Nobody downloaded yet

Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Lecturer’s Name: Date Submitted: Discussing a Dilemma from a Legal and Professional Viewpoint Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1994] 1 WLR 290) Outline 1. Introduction (Re C (Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1994] 1 WLR 290) 2…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint"

Download file to see previous pages Assessing Capacity f. Key Points about Mental Capacity Act (2005) g. UK Statutes of Law 3. Professional Implications of the Case a. Mental Capacity in Medical Profession b. Consent to Treatment c. Principles of Medical Laws d. Medical Principles 4. Conclusion Mental Capacity and Consent Scenario in Clinical Practice Alexander James is a 19 years old deaf teenager admitted in a mental institution for paranoid personality. Alexander was born deaf and abused by his siblings and friends because of his disability. He grew up believing that everyone is trying to plot a mischief against him. James’ parents admitted him in the mental institution because his paranoid disorder affected his academics, social life and relationships with other people. While at the mental institution, Alexander’s mental disorder intensified when he saw doctors communicating and laughing. He thought that they were laughing at his disability and were plotting to harmful activities against him with their medical practice. James became violent towards the mental health providers and other patients. He was sedated and kept in isolation while his mental health treatment began. During his treatment, James was diagnosed with early symptoms of leukemia. Doctors summoned his parents and informed him that immediate treatment would eliminate the cancer. However, James refused this treatment because he believed that God intentionally planned for his deafness and leukemia, which means that he wanted the cancer to take its own course. The doctors respected James wishes in the presence of an attorney and he received hospice care for the remaining months. In 1994 in England, a similar case of mental capacity and consent occurred when a 68 years old man refused treatment. The case is referred to as Re C (Adult: Refusal of Treatment) [1994] 1 WLR 290, where Mr. C was confined in a mental hospital because of a prolonged paranoid schizophrenia (Tan 4). He further explains that Mr. C had a gangrenous foot that threatened his wellbeing if untreated by amputation. However, Mr. C refused treatment and filed a case to deter doctors from amputating his foot in future. Justice Thorpe ruled in his favor because his delusions and mental illness did not affect his capacity to listen, understand and make solid judgments about his desires (Tan 4). Legal Implications of the Case In the case of James and the medical professionals in the mental institution, his wishes and beliefs were granted after a thorough consultation. Below is a discussion and analysis of the impact of James’ case on UK’s legal system. Capacity in Law Capacity is legally defined as individuals’ ability and freedom to make their own decisions or take necessary actions that will affect their own lives (Law 2). She further explains that the Law Commission of UK implemented a Mental Capacity Act that empowered and encouraged people to make their own decisions about important issues in their lives. Patients in the UK that refuse emergency treatment must be legally competent by exhibiting a high capacity. The wishes of these patients are respected after proving to the court that they have mental stability to reason clearly and deliberate (Buchanan 2). They should hold appropriate objectives and values concerning their refusal of treatment. The law requires patients that refuse emergency medical care to appreciate and acknowledge their current circumstances. Patients are required to understand the information presented by their doctors and finally communicate their desired choice, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint Essay”, n.d.)
Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint Essay. Retrieved from
(Discuss a Dilemma from a Legal and Professional Viewpoint Essay)
Discuss a Dilemma from a Legal and Professional Viewpoint Essay.
“Discuss a Dilemma from a Legal and Professional Viewpoint Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint

Legal, Ethical and Professional Issues

...?Legal, Ethical and Professional Issues Introduction The main objective of this assignment is to examine the professional, ethical and legal issues of which a qualified nurse should consider when dealing with a patient’s dignity. Social and cultural issues, confidentiality in respect of patients’ information, providing a safe environment as well as care as part of a multidisciplinary team will be discussed. In addition, theories relating to the topic with a special focus on the right to dignity will be applied to two hypothetical situations. Dignity can be defined as a precious personal possession that relates to the cognitive skills, sense of control...
21 Pages(5250 words)Essay

Legal and Professional Issues

...of doubt is removed before her actions can be measured in line with the provisions of the law. This case reflects a dilemma within the nursing profession where nurses are faced with hard decisions of responsibility. This is demonstrated by the fact that Nurse M is a single mother who is in need for her job. However, a disregard of the provisions of the law should be avoided regardless of the situation of the health care provider who violates the legal and professional framework of conduct. In this case Nurse M is to be reported after comprehensive consideration of all professional, legal and ethical frameworks which govern care. The Code of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Professional Workplace Dilemma

...? Professional Dilemma Professional Dilemma Introduction Dilemma is a situation that requires making a choice between two equal and in most cases desirable alternatives. Professional dilemma is a situation in which an individual who holds an office and is under specific codes of conduct finds himself in a situation in which he has to make a choice between breaking the professional codes of conduct or accepting an alternative which is of advantage to him (Meese and Ortmeier, 2004). This paper will discuss a specific dilemma that occurred to me while on lunch break from my...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Australian Legal Professional Practice

...Australian Legal Professional Practice Introduction The high level of significance laid upon the professional responsibility and the ethical behavior of lawyers during the practice of Law – has for a long time been an area given emphasis by legal practitioners, as an epicenter of their legal profession. However, it is a common contention – that considering the painstaking which legal practitioners must go through, before they are admitted as members of the bar, excess care is exercised during practice. Also, the institutionalized convention in terms of conduct – to which they must accord adherence, if they intend to remain as members of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Legal Professional Conduct Hypothetical

...?Legal Professional Conduct Hypothetical If the expression “general account” does not include a general trust account and if the sum of $2,800 is not related to a financial service, Warren has breached section 248 (1) of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (hereafter, the Act). This attracts a maximum of 100 penalty units (Legal Profession Act, 2007). Warren Robinson misuses it for various search fees. Thus, Warren Robinson has violated section 248 (2) (b) and penalty for the breach is maximum 100 units. Warren also has breached section 249 (1) (a) and (b) which obligate the law practice to hold the trust money on Peter’s behalf and to disburse only as per Peter’s directions....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Professional & legal issues

...of office computers for pornographic materials. Reference Akers, N.(2005) Patent Laws and Practice in Medical Devices, %20Devices.pdf Bott, F. (2005) Professional Issues in Information Technology. British Computer Society Can teachers or students use copyright material from the Internet, (2002) Oppenhum, C. (1998) Intellectual Property Anderson, R. V. (1971) "This legal definition of obscene is narrower than the ordinary meaning of obscene which is filthy, lewd...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Professional Workplace Dilemma

...The Professional Workplace Dilemma The Experience While I was working as a lower level manager at a major financial service center, a recently hired upper manager dictated a new formula for calculating workers' productivity. The new method was inherently flawed and actually rewarded the least productive employees, while the best employees were penalized. The issue was of great importance, as anyone falling in the lower ratings by this formula was subject to disciplinary action, which may have included termination of employment. I felt I had a responsibility to the people that I had working for me to get the problem corrected and get a system that was fair to all employees. I also had a duty to the company...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Professional Workoplace Dilemma Paper

...The rapid globalisation has brought in an era of pluralistic society so that one often comes across professional dilemma while dealing with people with cross cultural values. Understanding of different cultures becomes important to maintain a conflict free atmosphere at the workplace while at the same time it assumes more relevance when dealing with customers coming from different cultural background. Under these circumstances, workplace situations may come across ethical dilemmas which need to be resolved at the earliest so that better work conditions may prevail and pace of the professional advancements may continue. Moral and ethical dilemmas are becoming frequent in one’s professional life. The cut throat competition coupled... with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethical, legal and professional considerations

...Ethical, Legal and Professional Considerations in Agile Development al Affiliation: Ethical, Legal and Professional Considerations in Agile Development Introduction Software practitioners have always experienced pressure that forces them to compromise their work in order to offer reasonable care to other parties that are or rather will be in affected by the software. As much as development of software is becoming more beneficial, interconnected and pervasive, there is an increased potential of unexpected errors or rather harm. Agile Software Development is basically an approach that entails building creating a software system that will embody a given set of crucial...
4 Pages(1000 words)Coursework

Interview of a Legal Professional

...INTERVIEW OF A LEGAL PROFESSIONAL REFLECTIVE SUMMARY [Insert al Affiliation] Interview questions and their answers Why did you prefer this employment? Mallilo asserts that he was very interested with law materials since his teenage times. 2) What do you like most about your occupation? Helping people when they have legal problesm, being able to come to a successful completion when one has a legal case to ensure everybody feels contented. 3) What do you dislike about this job? The pressure and anxiety that comes with being the head of a law firm is one traumatic aspect. 4) What is the qualification for hiring in this position? To have a good work ethic Somebody must be...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Discuss a dilemma from a legal and professional viewpoint for FREE!

Contact Us