StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers. They have received no democratic seal of approval, Their amenability to judicial review is - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Can the President use "unconstitutional" authority in order to save the Constitution and constitutional democracy The answer should be understandable, but scholars and jurists have made the issue (and answer) more complex than it should be. Our saga about constitutional government refers to Ex parte Milligan, (1) Duncan v…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers. They have received no democratic seal of approval, Their amenability to judicial review is
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers. They have received no democratic seal of approval, Their amenability to judicial review is"

Download file to see previous pages In other words, the Constitution does not operate usually in abnormal times, and both the existence of a "wartime" constitution and the potential for "constitutional dictatorship" follow from that relevant fact. In spite of sporadic rhetoric, in contrast to statutes and decisions, very little has really changed in two centuries from the way presidents have invariably acted during a dire emergency. In answering Lincoln's question, raised in 1861, constitutional democracy can be very strong to keep up its own existence without undermining the liberties of the people it has been formed to protect. But the nation's political leadership must be so liable and at the same time be willing to stick to constitutional constraints.
Saying that, let me now spell out the content and issues that follow for discussion: 1) the president must possess emergency powers capable of operating in abnormal times; 2) prerogative powers innately belong to the president in his capacity as political head of the nation and definitive guardian of the Constitution; 3) the Bush administration is making many of the same mistakes in its war on terror as the Johnson and Nixon administrations made with regard to the earlier Vietnam misadventure; 4) Congress, while salvaging its capacity to work out real legislative supervision over the presidential use of war powers in 1973-76, finds itself reluctant or unable to say no to the President since September 11, 2001; 5) legislation enacted since the terrorist attack in New York and anywhere else has engorged not only the President's ability to take the nation into war but has revolutionized the whole concept of separation of powers/checks and balances; and 6) emergency/prerogative power must be used in a terrible emergency only, and when the initial emergency situation comes to an end so should the unregulated use of outstanding presidential power.
In Federalist No. 23, Alexander Hamilton, writing about the idea of crisis government and the need for indeterminate power in the national government, announced that the war powers "should exist without restraint, because it is impossible to anticipate or define the degree and variety of national emergencies, and the correspondent extent and variety of the means which may be indispensable to please them." (4) The period of civil war permanently transformed our understanding of the war powers. Lincoln's imaginative combining of the commander-in-chief, take care, and executive power clauses into a notion of presidential war power independent of legislative authority--where ends justified means--laid to rest the earlier, limited meaning of commander-in-chief. Lincoln's assertion of this independent, virtually unlimited war power, held together by Locke's "prerogative" theory, (5) was legitimized and sanctioned by the Supreme Court within two years. (6) This transformation set the stage for the modern presidential office, applied the notion of constitutional dictatorship in the United States, and began the development of the "wartime" constitution.
Earlier in the development of the Republic, generally that period from Abraham Lincoln to Franklin Roosevelt, presidents would act illegally and then depend upon Congress to ratify their actions after the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528872-there-is-no-place-in-a-modern-constitution-for-prerogative-powers-they-have-received-no-democratic-seal-of-approval-their-amenability-to-judicial-review-is
(There Is No Place in a Modern Constitution for Prerogative Powers Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528872-there-is-no-place-in-a-modern-constitution-for-prerogative-powers-they-have-received-no-democratic-seal-of-approval-their-amenability-to-judicial-review-is.
“There Is No Place in a Modern Constitution for Prerogative Powers Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1528872-there-is-no-place-in-a-modern-constitution-for-prerogative-powers-they-have-received-no-democratic-seal-of-approval-their-amenability-to-judicial-review-is.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers. They have received no democratic seal of approval, Their amenability to judicial review is

Judicial Review

...?JUDICIAL REVIEW According to Wolfe, “Judicial review is the series of checks and balances within a definite government can be seen most clearly by examining its approach to constitutional interpretation and its manner of exercising judicial review” (10). The traditional meaning of judicial review was illustrated in two instances. First is in Federalist No. 78 and second is in the case of Marbury Vs. Madison (5 U.S. 137). “Laws which are contrary to the Constitution are therefore void because the interpretation of the laws is the proper and peculiar province of the courts (Federalist No. 78), because it is emphatically, the province and duty of the judicial government to say what the law is (Marbury Vs. Madison), and because...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Judicial Review

... are enforced.” Importance of judicial review What makes control of administrative functions and power very crucial? The increasing relevance and growth of judicial review is as a result of the growth of the administrative functions and powers in the modern world and can be understood from a historical perspective. The period before 19th century was characterized by a societal mode of life known as laissez faire which connotes total individual freedom, contractual freedom, a free individual enterprise which diminish the government control and functions. In a laissez faire society the role of the state is negative and is limited to defending the country especially from external aggression. The advent of industrial revolution in the 19th...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Prerogative Powers in The Context of The UK Constitution

... Some of the public appointments are currently monitored by a Commissioner and guided as per the Nolan rules.12 The courts are allowed to review the legal right to use prerogative power in some cases; however, they cannot address all prerogative powers. Furthermore, the courts can assist civilians only after an incident takes place. Therefore, it is clear that between prerogative powers and statutory powers within the UK constitution, the former is more powerful, ceding the UK Cabinet Ministers a wide scope to exercise powers without prior Parliamentary or legal approval. Prerogative powers and their compatibility with executive accountability under current conditions: Originally, the ruling monarch exercised the Royal Prerogative laws...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Is judicial review consistent with democratic ideals

For Marx and Engels, there is no supernatural being, only matter exists and as such, humans are alienated from material conditions. In this case, alienation is only eliminated when true freedom is achieved The first premise of this theory therefore, is the existence of living human individuals who then engage in economic activities for their subsistence and in the process develop relations that form the basis of legal and political superstructures. However, to achieve freedom societies go through conflicts or class struggles whereby the ruling class is overthrown and new order established. So according to the Communist manifesto by Marx and Engels “the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.”1T...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

Judicial Review

.... In the case of Belmarsh33 which is also an important case for judicial review an over whelming majority of the House of Lords decided that the indefinite detention of foreigners, on the ground of terrorism suspicion was a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights. All these cases are a testament to the constitutional significance of Judicial Review. The Courts have used and will continue to use the vehicle of judicial review to stop the unruly executive from trampling the rights of citizens. An executive wary of the outcomes of its actions and accountable for any breach of the powers allocated to it will think twice before it takes any actions which violate the democratic ideals of the British Constitution. Conclusion...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Constitutional and Judicial Review

...Constitutional and Judicial Review Introduction: The Human Rights Act of 1998 became a part of the domestic law of the United Kingdom on October 2, 2000 and in that process made the European Convention on Human Rights applicable in the United Kingdom. The Human Rights Act of 1998 thus makes it possible to raise issues relating to the European Convention on Human Rights in the courts across the United Kingdom. The affect of this is expected to nurture a culture of rights and responsibilities in the United Kingdom. It also has its consequences on the courts in the United Kingdom and the sovereignty of Parliament in the United Kingdom. Human Rights Act of 1998 and Parliamentary Sovereignty: The Human Rights Act of 1998 has led...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Judicial review

...PART A. The act of reviewing the decisions of the lower courts, tribunals and administrative bodies by the High Court is known as judicial review in English law. Some of the court orders are certiorari, which sets aside a decision; mandamus, which makes it imperative for a duty to be performed; prohibition, which orders that an action should not be undertaken as it is unauthorized; a declaration, which defines the legal rights or obligations or an injunction. In short, judicial review is that power of a court, which empowers it to scrutinize a law or an official act of a government agent which violates the fundamental principles of justice or the constitution. In England and Wales the Civil Procedure Rules requires that any claim form...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Judicial Review

Kovac’s tea with sleeping pills’. The drug alleged to have spiked into the teacher’s hot beverage was diphendyramine citrate. The head teacher, in reaching his decision, relied on statements recorded by Ms. P, the claimant’s fellow student and Mrs. Kovac, the alleged victim.
3. According to the complainant’s main witness, one Ms. P who recordeda statementstating that during the morning break, she had been curious of what the claimant was up to and had followed her to classwhere the claimant was alone and seen “Veronica (the claimant herein)openherbag,takeoutasmallpacketofwhatlookedlike medicine(Icouldn’tseeexactlywhatitwasasitwas smallandIwastoofar away).Shethen wentovertoMrs.Kovac’s desk.IcouldclearlyseethemugMrs.Kovacusesonh...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Dental Veneers as a Breakthrough in Modern Dental Technology

In today’s fashion-conscious world, porcelain and composite veneers remain some of the most popular choices for people seeking to improve the esthetics of their teeth. Porcelain veneers have several advantages when compared to composite veneers including durability, resistance to staining, and amount of tooth structure removed during the procedure.
First and foremost, the porcelain veneers are very durable. They are also very thin – usually between 0.5 - 0.7 millimeters – and brittle, although once bonded to a healthy tooth structure they can become quite strong. The bonding process increases durability and veneers made of porcelain can last for many years, oftentimes between 10-15 years depending on how wel...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

The Importance of Place in a Groups Ethnic Identity

His work spans a broad range of subjects from ethnography among peasants in Algeria, to sociological analysis of nineteenth-century artists and writers, education, language, consumer and cultural tastes, religion, and science in modern French society. (p. 2)
Bourdieu’s major theoretical contributions to sociology are his notion of habitus and its associated concepts of social field and agency. Given the breadth of literature and uses of examples that Bourdieu produced in order to articulate these concepts, there is much room for interpretation of what they meant and how much social agency they afford to individuals. Nonetheless, this paper will explore the habitus, field, and agency in terms of the fluid dynamics of the...
13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment

Traditional Women in the Modern World

It is within the family that many attributes of gender inequality are generated and replicated. Economic and interpersonal dependence on both genders and in various instances more vicious forms of inferiority, are classic elements of marriage and family. Women’s long-established roles leave them with the trouble of widespread domestic and nurturance obligations in addition to limited authority within the family. These trends represent gender inequality within the home and are echoed in the ideology justifying a gender-separated workforce in which women’s earnings and prospects are disproportionate to men’s. While almost every woman has some family bonds to men, by their kinship ties to their fathers and brothers,...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Infrastructure Application and Review: France

Referring specifically to the country’s water network, Jacobson et al. (1995) notice that ‘although waterworks facilities in France are predominantly government-owned, private firms operate and manage most systems under an array of contracting and leasing arrangements’ (Jacobson et al., 1995, online article). The above study describes the general terms under which the development of infrastructure systems in France is progressing. It should be noticed at this point that in France, the government’s policies regarding the development of infrastructure systems were not always effective – moreover, they were rather limited. Indeed, in a report published by the OECD in 2005, it is noticed that ‘in 19...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

The British Constitution vs The Human Rights Act 1998

This research essay analyses the above statement and arrives at a conclusion.
Integration of the provisions of ECHR into U.K’s domestic law by way of HRA 1998 can be regarded as revolutionary as it facilitates the majority of the ECHR rights provisions directly applicable in the U.K. Before that integration, a U.K Court has to presume that when there is a clash between U.K’s domestic law and ECHR rights provision, the ECHR rights provision will always prevail. This principle has been laid down in R v Secretary of Home Dept ex parte Brind1 and R v Secretary of Home Dept ex parte Thakrar. 2
Courts have now the power to declare any statue which they find incompatible with ECHR provisions and order for fine-tunin...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

What Are the Most Important Factors in Explaining the Rise of the Modern State

Though the existence of the state can be felt in different walks of everyday life, yet it is an intangible whose nature is impossible to grasp. As a political institution, state embodies the concept of sovereignty. Devetak (2007) describes it as a political unit or a country that possesses sovereignty. State can thus be described as a single, unified whole confined within territorial borders. The state is built in a core geographical area with allowances to a certain extent on the boundaries. According to Strayer (1970), a state exists in the hearts and minds of the people. The collective personality of the state renders it immortal. The state is a multi-faced concept that is fuzzy around its edges. Consequently, we cannot develop...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Critical Review of Goth: Identity, Style and Subculture by Paul Hodkinson

The allure from this standpoint is seen by the author. This report measures mainly the methodology that Hodkinson uses, which is grounded theory research, and the report also examines questions of fixed vs. flexible research. The findings of the research are briefly presented before the current research investigation concludes.

The Goth subculture is founded on principles of viewing some of what society outside this subculture, or mainstream culture, views as abhorrent or negative. There is some fetish tendency in this subculture towards the macabre and death, with face-paint style makeup and mourning clothing being prominent features of belongingness, which are certainly not reflective of mainstream fashion and makeup....
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

The Functions of Modern Central Banking

It now directs and supervises banking activities through a complex set of tools and instruments that embody the country’s monetary policies.
Central banking can be traced to the 17th century Swedish Riksbank. The bank was created in 1668 as a joint-stock bank and helped the Swedish government with its monetary needs as well as serve as a clearinghouse for commerce. Just a few decades after, or in 1694, England established its own joint-stock bank called Bank of England. It was established primarily to buy the country’s debts. Other European countries soon followed and established their own national banks not only to serve their debts but also to solve monetary disarray as in the case of France’s Banque de Fr...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Humanistic Buddhism: A Way of Nirvana for Modern Man

However, how many people in today’s modern world are ready to renounce their life of comfort and materialistic pleasure to know the ultimate truth of life? Hardly anyone will be ready to renounce the pleasures of life. Hence, as Buddhism was believed to be a religion of suffering and severe self-discipline, very few people from the modern world were ready to practice it. However, Humanistic Buddhism, by modifying the teachings and simplifying the practices of the religion, gave a fresh and renewed beginning to Buddhism. Humanistic Buddhism, by modifying its practices to suit the social demands of modern life, has not just saved Buddhism from dying out but has also helped people to find happiness and satisfaction in life by s...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Discovering the Tragic Hero: Ancient and Modern

...Discovering the Tragic Hero: Ancient and Modern The concept of the tragic hero was first brought forward in ancient Greek mythology through the writings of the philosopher Aristotle as he described the important individual characteristics the tragic hero must possess. Although Aristotle outlines three requisite character traits that the tragic hero should possess, he qualifies the definition of the tragic hero with a set of events that must also take place before the hero can be considered truly tragic. Once this process is understood, it is easy to see how the sudden downfall of a mighty man, such as Oedipus the King from the play by Sophocles for example, would be dramatic and shocking to a public dominated by strict social classes...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic There is no place in a modern constitution for prerogative powers. They have received no democratic seal of approval, Their amenability to judicial review is for FREE!

Contact Us