ethical Framework in Practice". I think it is the best document I have seen so far.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Applying Ethical Framework in Practice

Applying Theory to Practice

...? Applying Theory to Practice Applying Theory to Practice Of the several problems that nurses handle in their professional life, pain has been a significant one. The management of pain has had guidelines from several associations concerning human health and the nursing profession. However the real situation is that the recommendations have not yet been applied. This paper deals with the practice problem of pain and how I would go about managing it in my health institution using one of two theories. I have selected a middle range theory for application to management of pain and then applied a known theory....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Applying Theory to Practice

...? Applying Theory to Practice Part 2 Application of Middle Range Theory to Problem Angelique Harris Grand Canyon Applying Theory to Practice Part 2 Application of Middle Range Theory to Problem Application of My Middle-Range Theory For Pain Management The theory that I have applied to suit my personal values would allow me to perform suitably in a crisis management of acute or chronic pain care. In line with my personal values, the applied theory allows me to deliver my best and perform suitably in cases of crisis management. Keeping closely to the recommendations of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations for patient safety goals, my theory for pain management includes the following plan which allows me... Headache...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...?` Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Inserts His/Her Introduction It is a fact that every nurse, regardless of his or her specialty, come across various ethical challenges. These challenges bring them in a situation in which they find it difficult to make an appropriate decision. Similarly, in one of the episodes of ER a girl named Andrea trusted a nurse that was caring for her and after requesting that the information should remain confidential, the nurse disclosed that she had been sexually active. Later, it was diagnosed that she had cervical cancer and needed immediate treatment which obviously required parental consent. Nurse Carol Hathaway...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Applying Theory to Practice

...put forward to emphasize on nursing practice and education (Cody , 2002) . Science based nursing practice is utilized in effective delivery of nursing care. Models of nursing practice provide the nursing knowledge framework in the provision of theory based care. (Burretti, 1988). A good foundation for nursing can be created and further be broadened by applying a theory in nursing practice (Karnick, 2008). Jean Watson is a nurse theorist whose cardinal focus is based on human caring. Watson’s (2008) theory of human caring is broadly applied in nursing practice nursing in its knowledge acquisition and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Investigating and Applying an Ethical Framework to a Nursing Scenario

...Investigating and Applying an Ethical Framework to a Nursing Scenario ethics has become an important aspect of the health care profession. To meet the demand for a professionally and ethically accountable workforce necessitates that nurses become better informed about ethics in heath care and their responsibility in general (Thompson, 2006). It follows that the relationship between the nurse and the customer causes the profession itself to become an ethical activity. This paper discusses various aspects of the nursing ethics and how it applies to a case study of a patient admitted to the hospital in the Emergency department. The Kerridge, Lowe and McPhee model (2005) suggests seven steps for decision-making... -making entails analysis of the fundamental ethical principles. A framework to analyze the fundamental ethical principles commonly used in bioethics, called principlism, includes four guiding principles: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice (Butts & Rich, 2005). Anwari (2008) states that beneficence and non-maleficence are old concepts whereas autonomy and justice are innovations of recent times. Autonomy refers to the patient’s take on the situation. Judy feels that she is not receiving proper care. Quoting the victim’s words, no one believes her, and everyone thinks she is making it up and feels very...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice In health care, the practice of patient confidentiality is very important for all practitioners involved because patients depend on their physicians and care givers to keep any identifiable information contained in their medical records private. This confidentiality encourages patients to open up more and more to their physicians and this facilitates effective treatment and medical care. It also encourages them to always seek medical attention for any medical condition without any fear. This means all practitioners should never disclose such information to any other person unless the patient permits such a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethical Framework: Social Work

...ETHICAL FRAMEWORK: SOCIAL WORK ABSTRACT This paper aspires to develop a theoretical framework on social work. It presents the Maslow’s Hierarchy of needs as a guiding principle wherein a social worker can use to identify the things to do when confronted on a risky situation in her work. Throughout the paper, the writer attempts to visualize how the Maslow’s theory is applied in her own life. Keywords: social work, theoretical framework, Maslow hierarchy of needs ETHICAL FRAMEWORK: SOCIAL WORK Social work is a field of expertise wherein people who are academically equipped devote their proficiency to...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethical Framework Analysis:

...ETHICAL FRAMEWORK ANALYSIS Introduction Ethical decision making refers to following a certain acceptable of ethicsin making decisions, especially those that affect a wide or a vast group of people. There are various frameworks for decision making and a variety of codes followed in making decisions. These frameworks guide what a person will decide and to what extent they can go in making these decisions. This paper aims at analyzing two frameworks for effective decision making. This will be achieved through comparing and contrasting Edward Veith’s spiritual framework and the management framework for...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice al Affiliation Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice One of the fundamental aspects in ethics as applied in healthcare by healthcare professionals is the need for confidentiality. Healthcare professionals that include nurses among others must, at all times ensure that they keep patient information confidential unless it is mandatory that they reveal such information to provide the care that the patient needs. A breach of confidentiality can have several ethical implications. First, a breach of confidentiality...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Applying Research in Practice

...Applying research in practice May 20, Applying research in practice Discrepancy from the guideline and possible solution The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence developed guidelines for management and prevention of pressure ulcers. Patient assessment for risk of pressure ulcers, further assessment of patients’ skin for patients at high risk, alteration of patients’ positions, and appropriate dresses for the patients are some of the guidelines recommendations for management of pressure ulcers. Other recommendations by the institution are empowerment through training and provision of information on pressure ulcers and prevention and management issues, besides...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Applying Ethical Framework in Practice for FREE!

Contact Us