StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice" discusses that social workers should look for a mental space within themselves and a physical space outside themselves in which it is possible to witness and to take into account what is happening within them and around them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice"

Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice Introduction What do people know about risk in mental health services? Like any other community members, people reflect about risks to the population; as professionals, people reflect on the risk that they face in their line of work, and of the danger to the individuals with mental illness which social workers are at risk of neglecting on occasions when ‘moral panic’ governs approaches to mental disorder in the community. One of the tasks of working with or caring for the mentally ill is to evaluate, to observe and to manage risk, and on account of this task to make sound decisions concerning the lives of mentally ill clients. As argued by Davis (1996), there is a component of risk assessment in most features of the task, from the decisions that influence the liberty of individuals and the amount of assistance and support they receive, to decisions about policy on resources provision. Social workers can only accomplish these assessments if they are capable of recognising the certainty of risk and to take into account their responses to it. Two such responses were identified by Davis (1996) as those of risk minimisation and risk-taking, asserts that “Risk-taking is... an essential element of working with mental health service users to ensure autonomy, choice and social participation. It is a means of challenging the paternalism and over protectiveness of mental health services” (Davis 1996: 114). Elements of paternalism and over-protectiveness are features of the condition of risk minimisation apparent in guidelines of care management, care programming (CPA), documentations of hospital discharges and supervision records which, if professionals are not cautious, could result in needless controls being placed on the liberty of individuals diagnosed as being a threat to themselves and to others (Tew 2005). This consequently curbs the likelihood of integrating individuals with mental illness in their communities. Social workers have to find a neutral ground between being overcautious by needlessly restricting the experiences of their own and of their clients, and being inconsiderate by putting themselves and others in excessive risk (Gitterman 2001). Social workers are concerned with delivering the most favourable and beneficial mental health service for carers and service users. This suggests a service that is helpful, involves carers and service users in the process of decision making and is risk-free for all involved (Garlick 2007). Risk-free, effectual mental health services adopt a developed approach to risk, in which managing risk is defined as “the culture, processes and structures that are directed towards realising potential opportunities whilst managing adverse effects” (Garlick 2007: 14). This framework deviates from a crude risk perspective in mental health as relating mainly to risks occurring from service users, and rather sees risk as complex and multi-dimensional, and highlights the possible benefits as well as the dangers of risk taking (Austrian 2000). This essay takes on this broader perspective, where risk management process is not merely concentrated on removing risk, but on understanding possible gains while lessening the possibility of harms arising as an outcome of risk taking. Thinking about Risk Mental illness makes any person behaviourally and emotionally impulsive. There is no prescription or government intervention that is going to purge either mental illness or risk, even though a number of debates would indicate that this may be possible if only professionals could formulate a strategy of more effectively observing the behaviour of individuals with mental illness and of their health care providers (Austrian 2000). Such a perspective is an illustration of how people are coaxed both to make rush decisions and to disregard those things that they know, when having knowledge of them is painful or tiresome, or both. By itself it is an illustration of mental disorder within the human society. There are risks to clients, social workers and to the community in the tolerant and somewhat unrestrained and unregulated setting of the society. Mental health service users, since the 1990s, have become more and more described in terms of risk and precariousness, in spite of consistent empirical evidence that their role in societal violence is negligible (Potocky-Tripodi 2002). As mental health policy has further progressed in the path of regulating individuals identified to be a risk to others and to themselves, risk management and assessment is now a major condition for mental health practitioners (Nash, Munford & O’Donoghue 2005). The sustained emphasis upon risk implies that there is a chance that individuals so stigmatised will be barred from decision-making about their own lives. Self-protective response is also more probable (Nash et al. 2005). Risk to Others The behaviour of individuals in some studies involved inappropriate sexual behaviours, grave verbal threats, hostility, and assaults. At times staffs were uncertain whether an assault or aggressive action was caused by psychosis (Henderson 1994). For instance, one man in a study consented that he was a risk to himself and to other people when encountering psychosis, but he had been goaded into several brawls with other men, at times caused by racist cruelty (Henderson 1994). Self harm, suicidal ideas, and substance abuse were also characteristics of the lives of many service users, as were troubles such as discrimination, racism or distress originating from being an immigrant or having been exploited and abused in childhood (Tew 2005). Risk assessment and service users There were handfuls of cases where service users were totally involved in the process of assessing risk. Nevertheless, majority of service users and relatives were unaware of the fact that professionals were officially conducting risk assessments (Tew 2005). Most professionals have a tendency to make use of their simple checklists or own techniques to assess risk. Service users were seldom furnished risk assessment copies, even though numerous social workers would like to give an effort towards this (Padgett 1995). Most social workers in various studies claimed that they talked about risk with the service users, though numerous found this challenging. There are users who are not clearly aware that they were believed to create risk to other people and to themselves. Mental health practitioners found conversation easier when they are well-aware of the user, as well as their positive traits, and had a healthy relationship with them, developed over time (Padgett 1995). There are service users who could not be invited to participate in studies because they were unaware that staff regarded them a risk to other people (Gitterman 2001). This could have repercussions for civil liberties, and the usefulness of subsequent service responses. Several of the explanations provided against complete and straightforward discussion of risk were: anxieties for personal security or that this discussion would reinforce stigma and agonise or lead to disentanglement from services (Gitterman 2001). Explanations for discussing about risk to others involved the right of users to be informed of what is written about them, and enhanced reliance between mental healthcare provider and user, with the possibility of mutual risk management (Austrian 2000). Risk management Care plan for each service user included observing mental status as well as promoting compliance with prescription if they were unsure or hesitant to take medication. Documented risk management or decline preparations were seldom even though, during a number of studies, the Mental Health Trust formulated integrated care planning and risk management (Nash et al. 2005). Handfuls of service users were regarded by professionals as concerned and expressive about what they would like from the care plan. Descriptions and levels of involvement differed (Nash et al. 2005). Several mental health practitioners took involvement to suggest the user articulating their views whereas others implied that they had in fact manipulated the outcome. Only a small number of professionals talked about how to involve individuals who were not cooperative (Tew 2005). Current studies reveal that involvement of service users in risk assessment and management was unpredictable and relied upon individual professional programme. Handful of professionals was taking on methodical risk assessment or risk management schemes (Tew 2005). Research practitioners do not think that risks would be more truthfully evaluated if they were. Nonetheless, they propose that a format for risk assessment and management is formulated to guarantee that views of service users about risks are considered (Tew 2005). It appeared that numerous professionals were concerned in working towards the involvement of service users but found it challenging. An eagerness to take proper risks, discuss risk and look comprehensively at all features of an individual’s life, such as other troubles they may be suffering, such as distress, racism, etc., could go one way or another to facilitate more successful risk management (Henderson 1994). Cultures within organisations also influence the level to which healthcare providers feel restrained to practice self-protectively rather than justifiably (Henderson 1994). Social Case Work: Young Black Males with Mental Illness Several young black males and minority ethnic groups are revealed in some studies to have higher incidences of hospitalisation, enforced confinement, and interventions including isolation, compared to the general population (Stanley & Manthorpe 2002). The explanations for these variations are not completely understood but the bigger threat of mental health disorders may somewhat be caused by social inequality, marginalisation and anxiety, while services and treatment grounded on improper assumptions and damaging stereotypes also contribute to the problem (Stanley & Manthorpe 2002). These inequalities have become a major emphasis within mental health research and planning. It has been proposed that national programmes to enhance treatment across various social groups are not likely to be effective without an improved knowledge of the processes of decision-making that evidently result in these more coercive and invasive outcomes (Gitterman 2001). There is information/data that young males from black and minority ethnic group might be hesitant to seek help from services offered by mental health institutions and might postpone an attempt until a condition becomes out of hand (Stanley & Manthorpe 2002). Members of black and minority ethnic communities who use services and their healthcare providers usually reveal discontent with ordinary services which they frequently view as misrepresenting or misinterpreting their condition (Stanley & Manthorpe 2002). Services can be enhanced by encouraging the involvement and report of black and minority advocacy groups and service users in risk management and planning. For instance, Hillingdon MIND has formulated an array of services for mentally ill Asian people, such as drop-in centres, assisting plans, and associations for women with depression and anxiety, programmes which show the importance of working collaboratively with the local community (Austrian 2000). Assessing and managing risk includes a practised duty of care of those serving in mental health institutions towards the young black male service users, in which health needs are complemented with matters of individual and public security. Healthcare providers should complement the encouragement of client involvement in decision making and independence with the burdens of personal, professional, and public responsibility (Gitterman 2001). Risk management must not only put emphasis on removing risk, it is about presenting a mechanism for ascertaining the possible gains identified are strengthened and the possibility of problems arising as an outcome of taking risks are lessened (Gitterman 2001). As part of their daily task, mental healthcare providers is obligated to adhere to specific duties under legislations on health and safety, such as taking practical care to secure his/her wellbeing, and those of others (Potocky-Tripodi 2002). Nonetheless, the multi-dimensional notion of risk necessitates that the array of co-workers in mental health services each fulfil their function in successful managing of risk including the service user as well as the healthcare providers and family members. This can be realised most successfully through the kind of partnership operating represented in the recovery approach, in which these individual obligations can be clarified and discussed (Potocky-Tripodi 2002). Service users might need further assistance to understand and adhere to their obligations in this regard, such as support and guidance from an independent sponsor. Successful assessment and management of risk, which enthusiastically involves the user in the course of action, can and must be motivating and health cultivating (Tew 2005). A number of interventions can proffer risks to users, such as several forms of prescription which might have unfavourable side effects (Tew 2005). Hence the notion of risk is more comprehensive than often described or recognised. Conclusion Social workers of individuals with mental illness should keep in mind as much as they can. They should be consciously sensitive of the indications coming from themselves and from others, and to be ready to contend with the obvious discrepancies. They have to be roused by the voice inside them urging them ‘to be irrational’ or ‘not to be irrational’ at occasions when they are feeling nervous, so that rather than reacting by turning away, then contend with their feelings with higher regard. Simply put it, social workers should look for a mental space within themselves and a physical space outside themselves in which it is possible to witness and to take into account what is happening within them and around them. Social workers can all recognise situations in which it seems impossible to accomplish this: when they are preoccupied, running from one task to another, when the workplace is extremely disorganised that it becomes impossible to reflect and when they feel overwhelmed by too much disruption that it feels rather impossible to take into account anything. These are the occasions when social workers are most at risk. Rules and guidelines can be valuable constitutions for thinking, as long as they are used to this purpose. Management that promotes thinking is important to successful risk task, but this can also be difficult to find. It is essential to hold personal power and influence in the work, but guidelines that seem to be always monitoring the worker weakens this. On occasions social workers may even feel coaxed to behave or act against their better judgment so as to be able to say ‘I already told you’ when a crisis occurs. However, when the outside environment is capable of providing workers with chances for building healthy relationships with managers and co-workers, enduring relationships with service users and clients, and successful inter-agency partnership, then they are capable of reflecting about risk and to make decisions that are sensitive to the varying demands of individual clients. References Austrian, S. G. (2000) Mental Disorders, Medications and Clinical Social Work, New York: Columbia University Press. Davis, A. (1996) Risk work and mental health. In H. Kemshall, Good Practice in Risk Assessment and Risk Management, London: Jessica Kingsley. Garlick, A. (2007) Estimating Risk, London: Ashgate Pub Co. Gitterman, A. (Ed.). (2001) Handbook of Social Work Practice with Vulnerable and Resilient Populations, New York: Columbia University Press. Henderson, G. (1994) Social Work Interventions: Helping People of Color, Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey. Nash, M., Munford, R., & ODonoghue, K. (2005) Social Work Theories in Action, London: Jessica Kingsley. Padgett, D. (Ed.). (1995) Handbook on Ethnicity, Aging and Mental Health, Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. Potocky-Tripodi, M. (2002) Best Practices for Social Work with Refugees and Immigrants, New York: Columbia University Press. Stanley, N. & Manthorpe, J. (2002) Students Mental Health Needs: Problems and Responses, London: Jessica Kingsley. Tew, J. (Ed.). (2005) Social Perspectives in Mental Health: Developing Social Models to Understand and Work with Mental Distress, London: Jessica Kingsley. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Social work- Understanding Human Behaviour Essay”, n.d.)
Social work- Understanding Human Behaviour Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561939-social-work-understanding-human-behaviour
(Social Work- Understanding Human Behaviour Essay)
Social Work- Understanding Human Behaviour Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561939-social-work-understanding-human-behaviour.
“Social Work- Understanding Human Behaviour Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561939-social-work-understanding-human-behaviour.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Assessing and Managing Risk in Social Work Practice

Managing Change by Managing Risk

“Much of risk management work is focused on the management of risk in a 'business as usual' and relatively stable environment” (Anderson 2004).... The key to organizational change and development lies in the understanding of people's requirements and work towards it.... The external forces of change include competitive business environment, technological development, and political and social environment of an organization.... The author of the paper will also discuss the role of risk management in managing organizational changes....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Risk Assessment and Management in Forensic Mental Health

This essay "risk Assessment and Management in Forensic Mental Health" is about an understanding of whether incarcerating are able to stay out of trouble once they leave incarceration, and how should be decided by who works with the individual outside of jail or prison.... risk for a mental health patient generally means an assessment of whether the individual will become violent against themselves or against others.... This is one of the reasons why Carroll (2007) suggests that more formalized instruments for assessing risk should be used instead of relying on programs that are developed locally....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Project Risk Management

As a good practice, risk management within projects requires improvements for contracts, providing incentives for quality and recognizing capabilities.... Table 1: Typical Risks Technical social Construction Economic Legal Financial Natural Commercial Logistics Political Table 2: Risks by Impact Dynamic vs Static Corporate vs Individual Internal vs External Positive vs Negative Acceptable vs Unacceptable Insurable vs Non insurable As suggested in both tables, the major source of risks for construction projects, are networks, this occurs either directly or indirectly....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Control of Risk Related with the Management of Customers Personal Data in Banks

(2004, 19), 'the benefits of advances in risk management in banking may be greater credit availability, rather than the reduced risk in the banking system'.... Relevant literature is also used in order to highlight the various aspects of risk in the specific sector but also to evaluate the effectiveness of the risk management cycle in relation to the specific business sector.... while being stored in a bank's database; therefore, the use of risk management cycle for assessing and addressing this risk is highly suggested – at the level that the plans developed are feasible – in terms of the resources required but also in terms of their common performance – referring to the effectiveness of similar plans used by firms operating in other industrial sectors....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Public Health Guidance Provided by NICE on Type 2 Diabetes

In the contemporary world, health has become an important issue especially due to its role in the economic, social and political development of a country.... Additionally, the paper will also discuss the role of other organizations in producing the guidance as well as evaluation of the social, political, economical and environmental aspects facilitating the public health guidance.... he National Institute for Health and Care Excellence aims at providing national guidance to improve health and social care....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Personal Development Plan as a First Line Manager

At the same time, the managing director needs the first line manager to submit a completed work schedule plan within a period.... From the example above, preparation of the work schedule plan and addressing concerns of employees assumes letters B and C respectively.... dmittedly, work plans come with restrictive timelines.... Tasks contained within each work plan have a prescribed deadline; hence time is usually a limitation in executing work plans....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Standard Definition of Risk

However, looking at the definition of risk, it can be concluded that risk means assessing the possibilities of positive and negative events, but in social work, the risk is more associated with life threatening situations or negative occurrences (Bearly, 1982; 82).... The paper "Standard Definition of Risk" discusses that risk is a part of social work that enables a social worker or the care provider to draw different strategies and techniques by incorporating legislation, policies and risk discourses to overcome the threat of risk....
25 Pages (6250 words) Research Paper

Recognizing Risks and Improving Patient Safety- Mildred Story

The evidence-based practice provides health care professionals with guidelines that incorporated into the routine healthcare service management processes to allow for systematic monitoring (Robinson 2008).... It is possible to add value to evidence-based practice through a systematic and strategic approach that is properly resourced and supported (Spark and Rowe 2004).... In addition, evidence-based practice also provides healthcare professionals with guidelines that provide quality assurance to the patients and is associated with service delivery priorities (Swage 2000)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us