Military intelligence ethicist - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
An action is deemed good, or morally right, when the outcome is good, and deemed bad or wrong when the outcome is bad. In the given scenario, the person in charge is faced with a…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Military intelligence ethicist
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Military intelligence ethicist"

A consequentialist ethics is one that holds the outcome of an action as the standard of value. An action is deemed good, or morally right, when the outcome is good, and deemed bad or wrong when the outcome is bad. In the given scenario, the person in charge is faced with a dilemma and is stuck between two options that vary in their desirableness depending solely on the ethical theory one subscribes to.
In the given hypothetical dilemma, the commander has three options. The consequentialist would urge the commander to commit the action that will lead to the least suffering or loss of life. The first solution, of taking no action, will leave tribal warfare unchecked and rampant in the area. Without a reason to stop, the warlords will continue raising armies, hording needed supplies, and violating international law. The second solution, of extensive intervention, leaves open the possibility of all-out warring between Americans and Kapawa fighters, with untold devastation on civilian populations. The third solution, a middle ground, will commit a small contingent of American troops to fighting the violence. However, this third option may do nothing more than put American forces in harm’s way for a mission that may end up being too small to be of great effectiveness.
From the consequentialist point of view, the third option of engaging in limited strikes is out of the question, insofar as it does not solve the underlying problem of warlords. The problem in the case of Kapawa is institutional, not merely an armed conflict. There are deep political and ethnographic problems in the state, which cannot be resolved by a minimal engagement on the part of American soldiers. Deciding from there, the consequentialist looks at the first option: to take no action. Although this option saves the lives of American soldiers, the loss of Kapawa life and infrastructure may be far too great of a cost. If the commander leaves the Kapawa people to deal with warlords by themselves, people will continue to die from the fighting and the resulting famine. Although help can be delivered from non-governmental entities, the underlying problem remains
Logically, the second option, of full-scale intervention, makes the most sense. It eliminates the institutional and political problems affecting the Kapawa people. It gives American the opportunity to establish a stable and functioning government, and settles disputes between the warring tribes. It reestablishes the opportunity for the fair distribution of resources inside the country and ultimately saves the most Kapawa civilian life. Although there is the problem of American casualties in a full-scale intervention, this cost is outweighed by the continuance of civil warring in the Kapawa country. With superior technology and weaponry, American military forces are capable of efficiently defeating the enemy, whereas a clan warfare situation in Kapawa presents the possibility of a long, drawn-out war of attrition.
The categorical imperative of a deontological ethics may bring us to a different conclusion in the case. For instance, the imperative that it is wrong to kill another human being may be respected in the form of no intervention, in which case the commander is not authorizing the murder of other human beings and thus abiding by the categorical imperative. This represents a classical gulf between the consequentialist and deontological ethics: that of intentionality. So long as it is not the commander’s intention to take the lives of other people, the action is commendable in some fashion to the deontologist. Nevertheless, if the commander does not take action, and there are far more Kapawa civilian casualties than there would have been, the two moral doctrines disagree on whether this was appropriate. The first option of nonintervention does not discount the possibility of helping afflicted individuals, which answers the need of some in the region. The second option of extensive intervention violates the categorical imperative not to kill others, but satisfies the consequentialist’s criteria of what the ideal option would be. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Military intelligence ethicist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Military intelligence ethicist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Military Intelligence Ethicist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Military Intelligence Ethicist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Military Intelligence Ethicist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Military intelligence ethicist

Intelligence uses at Abu Ghraib Military prison

...?Revisiting Abu Ghraib: HUMINT and Counterintelligence Deployed in the Global War Against Terror Human Intelligence (HUMINT) and counterintelligence constitute an integral aspect of military intelligence. It consists of a set of techniques and strategies designed to extract information from human sources that would aid in the fulfillment of the objectives of the military. It has been used throughout history in the interrogation of human prisoners from the opposite warring state. The Geneva Conventions and its protocols, as well as the Convention Against Torture, provided the safety mechanisms to ensure that no prisoners would be abused or subjected to torture. In 2004,...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Military leadership

...? Military Leadership Military Leadership “In the absence of inspired military leadership... the more powerful side wears down the weaker- Bevin Alexander”(Military leadership quotes, n. d). An intelligent military leader can gain victory over enemies even with limited resources whereas an idiotic military leader suffers defeat even if he has access to enough resources. In other words, military leadership is all about judicious usage of the existing resources like manpower and weapons. The military leader should have insights not only about their own capabilities but also about the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Book Critiques - British Military Intelligence in the Palestine Campaign

...?Describing the secretive nature of British Intelligence and its inaccessibility to research scholars until 1970s, this book discusses the level of success that British military attained in Palestine in its campaigns in the First World War, in terms of the efficiency of British military intelligence.1 Owing to reasons discussed above, it was nearly an impossible task for the author to collect all the documents concerned with British military intelligence of that period, and hence the author himself has admitted that his work could not be taken as a conclusive work on the topic2. But still it is hoped in the preface to the book that this...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review


...Intelligence Intelligence can be visualised from umpteen aspects. "From the perspective of the casual observer, intelligence is the capability to act intelligently when dealing with everyday life. If envisaged from an adult's eyes, intelligence is a specific measurement of their ability to learn. While not actually knowing their IQ scores, many adults have vague recollections of being labeled as an 'average,' 'above average,' or 'below-average' student". (2006a) According to Wechsler David, "Intelligence is the aggregate or global capacity of the individual to act purposefully, to think rationally and to deal effectively with his environment". (Wechsler, 1944, p.4) Intelligence is considered to be global as it characterises... the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Intelligence Task: Definition Intelligence is one’s ability or skills of analyzing, comprehending and explaining a situation. In other words, one’s intelligence can be defined as his/her ability of mastering and expressing social-construction concepts. Cultural frame influences my definition of the term intelligence because cultural concepts inform my assessment criteria. My culture guides me on which ideas or ability to associate with intelligence. This indicates that I value the concepts that my culture values and disregard the ones considered that are less significant to my culture. The concept of intelligence under different cultural...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...Explain why you think the United s still needs the capability to conduct amphibious operations. An Amphibious operation is one where the attack is launched from the sea or ocean by deploying the power of the navy and the landing forces on the hostile areas (Speller and Christopher, 2001). The U.S Military has a very significant history when it comes to amphibious operations, especially during the Second World War The Military has a strong force trained and deployed for the amphibious operations, in the even that any need arises. While the amphibious operations provide a definite advantage to the U.S military in terms of equipping it with unique and advanced capabilities, the need of an...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...Intelligence al Affiliation) Intelligence At the legislative level, there are things that should be done as an emergency. For instance, after the affair of Iran-Contra there was a ploy in renewing the interest in finding out the independent inspector at CIA according to their constitution. In1976, the committee of the church highlighted the CIA office to be having problems in identifying potential information, accessing information, and finding the personnel of high quality. This lacked the permission to offer assistance to the committees of congressional oversight. There is no reason in believing that the Inspector General is not trustworthy than other officials of the agency in handling information. ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Ethics of Spying - Intelligence

...Intelligence Intelligence The Permanent Secretary of Defence in the of the 104TH Congress created the Intelligence Community of the twenty-first century, commonly known as IC21. The primary reason the community was created was to reorganize the intelligence operations of the United States, notably that most of its intelligence activities had been largely and perhaps shaped by the cold war struggles with the then Soviet Union. The main recommendation put forward by IC21, was the ideology of centralizing all the intelligence organs within the United States. This recommendation was majorly to be effected by the CIA, as well as the DCI, as...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...INTELLIGENCE OF THE OF INTELLIGENCE 1Non actors (NSA) are influencethat affect or trigger in international relations. They are organizations with enough power and cannot be ignored any also do not belong to any legal institution of a state (Weiiss 2013). It is not possible to address The NSA as unitarily because some of them affect more than one country or even different regions. They muscle enough power to do this and if not worked together will only propel them to grow fast. They are disastrous to the government and if not handled carefully in a professional manner. Some of the NSA is small and if carefully managed from the top can be easily handled. Others grow due to a particular issue like lack of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

National versus Military Intelligence

...National Versus Military Intelligence Introduction Intelligence, whether national or military is a discipline that uses various information collection and analysis approaches to provide direction and guidance that supports decision-making. Numerous sources of information provide legal, management and technical insights for national and military intelligence with their interest being on analysis. The sources include studies in intelligence, international journal of intelligence and counter intelligence, intelligence and national security, defense...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Military intelligence ethicist for FREE!

Contact Us