Free

Ethical Case Analysis - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
It defines moral good and bad that in a society. This paper offers an ethical analysis to the case, ‘the ethics of hackivism’ from ethical principles and ethical codes’…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Ethical Case Analysis
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Ethical Case Analysis"

Ethical case analysis Ethics refers to a set of moral principles that are approved and are observed by a society. It defines moral good and bad that in a society. This paper offers an ethical analysis to the case, ‘the ethics of hackivism’ from ethical principles and ethical codes’ perspectives.
Summary of the case
The case explores the role of hacktivists in obtaining and disseminating information to the public. It defines hacktivism as a term for combined efforts of hacking and activism. It is however specific on a group called Anonymous that hacks organizations’ websites to obtain information that it disseminates to the public. It defines the organization’s role as the promotion of availability of information, freedom of speech and transparency. Hacktivism, however, does not necessarily mean criminal ventures as it includes application of websites’ links to publish information on social networks. Posts such as like a particular page for facebook to make donations towards a cause are examples. The author however simplifies its definition to application of the internet to facilitate an objective (Carter, p. 1).
Anonymous is the illustrated example of hacktivist group that breaks into websites whose opinion the organization does not agree with. The group also applies its high level of skills to close down websites such as those of governments and other organizations as counter attack initiatives for actions that are offensive to its objectives. Its reaction to the temporary closure of the Wikileaks website is the recent example. The group is also involved in other mass action movements. The author however notes that most internet users in social network unknowingly participate in hackivism through following hacktivists’ directives to publish links on their social network pages (Carter, p. 1).
Identity of the moral agent
The article identifies two moral agents. Anonymous group is identified as a specific moral agent and the social network users who engage in the type of publications as general moral agents in the case. This is because the parties’ initiatives that involve conveyance of information to the public can be determined as either right or wrong. The act can be right to the effect of truthfully criticizing an evil or advocating for a beneficial initiative but can be bad if the criticism is not based on the truth, leading to harm. Anonymous for example advocates for freedom of expression and acts in defense against authoritarian initiatives. Depending on the consequences of their actions, they can be judged as either good or bad. Actions of individuals in the social media, at least in the individuals perspectives, or if the cause of such publications were true, would be judged as good. Publication of offensive links would however identify bad intentions (Carter, p. 1).
The subject at stake and stakeholders
The issue at stake is hacktivism that involves hacking websites with the aim of intimidating its owners or with the aim of publishing its contents as well as publication of online links by social network users. This involves different groups of stakeholders. The first group of stakeholders is the referents whom are the victims of hacking and the owners of disseminated information. Anonymous that hacks websites for intimidation and publishing together with social network users who share links are another category of stakeholders. The public that forms the target audience of the published information is also a category of stakeholders to the case (Carter, p. 1).
Possible courses of action
One of the possible courses of action against hacktivism initiatives is to subject the organization and individual social network users to regulatory measures such as codes of conduct and subjection to legal frameworks. An authority over Anonymous will control its activities to ensure security of the target organization’s websites. Enforceable measures on social network users will also facilitate accountability to limit publication of links with adverse effects on any member of the society (Carter, p. 1).
Consequences of each course of action
Subjecting Anonymous to legal and ethical regulations will curtail its attacks on websites. Further, it will safeguard the victims’ freedom from intimidation. This will also promote sanity by weakening the organization’s ability to support other questionable initiatives such as those of Wikileaks. The actions will also promote accountability among social network users (Carter, p. 1).
Analysis of the case using ethical theories
The case’s critique over Anonymous’ activities adopts act utilitarianism theory. Under the theory, morality is defined by consequences of an act. An act is for instance moral if it maximizes benefits and immoral if it leads to harmful consequences. The case reviews consequences of the organization’s actions such as intimidation to parties with contrary opinions to those of Anonymous. It also identifies the consequences of published links on social network pages that initiates actions towards an activist’s call. It therefore identifies immorality in Anonymous’ actions and morality in social network’s activism, though the cause may not be real (Carter, p. 1; Landau, p. 414).
The case is however silent on application or rule utilitarianism that focuses on set standards for determination of morality of actions. This is because it does not criticize Anonymous and social network users on any set standard but on its actions (Carter, p. 1; Landau, p. 414).
Applicable clause from ACM code of ethics
Clause 1.1 of the ACM code of ethics and professional conduct, “contribute to society and human well being,” and clause 1.7, “respect the privacy of others” would be the most applicable to the case. This is because the case is a critique of integrity of Anonymous’ activities in breaching its victims’ privacy through illegal retrieval of the victims’ data. The case also points out to the humane attitude of social network users who participates in actions towards alleged charity (Acm, p. 1; Carter, p. 1).
Recommended course of action
The case establishes Anonymous’ activities that are technically independent from any form of legal or ethical control as well as possible participation of individuals to manipulate social network users. This paper recommends establishment of a framework to establish both legal and moral obligations on the organization and members of social networks. This can be achieved through international laws and regulations.
Works cited
Acm. ACM code of ethics and professional conduct. Association For Computing Machinary. October 16, 1992. Web. October 9, 2012. .
Carter, Nath. Hacktivism: The easy way to change the world. April 17, 2012. Web. October 9, 2012. < http://www.nathcarter.com/2012/04/17/hacktivism-the-easy-way-to-change-the-world/>.
Landau, Russ. Ethical theory: An anthology. Malden, MA: John Wiley & Sons, 2012. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethical Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1604888-ethical-case-analysis
(Ethical Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1604888-ethical-case-analysis.
“Ethical Case Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1604888-ethical-case-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Case Analysis

Case Study Analysis: Ethical Issues

...? Case Study AnalysisEthical Issues (Add (Add (Add Case Study AnalysisEthical Issues The given case study addresses compelling rights of a minor patient, his parents, and physicians. In this case context, Tyrell Dueck (the 14 year old patient) and his parents refuses the medically prescribed leg amputation on the ground of their religious beliefs. As the US Constitution allows citizens to freely exercise their religious beliefs, the government does not restrict people from refusing medication on the ground of religious perceptions. Earlier, the US government did not allow minor patients to refuse...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethical Case Study Analysis Paper

...?ETHICAL CASE STUDY ANALYSIS PAPER Identification of all ethical dilemmas presented Reading through the case and for that matter the issues presentedby Lisa to James, there are three major ethical dilemmas that can be identified on the part of Lisa. The first of these has to do with the academics and subsequently, the future carrier that the young lady wants to take up. This is because leading up to the break up that she had with her boyfriend she had lost concentration on her studies and is not sure if she can continue to pursue her dream of becoming lawyer. The second has to do with the dilemma of having to report her mother’s partner...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Ethical Analysis of the Ed Fischer Case

...Ethical analysis of the "Ed Fischer Case" There are instances wherein one needs to make a decision between the responsibility and the morality. There are responsibilities in all the professions, in all the fields, whether the person is a scientist, a lawyer, a politician or a doctor. We always need to do the job in a responsible manner. All the jobs are service oriented wherein one benefits from the other in some way. For instance, a scientist discovers new things just out of curiosity, to understand the mechanism or to know the unknown. Those discoveries are used in a way to help the human kind. Thus, the responsibility of the scientist is to discover new things. In the same way a lawyer...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Human Diversity and Ethical Practice in Mental Health: A Case Study and Analysis

...Human Diversity and Ethical Practice in Mental Health: A Case Study and Analysis This paper examines methods of developing the means to promote the care of patients with mental illness. The focus of the analysis is a brief case study on the biography of John, whose case profile has already been developed, and who has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. This study will examine coping mechanisms, analyze and diagnose John's case, and conclude with a brief overview of the role of a mental health nurse in the promotion and distribution of health care, with a specific focus on how human diversity should inform and determine...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Ethical analysis

...Ethical analysis Confidentiality in medical practice is one of the core health care tenets (Raymond 961). As a result, medical practitioners are faced with a challenge of keeping patient information private. However, confidentiality is not always an absolute obligation for general practitioners. This means that some circumstances would oblige practitioners to breach the confidentiality and thus the privacy of information on patients. A case of Richard who has tested HIV positive is presented with a dilemma surrounding the need to inform his spouse about the husband’s condition. Even though practitioners are expected to keep the confidentiality of patient information, Richard’s...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Analysis of an Ethical case in management

...Case Analysis: Applying Ethical Management Introduction Globalization of the business activity caused significant changes in business practice during the modern era of 21st century. However, due to shortening period of competitive advantage, businesses are neglecting to share critical information with their employees, consequently employees cannot respond effectively to fluxing job requirements (Donaldson, 2008), therefore majority of the modern day organizations are facing an eminent threat of having obsolete human factor with respect to modifying needs of corporate sector. At the same time, businesses are irresponsibly conducting their professional activities without accommodating...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Individual Ethical Case Analysis Social work/ Human services

...ETHICAL CASE ANALYSIS SOCIAL WORK Introduction This case study has been prepared by following the case study preparation guidance provided by Palmer (Palmer, 2008). It has been stated by the World Health Organization WHO (2011) that for a given year, almost 20% of the adolescents experience mental disorder which happens mostly due to anxiety or depression. As a result of this mental disorder the risk gets increased for young people in relation to experiences of humiliation, violence, poverty, devaluation and subsequently suicide which are one of the main causes of increased amount of death among the young generation. Creating life skills in young people...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Ethical Case

...CASE STUDY QUESTIONS Lecturer’s Introduction Wal-Mart, the largest private employer company in the United s, is faced with an ethical dilemma. The company is trying reduce its cost by changing the scheduling method of the work shifts of the employees to adopt the computerized system of scheduling (from Kronos) in order to maximize on its profit. However, this has faced a lot of criticism by the workers’ rights advocates for the impact the computerized system will have on the employee’s lives. 1) The ethical dilemma facing Wal-Mart Company and whether associates also face an ethical dilemma The company is desperate to adopt the move, as it will be very beneficial....
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

This Case Study Analysis coursework consists in writing an ethical reasoning and critical argument to identify, discuss and address potential ethical issues for a given computing project

...to the emergence of technology but also due to the implementation by the users. Moreover, the ethical issues may also involve the role of the developer of the system concerning the objective of the information technology system. The following analysis aims to identify the ethical issues surrounding a class project concerning intellectual property and reliability of the project. Section one Project title and description The case study for the analysis is based on the student workload tracker project. The student Workload tracker project was developed under the oversight of two administrator and nine project members who contributed towards the development...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Ethical case

...Ethical Implications of Takeovers Ethical Implications of Takeovers Ethical issue requires an individual or person to choose between alternatives that must be viewed as right or wrong. It is evident in this case that after Lisa Michaels was promoted to her dream job as a financial manager, she had the role of integrating financial and accounting functions related to all mergers and acquisitions. Lisa being ethical found herself unprepared for the different corporate cultures she would soon encounter. The acquired company approach to compliance with financial rules and regulations was not at par with the standards Lisa believed was ethical...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Ethical Case Analysis for FREE!

Contact Us