Free

Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The essence of Kant’s theory of enlightenment is the proposition that “enlightenment is man’s emergence from incurred immaturity” and that the concept of immaturity stems from self-infliction due to lack of courage. This in turn correlates to Kant’s central theory…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kants Questions
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions"

The essence of Kant’s theory of enlightenment is the proposition that “enlightenment is man’s emergence from incurred immaturity” and that the concept of immaturity stems from self-infliction due to lack of courage. This in turn correlates to Kant’s central theory pertaining to the underlying rationale of being human. There are many similarities between Kant and the earlier arguments of Aquinas, which have both proved important in developing ethical theory and international relations theory.
However, whilst there are similarities, Kant and Aquinas’ definition of human character has fuelled academic debate as to the differences particularly in relation to the theories regarding freedom, public and private interests in light of Kant’s extrapolation of the Supreme Moral Principle of Good Will. The focus of this paper is to critically evaluate these differences with a contextual consideration of Kant’s Supreme Moral Principle of Good Will in practice. To this end, this paper will consider Kant and Aquinas’ central arguments and evaluate Kantian assumptions of innate morality in ethical theory and international relations.
It is firstly submitted that Kant’s theory of enlightenment arguably focused on an attempt to seek out a truth of knowledge and similarly Aquinas’s arguments suggests that the underlying nature of being human was explained through rationale thought, which he in turn related to God. Furthermore, Deligiorgi posits that Kant’s philosophy belongs to an intellectual context in terms of the limits of enlightenment and he “defines enlightenment not in terms of rational certitudes but rather in terms of the freedom to engage in public argument” (Deligiorgi, 1).
Accordingly, Kant’s philosophy is rooted in an innate moral propensity towards democracy as a result of human intellectual independence. Kant’s theory of the rationale for being human suggests that it is the interrelationship between intellectual independence and morality that is central to concepts of democracy. Similarly, Aquinas’ proposition of what constitutes being human also emphasises the independent voluntary exercise of will.
However, in contrast to Kant, Aquinas’ theory was heavily intertwined with Catholic hierarchy and interpretations of existence (Ardley 3). Moreover, Aquinas’ central focus was on the issue of humanity in context of its relationship to God and the natural world. Additionally, Ardley highlights that the central difference with Kant’s principle of humanity was that “Aquinas represents the metaphysician of the philosophia perennis. Kant on the other hand, as we understand him, in his basic contentions gets to the heart of the characteristic non-metaphysical pre-occupation of the modern world which seem alien to the philosophia perennis” (Ardley 3-4).
Nevertheless, both philosophers have similarities in terms of their ethical views and attach significance to the role of practical reason in ethical life. It is further submitted that a fundamental basis in particular relating to Kant’s enlightenment theory was the supreme moral principle of good will, which catalysed the deontological approach to ethics. Moreover, both philosophers clearly believed that there is a fundamental principle of practical reason and morality which in turn presses the importance of law in ethics (Ardley, 5).
Additionally, whilst there are clearly similarities between Kant and Aquinas in their understanding of being human, whilst Aquinas’ rationale was often intertwined with the relationship of humans to God in the Catholic Church; Kant’s theory goes further in referring to intellectual independence irrespective of religion or cultural beliefs. This proposition has heavily influenced contemporary deontological ethical theory, which in turn has become extremely pertinent to the concept of international relations and human rights protection in the current political global framework.
For example, beyond the intellectual intelligence paradigm is Kant’s assumption of the supreme moral Principle of good will. This suggests that humans are innately moral and is supported by contemporary deontologist Somerville who refers to the “secular sacred” concept of ethics, which is that there are basic human rights and values that are common to humans irrespective of religious or cultural beliefs.
However, Somerville goes further and argues that the crux of ethics with regard to human rights protection is whether it is “inherently wrong?”(Somerville xi). Furthermore, Somerville argues in considering human rights protection, often the legal issue of human rights protection is inherently linked to the issue of whether it is ethical and that to consider ethics, “we must first ask whether what we plan to do is inherently wrong”(Somerville xi).
Therefore, Somerville’s ethical imagination echoes Kant’s theoretical idealism of the supreme moral principle of good will that a true system of politics cannot… take a single step without first paying tribute to morality. For as soon as those two come into conflict, morality can cut through the knot which politics cannot unite” (Kant, translated by Nisbet, 1991; Quoted in Fiala, 2002: 27).
However in terms of the current international political framework and mechanism for human rights protection, it is submitted that Kant’s belief in the presence of shared innate human morality is flawed and not reflected by reality. This is further supported by reference to Hobbensian ethical theory, which asserts that nature is scarce and “I put for a general inclination of all mankind, a perpetual and restless desire of power after power, that ceaseth only in death” (Hobbes, Leviathan, quoted in Morgan, 2001, p.523). Under Hobbes’ strand of realism, humans are only moral to the extent that they follow rules and regulations imposed by the state, which undermines any notion of innate “shared ethics”. Moreover, Kant’s belief in the prevalence of innate human morality is arguably flawed and not reflected by the reality of the current political approach to foreign policy in international relations.
Whilst Kant’s theory is rooted in the assumption of innate human morality, the realist perception is that human nature cannot be trusted. Indeed, Hobbes’ supporter Donelan argues that there is “senselessness for survival of being moral when you can have no confidence that the other will be also; when there is no common power over you” (Donelan, 1990).
Conversely, Kant argues the following principles of international relations under the enlightenment paradigm:
1) The Freedom of every member as human being;
2) The equality of each with all the others as a subject; and
3) The independence of each member of a commonwealth as a citizen (Kant, 74).
Kant’s theory regarding the moral development of the state weighs heavily on the presumption that the civil state will uphold these rights and claims “no-one can compel me to be happy in accordance with his conception of the welfare of others, for each may seek his happiness in whatever way he sees fit, so long as he does not infringe upon the freedom of everyone else within a workable general law…. he must accord others the same right as he enjoys himself” (Kant 74).
Kant extended his idealist theory to postulate the “original contract” between man and civil society (Kant, 79), which Kant argued was vital for man to maintain his freedom under the concept of supreme morality (Kant, 46). However, whilst Kant’s assertions may be realistic within the state’s internal framework, it is questionable how far this notion of an innate human need for mutuality extends beyond a state’s border in international relations vis-à-vis other states.
Kant put forward the argument that man would inherently be in favour of complying with this “implied contract” to prevent the anarchic state and that the sacrosanct status of the original contract extended to international relations with other states (Kant, 46). This idealism was rooted in Kant’s belief that an evolved moral state would become disgusted with war in the international system and that the idealism would result in an end to war (Kant, 125).
However, if we consider this in context of contemporary international relations theory, Weber highlights that the central basis of international relations is state self interest and is to prevent other states gaining advantage, which is considered key in shaping national foreign policy (Weber, 1946). Moreover, according to Donelan “Their efforts result in a stalemate in which they survive” (Donelan, 1990). Thus according to Hobbes’ theory of realism, every state works with self interest to be better than others with a rough balance of power resulting in stalemate, where foreign policy and international politics is locked in a repetitive cycle (Donelan, 1990).
However, as between states, there is no moral duty or extension of Kant’s “original contract” and therefore States can do anything to prevent the other gaining control (Jackson & Sorrenson, 1999). Jackson and Sorrenson further comment that “All states must be prepared to sacrifice their international obligations on the altar of their self-interest if the two come into conflict” (Jackson and Sorenson, 1999, p.69). This means therefore that progress in international relations cannot be made unless the international situation of each state is peaceful as if the state is suffering internal crisis then submit to self interest before international politics.
Accordingly, this clearly contrasts with Kant’s ideal, however Kant’s ideal is flawed by the presumption of the moral state in the supreme morality of goodwill. Therefore, whilst Kant’s original contract and cosmopolitan constitution concept is clearly an ideal approach in shaping foreign policy it is inherently flawed by relying on the morality of human nature.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ardley, G. Aquinas and Kant. Read Books 2007
Deligiorgi, K. Kant and the Culture of Enlightenment. SUNY Press, 2005
Donelan, M. Elements of International Political Theory. Oxford University Press, 1990
Fiala, A. G The Philosopher’s Voice. Suny Press, 2002
Jackson, R and Sorenson, G. Introduction to International Relations University Press, 2001
Kant, I. Kant’s Political Writings, translated by H.B. Nisbet and edited by Hans Reiss. Cambridge University Press 1991.
Morgan, W. Questionable Charity: Gender, Humanitarianism, and Complicity in American Literary Realism. University Press of New England, 2001
Somerville, Margaret. A. The ethical imagination: journeys of the human spirit. Anansi, 2006 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions Essay”, n.d.)
Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1558329-freedom-our-public-and-private-interests-and-kants-questions
(Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant'S Questions Essay)
Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant'S Questions Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1558329-freedom-our-public-and-private-interests-and-kants-questions.
“Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant'S Questions Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1558329-freedom-our-public-and-private-interests-and-kants-questions.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions

Public vs. Private school

...? ID Lecturer Public vs. Private School This is one debate that has been in the headlines for a number of different reasons. Whether or not private or public schooling manifests success for the sake of the students and their parents in the long run is something that needs to be comprehended in an effective way. This is because, both public and private schooling mechanisms are equally employed to derive the best possible value for the students yet the availability of resources is something that remains a problem nonetheless. One must understand that the discussion which centers on the premise of public and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Conflict of Interests in Public-Private Partnership

..., it is often intractable, there is no unilinear solution, moreover, there is no ‘stopping’ point, it is novel, any apparent ‘solution’ often generates other ‘problems,’ and there is no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ answer, but there are better or worse alternatives. Wicked problems within public-private partnership are characterized as recurrent or persistent problems, often defined by indecision and conflict over interests or purposes that could influence the process of decision-making (Hodge & Greve 2005). According to Grint (2005), there are no simple solutions to these wicked problems confronted by PPP. Remarkable progress can be achieved in mitigating them, but they will not be totally...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Public and private spaces

...? Public and Private Spaces PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SPACES Amendment I, or the First Amendment, is a section of the United s constitution that was added in 1791. It stops the formulation of any laws that; impede citizens from exercising their religion freely, respect the establishment of any religion, abridges speech freedom, interferes with the citizens’ right to assemble peacefully, infringes on press freedoms, or stops citizens from redressing their grievances to the government through a petition (Stowe & Stump, 2007: p12). The First Amendment is exploited in various ways. For instance, the movie Borat is presented as a satirical look of life in America. Using real events and people, the film’s star Borat becomes a basic lunatic... on the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Private and Public Education

...be noted that quality education is the basic right to every citizen of the nation. As what the author so rightly calims, it simply comes to our notice that both these sectors (public and private) are not fulfilling their job as they were supposed to. The author goes on to elaborate on the private education domain. One very important point the author brings to our attention is that the major problem faced by the private educational system manifests a lack of procedures by which systematic data collection can be made possible (Wenders, p. 217, 2005). The main reason for this point is that there are two major sources of data collection:...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Ethics of Dignity and Freedom by Kant

... of the critical ethics (Singer). The connection between Kant’s ethics and his theoretical philosophy, the genesis of his ethical ideas, formation of his thoughts in frames of study about freedom and ethics, dignity study (the central category of his moral philosophy) – these problems are at the centre of his ethical concept. According to Kant the only thing that is with every human being from the beginning of their life is striving for happiness. All the fundamental needs and interests lead to it. That is why it is appropriate to speak about egoism here. If morality were based on the striving for happiness, than the causes for actions would have a bit of heteronomous character – hope for achieving success and getting inner... Ethics...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Public and private

...In “Downward Mobility” the has painted a bleak yet detailed picture of the socio-economic Predicament of a divorced woman in America. He studied the cases of sixty women who discussed their plight both as a divorcee and as a single parent. Most of them were struggling at Socioeconomic as well as emotional and psychological levels. A considerable group was not even able to make both ends meet. Generally the participants discussed their individual situations and experiences but their statements were in agreement of one basic fact i.e. the gender issue which seemed to be an inbuilt phenomenon in the case of divorce. Women tend to suffer more economic and emotional Regression than a man. The reasons are manifold. Firstly, many... “Downward...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Public-Private Partnership

..., moreover, there is no ‘stopping’ point, it is novel, any apparent ‘solution’ often generates other ‘problems,’ and there is no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ answer, but there are better or worse alternatives. Wicked problems within public-private partnership are characterized as recurrent or persistent problems, often defined by indecision and conflict over interests or purposes that could influence the process of decision-making (Hodge & Greve 2005). According to Grint (2005), there are no simple solutions to these wicked problems confronted by PPP. Remarkable progress can be achieved in mitigating them, but they will not be totally eradicated. But the question is, why are PPP...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Private and public school

...Private and Public Schools Debate Introduction Education has become a significant but also complex topic of debate in the modern context with parents and guardians seeking to give the best education to their children. The statistics given by the Institute of Education Sciences, IES observes that since 1929, there has been a decrease in the number of public schools as private schools increase rapidly. Contrary to the postulate that private schools are better than public schools, public schools have been ranked better with regards to economic and academic impact. The first advantage of being in a public...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Private and Public Schools

...Private and Public Schools: The differences and Ultimate Goal A substantial part of a human life is attached to an important place that is called school. Parents try to send their children to the best possible school. The understanding best school is associated mainly with good education, and social atmosphere. A good education provides a foundation for acquiring cognitive intelligence, and a good social atmosphere develops an intellectual individual. The idea of best school has developed two types of schooling; they are termed as “Private school” and “Public school”. One group of people think that private schools deliver the best result while the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Public & Private enterprise

...Public and Private Enterprise Public and Private Enterprise Section One Question One The economic theory which is applicable in the country is the theory of welfare economic. This theory is applicable to the country, because it focuses on how to improve social welfare in a country. The theory analysis different issues like public policy design, government failure and market failure and public finance. This theory is used as a tool in a country to improve social welfare and it will help in improving the welfare of the people (Kelly, 2007). Question Two In today’s economy there is clear distinction of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions for FREE!

Contact Us