StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Restorative Justice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Restorative Justice" discusses that a study of William Nugent et. al. (Summer, 1999) on 1298 juveniles showed that throughout the late 1980s and 1990s there is a 32% reduction in recidivism among offenders who have undergone comparison group…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Restorative Justice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Restorative Justice"

Restorative Justice During the 8th UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, it was reported that country after country suffers burgeoning prisons and an absolute failure in reducing crime. The Congress that preceded it recommended an “increase in non-custodial measure, to reduce both the use of detention and the prison population” and the “use of alternatives to imprisonment for offenders.” (United, 1995) From all corners of the globe – from rich to poor countries - it is apparent that even with gravest penalty imposed – lifetime incarceration, capital punishment in all its versions – haven’t made any progress in curbing criminality. Punishment and penal institutions, which, ideally, should be the answer to this malady, seem to produce an angrier, undesirable convicts more likely to become recidivists. Judicial systems and policy makers are, thus, under public pressure to find alternatives to traditional justice systems. Ruth Morris (1994) explains that a shift to alternative models is practical because, first, it is expensive to maintain prisons and finally, incarceration and punishment is unjust and immoral. “Our retributive justice system is based on a spirit of revenge which does not satisfy the primary healthy needs of victims, offenders, or society.” (Morris, 1994) One of the emergent alternatives to traditional justice systems is the restorative justice model. Currently, it is being integrated and used in criminal justice systems of some countries like the United Kingdom. Restorative justice, according to Les Davey, Director Real Justice United Kingdom and Ireland (March 2005), are the processes that respond to crime and wrongdoing by involving victims, offenders and their communities of care, that is, their family and friends. “Restorative Justice centers around hearing what harm a crime has caused, and finding the best way to address that harm.” (Mediation) Paul McCold, et. al. (May, 1998) coined the words “full restorative” if all the participants are involved in the process, “mostly restorative” if there are two stakeholders and “partly restorative” if there is only one party involved. “Restorative justice sometimes happens in the context of a courtroom, and sometimes within a community or nonprofit organization. In the courtroom, the process might look like this: For petty or first-time offenses, a case may be referred to restorative justice as a pretrial diversion, with charges being dismissed after fulfillment of the restitution agreement. In more serious cases, restorative justice may be part of a sentence that includes prison time or other punishments.” (“Restorative”) At present, there are three main models of Restorative Justice being practiced in the UK. They are: victim-offender mediation, family group conferencing and restorative conferencing. (“Restorative”) Mediation “While considerable variation exists with respect to program goals, pedigree, and their appropriate location within the criminal justice system, the common element is a direct voluntary encounter between crime victim and offender.” (Gehm, 1998) This process of mediation is usually in the presence of a trained mediator and is often the only option available to an incarcerated offender. “ There are Home Office sponsored victim-offender mediation projects which revealed that majority of the victims offered the chance of meeting their offender would like to do so and the great majority looked backed on the experience as worthwhile. (Davey, 2005) Family Group Conferencing There are more participants in this model than the victim-offender mediation. Participants may include the victim’s and the offender’s family, friends and others which are connected to the primary participants. “Family Group Conferences (FGCs) are a decision-making forum on what should happen in the future in relation to any number of issues.” (Models) Restorative Conferencing Restorative Conferencing seeks to resolve violations of community expectations in a manner that satisfactorily meets the needs of all parties affected by an incident through a facilitated “conference”. This model often uses a script to encourage group interaction to achieve a set of objectives. Victimology In restorative justice, there is a special attention given to the victim. First, it is because the victim is a main participant in the criminal incident. The German criminologist Hans Von Hentig (1979) was the first to raise this point. He stressed that victims are classified according to the nature of their involvement in the criminal act. This aspect of restorative justice seeks to explain how the victim’s role can mitigate or precipitate crimes. To illustrate: the British Crime Survey (2000) Statistics, stated that “since 1993 the number of burglaries has fallen. The fall is likely to be partly due to the increased use by households of home security measures, such as window locks, security lights and burglar alarms.” The victim’s role in crime prevention is, thus, highlighted. Finally, victims and their pain in restorative justice are given primary concern. Through the years, a systematic way was developed to address the trauma that a victim and those related to him suffered. Creative approaches are introduced in such a way that accountability, restoration, and reintegration are achieved by means of reconciliation. Setbacks There are cases when restorative justice cannot be applied. One of them is when a victim refuses to participate. The victim’s input is important in each stage of the restorative justice process. Hence, the effectiveness of the entire process is diminished. Apparently, there are frustrated victims who have made strong statements that there can be no reconciliation without justice. (Maepa, 2005) Also, restorative justice cannot be applied when an offender denies responsibility or shows no remorse. Some critics argue that the government handles a big chunk of reparation to the victims and, so, restorative justice is severely wanting in terms of meting out the offender’s accountability. It is said that the offender could get away with barely an apology. Does Restorative Justice Work? Time and time again, it was proven that restorative justice program yield reductions on recidivism in comparison to non-restorative approaches to criminal behavior. A study of William Nugent et. al. (Summer, 1999) on 1298 juveniles showed that throughout the late 1980s and 1990s there is a 32% reduction in recidivism among offenders who have undergone comparison group. If we are to evaluate the aims and objectives of restorative justice, we can safely say that it indeed works. What’s more important in this model is that it seeks to restore what must have been damaged during the criminal incident. It does not merely try to retrieve justice but seek the holistic healing not just in the person of the victim but of the offender as well. References Davey, Les. (2005). The development of restorative justice in the United Kingdom: A Personal Perspective. Retrieved March 31, 2006, from http://www.realjustice.org/library/au05_davey.html Gehm, John R. (1998). Victim-Offender Mediation Programs: An Exploration of Practice and Theoretical Frameworks. Retrieved March 31, 2006, from http://wcr.sonoma.edu/v1n1/gehm.html Hales, Jon, Henderson, Lynne, Collins, Debbie and Becher Harriet. (2000). British crime survey. National Centre for Social Research. Appendix A Maepa, Traggy. (February 2005),Part 2: restorative justice in practice, Retrieved March 31, 2006, from http://www.iss.co.za/pubs/Monographs/No111/Chap6.htm McCold, Paul & Wachtel, Benjamin (May, 1998) Restorative Policing Experiment. Community Service Foundation, PA Mediation UK. (n.d.). Restorative justice. Retrieved March 31, 2006, from http://www.mediationuk.org.uk/template.asp?lv=2&MenuItemID=48&MenuID=1 Models of Restorative Justice, Retrieved March 30, 2006, from http://www.mediationuk.org.uk/template.asp?lv=0&MenuItemID=106&MenuID=1&PageID=2 Morris, Ruth. (1994). A practical path to transformative justice. Retrieved March 29, 2006, from http://www.rittenhousecanada.org/info/practicalpathtotj.html Nugent, William R., Umbreit, Mark S., Wiinamaki, Lizabeth, & Paddock, Jeff. (Summer, 1999). Voma Connections, New Smyrna Beach, Florida Restorative Justice. (n.d.). Wikipedia, Retrieved March 31, 2006, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restorative_justice) United Nations. (1995). United nations congress on the prevention of crime and the treatment of offenders. Cairo, Egypt Von Hentig, Hans. (1979). The criminal and his victim. Schocken Books Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, Essay”, n.d.)
CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536422-criminal-behaviour-restorative-justice-victim-offender-mediation-positive-impact-consideration-of-victims-in-cjs-negative-impact-does-restorative-justic
(CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, Essay)
CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536422-criminal-behaviour-restorative-justice-victim-offender-mediation-positive-impact-consideration-of-victims-in-cjs-negative-impact-does-restorative-justic.
“CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE VICTIM OFFENDER MEDIATION, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536422-criminal-behaviour-restorative-justice-victim-offender-mediation-positive-impact-consideration-of-victims-in-cjs-negative-impact-does-restorative-justic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Restorative Justice

Does Restorative Justice Prevent Crime

Does Restorative Justice prevent crime?... Restorative Justice is defined as a theory of justice which focuses on “repairing the harm caused or revealed by criminal behaviour”.... This justice process is said to be accomplished in a best way with the help of cooperative processes that incorporate all stakeholders (What is Restorative Justice?... According to Rogers and Robinson (2004), “Since Nils Christie's classic 1976 article ‘Conflict as Property', there has been widespread interest in the potential of ‘Restorative Justice' programmes – programmes that seek to give victims and the public a larger role in the criminal justice processes by bringing victims, offenders and their associates together” (Rogers and Robinson, 2004: p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Restorative Justice Process

Restorative Justice basically approaches the realization of justice by focusing on the needs of various stakeholders, chiefly the offender(s), victim(s) and community members as opposed to punishing the offender(s) as is commonly the case with legal proceedings (Morris &.... This paper will analyze the process of Restorative Justice. ... he process of Restorative Justice as applied in the case of David, Ed, and Mildred encompasses several processes....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Restorative justice canada

The Restorative Justice system in Canada is an alternative to the criminal justice system, which focuses more on punishing the offender, as opposed to establishing a truce between the victim and the offender2.... Under the system of Restorative Justice, Restorative Justice Canada The principle of Restorative Justice in Canada focuses on the needs of the offenders and those of the victims.... The Restorative Justice system in Canada is an alternative to the criminal justice system, which focuses more on punishing the offender, as opposed to establishing a truce between the victim and the offender2....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Restorative Justice in United Kingdom

The paper will discuss how Restorative Justice is in use in the Youth Justice Board in prisons and in the issuing of dispersal orders and will consider the use of Restorative Justice in Northern Ireland.... In the United Kingdom, Restorative Justice relies on programs such as victim-offender mediation, conferencing, victim assistance, community service, ex-offender assistance, and restitution.... Restorative Justice programs also promote the inclusion of ex-offenders in community projects....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Victims, Victimology and Restorative Justice

This essay analyzes how the study of victimization has affected the manner in which the youth today is provided justice.... In this regard, the paper also tries to focus on the services that are provided to the youth to make them more powerful as far as contemporary youth justice is concerned.... As Walklate (1991) relates, this is done in order to determine the effectiveness of the surveys for the purpose of the deduction of its implications on the providing of justice to young individuals....
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper

Crime Prevention and Restorative Justice

The author states that opportunity reduction or increased surveillance limits the number of criminal activity, but hardly anything to lessen the number of potential criminals.... All too regularly, the outcome of this neglect may less the reduction of overall crime rates than temporal disarticulation....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Concept of Restorative Justice

As the author of the paper "The Concept of Restorative Justice" outlines, Restorative Justice examines the issues for why legal punishment is necessary to restore justice to society and keep some form of social control over the many communities in the UK.... There are many judicial theories behind the reasoning for the necessity of penal punishment against criminal offenders with Restorative Justice being one of the newest models in the legal system....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Restorative Justice or Criminal Justice

This paper "Restorative Justice or Criminal Justice" argues that neither the use of any of these approaches in GBV guarantees absolute success, but their application to GBV should be determined by the circumstances surrounding a particular case.... Is Restorative Justice or a criminal justice response more appropriate in cases of gender-based violence?... The traditional criminal justice approach and Restorative Justice approaches have been both found to be inadequate in dealing with the issue of GBV as they are both flawed....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us