StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Languages Reflect Societies - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The short version of the first question for this assignment appeared to me like “do you agree with the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis”? Agreeing or disagreeing…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Languages Reflect Societies
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Languages Reflect Societies"

Does language determines thought? I never thought that I will enjoy making this paper – from researching about to the topic to writing about the subject. The short version of the first question for this assignment appeared to me like “do you agree with the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis”? Agreeing or disagreeing with a theory in an academic perspective and manner seems a little bit daunting, but I never knew that it could be fun too. To answer the first question, I would like to present first the answer to the second; on what the current literature says about the hypothesis.
Controversial! This word still aptly describes the hypothesis up to these days attracting continued studies about the relationship between language, thought and culture. Its strong version called Linguistic Determinism, posits that “people’s thoughts are determined by categories made available by their language” (Pinker, 1994, p. 57), that “language may determine our thinking patterns” (Liang, 2011, pp. 569-570), or that “one cannot think outside the confines of their language” (He, 2011, p. 562). Linguistic Relativity which is its weaker version, maintains that “differences among languages cause differences in thoughts of their speakers” (Pinker, 1994, p.57).
Among the articles that I have read, I summarized the strengths and weakness of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis in Table 1. Pinker (1994) thoroughly debunked the hypothesis in his book The Language Instinct. From the circumstances that contributed to Whorf’s formation of the hypothesis – to the two aspects of the theory, the strong and weak versions, Pinker (1994) questioned them all using anthropological and logical reasoning and results of empirical studies. As Pinker (1994, p. 67) have said, “Linguistic determinism is just a conventional absurdity”.
Liang (2011) also examined the same hypothesis and came up with views similar to the ones maintained by Pinker. The study of Chi-Shing and Altarriba (2008) yielded a result contrary to the theory. Though He (2011) in his study acknowledged the shortcomings of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis due to lack of empirical evidences, he focused on cross-cultural communication which made the hypothesis in one way, promote cultural diversity.
If there are studies that question the authenticity of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis, there are studies that support the views of Sapir and Whorf. One such study is that of Kodish (2003). As he penned it, Whorf “did not posit a language isolated from human behavior-in-a-culture as the sole, one-directional, single-valued determinant of some separable entity called thought” (Kodish, 2003, p. 385).
Now why did I not put his arguments in Table 1? I did not do so for the reason that his arguments do not directly tackle the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis.
If he presented arguments and evidences which will support the stand that “language determines thought” which is the main concept of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis as a whole, then he would have given strength to the hypothesis. His statement looks like he defended the person, Whorf, rather than the hypothesis known as Sapir-Whorf.
To prove that a statement is true one has argue and present evidences in support to that statement and not just give credit of the source of the statement.
Rather than to what Whorf have said, I agree to what Pinker (1994) mentioned. First, that “our internal representations which are our imaginations which underlie thinking, in many ways cross purposes with the sentences in a language” (p. 81). And ultimately I agree that “mental life goes on independently of particular languages” (p. 82).
References
Chi-Shing, T & Altarriba, J. (2008). Evidence Against Linguistic Relativity In Chinese And English: A Case Study Of Spatial And Temporal Metaphors. Journal Of Cognition & Culture 8.3(4), 335-357. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete.
He, J. (2011). The Validity Of Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis--Rethinking The Relationship Among Language, Thought And Culture. US-China Foreign Language 9(9), 560-568. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete.
Kodish, B. (2003). "What We Do With Language -- What It Does With Us. ETC: A Review Of General Semantics 60(4), 383-395. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete.
Liang, H. (2011). The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis And Foreign Language Teaching And Learning. US-China Foreign Language 9(9), 569-574. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete.
Pinker, S. (1994). The Language Instinct. New York: William Morrow and Company Inc. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Languages Reflect Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Languages Reflect Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1592515-languages-reflect-societies
(Languages Reflect Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Languages Reflect Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1592515-languages-reflect-societies.
“Languages Reflect Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1592515-languages-reflect-societies.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Languages Reflect Societies

Classical Societies

...?Topic:  ical Societies Essay Style of Art – ical Greece Reference Link - http www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/27.45 Introduction Theart work here portrayed is classical Greece and this style of art is produced by most exquisite sculptors of the time.The sculptures behind these artwork are extra- ordinary and pioneers of this field. They are mostly influenced by the nature of work they produce as they are of unique and elaborate quality. According to (Hunt For,2007)“ Classical period of ancient Greek history is fixed between 480 B.C., when the Greeks began to come into conflict with the kingdom of Persia to the east and 338 B.C., when Philip II of Macedonia with son Alexander defeated the Greek”. The art work of classical Greece style...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Programming Languages

...?Introduction Computer programming languages are engineered by human beings for conveying instructions to the machines solving their problems. The computer programming languages have tremendously been increased (developed), used and discarded, since the computer science recognized as a distinct academic discipline. As the computer science is an evolving and dynamic discipline, therefore, it is difficult to categorize the already developed computer languages. Some of the authors have classified the computer languages into three (3) categories include: machine level language, assembly level language and high level language (Venit and Drake, 2010). Whereas, the other authors have categorized the computer languages keeping in view...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Web Languages

...CW assessment for mark up languages for the web Word Count: 1500 {Introduction to Conclusion} Contents of the Report: Introduction. Markup Languages. Evolution of XML. Case studies. Conclusion. References. Introduction As the technology was pacing up there was a necessity for all the information present online to appear consistent and easily understandable. Internet was a powerful weapon to provide the required information to a user that was relevant and easy to access within a split second. This had to be carried out by implemented various styles (Natanya Pitts-Moultis and Cheryl Kirk, 1998). The problem faced was that various clients would adapt different styles of their choice which might result in incompatibility over the wide spread...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Societies

...Comparison between Egyptian/Muslim society and Chinese/Confucian society. The timeless tale of a woman, in any society is a reflection of the wholerange of experiences which she has undergone, and it does not differ greatly whether it is 20th century Egyptian women of Muslim culture or the 17th century Chinese women of Confucian culture. The pain and the anguish to which they are exposed is the same. The differentiation lies more in the feminist and male dominant society rather than the geographical region. The relationship between the man and the woman surpasses all geographical boundaries, cultural barriers and religious beliefs, as their suffering is the same regardless of their caste, creed and culture. It is complex play of power...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Islamic societies

...Take Home Test While some Western scholars believe that Islam is on a collision course with West and is inherently inimical to the modern age we live in (Huntington1993, 1996, Armesto 1995; Fukuyama 1998; Kepel 2002; Lewis 2002), other scholars (Muslims and non-Muslims), Noorani, Tibi, Bloom & Blair, Seyyed Nasr, and John Esposito suggest that Islamic societies-like other world cultures influenced by traditional religions- are reacting to the global transformation taking place. The reaction is a mixture of anger, denials, and social tensions. Like Christianity or Judaism, Hinduism or Buddhism, Islam has been adopted for many causes, from modernism to traditionalism, liberalism to conservatism, which may have nothing to do with its...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Secret societies

...Thesis Proposal Since the advent of this world violence has been prevailing in different forms. This violence has now spread such that it has become a threat to the integrity of this world. Different types of weapons and armor is being used to spread this terror all over the world. The topic I have chosen to write is on Gun Control. Gun Control here refers to control of arms and weapons in the countries. I have chosen the topic of Gun Control because I believe that this control has to play a major role in the violence rates currently prevailing in this world. All over the world different countries have passed legislations to control these killings. These legislations or law either snatch the right of someone to possess a gun...
2 Pages(500 words)Thesis

REFLECT THOUGHT

...Reflect Thought Give an example of something that one culture might regard as a virtue that another culture might not. Explain why this could leadto relativism. There are many things that are considered a virtue in one culture that are regarded as a fault in another culture. One specific example of this can be identified in terms of relative levels of strength and intelligence. While in developed regions such as France or Western Europe there is a considerable value placed on intellectual ability. This may be due to the nature of high technology and skilled position jobs in these regions that require individuals of intellectual ability and tendency. This can be contrasted with virtues of strength in developing regions, such as Africa...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Functional languages vs. imperative languages

...Imperative Languages vs. Functional Languages Basic constructs The fundamental construct in imperative languages, like Ada, C, C++, Fortran, Java, Modula, Pascal, Python, and Ruby, is the assignment statement. A program written in any of these languages contains variables which are declared and assigned with values, and changes in the values of these variables during a program’s execution update the “state” of a program (Lee 118). Functional languages, like Haskell, Lisp, ML, and Miranda, are based on the declarative construct and mathematical concepts of a function. Programs written in functional languages do not contain assignment statements and their execution progresses primarily by evaluating expressions (Lee 119). 2. Computation...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Arab Societies

...The Implications of Wearing theTraditional Dress Fashion in the modern world today de s a person’s style, personality and status in life. It can be an expression of creativity when people integrate into their wardrobe some special item that reflects something about them. However, in Arab society, one’s dress is indicative of more things, usually coming Arabian perspectives and interpretation of the Qur an, or scared book that tells them how they should live in the way Allah would have wanted. Since Islam is very conservative, worldly values and practices are prohibited in their society. The Al-Ziyy Al-Islami or Islamic dress is something that distinguishes them from others because such dress should reflect the cornerstones...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Languages

...Draft Language is the manner on how living creatures communicate with each other. They come in many forms. They could be the spoken language, sounds and symbols. Language are necessary for survival. Language can come through the spoken language. Humans communicate using the spoken language with the use of vocabularies, grammar and syntax. Noam Chomsky explained that this is so because of the human being’s brain structure that allows speech. Human beings also have vocal tracts that allows the use of spoken language. The spoken language is a uniquely human characteristic because other animals cannot use language “because they lack the human brain structures that create language. Our level of intelligence also allows us to use...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Financial System: An Overview of Building Societies

...Running head: Financial system: An Overview of Building Societies Financial system: An Overview of Building Societies s Name] Financial system: According to the definition given by (GAO) the financial system is: An information system, comprised of one or more applications, that is used for any of the following: collecting, processing, maintaining, transmitting, and reporting data about financial events; supporting financial planning or budgeting activities; accumulating and reporting cost information; or supporting the preparation of financial statements. (GAO) Financial Markets: Financial markets facilitate the lending of funds from saving to those who wish to undertake investments. The various forms of IOUs are known collectively...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Does Media and Societal Changes Reflect the Group Behaviour of Young Adults

Now that young adults live in the radically different Internet age, in which more forms of media and communication vie for their attention, this compounds the reasons for adults to feel concerned about the possible distraction the new media could bring to stunt the proper development of their children. A big part of this fear relates to the sex-and-violence content of media, which is widely construed as capable of eroding the moral and social fiber of a nation that does not subscribe to media censorship. This is especially the case in the UK, which steadfastly pursues the media policy of self-regulation (PCC Citing online source).

Amongst the more popular complaints raised by older people against the Internet generation...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

Napoleon and the Transformation of European States and Societies

Napoleon’s unyielding battle cry required huge recruitment into the army, the radical aspect of the modern state that created the main inconsistencies of the Empire making his rule remain contentious (Brown, 2007).

The period of Napoleon, that is 1801-1805, is marked as the formation of the Grande Armee1 and the allied armies of European empires demonstrating warmongering tendencies. It wa5snt just France and Napoleon but also Great Britain, Russia, Austria, and Prussia that were belligerent empires, as is obvious from the outcomes of the Congress of Vienna in 1814-18152. The new geopolitics and resolutions thus resulted in continued till 1848 when revolutions across the continent ended the Vienna arrangement. The...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Latin and Greek Classical Languages

... By “By their very nature, languages have histories which reach far back in time. It is the task of historical, comparative linguistics to recover the details of that history. From the evidence of the ages, including the present, a composite picture of the linguistic past is assembled.” (Baldi, The Foundations of Latin p 1) Greek and Latin are often associated and both are academically classified as classical languages, with Greek evolving as the language of intellectual choice. The supposition that the latter derived largely from the former is a prevalent point of view and seems to have basis in fact, if one takes Diringer’s extensive analysis to heart as presented by J.B.Calvert in The Latin Alphabet, an extract of which appears...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Assess, plan and design possible teaching and learning interactions that promote acquisition and learning of oral, visual and written languages/literacies for the child

She even suggested to put clamps so that the fluid will not run down.
Taking responsibility. She asked that a note be placed on the medical equipment she was playing with so that no one will touch it and that it will still be available when she comes back to it next time.
2. Assessment: The assessment framework adopted is the Learning Stories Framework (Carr, 2001). It is an approach that tells a story about a child in action as observed and documented by a teacher or practitioner. It is a more holistic approach in assessing a child’s knowledge, skills and attitudes, which are reflective of the child’s competencies (Carr, 2006)
Observation of Daneka’s play gives the teacher an idea of how she thinks and expresses h...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

How Learning of Literature and Science Contributed to Understanding of Individuals and Societies

... labor and production costs. In these regards, the oppressive and exploitative nature of the economic climate in the novel is mirrored in the exploitative practices of companies that have moved their production operations to China and to Mexico. Ultimately, Dickens opposition to these conditions in 19th century Victorian England greatly contributed to my understanding of the historical nature of labor and exploitation in societies. In addition to the novel format, poetry has a powerful literary message in regards to the individual and society. The nature of poetry throughout history has been one that is crucial to the English language. Poems have experimented with the borders of language as a means of powerfully expressing the abstract...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Moving Societies to Green Governance

...Moving Societies to Green Governance I. Preliminaries The movement for a better environment is a collective effort of people to raise their qualityof life. In the same way that Kettleman City has struggled against “the disproportionate distribution of environmental hazards,” people worldwide have been struggling to create a better world by engaging in various movements to realize a better environment.1 Perhaps, one of the most important advocacies or concerns of the said movements is environmental justice.2 According to Cole and Foster, “environmental justice requires democratic decision making, community empowerment, and the incorporation of social structure---for example, existing community health problems, cumulative impacts...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

Circumstances and Causes Around the Death of Canadian Aboriginal Languages

..., including concepts of time, the physical environment, the weather and personal relations. (Leavitt, 1985, p. 266) The indigenous culture embraces time as a continuous process, rather than fixed blocks, while the physical environment is perceived in relation to the speaker, and not to arbitrary compass directions. Weather is spoken of in terms of on-going actions, while relationships are ordered in complex subject/object interactional forms. These structural forms are closely connected with the landscape and lifestyle of the indigenous nomadic societies of previous centuries. The death of such a language causes a dislocation of the community from its traditional understanding of all these key areas, and this, it seems, is why language...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

How to Learn Other Languages and Be Able to Communicate with People from Different Backgrounds

...Business Communication Table of Contents Part A 3 My language 3 How to improve English 4 Training Plan 5 Cross- Culture problems 6 Business ethics 7 Part B 8 Report: Green University 8 Meeting Minutes 10 Reflection: Group presentation 12 Semi-formal email to Manager 13 Formal Letter to Mr. Philip Hargreaves 15 Reference List 18 Part A My language I was born in a Chinese family and was brought up in the capital city of China, Beijing. As a child, I studied in a national school, where classes were conducted mostly in the local language. This did not give me sufficient opportunity to get exposed to English. There was also a small section of students who spoke Korean and communicated in their mother tongue. Such circumstances made me...
10 Pages(2500 words)Personal Statement

Social Identities Across Languages, Discourses, Cultures

... encounter in all the phases of life. Identity depicts the existence of an idea that tends to resemble the original idea and makes the design easy to recognize and identify. The language that a person learns tends to give a person a sense of identity. The main construct, therefore, illuminates on the fact that if an individual learns a language through teaching, a person acquires an identity that reflects the consequent social relationship (McCormick). In the art of learning language, there is the need of the influence of power from different sources. Other authors agree on the proposition that there is a great deal of relation of language with the acknowledge capacity that human beings possess. The example here illustrates the relevance...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Languages Reflect Societies for FREE!

Contact Us