Free

Critical Analysis - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The agencies have taken into deceitful ways of performing-or creating the illusion of performing- the mandates for which they were formed. It also points out how the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Critical Analysis
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Analysis"

Critical Analysis Critical Analysis Summary of thesis: The article talks primarily about the dissertation of roles by agencies in the Bahamas. The agencies have taken into deceitful ways of performing-or creating the illusion of performing- the mandates for which they were formed. It also points out how the Bahamian society in itself has also veered off the very principles that harmoniously bind the society together. The author condemns the political elite for letting the church take root in its establishment. A clear separation must be made as between rule in a secular state and the church. However, in this case it appears that the church has developed a political arm, which has a firm grip amongst the legislators.
Secondly, what is the purpose of the writer? The author tries to shed light on gross violations in the Bahamian society which are going on unabated yet, the very agencies designed to safeguard against this take to shifting responsibilities and sometimes taking part in perpetuating these violations themselves e.g. the police, specifically in-charge of security, differ it’s duty by pegging it’s performance on the church’s intervention. Secondly, he condemns the church over its abuse of public trust by getting swayed into primarily pubic-related issues as opposed to their divine calling to administer matters of faith. Thirdly, he serves to open the eyes of members of the society to the realization that the overall change as desired by the state-to free Bahamas of the previous year mishaps-lies ultimately in themselves as citizens. He accomplishes this by showing failures of the legislatures, the security agents, and the custodians of the society such as the church.
Thirdly, we examine the writer’s tone and feelings. The author is disapproving-even critical-about the ability of realizing the objectives of state for the New Year. He begins with much hope following the declaration by Bahamas Christian Council that calls on a change of people’s attitudes. This hope gradually ebbs away into despair, and he appears disillusioned in lieu of the rot within the very council empowered to oversee the transition. He appears enraged at one point when the BCB makes submissions to the local cable network and the URCA on suitable time to air adult-rated programming. To him, it seems the council is being hypocritical by at one point rightly condemning airing of pornography due to its impact on children, yet in the very same breathe appears to approve its viewing by the adult population (White field 3, paragraph 5). Shouldn’t the council condemn and propose a ban of pornographic content in its entirety? Secondly, what legitimacy does the council’s act to endure the entire duration of the 12 pornographic programs has? The alignment of paragraphs helps propose a contrast and comparison scenario for the audience. At the very beginning, he precedes by showing the genesis of the discussion alongside the statement of New Year objectives by the State of Bahamas. This is followed by the explanation of who is responsible for the administration of these objectives. This includes the church and the police. The subsequent paragraphs are structured to show the norm vis-à-vis the prevailing condition one of the participating agents in the change process. These latter sections help build the writer’s case for opposition. Ultimately, it legitimizes the writers almost disillusioned verdict over the Bahamian society.
Next, is there evidence for the writer’s argument? The writer brings forth documented proof that substantiates his repugnance as to the church’s-and in particular, the BCB’s - inability to impartially, and effectively address “the erosion of decency and standards in the Bahamas.” The writer points to some of the court cases that have been brought forth against members of the clergy accused of depraved social misconduct and some even jailed. Common sense aids in the writer’s dismissal of the council’s use of media limelight as opposed to the much more authoritative and ever-present pulpit. The council’s selective approach on which matters to handle, and which to turn a blind eye on, and its political association has considerably dented the writer’s and the greater society’s faith in the council to deliver.
Thereafter, we analyze the use of figurative language. The council has been accused of being as “quiet as a church mouse.” The idiom is used to symbolize the BCB’s silence over matters, which ordinarily they should be very vocal on. In this case, the molestation of local innocent children by Bahamian teachers seems not to have caught their interest but the docking of a cruise ship carrying lesbian and gay couples-both mature and consenting-bolted them into an uproar. The author says that, it was “refreshing” to hear about the BCB’s bold strategy of re-engineering morality in Bahamas as if it was a drink quenching thirst. Another figurative language is seen in the council’s “turning of a blind eye” towards local cases of sexual abuse by local teachers against innocent school children and the “hue and cry” following the docking of a cruise ship bearing what it considers questionable cargo in the form of lesbian and gay couples. The council has been personified and given human-like attributes such as physical features, for example, eyes and emotions. There is constant use of irony in the extract. The author shows the irony in the council’s patience to watch 12 porn programs for the entire duration and in the house of a senior citizen. It is as if the “distinguished” council members are ignorant about the obvious potent content at sight that they must watch it at their complete duration. He also uses irony in dismissing the BCB’s tough stand against legalization of gambling in the Bahamas yet the very same earnings from the trade find its way into the church’s coffers during Sunday prayers to fund the extravagant life that the council members enjoy. The use of personification, similes, and irony are critical in building the writer’s purpose. Ultimately, this legitimizes his tough criticisms of the council. The figurative languages help a third party audience to almost naturally side with the author as against the state and the church.
Sixth, is an assessment of fallacies therein and their interpretation. The fallacy of begging the question is evident in the BCB’s claim that children have technological access within their bedrooms that they use to access pornography at odd hours. Their proof being that the house of a prominent woman-whom they do not disclose - being frequented by minors falls short of their proposal to URCA or Cable Bahamas to restrict the airing of adult-content is inconsistent. The fallacy of hasty generalization is also displayed in the same process. The council assumes that since there is evidence of the senior citizen host’s inability to use the set box effectively for parental control then all parents are ignorant of the same (White field 3, paragraph 7). A fallacy of false cause is seen in the speech by the council’s president where he quotes directly from the Bible in an attempt to portray the church clergy as “a royal priesthood” as the rightful and endeared group that can bring liberation to the Bahamians (White field 4, paragraph 1).
Next, we examine the writer’s opposition. The writer refutes the idea that a generally morally unconscious body in the form of the Bahamas church council should be designated the front line in the war against social problems in Bahamas. He provides resistance that a council that directly gets emoluments in forms of offerings from the very corrupt acts of members of the society does not have the moral authority to condemn the practice (Whitefield 2, paragraph 9). Furthermore, he argues that the selective application of duties and responsibilities constitutes a lack of will on the doer’s part to be fully accountable to the people of Bahamas. Such hypocrisy, according to the author, depraves the doer of any legitimacy.
Consequently, a table of claims and proof for the writer’s cause is required. Claim of facts is seen in the writer’s expression that the church ministers will better win their war against child pornography viewing and generally the decaying moral sense of society in the pulpits instead of behaving like politicians in the media (White file 3, paragraph 6). Secondly, it is seen in the court cases against some church ministers leading to jail sentences in some (White file 3, paragraph 1). Claims of policy are seen in the church’s tough stand against gambling dating as back as 1960. Proposals in 1979 that would have legalized the act were shot down due to intense lobbying by the church (White file 2, paragraph 6-7).
Lastly, conclusion and reactions to the extract: The passage is very informative and shocking in the same breath. The occurrence of such gross sexual violations as indicated against innocent school-going children is very alarming indeed. Traditionally, the church has had significant power but only as far as its excision is within the perimeters of moral and religious matters of the society. The power of BCB, its proximity to prominent politicians and poor record of accomplishment in handling cases involving their own and evolving around their mandate portends doom for an already ailing society. I find it highly inappropriate that an already battered council should be entitled with the restoration of normalcy in the Bahamian society. I find it also key that parents should take a more pro-active role in guiding both their children and in preventing the pervasion of moral values as between the adult population. After all, charity begins at home.

Reference
White, P. A. (2012, January 23). The writings of esteemed Bahamian journalist, P. Anthony White. Retrieved March 04, 2012, from wordpress.com: http://pawbahamas.wordpress.com/2012/01/09/white-file-thanks-to-the-bcb-too-many-still-walk-in-darkness/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590617-critical-analysis
(Critical Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590617-critical-analysis.
“Critical Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1590617-critical-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Analysis

Critical Analysis

...?Critical Analysis Table of Contents Critical Analysis Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Focus 4 Analysis 5 Conclusion 8 References 9 Bibliography9 Introduction The era of globalisation and competition has led to a situation of intense market competition. Business organizations are getting engaged in price wars that have severely eroded the bottom lines of business organizations. Firms in highly competitive environment are looking to attract new customers by competing on the basis of pricing strategies so as to gain an edge over their competitors. Predatory pricing is one such strategy that is being used by business organizations across the globe....
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Critical analysis

...represented through the lens. It can be observed how the acts are conforming to the intended obscenity, the poor lighting, and the predating conditions before Yoshiyuki’s encounter with the couples. No one could honestly testify the real intent behind the scopophilia but judging from a critic’s point of view, there seems to be no cooperation between Yoshiyuki and the group of people. In the context of photography, while Yoshiyuki did not anticipate the happenstance, the drive that sticks him with the ongoing public demonstration could be related to personal photography, wherein he intended to seize the image for personal use (Wells 56); “here is a person making choices, not a stationary camera recording what passes...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

(Critical Analysis)

...? Critical Analysis of a Film Introduction This paper will critically analyze the film produced by Lionsgate and Reuben Cannon production titled ‘I can do bad all by myself’ dwelling on the need to elaborate and apply interpersonal theories and general interpersonal communication, which is brought out by this film. The movie was released on the 11th September, 2009. Critique The film is centered on the reality of family struggles and life challenges in general. The film includes 16 years’ old character named Jennifer, who has taken the responsibility of taking care of her brothers. She goes to the extent of looting to ensure that her sick brother gets daily medicine for his survival. The film shows some religious institutions... Critical...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Critical Analysis

...The articles, Motivating boys and motivating girls: does teacher gender really make a difference? by Marsh and Martin and You don’t bring me flowers any more: a fresh look at the vexed issue of teacher status by Rice, explore into the problem areas that have come up in the recent educational discourse of the Australian educational system. It is understood from the article titles that student motivation and the teacher status factors have become pressing issues that require immediate attention. The articles present accurate pictures of the said topics on the basis of thorough research. At the same time they aim to deliver specific suggestions through analysis of the research outcomes. The suggestions would be of much...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Critical Analysis

...of a revocation of an offer. The writer would be putting arguments form both sides, but would eventually prove that an offer had been constituted, but the revocation had not been successful. The case law on offer, acceptance and revocation will be dealt with and finally an analysis would be made as to whether there has been an offer, acceptance and revocation. The first important point that needs to be established is whether it was a unilateral offer or an invitation to treat. Analysis An offer is defined as an expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound on certain terms. (Storer v. Manchester City Council1).However it must be stressed that not all communications are offers. An invitation to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critical analysis

...A Critical Analysis of Danielle Crittendens "About Love" What Danielle Crittenden wrote about love is quite interesting although I beg to disagree onmany of the points that she has presented. No, I have nothing against women who choose to give up their careers and focus all their energies in making a home for their families but I cringed at the thought that marriage is a kind a of light at the end of the tunnel that all of us must embrace in order to be happy. Although I have high respects for the author, I would rather not call marriage as a liberating experience as she would want it to be nor do I agree with her implications that our generation today is self-absorbed, less committed than the previous...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critical analysis

...Critical analysis The balanced scorecard is a strategic development and administration system that is used widely in business and industry, government, and nonprofit institutions globally to support business activities to the revelation and strategy of the organization, advance internal and external communications, and examine organization performance aligned with strategic aims. It was introduced by Drs. Robert Kaplan and David Norton as a performance measurement structure that added strategic non-financial performance measures to conventional economic metrics to provide administrators a more unbiased study of managerial recital. The reason why the Balanced Scorecard notion has so extensively accepted...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Critical Analysis

...Critical Analysis The introduces the objective of the research which is to evaluate the messages of crisis pertaining to the US E. coli spinach and to the Korea’s rotten dumpling as they have been conveyed by the media. The authors have mentioned the methodological approach they had adopted to attain their objectives and have summarized the findings, practical implications of the conclusions drawn from the research and an in-sight into the significance or value of the research. The section ends with the keywords and the type of paper that it is. The strength of this section is that the authors have titled the various sections of information within the abstract with their respective headings which makes it...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Critical Analysis

...). [Retrieved March 31, 2014]. Benets Readers Encyclopedia (1996) Fourth Edition. New York: HarperCollins. p. 734. George Orwell (2013). Nineteen Eighty-Four, London: Penguin Press Howe, I. (1982). Orwells Nineteen Eighty-Four : Text, Sources, Criticism. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. (pp. 290–3). King, T. (1998). “Borders.” The Harbrace Anthology of Short Fiction. Ed. Jon C. Stott et al. Toronto: Harbrace. 1163-71. Keyes, R. (2009). I Love It When You Talk Retro. St Martins. p. 222. Oxford Dictionaries (2012). "Definition of Dystopia", Oxford: Oxford University Press. Slouka, M. (2009). Dehumanized: When Math and Science Rule the School. Harper’s Magazine. September Issue.... head: Dystopia RESPONSIBILITY OF CITIZENS IN CREATION AND...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Critical analysis

..., in academic writing, one maybe required writing on a totally new topic, and this requires one to have good research skill. Research in academic goes beyond Google and Wikipedia, to databases with scholarly writings. One also must have the ability to read complex texts and analyze them to succeed in academic writing. Academic writing is described as an argument. This is because; one presents a case and offers support to it, in an attempt to convince others. This depends on the writers ability to present their ideas in an organized manner and persuasively. Academic writing is also an analysis where the author focuses on the how and why questions. It is advisable to start with a draft and then develop the ideas...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical Analysis for FREE!

Contact Us