StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete" discusses that the courts concede the presence of consideration if one of the parties exceeds what is required of him, according to normal contractual duty. In Ward v. Byham, the mother of an illegitimate child went beyond her legal duty…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete"

Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete? At present consideration has been reduced to a mere technical condition of the law, which is unrelated to equitability or fairness in implementing a promise. This change in attitude towards the notion of consideration has transpired over a period of time. Effectively, consideration has been transformed from constituting a cause for enforcing a promise to a technical dogma that has minimal or no bearing on either the fairness of or advantage in carrying out an assurance, or acknowledging a commitment. Consequently, there exists the possibility of enforcing a promise that lacks consideration, whilst it is also possible that even in the presence of consideration a promise may not be enforceable1. The extant practice of the courts is to reject a transaction even if there is consideration for the promise; if it is illegal in nature. Furthermore, it has become accepted practice to refuse enforcement of a promise, for the reason that it had not been the objective of the promisor to create any legal association by that promise. As such, consideration is no longer perceived to be a concise term that indicates the presence or absence of justification for enforcing a promise2. Albeit, consensus demands unconditional acceptance of an offer, consideration is also required, if a valid contract is to come into existence. Consideration is related to various legal concepts and provisions. A mere inclusion of consideration in the contract is insufficient to make it valid. Consideration should be either in a monetary form or in a form that can be estimated monetarily. A promise that lacks consideration is not capable of being legally enforced3. In general, the provision of goods or services constitutes the consideration on account of one of the parties to the contract. The other party pays money for these goods or services. Agency law terms such financial consideration as commission. Such consideration is known as price in sale of goods; receipt of wages or salary by employees in employment contracts; freight in the carriage of goods; and premiums in insurance contracts4. In Collins v Godefroy, the Court found that the defendant was duty bound to execute a promise. Therefore, the court held that good consideration was absent5. As such, persons, who are under a legal obligation to perform some duty, need not be provided with consideration, in order to perform the same. This is due to the reason that they are legally bound to complete the duty. Thus, anyone who is under a legal obligation to do something cannot make a good consideration by merely completing it. Performing a duty beyond a person’s legal obligation can constitute good consideration. This principle was established in Glasbrook v Glamorgan County Council. In this case, the court held that good consideration could be provided by persons whose actions had been in excess of what was required by their public duty6. Execution of contractual duties does not provide consideration for any new promise. However, the law provides for two exceptions to this principle. First, if the promisee agrees to or executes more than what is demanded of him by the contractual duties, he can claim such additional performance as consideration for a new promise7. Second, promisee can enforce a fresh promise by the promisor, if he had previously refused to execute his contractual duty, on account of unanticipated circumstances8. The courts attitude towards consideration in different situations has been discussed in the sequel. In Hyundai Heavy Industries Co Ltd v Papapoulos a ship building contract had failed before delivery, the House of Lords ruled that it could not be construed that there had been a total failure of consideration9. On the other hand, if the contract had entailed a sale, then there would have been a failure of consideration10. Past consideration has been deemed to be legally invalid, and this principle was established in the case of Eastwood v Kenyon11. Nevertheless, in the Pau On v. Lau Yiu Long case, the court ruled that past consideration could be considered as a valid consideration. Thus, in some situations, past consideration constitutes good consideration12. Williams v Roffey was a landmark case in the area of consideration. In that case the Court of Appeal held that if a party to an existing contract offered extra payment to the other party, in order to ensure the proper execution of contractual obligations; then the agreement would be binding, if the offering party received some new practical advantage. The agreement is also held to be binding, if there is a consequent avoidance of disadvantage13.The decision in Williams v. Roffey does away with the fundamental requirement of consideration, if there is a modification of the contract. This ruling upheld the commercial interests of the parties to a contract. In Tool Metal Manufacturing Co Ltd v Tungsten Electric Co Ltd, the patent owners promised the plaintiffs that they would suspend payment of periodic compensation, during the wartime, from the manufacturers. The House of Lords held that the promise of the defendants was binding on them during wartime. However, the patent owners could subsequently return to what was due to them under the law, after issuing suitable notice to the other party. As such, the owners did not cease to be eligible to receive these payments14. In CTN Cash and Carry Ltd v Gallaher Ltd, one of the parties had promised additional payment to the other party. This additional payment resulted in practical benefit to the promisor. The court held that this practical benefit was the consideration received by the promisor for the additional payment made by him15. The Court of Appeal in the Selectmove Ltd case, held that an offer, in respect of a particular contractual agreement could not constitute consideration for some other agreement16. In Hartley v Ponsonby, the court held that the additional payment offered by the defendant was the consideration to the remaining sailors to sail the ship home; subsequent to a large number of desertions among the crew17. The courts concede the presence of consideration if one of the parties exceeds what is required of him, according to normal contractual duty. In Ward v. Byham, the mother of an illegitimate child went beyond her legal duty. The court opined that parents had to necessarily provide adequate care to their child. However, the court ruled that she had gone beyond her legal duty to ensure the happiness and welfare of her child. Consequently, the court ruled that the father of that child had to bear the necessary expenditure to nurture the child18. As such, the concept of consideration, which was hither to fore, an important element of a contract, has been transformed drastically, by the case law. Over a period of time the decisions of the courts reveals that the courts have ignored the principle of consideration, if some practical benefit accrues to the offeror. For instance, even intangible benefits have been deemed to constitute consideration, under certain circumstances, like performing actions beyond one’s duty. Furthermore, consideration has been reduced to a mere legal technicality that has no bearing on the carrying out of an assurance. Consequently, the enforcement of an agreement does not depend on the presence or absence of consideration. Moreover, a promise could prove to be unenforceable, even if there were to be consideration, if the agreement were to be illegal. List of references Agreement not legally binding, The Times, January 13, 1994 from LexisNexis Academic Atiyah, P.S. Essays on Contract, (1990, OUP) CTN Cash and Carry Ltd v. Gallaher Ltd (1994) 4 All ER 714 Collins v Godefroy (1831) 1 B & Ad 850 Eastwood v Kenyon (1840) 11 A&E 438 Furnnston, Michael Philip, Sale and Supply of Goods, (2000, Routledge) Glasbrook Brothers v Glamorgan County Council (1925) AC 270 Hartley v. Ponsonby (1857) 7 E B 872 Hanson v Royden (1867) LR 3 CP 47 Ellis, Henry, Modern Irish Commercial and Consumer Law, (2004 Jordans) Hyundai Heavy Industries Co Ltd v Papapoulos (1980) 2 All ER 29 Pau On v Lau Yiu Long (1980) AC 614 (PC) Re Selectmove Ltd (1994) BCC 349 Tool Metal Manufacturing Co Ltd v Tungsten Electric Co Ltd (1955) 1WLR 761 Ward v Byham (1956) 1 WLR 496 Williams v Roffey Bros. and Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd (1991) 1 QB 1 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Consideration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Consideration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1551660-consideration
(Consideration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Consideration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1551660-consideration.
“Consideration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1551660-consideration.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Has the Concept of Consideration Become Obsolete

The Extent of Individual Freedom

In country like America, freedom of individuals has become more controversial and probably more intensely contested because of the diverse society and history of racial discrimination.... The informal social control, exerted by various social paradigms of the system within which individuals co-exist, become strong tenets of restrictions on personal freedom of the people.... Personal freedom is described as doing what one pleases without restrictions from government or anyone but within the broader precincts of ethical consideration....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

A Discussion of the Marketing Concept and the Implementation of those Concepts

Marketing invites the consumer, through exchange, to become a part of that culture through ownership.... Marketing and the Macro-Environment: A Discussion of the Marketing concept and the Implementation of those Concepts.... Conclusion 13 References 14 Marketing and the macro-environment: A discussion of the marketing concept and the implementation of those concepts.... The development of a macro-environment has meant that the field of marketing has had to expand its methods and beliefs as the meanings of consumerism have shifted to a global field of engagement....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Democracy and the foreigner

the concept of 'general will' introduced by Rousseau in this work immediately generated intensive debate in Europe.... The Athenian concept of 'citizenship' entailed taking a share in legislative and judicial functions, participating directly in the affairs of the state.... The 'general will' concept and other novel ideas expressed by Rousseau in the Social Contract probably played a pivotal role in setting the stage for deep political reforms and revolutions which occurred in France and other European countries in the subsequent decades....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Formalism, Modernism, and the Connection to Sociological Discussion

his article makes a conclusion that the formalist concept of art is defined by its need to see a representation from which meaning can be interpreted for a piece of art.... Formalism is the theory of art in which form is the primary concept through which the aesthetic value of a painting is judged.... Contemporary art has abandoned pure references to nature Contemporary art defies the nature of Modern periods in that it no longer concerns itself with form and the emotional intent of the artist, but begins to contract art so that it is all about form and is concerned with context rather than style....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Sustainable Development as a Global Concept

The first one is the concept of needs which especially covers the needs of the world's poor that needs to be prioritized.... Consequently, the concept of sustainable development should be perceived as an equitable and balanced development.... he concept of sustainable development has in its core the needs of human beings as opposed to those of other species, animals, or ecosystems.... Additionally, these strategies have to be ambitious, doable, and collaborative in addition to taking into consideration the uniqueness of each country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Theory of Philosophy

Also, the author describes why philosophy is not an absolute discipline but it is not an obsolete one either.... There are many in the 'hard' scientific communities that argue that philosophy is obsolete as a whole and has been essentially unchanged for 2000 years (Andersen 1).... Each of the philosophers mentioned has contributed greatly to the discussion of the human experience and remains relevant today....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Political Theory- John Locke, Second Treatise of Government

These concepts of consideration closely inter-relate to each other as it sounds impossible in some instances to mention one without the other.... It is also evident that other works of other authors influenced Locke's writing while he also influenced other authors many years later, with his concept of right to revolt mostly borrowed during the American Revolution.... The paper "Political Theory- John Locke, Second Treatise of Government" develops the assumption that forming his basis on a number of concepts, Locke successfully manages to cross-examine the different concepts under consideration that will ensure the formation of an effective government....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Cultural Relativism Theory Critique

Thus, universality is created by the concept of changes within various societies that cause their beliefs and practices to converge to similar actions or morals.... The basis of this theory is from the concept that judgments about right or wrong are a subject of a given society.... This, thus, creates the concept that morality behind various cultural practices is only challenged within that culture.... Hence, ethical concerns become subjects of relativity to their respective cultural backgrounds....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us