StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition" discusses The rational expectations theory that is the basis for the policy ineffectiveness proposition, the rational expectations theory states that the optimal forecast be used to predict the future but this does not take the human judgments…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition"

1. Policy ineffectiveness proposition was proposed by Thomas J Sargent in 1976 and this theory is based upon the rational expectations theory. The rational expectations theory is the basis for the policy ineffectiveness proposition, the rational expectations theory states that the optimal forecast be used to predict the future but this does not take the human judgments into consideration and assumes that humans do not make mistakes which are systematic this theory is in stark contrast with previous economic theories which were actually based on the adaptive expectations theory which says that people form their expectations of the future from what ever has happened in the past for example if inflation rates have been high in the past the people would revise their expectations of the inflation rates in the future because this is what has happened in the past and people would naturally behave in this manner because if this is what has happened in the past then people will expect it to happen in the future as well. By rational expectations it is meant that the government cannot then influence the output of the country because when the government tries to influence the output through monetary expansion then if the rational expectations theory is applied agents would recognize the effects of such a policy before hand and hence would revise their own policy regarding price and wages upwards hence when this takes place the wages and price remain constant and hence also the out put. There have been many criticisms to the theory but the fact remains that this was a pretty acceptable theory in view of the adaptive expectations and rational expectations theory this theory has been a sort of a comparison between the two but never the less his has resulted in to a theory that stands on its own and challenges the integrity and the worth of the some of the oldest and the most well known theories of the macroeconomic sphere. This theory has also come under severe criticism because it has challenged the integrity of macroeconomic theories in general, the most formidable criticism came from Fischer who pointed out that when employees are engaged they are made to sign a contract which then means that they have agreed to work on a pay for a certain amount of time hence making wages sticky, so if the government does decide to influence the output then it would be able to do so because of the sticky wages concept.. another criticism of the theory came from Sanford who pointed out that although the economic agents do have the resources and the mental ability to sort out government policies and then react to it but that is highly unlikely because when they act upon the information that they have gathered then others would follow suit and gain from their actions which is not desirable because every one gains from some one else’s costs. These arguments have made the policy ineffectiveness proposition lose its weight amongst other economic theories. 2. The new Keynesian framework or the new classical monetarist draw upon the classical assumption that price and wage are inherently flexible in nature, this means that the wages and price simply change to adjust to the demand and supply of a product or an industry. Secondly, the new Keynesian framework assumptions draw upon the modern developments in the field of statistics and human behavior. They expect every human to have knowledge about the economy and what the government is trying to do so that no body can be fooled into thinking that the government is doing all that it can to better off the state of the economy when that is not the case or the government announces some policies and then does not pursue them, then the people should know by their own knowledge what the government is in effect actually trying to do. It also assumes that the people and the government have the same amount of information available to them so when the government acts the people would know on what information it is taking action and hence they can take rational decisions. The Keynesians or the new Keynesians also believe that much of the unemployment in an economy is voluntary because people do not want to work and there are various theories supporting this claim, the best one being the misperceptions and the illusory Philips curve. The new Keynesians also have their own way on the fiscal policy known as the ‘Ricardian view of fiscal policy’ which implies that the changes in taxes do not have any effect on the amount of the spending or on the spending level. If the economy is such conditions experiences a demand shock then the first thing to happen would be that the firms will want to produce much more and hence they will want to employ more and more people, if the unemployment is voluntary then these people might not be willing to work at very high wages as well because they have decided to take this time off and would have some definite plans for the whole time off and high wages might not draw every one into working at once so the supply side might not be able to cope up with the demand shock because of the shortage of the skilled labor. As aggregate demand increases the price levels in the economy would over all go up according to the ASAD framework, this would lead to people demanding more money and hence the demand for money increases manifolds, this would lead to higher interest rates according to the ASAD framework . This would lead to the prices going up and since every one in the economy has perfect knowledge firms will tend to raise wages even further and at this point according to the misperceptions theory people would be confused about their status as employees because they would think that their real wage has risen and hence more and more people would tend to drop down from the production lines or the services departments because they feel they are better off and they need a vacation or they need to take a break from their work for the time being this leads to further problems for the firms and also the government because they then need to cope up with this added burden. References 1. nordhaus, samuelson (1997). Economics. Mcgraw Hill Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Q1. Explain in detail the analytical justification for the 'policy Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1541592-q1-explain-in-detail-the-analytical-justification-for-the-policy-ineffectiveness-proposition-q2-explain-the-response-of-an-economy-to-an-adverse-demand-shock-in-a-new-keynesian-framework-with-normal-rigidities
(Q1. Explain in Detail the Analytical Justification for the 'Policy Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1541592-q1-explain-in-detail-the-analytical-justification-for-the-policy-ineffectiveness-proposition-q2-explain-the-response-of-an-economy-to-an-adverse-demand-shock-in-a-new-keynesian-framework-with-normal-rigidities.
“Q1. Explain in Detail the Analytical Justification for the 'Policy Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1541592-q1-explain-in-detail-the-analytical-justification-for-the-policy-ineffectiveness-proposition-q2-explain-the-response-of-an-economy-to-an-adverse-demand-shock-in-a-new-keynesian-framework-with-normal-rigidities.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition

Gun control

The first proposition draws its strength primarily from the premise that there is no such basic right as to own a gun.... The proposition is further supported by the claim that self-defense by way of gun use is counterproductive, since some studies seemed to show that domestic violence is in fact increased as a result of the presence of firearms.... The second proposition takes its strength from the premise that there is a fundamental right to own a gun, as stated in the Second Amendment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Powers to Lead

Smiled argued that despite all of this, 'A clear majority is satisfied with a government they feel works on their behalf, but given recent election results, and some disturbing trends in Chavez's policies, such a proposition is increasingly difficult to support.... This paper ''The Powers to Lead'' tells us that it is worth beginning by outlining the main conclusions of Nye's analysis of what makes a good leader and exploring the focus of this paper – what makes an effective leader....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Evaluation of Deterrence Theory

In this technique, the theory is evaluated using its scope, logical consistency, parsimony, testability, empirical validity, and its usefulness and policy implication.... The author evaluates deterrence theory to find out whether it can be regarded as a good criminology theory.... There are various ways in which a scientific theory can be evaluated....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Wage and Price Rigidity or Stickiness

In order to explain and critically assess the statement "A degree of wage and/or price rigidity or stickiness is a way to overcome the implications of the Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition (Sargent and Wallace1976) for demand-side stabilisation policies", we should first understand the full meaning of Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition for demand-side stabilisation policies as explained by Thomas Sargent and Neil Wallace. ... he Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition (PIP) is the idea in new classical economics that rational expectations implies that government policy can have no impact on real economic variables....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Stanley Fischer's model

Stanley Fischer's model of multi-period contracts (1977) is a way to overcome the implications of the Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition (Sargent and Wallace1976),re-establishing the desirability of demand-side stabilisation policies.... In order to explain this statement and critically assess its significance, we should first understand the full meaning of Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition for demand-side stabilisation policies as explained by Thomas Sargent and Neil Wallace. ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Barbara Jordans Use of Ethical Appeals

he first is the proposition of fact, which deals with alleged facts which are debatable or inconclusive.... he second is the proposition of value, which treats on the morality, rightness, merit or worth of an idea or an action.... he third is the proposition of policy, which encourages an audience to agree with an idea or to take an action.... An example of this type of proposition is: “Millionaires who lost their jobs in the recent recession should not be allowed to claim welfare....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Effectiveness of Community Policing

Community policing as a policy was established to eliminate crime by closing the gap between the British police force and the public.... This paper discusses the effectiveness of community policing in combating crime and the challenges facing the policy.... In addition, the policy has increased the public power to deal with criminals which has led to an increase in cases of social and mob justice....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Heuristic versus Systematic Processing of Online Privacy Policy

This research paper "Heuristic versus Systematic Processing of Online Privacy policy" presents how and why individuals mindlessly respond to a privacy policy provided by online media.... As it turns out, familiarity plays a powerful role in determining Internet user's acceptance of privacy policy.... Finally, information perceivers' adoption of heuristic processing leads to acceptance of privacy policy.... In our study, information evaluation refers to an individual's acceptance of privacy policy provided by online media....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us