Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

World History The Eugenics Debate - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Introduction. In his essay "Eugenics: Economics For the Long Run", Dr Edward Miller proposes a system of eugenics for those members of the population that are living on welfare, or who have committed crimes such as rape or other violent crimes. Dr Miller notes that there are ethical questions involved in this issue, but believes that economic considerations will force governments to reduce the population, and that preventing childbirth among the poorer members of society…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
World History The Eugenics Debate
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "World History The Eugenics Debate"

To What Degree Do You Think That Dr Miller's Ideas Are Politically Feasible In A Democratic Society Introduction. In his essay "Eugenics: Economics For the Long Run", Dr Edward Miller proposes a system of eugenics for those members of the population that are living on welfare, or who have committed crimes such as rape or other violent crimes. Dr Miller notes that there are ethical questions involved in this issue, but believes that economic considerations will force governments to reduce the population, and that preventing childbirth among the poorer members of society. However, with eugenics' past history as a tool of repressive governments and its image as a coercive tool, is there any way in which a democratic government would be able to utilise eugenics. However, due to flaws within Dr Miller's theory of genetics, and his proposals for eugenics are impractical, it should be argued that Dr Miller's ideas are not politically feasible. This brief essay will attempt to examine: Miller's description of genetic inheritance in criminality, poverty and intelligence, considering if this is good reasoning; consider whether his strategies for limiting undesirable births is practical; look at the position of eugenics in economics and democracy; and calculate whether these elements combined make eugenics practical in a modern society.
Considering the role of genes in criminality, poverty and intelligence in Miller's essay. Any policy which argues for the reintroduction of eugenics must base its arguments upon the genetic factors which influence behaviour. In his essay, Dr Miller argues that there is 'a strong genetic component' in both criminality and those who live below the poverty line. However, while he makes a small amount of room for the theory that environmental influences may also have a strong impact upon behaviour and intelligence. He chooses to point at adoption and twin studies to demonstrate that there is a strong link between genes and criminality, poverty and intelligence. Other studies have demonstrated that, while genes have their place, they are not determinants: i.e., it is not enough to simply inherit such a gene from a parent. Genes alone cannot predict how a child may develop: it is only necessary to look at the families of successful people to find that many of them came from underprivileged and criminal environments, and that criminals such as rapists and murderers are not limited to the poor.
Dr Miller's strategies for limiting births have flaws. While Dr Miller is putting forward an argument for economic eugenics, he has concentrated his theory upon coerced birth prevention, or mandatory eugenics. This, however, is not the only method of controlling the population, and in fact, may be the most uneconomic, since people are bound to resist these measures. As Dr Miller's strategies are all compulsory, this raises many challenges to implementation in a society based on democracy.
Economics, democracy and their role in considering eugenics. The question of whether it is possible to bring eugenics into a democratic society. In democracy, citizens that have committed no crime should not be coerced into receiving surgery or other severe measures. The economic factors surrounding eugenics also do not consider whether the long-term implications of birth control could mean that workers fall dramatically. Capitalism depends, sadly, on there being an excess of workers at the bottom, driving down wages. Dr Miller believes that eugenics will mean higher wages for workers, though he does not consider whether this is economically viable, or whether it will mean that the normal worker overprices themselves, and companies turn to illegal immigrants (who will not be under the eugenics program) in order to keep costs down. This seems a more likely outcome of limited worker stock, rather than simply paying the few more.
Is eugenic practice really feasible in a democracy Although Dr Miller believes that eugenics is economically necessary, he does not consider promotional voluntary eugenics, where birth control is promoted to the people, but not forced upon them. With concerns about population growth and sustainability, this may prove popular in future decades, and the government would not have to bear the brunt of forcing their voters to be sterilized. Forced programs of eugenics are likely to be seen as breach of a person's human rights, but voluntary programmes offer voters the choice, and therefore cannot be criticised as inhumane. This solution would lead to a population reduction, while still keeping enough of the population to supply businesses with labour. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“World History The Eugenics Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(World History The Eugenics Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“World History The Eugenics Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
yundtelaina added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
I didn’t know how to start my research paper. "World History The Eugenics Debate" helped me out a lot! Especially the list of first sentence was valuable.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF World History The Eugenics Debate


...?Your Full Your s 22 March Eugenics Eugenics, simply put, is the practice of producing perfect humans by selective breeding and only allowing healthy babies to be born. Considered barbaric and strictly carried out in ancient Nordic and Germanic cultures, eugenics has made a stealthy return aided by modern science. In his article, Politically Correct Eugenics: Brownback and Kennedy do the right thing, Wesley J. Smith discusses the human race’s slow march towards eugenics. He points out that aborting fetuses diagnosed with abnormalities is commonplace now. Despite advocating human rights, studies show that abortion of such babies is ‘encouraged’ in the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Eugenics in the Modern World

...Eugenics in the Modern World The discipline of Eugenics aims to study the probabilities of bringing improvements in the characteristics and quality of population belonging to some specific area, by making alterations in the genes of the individuals, so that the fittest and the most suitable breed could be produced in order to make the world a better and magnificent place to reside. First coined by English scientist Francis Galton by 1883, the discipline looks to be seeking inspiration from Darwinian doctrine of Survival of the Fittest (1859), where Charles Darwin submits to state that only the superior, powerful and refined species survive in the world because of their multiplication through their future generations; and thus... and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


... “Origins and Myths of Social Darwinism” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 71 2009) 37-51 retrieved from 3) “Lester Frank Ward” Reference retrieved from 4) “Lester Frank Ward” Encyclopedia of World Biography 2004 retrieved from 5) “The Misinterpretation of Darwinian Theory 2002” retrieved from 6) “The History of Eugenics in the United States” retrieved from https//…/Eugenics/History %20 of%20Eugenics.... that the genetic superiority of the elite could be enhanced by discouraging reproduction of those alleged to have inherited undesirable traits ( negative...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper


...Eugenics In a book written in 1914 a discussion was undertaken about a lecture given by the cousinto Charles Darwin, Sir Francis Galton. A newly formed organization, the Sociological Society of London, was being lectured on the topic of eugenics. During this lecture Galton defined eugenics as “the science which deals with all influences that improve the inborn qualities of a race” (Alsdrich et al 214). This was likely the beginning of the eugenics movement. Eugenics is often associated with ideas of improving the human species by selectively breeding certain traits, while eliminating undesirable traits. As a consequence of this concept,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

World History

...soldiers surrounded the Sabra and Shatila camps. No IDF soldier entered the camp, but prevented refugees from leaving when Phalangists (a Christian faction in the Lebanese civil war) entered the camp seeking terrorists. What happened next is of great debate. When the smoke cleared a disputed amount of Palestinians were dead. Some figures are as low as four hundrend, but some figures are as high as four thousand depending on the source. Since Ariel Sharon was the Israel Defense Minister, he was blamed because the IDF reported directly to him. Another similarity in both men’s lives were they both waged war with their respective enemies, without falling in battle. Charlemagne fell ill in his seventies, dying in his...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

World History

...How the British controlled Palestine between 1940 and 1945? Number: Palestine was a part of the Ottoman Empire under the rule of Turks before the end of World War One. Palestine is the name given by the Arabs to an area in the Middle-East. Led by General Allenby, the Turkish forces were defeated by the British in 1917 who then occupied the Palestine. The British then controlled Palestine under a League of Nations Mandate from 1920 to 1948 (Wikipedia). The League of Nations entrusted the mandate to the United Kingdom to establish a home for the Jewish people. Following the London Conference in 1939 between the British government and representatives of the Arab governments, the Palestinian Arabs and the Jewish Agency, the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

World History

...WORLD HISTORY When World War II ended on August 15, 1945 the Japanese economy was in a sorry Statistics for 1946 indicate that industrialoutput had fallen by one third, while agricultural output had dropped nearly 60% of pre-war levels. This bleak situation was further exacerbated by the impending repatriation of nearly 7 million Japanese from abroad. The general consensus was that the Japanese economy was expected to descend further into hopelessness and despair (Diplomatic Blue Book). The situation I consider to have had the biggest effect on the rapid and success re-emergency of the Japanese economy as world-class after the end of World War II is...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...fraught with controversy, but extremely popular with members of the elite or dominant group (past and present); even the wealthiest, philanthropic American families, such as the financial support given by John D. Rockefeller; Mrs. E. H. Harriman (who gave much of her time and finances, with unprecedented zeal to the Eugenics Record Office), supported the eugenics movement. (4) This wave of eugenics reached up to as recently in the United States history as the 1970s. However, the right-wing of politics is far from innocent in its handling of eugenics. Nazism, a far-right political group, created the most horrible method of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

World history

...World History The Ramayana Analysis Believe it or not, we are faced with a multifaceted way of thinking and viewing the world. The minute we wake up, we are pressured to greet the world. We can choose to greet it with kindness, or anger regardless of what it has to offer us. Morality and ethics are the two factors that drive our behavior and attitude on a day-to-day basis. In addition, it is every day that we place ourselves in a battle. A battle between right and wrong. Morals dictate our spiritual essence and ethics dictate our instant gratifying demands. In the novel The Ramayana, written by R.K Narayan, we see a battle take place. The battles are always between the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

World History

...World History World history entails evaluation and examination of multiple cultural and national histories from a globalperspective. This implies that world history seeks to find mutual patterns within different cultures and nations thereby deriving similarities and differences of human experiences across different parts of the world. This evaluation is arguably done through study of various major events that happened in the past such as wars, rise of new nations, and creation and adoption of new theories. 1. Atlantic Revolution The Atlantic revolutions mark a highly significant trend that saw the rise...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic World History The Eugenics Debate for FREE!

Contact Us