StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Fair Value Accounting - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Fair Value Accounting" talks about how the proponents of fair value accounting state that fair value accounting is important for a number of reasons: They provide information that is very relevant to users of financial statements, and they ensure comparability of financial statements…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Fair Value Accounting
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Fair Value Accounting"

Fair Value Accounting The Use of Fair Values in the Preparation and Presentation of Financial ments A number of arguments have been levelled for and against the use of fair values in the preparation and presentation of financial statements. Arguments in favour of fair value accounting The proponents of fair value accounting states that fair value accounting is important for a number of reasons: They provide the information that is very relevant to users of financial statements; and they ensure comparability of financial statements. Relevant Information Information needs to be relevant to the needs of users in order to serve its purpose. However, there are also other fundamental qualities that financial statements need to have. These qualities include comparability, faithful representation, consistency, completeness, understandability and reliability (BPP 2009a). Information is useless if it is not reliable and in a number of cases the values described as fair values in the accounts does not provide a reliable estimate of the value of assets and liabilities. According to Bath (n.d.) concerns also focus on this matter. It should also be noted the more reliable the information is the less relevant it will be. Relevant information has predictive value, feedback value and timeliness. Reliable information is verifiable Comparability of financial statements Financial statements need to be comparable from one year to the next and between one company and another. However, even though fair values may be said to be current and therefore more comparable, the fact that judgement need to be exercised brings subjectivity into play. In addition to that, those judgements on which investors and other stakeholders depend have their own agenda. In some cases they may exercise their judgement in such a way as to manipulate the accounts. This therefore brings us back to the reliability of the figures in the financial statements. Arguments against fair value accounting The arguments against fair value accounting appear to outnumber those in favour. Most of the arguments against essentially relate to the classification of financial instruments the fair value hierarchy. According to Ernest and Young (2009) the 2008 amendment of the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) requires that the classification of financial instruments be recorded at fair value in a hierarchy consisting of three (3) levels. The first level (level 1) relates to quoted prices that have not been adjusted for identical assets and liabilities in active markets. The second level (level 2) relates to input prices but excludes quoted prices which are included in the first level and which can be observed directly for assets and liabilities, in the form of prices or in the form of derived prices indirectly. The third level relates to both assets and liabilities that are not based on market data that can be observed. IASB concluded that this would result in improvement for comparability purposes as well as assist in the convergence process of the IFRSs to the United States generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). The basis that was given for that conclusion relates to the disclosures required by IFRS 7 and ASC having no differences in terms of their application. Khalik (2008) in his paper entitled ‘The case against fair value accounting’ indicated that its critics have suggested that in times of poor economic conditions fair value (FV) accounting leads to the generation of pessimistic assumptions that further result in significant reductions in asset values as well as major reductions in earnings because of the fact that unrealised losses is taken into account in the income statement. As a result of this they put forward the following arguments: It is rather subjective and arbitrary It reflects poorly on the performance of the company and presents no evidence to support it It may result in a significant increase in the volatility of the earnings that is reported It may result in investors being misled into thinking that poor financial conditions will continue into the future. According to the critics those conditions have resulted in investors dumping their shareholdings in 2008 during the financial crisis and also caused a run on banks as it occurred in the 1930s during the great depression. However, Khalik (2008) points out that when it suits them they do not mind fair value but when it does not they are totally against it. Khalik further indicates that when prices were rising, these opponents of FV had no concerns or even second thoughts about these unrealised gains that they benefited from. Subjective and arbitrary In relation to this point subjectivity directly contravenes the concept of objectivity. However, objectivity is not one of the fundamental accounting concepts and so the fundamental accounting concepts take precedence. While it may be seen as arbitrary the persons who apply them should have knowledge of accounting and accountants are expected to use their professional judgement is making decisions. The accounting standards framework provides a basis for the exercise of this judgement. Of course businesses operate in different industry sector and in different environments so these subjective factors will come to play in issues relating to valuation of assets and liabilities. Poor reflection on the performance of the business It is important that prudence be exercised in accounting for unrealised losses. According to BPP (2009a), although prudence is no longer a core concept in IFRS accounting losses should be recognised more readily than gains. Therefore it is important that unrealised losses are provided for, and this is especially so in an environment where businesses are not performing well due to a downturn in the economy, as happened in 2008. If the business is not performing well then it makes no sense to allow bad debts and other items to remain on the books, thus overstating assets when it should be written off or provided for where necessary, as a matter of prudence. If this is not done then it may appear as if profits are being made when it is not really so and dividends might be paid out of income which may never be realised. If things are not identified in the correct period then the impact on the financial statement will be great in the next financial period so it is always best to make provision in advance. This will help to lessen the volatility in income Significant increase in the volatility of the earnings that is reported According to BPP (2009b), the more volatile the fair value the more frequent is the revaluations. This may or may not affect the income statement. If a loss on revaluation was previously expensed than a subsequent gain would be included in the income statement. However, if there was no previous loss on that particular asset then any gains would be carried to the surplus. This means that care is taken not to overstate income but to exercise prudence in providing for unrealised losses. According to Bath (n.d.) volatility will occur because of the fact that fair values and therefore a change in an expected stream of cash flows changes the fair values. Bath (n.d.), further states that understanding the sources of volatility is very important and stresses that financial statement volatility is in no way a representation of financial reporting that is flawed. As a matter of fact Bath makes reference to the fact that historical accounting masks underlying economic volatility and is therefore not the result of superior accounting Investors being misled that poor conditions will continue into the future Financial statements that are prepared using FV accounting indicate factors that affect the performance of a business. Therefore, if there is an economic downturn and it is impacting on the business then investors would like to know. Additionally, the figures should reflect any changes that impact their values. The statements would also indicate the current outlook in order to indicate to investors that based on where we are now. References Bath. (n.d.). Fair Values and Financial Statement Volatility. Retrieved http://www.iasb.org/NR/rdonlyres/721AD4A0-42BB-4A09-9A91-140D27D65B84/0/FairValuesandFinancialStatementVolatility.pdf. Last accessed 6th May 2011 BPP. (2009a). F3-Financial Accounting. 3rd ed. London: BPP Learning Media Ltd BPP. (2009b). F7-Financial Reporting. 3rd ed. London: BPP Learning Media Ltd Ernest & Young (2009). Classification of Financial Instruments Within the IFRS 7 Fair Value Hierarchy. Retrieved: http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Fair_Value_Hierarchy_GL_IFRS/$File/Fair_Value_Hierarchy_GL_IFRS.pdf. Last accessed 6th May 2011 Khalik, A (2008). The case against fair value accounting. Paper: Paper : CGA conference in Ottawa, Canada. Retrieved: http://www.sec.gov/comments/4-573/4573-229.pdf. Last accessed 6th May 2011 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically discuss the arguments for and against the use of fair Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1576957-critically-discuss-the-arguments-for-and-against-the-use-of-fair-values-in-the-preparation-and-presentation-of-financial-statements-cite-literature-to-support-your-answer
(Critically Discuss the Arguments for and Against the Use of Fair Essay - 1)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1576957-critically-discuss-the-arguments-for-and-against-the-use-of-fair-values-in-the-preparation-and-presentation-of-financial-statements-cite-literature-to-support-your-answer.
“Critically Discuss the Arguments for and Against the Use of Fair Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1576957-critically-discuss-the-arguments-for-and-against-the-use-of-fair-values-in-the-preparation-and-presentation-of-financial-statements-cite-literature-to-support-your-answer.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Fair Value Accounting

The Case Against Fair Value Accounting

This essay "The Case Against Fair Value Accounting" discusses FASB (Financial Accounting Standards) and IASB (International Accounting Standards Board) that are to a great extent utilizing the fair value method of measurement in place of the historical cost method.... This is since they still find flaws in the fair value method.... The main objections against the fair value method are; that fair value is continuously a subjective method and that its use in financial statements of companies is to some extent likely to trigger short-term behavior as regards managers....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Fair Value Accounting, Financial Economics, and the Transformation or Reliability

The paper 'Fair Value Accounting, Financial Economics, and the Transformation or Reliability' provide evidence on the drivers of fair value application in accounting.... It explains how Fair Value Accounting gained such a role before the financial crisis of 2007 despite the growing opposition.... The author of the article 'Fair Value Accounting, financial economics, and the transformation or reliability' draws from several summaries and analyses to discuss the debate about fair value....
3 Pages (750 words) Literature review

Financial Crises and Fair Value Accounting

The author of the paper "Financial Crises and Fair Value Accounting" states that after the financial crisis, the opponents of the Fair Value Accounting method pointed out that the Fair Value Accounting method was one of the main factors which intensely fuelled the financial crisis.... Prior to the financial crisis, the Fair Value Accounting method was adopted as a main part of the financial accounting reform process by the FASB and the IASB due to the evaluated benefits of the Fair Value Accounting methods over other accounting methods like historical cost, deprival value costs and replacement cost accounting methods....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Fair Value Accounting Comparing to Other Measurements

The paper "Fair Value Accounting Comparing to Other Measurements" will discuss the benefits and drawbacks of Fair Value Accounting measurement compared with other measurements (historical cost, replacement cost, and deprival value) in enhancing the quality of financial information.... This paper seeks to critically appraise the statement that the recent financial crisis has led to a strong debate about the advantages and disadvantages of Fair Value Accounting (FVA), particularly on the argument by critics that fair-value accounting has significantly contributed to the financial crisis or, at least, aggravated its severity....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Fair Value Accounting and Its Role in Financial Crisis

The paper "Fair Value Accounting and Its Role in Financial Crisis" states that Fair Value Accounting is not responsible for fuelling financial crisis and the crisis was inevitable considering the given situation while adopting any other accounting approach.... Fair Value Accounting has been an important aspect of US GAAP (the United States Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) for over five decades yet its implementation increased significantly since the issuance of the Fair Value Measurement Standard (FAS 157) in 2006 by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) (Ryan, 2008; Khan, 2010)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Importance of Fair Value of Accounting

Apart from the above-mentioned factors, there was another factor that was considered an important determinant of the recent financial crisis, named Fair Value Accounting.... This led to a change in accounting regulation to Fair Value Accounting from historical accounting.... The paper "Importance of fair value of Accounting" is a great example of a report on finance and accounting.... The recent financial crisis had raised issues on the advantages and disadvantages of fair value in accounting....
13 Pages (3250 words)

Role of Fair Value Accounting in the Financial Crisis

The paper "Role of Fair Value Accounting in the Financial Crisis" is a wonderful example of a literature review on finance and accounting.... The paper "Role of Fair Value Accounting in the Financial Crisis" is a wonderful example of a literature review on finance and accounting.... The role of Fair Value Accounting (FVA) as a reason driving the financial crisis is identified as a debatable topic.... Role of Fair Value Accounting in the financial crisis The regulatory framework underlying the concepts of Fair Value Accounting is governed mainly by accounting standards....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

The Role of Fair Value Accounting

The paper 'The Role of Fair Value Accounting' is a spectacular example of a finance & accounting literature review.... Under the Fair Value Accounting concept, business entities are expected to certain assets and liabilities at their immediate fair values.... The paper 'The Role of Fair Value Accounting' is a spectacular example of a finance & accounting literature review.... Under the Fair Value Accounting concept, business entities are expected to certain assets and liabilities at their immediate fair values....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us