Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...


Comments (1) Cite this document
In the practice of health care provision, individuals face moral challenges that propagate them in to undertaking practices that are ethically in correct. Ideally, euthanasia is the most common ethical dilemma that that many individuals tend to battle with from within…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Read TextPreview


Healthcare Ethics Case Study Healthcare Ethics Case Study In the practice of health care provision, individuals face moral challenges that propagate them in to undertaking practices that are ethically in correct. Ideally, euthanasia is the most common ethical dilemma that that many individuals tend to battle with from within themselves. For instance, euthanasia is the merciful take away the life of patients because of their state due to sickness (Pozgar, 2012). According to religious scholars, this practice is unethical, as they hav the belief that no man has the power to deprive any one of their life irrespective of the health suffering that they may be going through. This causes an ethical challenge because decision is critical in the solving of the problem.
In this regard, this essay will tear in to one ethical and moral dilemma case that will help in understanding this view. Further, the essay will focus on vital ethical principles related to the case and the process of making the ethical decision by medical administrators entangled in the case (Pozgar, 2012). In addition, the essay will provide an argument as to whether the handling of the case was appropriate then try to point out ways that would have the situation turn out differently. Therefore, the chosen case involved a sixteen-month-old baby boy whose father chose to end the life of his son at gunpoint.
Key ethical principles
As per the case, hospital administrators refused to remove the boy from the respirator citing the right to life principle, as they did not agree to the father ending the life of the boy prematurely. In addition, the case presented the respect for autonomy to which the boy could not make the decision on whether to live or not because of the medical state and age of the boy (Zahedi, Larijani & Bazzaz, 2007). In this regard, the father decided to pull the plug after seeing that the boy was not getting any better hence going contrary to these two ethical principles.
Reasons leading to the decision made by medics
Ideally, siding with the request made by the parents of removing their son from the machine was not an option that the healthcare providers were willing to entertain. They stood their ground by maintaining that their hospital could not support their decision citing ethical reasons. Therefore, to them the decision was not a moral obligation rather an ethical move that they had sworn by before joining the practice.
For one, every individual involved in the case acted out in a manner that they all saw fit hence justifying their deeds. Therefore, the handling of the matter was appropriate because there were injuries despite the presence of a riffle during the scuffle. In addition, the verdict by the judge also proved that the events at the hospital were appropriate hence influencing the delivered judgment. However, the father to the boy should not have used a gun to push the request home, but could have acted with ultimate discretion to avoid a scuffle and attention. This means that the decision to remove the plug on the boy was a relief to the family because of the accumulation of the hospital bill that did not help the boy to recovering hence distributing the risks. Essentially, this forms the justice principle. Lastly, the father acted autonomously on behalf of the son because the boy was in no state to make the decision on whether to live or die as provided in the autonomy principle of ethics (Zahedi, Larijani & Bazzaz, 2007).

Pozgar, G. D. (2012). Legal aspects of health care administration. Sudbury, Mass: Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Zahedi, F., Larijani, B. Bazzaz, T. J.(2007). End of Life Ethical Issues and Islamic Views- laari. Iranian Journal of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
Retrieved from
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
henriette33 added comment 2 months ago
Student rated this paper as
The topic of "HEALTHCARE ETHICS AND END OF LIFE DECISIONS" was tough to find. I spent ages to find it. Here at StudentShare, I got the best sample. Many thanks!


End of life debate

...? Ethical End of Life Decisions and Different Considerations: A case of Systemic Lupus Erythematous (SLE) Patient College) This paper will try to discuss and justify my position to support the continuity of life of patients with Systemic Lupus Erythematous (SLE) in reference to various end of life decisions by looking into the different aspects of medical care as well as the ethical, social, and financial considerations that should be taken relative to the patient’s medical care.It consulted several academic materials in order to support and understand the above considerations to support...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Alzheimer's Disease and End of Life Decisions

... patient died (Lau, 2007). The susceptibility of a person being infected by this disease increase with increase in age, hence older people are most likely to get it. Alzheimer’s disease, once diagnosed has no cure or reverse, death is always there even after treatment (Soukup, 1996). This work shall be divided into three main sections, where the first section will address the disease, what causes it, what are the symptoms of the disease in each stage, and briefly address the issue of prevention. The second part of this work shall address the very sensitive part on the ethical issues faced by families /surrogates making end of life decisions on behalf of family members with Alzheimer’s disease. The last part will be a discussion... are to...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Decisions at the End of Life

...Decisions at the End of Life Introduction: Medical profession today is 'Accountable' to the society .i.e. obliged to the laws regulating the professional activity. One of the most difficult realities the doctors face is that, despite efforts and good care, some patients will die, either due to the nature of the diseases like Cancer or AIDS or due to developments related to patient's age and health conditions. Although, technological advances in health can bring extended and improved quality of life, the ability of these technologies to prolong life beyond a meaningful point has raised ethical issues, especially in "nothing more can be...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

End-of-Life Care

...on communication skills in bereavement, understanding loss, cultural and spirituality issues, providing support and information for the bereaved. An article by Rolland & Kalman says that although there are programs in place to educate nurses but many have not been evaluated for efficacy. They recommend including hospice and palliative care clinical rotations to provide practical experience with dying patients. They also recommend that healthcare institutions need to include end- of- life competencies for new RN graduates (2007). A study by Adams (2010) encourages the incorporation of end-of-life courses in nursing curricula so students can become more...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


...Law Healthcare Ethics and End of Life Decisions Factors considered in court in defining death When it comes to law death is taken as an event that happens at a particular and precise moment in time and not a continuing event. In determining whether a person is dead or not in which proof is taken through checking of a person’s vital signs is not part of legal conclusion but relatively a medical judgment (Leaman & Glennys, 2001). In a court of law there are various factors that ought to be considered in defining. These factors include when and how the death occurred. Another factor that has to be considered is whether another individual needs to be charged...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...are not worthy of living. Those in support of wrongful births maintain that the parents of the unborn child should have the autonomic interest of settle on whether or not to have a child. Further, the parents might want to know whether their fetus is in danger of a congenital or a genetic disease. In this regard, the doctor who negligently fails to put the parents of the unborn child aware of their baby’s condition deprives them of a right; a right to make informed choices or decisions regarding their procreative lives. Conclusion Humanity can solve the controversies surrounding wrongful births. The best way to approach these issues is to determine the value of life. However, none should get away with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...Healthcare Ethics and End of Life Decisions Physician assisted suicide is one of the most controversial issues in the medical field. A large section of society feels that it is wrong for anyone to aid another in terminating life. This is irrespective of the health situation or condition. However, this position is considered more ideal than actual given the situation of terminally ill patients and others undergoing absolute suffering. Under these circumstances, it may be considered fair for a physician to help in terminating life. In such a situation, assisted suicide is considered a preferable option given that there is no chance that the patient may recover. Given a situation where the patient prefers death, the physician has... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

End of Life Decisions: Making the right choice for you interventions. Patients’ rights to self-determination of treatment help them to participate in making key decisions about healthcare. Self-determination refers the right of competent individuals to decide about their health during medical treatment (Cersosimo, 2011). Medical experimentation during end life can sometimes be stopped especially when physicians realize that cannot be controlled anymore, but again the patient has all the right to refuse certain therapeutic or diagnosis to be performed on them. Furthermore, ethics and effectiveness of continued routine medical interventions play a significant role in enabling patients’...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Honoring Patient Autonomy at End-of-life decisions

...-of-life patient would want. This makes it very difficult for medical practitioners who must reconcile ethical and legal responsibilities linked to patient autonomy with substitute decision-makers (Dreyer, et al., 673). At the end of the day, end-of-life patients’ consent is important because it can be assumed that rational human beings would not want to be subjected to futile and often invasive, life-prolonging treatment or given false hope of prolonging life. At the same time, the quality of life for end-of-life patients is an important aspect of the...
20 Pages(5000 words)Thesis

End of Life Paper

...Nursing care for dying children PART There are a lot of things living in the world and each one of them has a life time that once its end comes around, there is little that even science can do; a phenomenon which has led to the shifting of blame to the failure of science (Morgan,2009). With this in mind, human beings have accepted the fact that one has to die to complete the cycle of life. According to Morgan, when a child dies, this cycle seems unnatural; it’s so sudden that the human potential is lost, and dreams quickly become shattered and vanish while its regarded as a loss to not only the parent, but to the society. (Morgan, 2009). The parents, siblings and the health care...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic HEALTHCARE ETHICS AND END OF LIFE DECISIONS for FREE!

Contact Us