Nobody downloaded yet

Humes Moral Judgement Theory - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Hume claims that our moral judgments about the actions of others do not express beliefs, but rather certain subjective emotional reactions to those actions. Summarise Hume's argument for this conclusion.
Hume claims that our moral judgments of the actions of others are based upon our own feelings, desires, and attitudes…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Humes Moral Judgement Theory
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Humes Moral Judgement Theory"

Download file to see previous pages The nonpropositional interpretation of Hume's claim states that moral judgement does not express truth or fact, it is merely the expression of a feeling or a feeling itself. The subjective description on the other hand, takes the view of the spectator's moral evaluation simply being the contemplation of the common point of view.
The dispositional interpretation understands moral judgements about good and evil have a motivational influence on our actions. Hume also states that moral evaluation involves the spectator's feelings in relation to witnessing the agent's act. Since these feelings are involved, then moral judgment must be subjective. In terms of dispositional interpretation, the agent's action can cause the spectator to either approve or disapprove. For instance, if a character trait is in accordance with the spectator, it will elicit feelings of approval. Moral judgments are subjective because they are based on the feelings of the spectator, and spectators will either approve or disapprove of the agent's actions, and their judgment is the result of whether or not they identify the character of the agent as appropriate or not.
These brief explanations of Hume's moral judgement theory illustrate Hume's basic assumption that it is only feeling that generates action and feeling that labels any action as morally right or wrong, good or bad. This is based upon the perceptions of the spectator, rather than the motivations of the agent of the action.

While Hume asserts that moral judgements are based upon emotional motivations such as desire, he claims that moral judgements based upon the actions of others do not express beliefs. According to Hume, desires and beliefs are distinct, contradictory states. Desires are not rationally criticisable as they make no reference to truth or reason. A belief on the other hand, is merely a copy of an assessable truth. Here reason alone is motivationally inert and moral judgements cannot therefore be derived from reason.

Another aspect of moral judgment is moral sentiment. Sentiment is an emotion caused by thinking about the action to be evaluated without any level of self-interest. Examples of moral sentiment are approval (a pleasure) and disapproval (a pain). Consequently, people can differentiate which traits are virtuous or vicious. The use of emotions and feelings (especially approval and disapproval) towards traits leads to approval of actions. Hence, agreeable traits tend to cause feelings of approval; whereas disagreeable traits tend to create feelings of disapproval.

Moral judgment is also affected by sympathy. Hume believes that by observing a person's outward appearance, the spectator can comprehend the passion of the person's mind. When these characteristics resemble or are contiguous with their own, the spectator is more likely to experience sympathetic feelings of pleasure and enjoyment.

In conclusion, Hume asserts that people can take different roles in terms of being an agent, a receiver, or a spectator. Since people can observe their own actions and also sympathize with their moral sentiments, it is possible for significant actions to fall into more than one category. Likewise, I agree with Hume that moral approval is based on emotional responses. Human nature is not based on expressed beliefs but on moral judgments substantiated by feelings. Hume's opinions of moral beliefs were radical or even contentious to his own contemporaries in the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Humes Moral Judgement Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Humes Moral Judgement Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from
(Humes Moral Judgement Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Humes Moral Judgement Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words.
“Humes Moral Judgement Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Humes Moral Judgement Theory

Ethics -- Moral Theory and Moral Issue

...-adjusted life year.” (“Should,” 2012). British philosopher John Stuart Mill supports the moral aspect of euthanasia. A philosophical utilitarian, Mill supported the “Greatest Happiness” principle. Euthanasia satisfies the utilitarian perspective because it stops a persons suffering and affords them the choice to do with their life as they wish. Legalized euthanasia is a way to end life with the greatest happiness for a great number of patients. In the same vein, the Utilitarian Theory holds an assumption of living that includes pursuing happiness. Mill taught that there are two classes of pleasure: a person’s intellect reflects the higher class and their body the lower. When a patient has come to the end...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Philosophy - Moral Theory

...? Philosophy- Moral Theory Introduction Theories have been developed with time with an aim of expressing longtime thoughts and admiration of a phenomenon in order to convince society or a certain setting on the importance and relevance of the subject matter. Majority of theories are presented through generalized abstracts illustrating the theorist’s conclusion or view over particular phenomenon and/or estimated/ forecasted strategies of achieving and understanding the same phenomenon but on a broader perspective. In contextual and epistemological analysis, theories differ with hypotheses in that they provide explanatory framework for some observations which are a product of testing the hypotheses; designed to support or challenge... in that...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Moral Theory

...Moral Theory: Relativism In the United s the innocent kiss in the park by a young couple is looked uponas a cute display of endearment. Yet in India the practice is frowned on and can result in severe social sanctions. Prostitutes can openly display their wares and market their vocation in the Netherlands, but in the United States that same activity could result in a prison term. These cases are examples of a social group or culture making a moral judgment on behavior. Morality seems to shift like quicksand as we travel from our inner social circles to larger cultural groups and the interacting people of the world. It is often on a continuum that has no set boundaries...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Moral Theory of War

...You're Ethics 8 December 2005 Moral Theory of War Socially speaking, what morals can be substantiated in behind the reasoning for the war in Iraq If looking at the rationalization for war from an 'ethical egoism' type of moral view point, there is a definite cause to be found in the current war fare occurring in the Middle East. If war had not been declared on Iraq then who is to say what the long term interests of our country and other countries would be right now The moral judgment that was made to enter into this conflict was based upon what seemed ethically right and correct at that precise time. Though war can not be presumed as intrinsically...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Kantian Moral Theory

...Running Head: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF KANT'S MORAL THEORY Kantian Ethics: A Comparative Analysis of Kant's Moral Theory (Institution's Name) Kantian Ethics: A Comparative Analysis of Kant's Moral Theory Introduction This essay deals with the identification of any possible element of Kant's work in moral philosophy which can be used as a substantial theoretical source for the support of other theories of justification. Thus, it is necessary to compare Kant's views about moral judgements with each of the theorists discussed below, and identify the similarities...
20 Pages(5000 words)Book Report/Review

Moral Development Theory

...Moral Development Theory Moral Development Theory In one of the women’s prison in South America, Mary, who was one of the prisoners, suffered sex abuse from a prison warder named John. The abuse was accompanied with promises of a better life in prison; John physically abused Mary whenever she tried to resist his advances. This continued for several months, out of frustration she resolved to put an end to this abuse. Mary secretly sneaked a penknife into her cell for self-defense. When John attempted to rape her, she did not hesitate to use it; as a result, John was badly injured and hospitalized. John’s attack attracted a lot of media attention and Ronald, who was in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Humes Theory of Sense Impressions

...Hume’s Theory of Sense Impressions Hume’s arguments that we are merely a result of the sense impressions that we experience suggest that we do not really experience the world nor is there an existence of a self or a world out there since we cannot prove that there objects possessing primary qualities in existence (Passer et al 110). However there are a number of flaws that can be identified in this argument and as such prov e that there is indeed an existence of a “self” in reference to individuals and by default proving the existence of what he referred to as “a world out there”. The main basis of the argument against Hume’s theory is actually based on the pointers that he makes within the same theory. He states that we do... impressions...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Humes Dialogues

...Hume’s Dialogues In Hume’s dialogues, Cleanthes explains the existence of God by using cause and effect experience. He suggests that just as human beings are able to design certain things such as cars, clothes, buildings, etc; so did God create the universe. In this case, Cleanthes argues that because human beings are able to design such structures and objects, there should also be a supreme being – whom he called God, who created the universe in a similar way as human beings design objects. According to him, this shows that God who is the creator of the earth is similar to human beings. He asserts that fitting of means to ends throughout nature is similar to the manner in which human beings fit means to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Vallee vs. Birchwood Court of Appeal Judgment Facts of the Case The facts of this case are as follows. Wrodzimierz Bogusz arrived in the UK from Ukraine as a post-war immigrant and married in 1948, during which time he had one child named Cheryle Vallee prior to his divorce in 19581. Vallee grew up in foster care and her carers eventually adopted her when she was aged 13. Four years after his divorce, Mr Bogusz bought unregistered land in 2 Eldon Street in Reading. His daughter, Ms. Vallee was married to a French national, after which she moved to China and finally to France. Occasionally, she visits her father Mr Bogusz, especially during Christmas, who has become increasingly isolated and distrustful of everyone, living without... vs....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Kohlbergs Moral Stage Theory

...Kohlberg’s Moral Stage TheoryMoral Development, according to Kohlberg & Hersh (1977), does not merely envisage an increase in the “knowledge of cultural values” through which a person understands ethics but it also encompasses all the changes that occur in an individual’s “form or structure of thought” (p.54). This notion mainly emerges from the fact that culture varies in societies and hence study of the “cultural values” cannot inform on how individuals interact in their social environments or how they solve their problems in a social context (p.54). On the other hand, an examination of “developing structures” through which an individual makes moral judgments will enable us to understand moral development (p.54). I agree... with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Humes Moral Judgement Theory for FREE!

Contact Us