Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
With the growing competition in pretty much all parts of life, it isn’t a surprise that education too has becoming an avenue of great contest…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical)"

Are legacy admissions ethical? With the rising enrollment in the public and private universities, legacy admissions have become a topic of hot debate. With the growing competition in pretty much all parts of life, it isn’t a surprise that education too has becoming an avenue of great contest. All parents and students alike want to be part of the best universities and colleges; a good education has become the cornerstone to leading a successful life. Here comes in the question of legacy admissions and justice. Typically when speak of justice you would assume that all people would be treat with fairness, equity and impartiality; however in the case of the legacy admissions is such a feat possible? Does a person who works hard his whole life to get into a good college deserve an admission more than one whose father is capable of writing a large check? Legacy admissions are not based on merit but the wealth of your family and their history with the university that you are applying to. Your father went there, so did his father and you must follow in their footsteps regardless of how capable you are of doing so (Sacks 155).
As per the article under discussion, it is stated that, “justice calls for evenhanded treatment of groups and individuals,” while this is a very noble concept, it is practically impossible. Yes, in autopian world society holds all individual equal. But is it a good idea to put the good of a few people above greater benefit for all? At a glance it wouldn’t be inaccurate to say that such admissions are unethical, but the question is, who are they harming? Those that are denouncing legacy admission are doing so by promoting merit. Even former president George Bush spoke against legacy admission, however he himself has been known to graduate from Yale while his academic record shows no distinguishing patterns. Legacy admissions help by giving the educational institutes funds which they further utilize to make the edification experience more enriching. These funds result in high labs, competitive sports programs, state of the art libraries etcetera.
Investopedia, an investment company came up with a very simple calculation of yield-measurements e.g. if the university has an endowment fund of $160 million and it has a 7% spending amount, this would yield an annual available income of $11.2 million. For instance the university has allocated an annual budget of $7 million, the access amount $4.2 million is then spent in adding up to the prestige of these universities by offering more scholarships and building up more halls, libraries, auditoriums computer labs etc. Considering the huge amount of profits they gain from these endowments it is hard to say that admissions on such conditions should be stopped.
The problem is that the discussion of ‘fair’ and ‘ethical’ admissions will not stop at this one issue. There is actual standard of fairness that can be applied. Shepard & Thomas (2003) proved this point further when they wrote, “Should a state university give preference to in-state students? We would suggest yes, since the taxes paid by state residents support the institution. If one agrees, then that establishes that preference is permissible for those who financially support the university--especially if their support contributes to a better education for all of the students enrolled.” Hence, even if an out state student has the best position in his entire state, he will still be at the bottom of the food chain in any other state.
The fact is that most state cannot claim that they fully support their universities. By removing legacy admissions, you would be putting the entire education system at a disadvantage. Public universities thus have two choices, turn a blind eye to a few academic records and enroll them for their monetary value or let the entire quality of education deteriorate due to lack of funds. Realistically speaking, the government will never be able nor willing to invest the kind of money that legacy admissions bring in to a single university. Raising the tuition is one other option that they can take up but affects all the students in an adverse manner. Not every disadvantaged student will be able to get a scholarship and many will not be able to afford a degree at all.
The article further goes onto state that, “justice is largely based on the moral rights of individuals; the moral rights to be treated as a free and equal person.” This is again a very noble thought, this would knock legacy admissions right off the map. Then we can look at the question of special admission cases i.e. those based on minorities like blacks, Hispanics and Asians. The next step would be to cut these out of the system too because if everyone is equal, such an allowance should not be given. And if we go by that rule than legacy admissions seem to go hand-in-hand with sports scholarships. Students who are awarded placement because of their atheletic abilities at times have a very disturbing academic record and many with high merit lose out because of their skills as athletes.
In a nutshell, the concept of justice is very tricky to tackle. It is very easy to say that justice should provide equality for all, but we live in a complicated world where not everyone can have what they want. Legacy admissions do trample the prospects of some deserving students with higher merit but if you look at the bigger picture, in general these admissions raise the value of education that all the students are receiving.
Works Cited
“How do university endowments work?”, Investopedia ULA, 10 June, 2009, 29 Oct, 2009
Sacks, Peter, “Tearing down the gates: confronting the class divide in American education” ,
Thomas, Debra, and Terry Shepard "Legacy Admissions Are Defensible, Because the Process Cant Be Fair." Chronicle of Higher Education 49.27 (2003): B15. Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 1 Nov. 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Analysis Paper on ( Is Legacy Admissions Ethical) Essay)
“Analysis Paper on ( Is Legacy Admissions Ethical) Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical)

The Debate Over Legacy Admissions: Rationality Or Ideology

...? The Debate Over Legacy Admissions: Rationality or Ideology? al Affiliation The Debate Over Legacy Admissions: Rationality or Ideology? The purpose of this paper is to provide an explanatory synthesis of the debate over legacy admissions, drawing on four articles (Thomas and Shepard 2007; DeKoven 2007; Megalli 2007; USA Today 2007). Overall, these articles demonstrate that, though drawing on facts, the debate about university legacy admissions is essentially political and ideological in nature. Facts sharpen and focus the arguments on either side, but the problem is that neither side...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethical Analysis

... The board of directors is a group of individuals who are responsible for running an organization. They work closely with the managerial staff in order to create a strategic plan for a company. Due to their position the members of the board of directors are entrusted with information that can change the future of a company. In the situation depicted in the case study the board of director member wanted to take advantage of an investment opportunity based on privileged information. The actions of the board of director member are unethical due to the fact that the person was making an investment decision utilizing insider’s information. Insider information can be defined as intimate knowledge or material non public information... The board of...
1 Pages(250 words)Term Paper

Ethical Case Study Analysis Paper

...?ETHICAL CASE STUDY ANALYSIS PAPER Identification of all ethical dilemmas presented Reading through the case and for that matter the issues presentedby Lisa to James, there are three major ethical dilemmas that can be identified on the part of Lisa. The first of these has to do with the academics and subsequently, the future carrier that the young lady wants to take up. This is because leading up to the break up that she had with her boyfriend she had lost concentration on her studies and is not sure if she can continue to pursue her dream of becoming lawyer. The second has to do with the dilemma of having to report her mother’s partner to her mother....
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Data Warehouse Project Management

...into the data warehouse does not have a maintainable and scalable architecture. The rpocessing times were extremely high and were interfering with the other tasks. The legacy student data mart included fields for student colleges, student careers, academic program, academic plan, academic sub plan, instructor advising, enrollment, application, financial and admission. Aims and Objectives The primary objective of the data warehouse project is to re build the existing setup for reporting, analysis and satisfying legal compliance. The existing architecture will be revamped to be more scalable and maintainable, thereby reducing processing time. Various line departments such as...
20 Pages(5000 words)Essay

Freshman College Admissions Paper

...This paper is for my admission essay to Illinois I have applied to ISU as I feel that it is the right place for me considering my background so far and that it would launch me into a career after my undergraduate program. Presently, I am a senior at Deerfield High School in Illinois and want to major in Business Management at ISU. I have always dreamt of a career as a corporate manager and hence my decision to opt for an undergraduate program in Business Administration. I am an extroverted person by nature and I love the outdoors very much. I like to go trekking and exploring the parks around my district. I like to do this in groups of friends and acquaintances. I believe that this gives me a chance to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethical Analysis

...Illegal Immigration: The Ethical Dilemma for Health Care Professionals It is obvious by now that economic, cultural, technological, social, and psychological processes affect modern health care, particularly how that health care is provided and to whom. An important social element in this conversation must be the current hot-topic of illegal immigration and the health community’s ethical responsibility to provide health care to members of a sub-community that technically does not exist under U.S. law, yet drains its health resources. The treatment of illegals in the U.S. health care system must include a realistic yet ethical component consistent with our human values. California: Cost...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Legacy Admissions

...the donations from legacy admissions, better education is provided to non-legacy students even, and thus “quality” of education is maintained (p.222). Megalli (2008) is opposed to this view as she has found the legacy contribution comparatively meager as compared to other available funds (p.231). This is yet another statistical play with data and calls for deeper introspection to be proven either way. But still Megalli’s (2008) position is more ethically valid as it stands for “meritocracy” and against “elitism” so that long term goals of education are in focus (p.231) whereas Thomas and Shepard (2008) seem to be more inclined towards the lesser goals of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethical analysis

...Ethical analysis Confidentiality in medical practice is one of the core health care tenets (Raymond 961). As a result, medical practitioners are faced with a challenge of keeping patient information private. However, confidentiality is not always an absolute obligation for general practitioners. This means that some circumstances would oblige practitioners to breach the confidentiality and thus the privacy of information on patients. A case of Richard who has tested HIV positive is presented with a dilemma surrounding the need to inform his spouse about the husband’s condition. Even though practitioners are expected to keep the confidentiality of patient information, Richard’s case demonstrates a need...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethical Paper

...Ethical Paper Ethical Paper Introduction Counseling process is a structured and planned dialogue that takes place between a counselor and his or her client. Clients who have problems of various magnitudes visit a counseling specialist who helps them through identification of areas of difficulties and concerns that client experiences. Counselor help client to develop ways and means of dealing with and overcoming identified problems. Consequently, the client develops new skills and enhanced self-understanding. Hypothesis of a Counseling Situation with a Client I am a new male counselor who recently had a counseling session with a young female college student. The student...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

College admissions

...College Admission College Admission George Mason and I posses a common vision of exceeding expectations in life and standing out as the greatest in whichever goal I set. My private past time, up until now, is to become a successful special education teacher. My experience at Northern Virginia Community College has prepared me adequately for this lifelong dream to guide students with disabilities. I garnered an acceptable GPA and considerable experience in the field of special education and I would now like to further my studies. Despite my accomplishments in school, I have some challenges that I would like to be considered because they may limit the chances of me furthering my education. My cumulative...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Analysis paper on ( is legacy admissions ethical) for FREE!

Contact Us