Philosophy of Ethics - Research Paper Example

The case revolves around these issues of integrity and the morality and ethics tied to making accommodations for racism and giving in to the racist biases of clients and their communities when making consulting and business decisions (Chapter 21, n.d., pp. 203-204) The first ethical problem has to do with the ethics of Mr. Wileys insistence that hiring a black consultant for the job at the hotel would not sit well with a backward community as the one that is present in the island. It is backward in the sense that it is unable to tolerate having a Black person doing the work, regardless of the persons qualifications, and regardless of the fact that Mr.

Wiley respects Lenore and the consulting team that she has. The ethical problem here can be distilled into a question: Is it ethical to not hire a person because of his color/race, even though he is the most qualified for the work? The second ethical problem emanates from the first one. When Mr. Wiley insisted that hiring a Black consultant will not work, Lenore succumbs and recommends a white consultant instead, even though Dave Maverick, the black person, is the most qualified by her own professional estimation.

The ethical problem is is it ethical for Lenore to give in to the demand of Mr. Wiley and make a recommendation based on skin color rather than on who is best qualified for the work? (Chapter 21, n.d., pp. 203-204) There are two sets of stakeholders here that are relevant for the purposes of the ethical analysis, one set consisting of the hotel employees, guests and the Elura residents surrounding the hotel, as well as the guests; and the other set consisting of the consultants working for Lenore.

Taking a step back, the ethical theories to guide the analysis center on Kantian ethics and Kants theory of duty. According to Kant, that which is moral or ethical is that which is dictated by our duties, meaning that an action is deemed right or wrong depending on