Nobody downloaded yet

The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets' Abolish high School by robert Epstein - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The roots of adolescence and society's view of this transformational bridge from childhood to adulthood almost defy description as it is studied in cultures around the world. Sociologists and anthropologists have argued for decades about the degree to which culture molds the teenage years and how much of a culture is a reflection of the teenager's biology…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets Abolish high School by robert Epstein
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets' Abolish high School by robert Epstein"

Download file to see previous pages A second article titled The Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman Debate, written by Ann M. Bender, Trevor Humphries, and Trevor Michael illustrates the ongoing contention brought on by the nature versus nurture debate. We are a product of both biology and culture and both Margaret Mead's book Coming of Age in Samoa, as well as Epstein's article, reinforce this understanding of the debate about how much of our teenage years are a product of biology and how much comes from society.
Epstein's article, which calls for a rethinking of adolescence, traces a logical path that concludes that our concept of teenager is a product of our culture. Indeed, Epstein's book, which served as a basis for this article, has been the subject of a considerable number of positive reviews. Authors, professional psychiatrists, and other academic professionals have stated their acceptance and praise. Epstein does make several salient points about our view of the teenage years, how we got this way, and the potential problems that it causes. Yet, Epstein seems to contradict his own view of nature. He seemingly supports the nature argument by stating, "technically speaking we're not really children anymore, and presumably through most of human history we bore our young when we were quite young ourselves". However, in the same writing he argues about the impact of society when he laments the teenage years as a time when he "couldn't own property or do any interesting or fulfilling work, and he had no choice but to attend high school for several more years before getting on with his 'real' life". While biology propels the body into adulthood, society meters its progress and deliberates the impact of socialization. Unfortunately, Mead's book, which also found that teenagers are a product of their culture, was heavily criticized and its results were questioned. In fact, both books highlight the need for teaching children how to learn, and the vital skill of being able to think and write critically. These are traits of nurture that nature could never provide.
Margaret Mead made several of the same points as Epstein in her book, yet was heavily criticized by Derek Freeman. Though Freeman's criticism largely rested on the quality of the process and not the results, his criticism does attempt to neutralize the view that adolescence is the product of culture. Clearly, both Epstein and Mead were correct in their assessment that adolescence is molded from cultural expectations. We see this when a young man steps up to be the breadwinner when a father has suddenly disappeared from the family scene. It is apparent when a young girl becomes the homemaker when the family faces life without their mother. Freeman, though maybe technically correct, did sociology and anthropology a disservice by diminishing the importance of Mead's work and her revolutionary insights. Epstein's view that we should teach our children how to learn and send them off as teenagers to discover knowledge makes more sense in a globalized community with few borders or obstacles to information.
In conclusion, the ages old argument about nature versus nurture is not an either or and exclusive argument. Teenagers are molded by human nature as well as the society in which they are ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets' Abolish high Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526085-the-margaret-mead-and-derek-freeman-debate-vs-lets-abolish-high-school-by-robert-epstein
(The Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman Debate Vs Lets' Abolish High Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526085-the-margaret-mead-and-derek-freeman-debate-vs-lets-abolish-high-school-by-robert-epstein.
“The Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman Debate Vs Lets' Abolish High Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526085-the-margaret-mead-and-derek-freeman-debate-vs-lets-abolish-high-school-by-robert-epstein.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets' Abolish high School by robert Epstein

Freeman vs. Quicken Loans, Inc

...Freeman v. Quicken Loans, Inc. The case relates to the Real E Settlement Procedures (RESPA) which entailing regulations that guide purchase and sale of real estates. In this case, persons paid discount fees on their mortgages. There was no division of the fees, leading to the charging of the third party together with the interest rate of the client (Freeman v. Quicken Loans 2). This was supposed to be as the entire section price of the loan. With reference to RESPA 2607(b), the practice did not commit any violation of the clause. RESPA’s aim is to forbid any split of offending fees between corporations in the absence of unearned fees by the beneficiary. After Freeman and other couples...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

What makes Margaret Mead so important in Anthropology circles

...?Watch all videos on Margaret Mead. What makes her so important in Anthropological circles? It is fair to say that Margaret Mead is one of the most influential cultural anthropologists of the century gone by. Although some of her inferences have been proven to be flawed, she is a pioneer in the field who opened new vistas within the field of anthropology. In the documentary videos about her life and work perused for this essay, one could witness the key developments in anthropological study that she initiated. One could see in the videos, that Mead contributed immensely to not just the study of cultural anthropology retrospectively, but she played a role...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

High School vs. College

... High School vs. College Introduction It is commonly believed that in order to live a positive future and a life of high quality, one need to attend high school level education and after its completion they should even continue studying for the higher level in college. Students as well as instructors and other stakeholders of the educational system assert that there is tremendous amount of difference between high school and college, even though both share the purpose of educating individuals. There is even ample amount of difference between the purpose of attending high school and colleges. Those who attend these levels of education are of the idea that both high school and college are as different from each other as humans living... in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

High School vs College

... Community college Vs. High school College is the next level of education after high school. A community college is best for students who have near clear goals or career choices. It differs with the four years in university in several ways. For instance, a university is more expensive but productive than the community college. Students in both community colleges and high schools tend to have some common and different experiences as far as school life is concerned. High school students in major occasions are usually younger than the community college students. This discourse tends to compare and contrast experiences in community colleges with that of high school. Students in community colleges tend to have few interactions... with the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Public School Vs. Private School: An American Debate

...represent the full range of current education advances, because they are self-regulated and free of local curriculum mandates. Because they are independent, private schools can provide a variety of instruction streamlined to fit a high standard of education. Private schools also attract talented teachers interested in learning-based curriculum and few discipline problems. The debate forges on as the middle class weighs the educational options available for their children. While private school students continue to excel, it is important to remember that public schools were founded on values, theories, and skills that are central to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

High school

...Mazen Alqethamy ENIN450 November 30, High Schools What kinds of relationships exist between and teachers? There are a lot of relationships between students and teachers. Barriers play a key role in these relationships. Some teachers do not like to talk much with students, and some students do not like to speak with teachers. Communication exists between students and teachers inside and outside the school because sometimes, teachers help students in things, issues and concerns outside the academic endeavor. Also, some students have established friendly relationships with teachers. The high preference for feedback from teachers apparently results from students’ positive...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Privite high school vs public high school

... schools while 12% send their kids to private schools (National Center for Education Statistics). In short, both the kinds of schools have their own unique aspects. Private high schools provide more attention and lavishness, but public high schools tend to be affordable for common people. Works Cited National Center for Education Statistics. Private School Statistics. GAPE, 2013. Web. 14 Apr 2014. school-statistics/>. The Home Economist. Public vs. Private Schools, New Facts Revealed. The Home Economist, 2013. Web. 14 Apr 2014. schools-secret-gov-stats/>.... Your full April 14, Comparison/Contrast It is all a matter of affordability; otherwise, who does not want to admit his children in a school that is unique in manifold aspects (hook). There are a lot of advantages...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Margaret Beaufort School

...ESSAY – EDUCATION Margaret Beaufort School Lecturer’s Part A of the organizational context of Margaret Beaufort SchoolMargaret Beaufort School is a rural middle school in Riseley, a village in North Bedfordshire. The school is a mixed gender middle school with aspirations of improving on a poor Ofsted report. In 2010 the school joined the North Bedfordshire Federation (NBF), which is a union of four schools close to Bedford. At this time the focus of the school appears to be pastoral and there is reference in the transcript to strong...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Margaret Beaufort School

...Section A The organizational context of Margaret Beaufort School The is an academic organization in Riseley that comprises of the instructors, the guardians and the pupils. In addition, there is the management of the school that includes the school head and parent representatives. Another constituent of the school is the association of parents. The teachers make a major contribution to the output of the students. The parents, on the other hand, provide for the children and make sure that they arrive early for the class sessions. The teachers in turn provide a conducive environment for learning and provide the right content for education (Yukl, 2002, p....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Junior high vs. High School

...Junior High School versus Middle School Junior High School versus Middle School Question one: a) The model junior high school model is the best. It allows the students to socialize, have standard classes and places them at a better position to learn from one another through socialization. b) Strengths: In the junior high school, the children spend more years with their tutors. The situation allows them to develop deep understanding of their needs and strengths thus helping and supporting their learning. The older students can model the complicated approaches towards a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Margaret Mead and derek Freeman debate vs Lets' Abolish high School by robert Epstein for FREE!

Contact Us